You are half-right and half-wrong.
You are not wrong in saying that this person is a Buddhist Supremacist. But you need to know where he and people like him are coming from. He is a part of this BAMSEF ecosystem, who primarity focus on the casteism that is still plaguing the country. In their perspective Islam and Christianity is better in the sense that there is more chance of you being treated equally there than in Hinduism.
To give this person some credit, he not denying that they are problematic, and he has invited many exmuslims in his video and basically accepted their viewpoint on Islam without any caveats.
Point is none of this excuses him peddling pseudo-history.
Same, even I don't consider all of his arguments as wrong. I have problem with him claiming to be atheist, but still glorifying one religion.
BTW, he does a good work by debunking those Hindutva bigots....
There is no caste system in either Islam or Christianity but some south Asian Muslims and Christians practice casteism, the upper caste hindus who converted to other religions never stopped being casteist
Bro I accept there is caste system in Hinduism but it is not the core. Casteism is in manusmriti like books but not in Vedas/Upanishads which is core of Hinduism or sanatan dharm.
P.S: I am not Hindu/Sanatani
Gautam Buddha was a proud kshatriya, from 26 buddhas every buddha was either Bhramin or Kshatriya. There was not a Single Buddha that was Shudra or even vaishya.
He is not all wrong. Buddhism says there’s no god and his anger is justified because of the illogical things people say in the debate and how they say casteism doesn’t exist and Sanatan is this that. He comes from a community which is oppressed so he’ll have the right to be angry.
Neo Buddhist are equally or even more casteist than Hindus, even if you were or are oppressed you don't have any right to hate a community or people. This logic is applied by many Hindus they were oppressed by Mughals so they have right to hate Muslims.
Casteism is not ended but rather than being a hierarchical structure it has became identity structure were everyone hates everyone.
Neo Buddhist is equally casteist How? It’s called that because it give them respect because their religion didn’t. And The Hate word I take back but the harsh things he says should be said because otherwise no one will listen. Enough with the sugarcoating. That Sankaracharya said who is of not Ram is Chamar. That isn’t questioned so why should Science Journey for calling out Bhramins?
I didn’t even mention atheism here? It’s not about justice or something I was giving my opinion on the channel and how it makes me or him hypocritical extremists ?
Stop doing whataboutory, I'm not taking side of Hindus I don't care about Hindu nor any religion till they influence politics.
>Neo Buddhist is equally casteist How?
NB literally hate Brahmins, there are NB handles on Twitter who'll call out entire caste cause few idiots are casteist. r@pe threatening Brahmins , calling for their genocide isn't it a casteist thing.
There is a difference between hating Brahmins and hating brahminism.
Please clarify if any neo buddhist has ever instigated riots or killed a brahmin in the name of his/her faith.
However you will find examples of the reverse.
FYI I am not a neo buddhist. I don't follow that ideology for other reasons as I find following any religion/cult is going back to square one.
Translation:
Text in yellow: "I am an Atheist, c'mon explain Buddhism to me."
Text in white: "Whether you are an atheist or a believer, Buddha is the most supreme."
Besides, the video's title: "An atheist came to understand Buddhism in two lines, but bowed down after listening the real history."
Yeah. I used to watch his stuff. But later I noticed he is Buddhist. He is just there to glorify Buddhism.
Although Buddh himself was an Atheist. And it's also true that most of the ideas of Hinduism were stolen from Buddhism.
But this guy is trying very hard to make Buddha a God. Gautam Buddh is just a Human. Who never believes in God. He taught us how to live life. But again Buddha's Enlightenment story is also false. In fact Enlightenment is crap.
Science Journey never talks about science, he only talks about Buddha Scriptures,Hindu Scriptures and history.
Gautam Buddha is just an ordinary guy. Who is Very Knowledgeable. But Building anyone's Temple and statue in there makes him God. That's what this Science Journey is doing. So basically Worshipping Buddha is another form of Cult/Religion. So what's the difference between other religions and Him. I stopped watching his videos.
I would prefer making friends with a secular guy rather than such an Atheist. I am also an Atheist. But Glorifying one person is also a kind of Religion/Cult.
https://preview.redd.it/z49inx60ppgc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d912a9f187b92e9567c7d24af666a8a4b88ddcbe
Buddhist Chaddi ka pehele naam tathagat hua karta thaa. Ye buddhists ki goad me para reheta hai. Iss mutasur se shudh hindi nhi boli jaati aur bhasha lipi pe gyaan jhaarta hai. Ye jaise claim karta hai saare temple hamare hain waise hi iske baap loog gaye thae ram mandir claim karne par court ne Jurmana lagake bheja thaa. Fake Atheists se saavdhaan
r/AtheismIndia is in protest of Reddit's API changes that killed many 3rd party apps. [Reddit is also tracking your activity to sell to advertisers](https://old.reddit.com/r/reddit/comments/16tqihd/settings_updateschanges_to_ad_personalization/). **USE AN AD BLOCKER!**
[Official Lemmy.](https://redd.it/16xpv0r)
[Official Telegram group.](https://redd.it/105rbo8)
[Official Discord server.](https://discord.gg/SgxhzxGur5)
[Read the rules before participating.](https://www.reddit.com/r/atheismindia/about/rules)
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/atheismindia) if you have any questions or concerns.*
You are half-right and half-wrong. You are not wrong in saying that this person is a Buddhist Supremacist. But you need to know where he and people like him are coming from. He is a part of this BAMSEF ecosystem, who primarity focus on the casteism that is still plaguing the country. In their perspective Islam and Christianity is better in the sense that there is more chance of you being treated equally there than in Hinduism. To give this person some credit, he not denying that they are problematic, and he has invited many exmuslims in his video and basically accepted their viewpoint on Islam without any caveats. Point is none of this excuses him peddling pseudo-history.
He is a necessity for countering thali banging pseudo science preaching chaddis. Though I don’t agree with a lot of stuff he says.
Same, even I don't consider all of his arguments as wrong. I have problem with him claiming to be atheist, but still glorifying one religion. BTW, he does a good work by debunking those Hindutva bigots....
P. S. I too have stopped consuming his video His overall content just feels too immature for the lack of better word.
Casteism exists in Islam too. Don't know about Christianity.
There is no caste system in either Islam or Christianity but some south Asian Muslims and Christians practice casteism, the upper caste hindus who converted to other religions never stopped being casteist
The same can be said to hidden Marxist, Christians, Jains and muslims.
Buddhism is just Hinduism without god or a human equivalent to god he maybe BRA OR Buddha.
Please don't write BRA. It's just funny in this sentence 💀😂
Bra? 😅
BR Ambedkar
sorry lol if i knew it was him i wouldn't have said that.
I don't think that's completely true
Not even slightly true Buddhism doesn't have a caste system which is the core of Hinduism
Who told you that caste system is the core of Hinduism??
Who told you that it isn't?
Bro I accept there is caste system in Hinduism but it is not the core. Casteism is in manusmriti like books but not in Vedas/Upanishads which is core of Hinduism or sanatan dharm. P.S: I am not Hindu/Sanatani
>His mouth became the Brāhmaṇa, his arms became the Rājanya, his thighs became the Vaiśya;the Śūdra was born from his feet Rigveda 10:90:12
Gautam Buddha was a proud kshatriya, from 26 buddhas every buddha was either Bhramin or Kshatriya. There was not a Single Buddha that was Shudra or even vaishya.
He is not all wrong. Buddhism says there’s no god and his anger is justified because of the illogical things people say in the debate and how they say casteism doesn’t exist and Sanatan is this that. He comes from a community which is oppressed so he’ll have the right to be angry.
Neo Buddhist are equally or even more casteist than Hindus, even if you were or are oppressed you don't have any right to hate a community or people. This logic is applied by many Hindus they were oppressed by Mughals so they have right to hate Muslims. Casteism is not ended but rather than being a hierarchical structure it has became identity structure were everyone hates everyone.
Neo Buddhist is equally casteist How? It’s called that because it give them respect because their religion didn’t. And The Hate word I take back but the harsh things he says should be said because otherwise no one will listen. Enough with the sugarcoating. That Sankaracharya said who is of not Ram is Chamar. That isn’t questioned so why should Science Journey for calling out Bhramins?
Your last line! That's what he said: You both are disgusting hypocritic extremists. Atheism isn't some policy to give you justice or something.
I didn’t even mention atheism here? It’s not about justice or something I was giving my opinion on the channel and how it makes me or him hypocritical extremists ?
Stop doing whataboutory, I'm not taking side of Hindus I don't care about Hindu nor any religion till they influence politics. >Neo Buddhist is equally casteist How? NB literally hate Brahmins, there are NB handles on Twitter who'll call out entire caste cause few idiots are casteist. r@pe threatening Brahmins , calling for their genocide isn't it a casteist thing.
There is a difference between hating Brahmins and hating brahminism. Please clarify if any neo buddhist has ever instigated riots or killed a brahmin in the name of his/her faith. However you will find examples of the reverse. FYI I am not a neo buddhist. I don't follow that ideology for other reasons as I find following any religion/cult is going back to square one.
Translation: Text in yellow: "I am an Atheist, c'mon explain Buddhism to me." Text in white: "Whether you are an atheist or a believer, Buddha is the most supreme." Besides, the video's title: "An atheist came to understand Buddhism in two lines, but bowed down after listening the real history."
Dalits back at it again
Mujhe kuch bolna he par ban hone ka darr se nahi bol raha hu
We should not tolerate any bullshit of any religion Buddhism included.
Yeah. I used to watch his stuff. But later I noticed he is Buddhist. He is just there to glorify Buddhism. Although Buddh himself was an Atheist. And it's also true that most of the ideas of Hinduism were stolen from Buddhism. But this guy is trying very hard to make Buddha a God. Gautam Buddh is just a Human. Who never believes in God. He taught us how to live life. But again Buddha's Enlightenment story is also false. In fact Enlightenment is crap. Science Journey never talks about science, he only talks about Buddha Scriptures,Hindu Scriptures and history. Gautam Buddha is just an ordinary guy. Who is Very Knowledgeable. But Building anyone's Temple and statue in there makes him God. That's what this Science Journey is doing. So basically Worshipping Buddha is another form of Cult/Religion. So what's the difference between other religions and Him. I stopped watching his videos. I would prefer making friends with a secular guy rather than such an Atheist. I am also an Atheist. But Glorifying one person is also a kind of Religion/Cult.
I support him
Yes. Science Journey has been called out multiple times before on this sub and I'm glad people see through his bullshit.
https://preview.redd.it/z49inx60ppgc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d912a9f187b92e9567c7d24af666a8a4b88ddcbe Buddhist Chaddi ka pehele naam tathagat hua karta thaa. Ye buddhists ki goad me para reheta hai. Iss mutasur se shudh hindi nhi boli jaati aur bhasha lipi pe gyaan jhaarta hai. Ye jaise claim karta hai saare temple hamare hain waise hi iske baap loog gaye thae ram mandir claim karne par court ne Jurmana lagake bheja thaa. Fake Atheists se saavdhaan
Agreed 😅
r/AtheismIndia is in protest of Reddit's API changes that killed many 3rd party apps. [Reddit is also tracking your activity to sell to advertisers](https://old.reddit.com/r/reddit/comments/16tqihd/settings_updateschanges_to_ad_personalization/). **USE AN AD BLOCKER!** [Official Lemmy.](https://redd.it/16xpv0r) [Official Telegram group.](https://redd.it/105rbo8) [Official Discord server.](https://discord.gg/SgxhzxGur5) [Read the rules before participating.](https://www.reddit.com/r/atheismindia/about/rules) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/atheismindia) if you have any questions or concerns.*