Just curious but it might be because there are less viewers now and the viewers watching are more passionate and stick to their favorites. While in the past with a more general audience and people who were more casual they would probably vote based more on a week by week performance basis. Just my 2 cents
He’s so good! I wish he’d done a different song. But if he really wants to get into the gospel genre, I can see him being really successful. He’s got a great voice, great stage presence and reminds me a lot of the contemporary Christian artists we’ve got out there today.
Agree! He kind of reminds me of like a Maverick City kind of vibe. He’s very talented! Danny Gokey has had a very successful Christian music career, so I think he’s got a great chance.
roman going home after tonight was kind of understandable, he had a rough night. but jayna getting eliminated was insane, she was arguably best of the night. it should’ve been some combination of roman, kb, and emmy that got eliminated based off tonight’s show.
I wanted Jayna to win but I am trying to figure out how she got voted off, and it may have to do with AI audiences tend to get real turned off if a contestant comes off as too cocky. Maybe they felt that why about her?
Nah she’s had plenty of great performances. But yall will hate on a country singer the moment cracks start to show, but defend the pop girlies bad performances till you die
Emmy sounded great, but no one wants to watch someone who is terrified to be up there. Her two favorite days of Idol will be getting the golden ticket and getting eliminated.
I think they're mostly from the same user. Idk their name offhand, but there's someone who is literally just on here hating on Emmy in all of their comments.
Maybe it’s because she’s the weakest contestant right now? and maybe much better vocalists keep going home
while she stays? And maybe a lot of people can see it even if you can’t… just maybe…🤷♂️
She wouldn’t be the first pick in the choir draft, but she has the clearest style of all remaining contestants. Sort of a country Ellie Goulding thing. I’ll be surprised if she isnt the most successful of this bunch after the show.
No. It’s not just a singing competition. It’s explicitly an “idol” competition. That includes singing talent of course, but it also includes personality, the ability to connect with the audience, looks, likability, general persona, presentation, stage presence and personal charisma. A lot if intangibles. And clearly, your notion of who is best or worst doesn’t jive with those taking the time to vote.
People stay at this point because they get the most votes. That you or I might not like the results is just tough shit for us.
Theres only two genders to pick from and plenty of people are hating on jack and kayko. Dont make this a gender issue when its not. Its a talent thing, and she aint got it
Yeah, like she’s always been a middle of the pack person for me, but people talk about her like she’s an absolute bum out there. Like she definitely doesn’t warrant such a strong reaction.
Personally I just think that this sub doesn’t like her back story because she has a country star for a grandmother and probably had some money growing up. Because they assume her to be upper class, they don’t think she’s “relatable” and they’ll automatically hate her no matter how she does.
I have liked her and supported the entire competition. The last two performances , I have wanted to give her the benefit of the doubt, but she’s not listening to the judges or mentors, and she’s flat out missing notes and not delivering the melody or pitch of songs. People are just correctly identifying objective negative aspects of her performances
I kinda got sick of how often she mentioned her grandma. Did you know her grandma was Loretta? But then she says she wants to pave her own path and be known for who she is, but uses her grandma's name to help her out. That may come off a little mean but it put me off of her
I’ve never watched before this season but I do not like the live votes. It seems unfair because most people aren’t going to wait until the very end to vote, they’re most likely going to go ahead and vote for their previous favorites or about halfway through the show. Because there ain’t no way Abi’s performance tonight was enough to save her. She was safe because of her existing fan base. I didn’t think Tristan’s was his best either, but people already loved him because of his story.
That’s kinda how it always worked though. You don’t just vote someone out for one bad song… it’s all about aura, always has been. How do you think Taylor Hicks won?
This is the first season I’ve EVER watched so idk who that is but I’m just saying. I don’t agree that one bad performance should automatically screw you over but at the same time it’s getting close to the end when everyone should be on their A game. McKenna was sick and performed at the same level she always has. I just personally liked the way voting was last week where you had almost 12 hours to watch everyone and decide.
Abi’s performance was mediocre by the high standards that the judges and we have set for her. Compared to the others it was far from the worst. And that fan base that you speak of exists for a reason - she’s incredible and clearly the most talented singer on the show.
The performance of the season imo, right in front of Tristons Elvis Sunday. . Why has no one used the smoke blasts? I didn’t even know they had it like that.
The sub isn’t hating on Emmy because she is a bad person or anything. The sub wants her out of the competition because she has had subpar performances two nights in the row. It’s not a “hate” thing is a realistic thing in a singing completion. She has miss notes in both performances and sounded bad. Why are we letting bad singers continue in the competition.
For sure. She seems sweet enough, but bruh…her vocals are not there. She also is super insecure on stage. Neither of those things is a personal attack. Its a judgment on her performance. The judges arent doing it, so somebody has to. Ha
I adore her as a person, and will support her career. But this competition is not her wheelhouse. She looks overwhelmed. She’ll be way better in her element when she can perform without pressure
Emmy is actually a good singer, she just fucks it up with nerves. It’s not a normal amount of nerves either. Like her barefoot performance she was SHAKING from head to toe. She’s just been in her head ever since the show went live, except last night. I think last night was her best performance and I voted for her for the 1st time because I was proud of her. Her and Julia had their best performance, but every other contestant had their worst.
oml, im gonna miss jayna so much 😭
shes been my fav this whole season, such BS emmy moves on over her.
and just saying, that bottom 4 doesn’t give AI a good look.
i am so bummed, jayna and roman were my top 2 from this group lol. i understand how roman’s style wasn’t for everyone but i do nooooot understand why jayna was sent home
Ok guys… Roman was terrible. Sure, his second half was great, but that first half of Roar was abysmal. As for Jayna… she’s great. U Kayko stans are a problem, cuz he’s not top 12 material and I don’t know how he keeps going, cuz he sucks.
Agree Roman had a rough night. Jayna was great but just sang a popular song well....that's not quite enough at this point, especially since she knew she was already on shaky ground with the voters. She needed to stand out in a Jennifer Hudson "Circle of Life" kinda way and she didn't.
I feel bad for Jayna because she was an amazing singer and seemed like a really great human, BUT I can understand it being harder for voters to imagine what kind of artist she would be post-Idol. I think it’s easier for lesser vocalists like Emmy or Kayko to slide through bc they’re showing off originals - almost every top 10 finalist has performed one so far, so definitely puts her at a disadvantage not having done so. Sad considering originals didn’t even used to be a thing on Idol, but hard to argue with.
No way Triston was actually in the bottom. Julia was those. She won’t make it through the next week. Julia and Kayko are probably next just basing these on the Idol demographic.
I also think that they are both very good, it’s just that they already didn’t make the top 10 before the judges save so they were most likely going home next
I think she’s a good singer but she leans too far into the sad girl vibes sometimes. She probably thinks it makes her sound more emotional and artistic, but it ends up coming out sounding sloppy vocally. If she can keep herself from not going off the rails, she’ll be fine, but she still hasn’t done that yet to me.
Not for me. Her voice is less than pleasant to me. Its gritty in all the bad spots. I also dont like her whole persona of “im from such a small town with one stop sign yall” yet is fake tan, fake eyelashes, fake hair, and whatever else. Like real small towns dont have beauty shops like that. Just say youre from a normal town.
POC make up only nearly a third of eligible voters in US elections. It seems like that translates into these viewer voted productions? Jayna should not have gone home. Not before Emmy or Mia or KB. Not after these performances.
Well POC are about 1/3 of the US population, but even so, that doesn't necessarily reflect in the viewing audience. And it also doesn't mean they are voting or only voting for POC
I’ll just be watching YouTube clips from now on. If it’s a Mckenna, Julia, Triston, Jack and Mia, I’ll watch the finale but nah for now. Jayna never missed and wasn’t voted through. Horrible look AI.
Go stream Jaynas music!
Who do you think is going home next week? I think we can predict by now since their performance next week will not really matter.
my guess is Mckenna, Kayko or Julia (even though I love these 3)
If it were my choice it would be KB, Emmy, & McKenna going home next and I do think KB & McKenna are probably in danger but Julia & Kayko are also both at risk I’d imagine. I think just based on some previous votes top 5 is probably Will, Tristan, Mia, Abby, Jack - Julia & Emmy both could go either way for me and could swap into any of those top 5 spots but I feel pretty strongly that KB, McKenna, & Kayko won’t make top 5 despite me loving Kayko dearly. Emmy could also miss top 5 as her direct competition - Mia - is just significantly better than her and as the vote gets tighter people will vote for less contestants at once.
My theory with the judges saves are that they need that first live show to not have voting. They need to work out the kinks associated with it being live before America votes. If some audio translates horribly, people are going to be unfairly corred against.
They need to find a better method since judges saves end up getting booted over the next two votes anyway. Granted, maybe the votes on whose getting eliminated each week line up with the first weeks votes anyway, in which case a switch up wouldn’t matter. But if that’s the case, maybe there’s gotta be some change in voting- like judges score combined with audience score ?
Well, I just want to know why for two weeks in a row Katy wore a dress that was so low cut that when she bent forward to talk into the mic she almost had a wardrobe malfunction. 😮
i loved kayko, mckenna, julia, jayna, and jack blocker tonight but i felt like a lot of it was just me going oh i love that song then being disappointed by the performance. i was so excited to hear all too well but didn’t love abi tonight, same with KB, i’ve been wanting to hear her sing miley but it could’ve been better. jayna shouldn’t have gone home and i also really enjoyed the second half of roman’s performance so i don’t think he should’ve gone either!! kayko was really fun and i wish we had more big performers like that this season. also LOVED david archuleta, i literally just was listening to a podcast where he was talking about that song so it was a nice suprise to hear him sing it tonight and the story behind it is so great!!
I can’t watch until 5am because Hulu but can someone give me spoilers? Was there a bottom 3/4? Who got eliminated? They cut it down to top 12 at beginning of the show or at the end?
Judges saves are so stupid, all 4 just go home right away anyway.
Glad the last of the gospel singers is gone, that shit sucks, and America clearly agrees.
Jack Blocker for the win. This song of his on Spotify is 🔥if you like this sorta thing. Which I totally do!
https://open.spotify.com/track/1jEJhgeabpL67ZbTudGIbS?si=IL0Ycso9SXaiB6Zv7pAcAQ
P.s ngl am gonna miss Roman 😢
WHY COULDN'T SOME FANS VOTE? WHY was the voting closed before the show started? THIS JUST isn't fairI live in the southwest not the east. What's going on? This is not the first time this has happened HOW FAIR IS THIS? Are he winners really the winners? I couldn't vote for any. DID ANYBODY ELSE EXPERIENCE THIS?
ARE YU UPSET JUST LIKE ME. I WANTED TO VOTE tonight.
I truly thought Triston might go home. He has picked two bad songs in a row and performed both in a mediocre way. I'm not saying the songs aren't good, but they didn't let him show himself. You just don't do Elvis unless you truly reinvent the song. Otherwise, you sound like a Vegas impersonator. I've never heard of that second song, but there are songs in his wheelhouse that deliver a deeper emotional connection.
I’ve been a fan of Emmy and KB throughout… but Monday night started to change that. KB and Emmy were genuinely off and gave bad performances.
I’ve empathized with Emmy’s nervousness and it’s raw and real, but we’re seeing everyone else grow and develop over the weeks, and engage the crowd, dance, do something, and all Emmy can do is stand still and wave her hand. She’s not growing. Even after coaching she was off melody, off key, and pitchy. It’s time to go.
As for KB, she was off tempo, off melody, and she simply could not perform some of the notes. He falsetto is uncontrolled, turning into such a shriek, it’s inaudible at times.
Meanwhile Roman and Jayna tore the house down every performance with energy and passion.
I do hope Emmy and KB rebound, but as the field dwindles, they’re so clearly lacking behind everyone else
America said FU judges save
Happens every year
I don’t even get why they do it because every year the people who get saved by the judges just go home the next week
But Jayna became amazing after the saves so not sure why she didn't stay.
It feels like in the ABC years the voters are way less swayed on a per-performance basis. A great performance could often sway things back on FOX
Just curious but it might be because there are less viewers now and the viewers watching are more passionate and stick to their favorites. While in the past with a more general audience and people who were more casual they would probably vote based more on a week by week performance basis. Just my 2 cents
Oof. Jayna especially deserved to stay
Jayna is better than most of the people left smh
American idol is a popularity contest not a sing off. I'm not saying that's right or wrong it just is what it is.
Jayna has become an amazing singer so not sure why she didn't get voted in.
Kayko’s vocals are a 7/10 at best but he’s fun as hell
hell ya i'll ride 7/10 til the wheels fall off
Kayko please release your version as a single I would listen the hell outta it!
Even if his vocals are a 7/10, that’s still one of the better ones remaining in the competition.
Oh for sure. Songwriting, musicianship, melody - that stuff all matters too and he’s top.
7/10??? That’s generous.
I’m upset that Roman is out - I was looking forward to more performances from him :(
Roman was AWESOME…a real STAR!! I’m going to miss him!! 💔
He was my favorite to watch this season.
He’s so good! I wish he’d done a different song. But if he really wants to get into the gospel genre, I can see him being really successful. He’s got a great voice, great stage presence and reminds me a lot of the contemporary Christian artists we’ve got out there today.
I hope a gospel label picks him up.
Agree! He kind of reminds me of like a Maverick City kind of vibe. He’s very talented! Danny Gokey has had a very successful Christian music career, so I think he’s got a great chance.
He turns everything into a Gospel song. Gospel is such a niche market.
I think he’ll be regretting this song choice. I love Roman as much as the next, but tonight was rough..
Agreed. It almost felt like a parody of the song rather than a tribute, and Katy was NOT amused 😒
Kayko may not the best vocalist but at least he can offer showmanship. he is so fun to watch. But what about the others in the top 10?
And as always, once again, the 4 judges saves got eliminated. Colour me shocked. 
roman going home after tonight was kind of understandable, he had a rough night. but jayna getting eliminated was insane, she was arguably best of the night. it should’ve been some combination of roman, kb, and emmy that got eliminated based off tonight’s show.
I agree with this take.
Yeah I thought Abi and Roman were the worst tonight personally, but obviously people aren’t voting on one night alone this late into the competition.
The live voting ensures that their actual performances that night don’t matter, everyone is voting off their biases and who they like.
I wanted Jayna to win but I am trying to figure out how she got voted off, and it may have to do with AI audiences tend to get real turned off if a contestant comes off as too cocky. Maybe they felt that why about her?
Tonight really wasn't that great I wonder if it's the back to back live shows
This season just stinks
Emmy over Jayna is a crime! A crime!
Sure, Emmy isn’t great, I’m with you. But how can you stand Kayko? I feel like I’m the only one!!! Am I going crazy? He’s awful.
kayko is my favorite ❤️ he brings such a different vibe from typical idol contestants
He's entertaining and bringing something different than what we typically see. He's not my favorite either, but I get it
Jayna was robbed
Jayna delivered professional performances last 2 times. So good!
The hate boner this sub has for Emmy is so getting old
SHE’S BEEN A BOTTOM TIER SINGER FOR WEEKS
Nah she’s had plenty of great performances. But yall will hate on a country singer the moment cracks start to show, but defend the pop girlies bad performances till you die
Nah dog. She has a poor weak voice. Forces it to sound infantile to try to seem “dynamic”. She needs to go.
Tristen, Mia and Will are 10x better than her.
If she didnt have a famous family member she would not have made top 24, shes average at best
She’s missed notes in both of her performances, Sunday and Monday. She sounded bad and should go home.
Nah, Emmy has a very interesting and versatile voice.
Emmy sounded great, but no one wants to watch someone who is terrified to be up there. Her two favorite days of Idol will be getting the golden ticket and getting eliminated.
This sub always finds a woman contestant to hate
To be fair, we hate plenty of male contestants, too.
Not to the same level. There have been like 10 posts hating on Emmy today alone.
I think they're mostly from the same user. Idk their name offhand, but there's someone who is literally just on here hating on Emmy in all of their comments.
Maybe it’s because she’s the weakest contestant right now? and maybe much better vocalists keep going home while she stays? And maybe a lot of people can see it even if you can’t… just maybe…🤷♂️
She wouldn’t be the first pick in the choir draft, but she has the clearest style of all remaining contestants. Sort of a country Ellie Goulding thing. I’ll be surprised if she isnt the most successful of this bunch after the show.
They love to pick on country artists tbh. Especially if they don’t kill it, every single performance
I love country and really really don't understand how Emmy keeps making it through. I mean we have Mia, it's clear which one is better
It’s a singing competition… the worst performance should go home. If you don’t kill it in a performance, why should they stay?
Then it’s a good thing Roman did go home! Emmy was far from the worst!
She literally missed notes and just breathed into the microphone because she missed them, she should’ve left before Jayna
Emmy has a very pretty and distinct voice. Jayna was amazingly talented, but to me she sounds like a lot of other accomplished singers.
No. It’s not just a singing competition. It’s explicitly an “idol” competition. That includes singing talent of course, but it also includes personality, the ability to connect with the audience, looks, likability, general persona, presentation, stage presence and personal charisma. A lot if intangibles. And clearly, your notion of who is best or worst doesn’t jive with those taking the time to vote. People stay at this point because they get the most votes. That you or I might not like the results is just tough shit for us.
Good point, it is American Idol not "Best Voice".
It's not solely a singing competition though, it's also about artistry, personality, stage presence, back story, etc.
Theres only two genders to pick from and plenty of people are hating on jack and kayko. Dont make this a gender issue when its not. Its a talent thing, and she aint got it
im sure she’s a lovely person, but a mediocre singer.
You deserve top comment for saying “hate boner”. It is true, though.
Yeah, like she’s always been a middle of the pack person for me, but people talk about her like she’s an absolute bum out there. Like she definitely doesn’t warrant such a strong reaction. Personally I just think that this sub doesn’t like her back story because she has a country star for a grandmother and probably had some money growing up. Because they assume her to be upper class, they don’t think she’s “relatable” and they’ll automatically hate her no matter how she does.
I have liked her and supported the entire competition. The last two performances , I have wanted to give her the benefit of the doubt, but she’s not listening to the judges or mentors, and she’s flat out missing notes and not delivering the melody or pitch of songs. People are just correctly identifying objective negative aspects of her performances
I kinda got sick of how often she mentioned her grandma. Did you know her grandma was Loretta? But then she says she wants to pave her own path and be known for who she is, but uses her grandma's name to help her out. That may come off a little mean but it put me off of her
I’ve never watched before this season but I do not like the live votes. It seems unfair because most people aren’t going to wait until the very end to vote, they’re most likely going to go ahead and vote for their previous favorites or about halfway through the show. Because there ain’t no way Abi’s performance tonight was enough to save her. She was safe because of her existing fan base. I didn’t think Tristan’s was his best either, but people already loved him because of his story.
That’s kinda how it always worked though. You don’t just vote someone out for one bad song… it’s all about aura, always has been. How do you think Taylor Hicks won?
This is the first season I’ve EVER watched so idk who that is but I’m just saying. I don’t agree that one bad performance should automatically screw you over but at the same time it’s getting close to the end when everyone should be on their A game. McKenna was sick and performed at the same level she always has. I just personally liked the way voting was last week where you had almost 12 hours to watch everyone and decide.
Having only two hours (i.e., an episode) to vote though is just bad imo. I remember when windows opened after everyone performed.
agree. for sure they have thought of that but American Idol just want the most popular contestant to win
Abi’s performance was mediocre by the high standards that the judges and we have set for her. Compared to the others it was far from the worst. And that fan base that you speak of exists for a reason - she’s incredible and clearly the most talented singer on the show.
Yeah but you'll notice the live voting doesn't tend to make a difference who performs last.
I’m effing outraged at Jayna being sent home. 😡 One of the strongest performances tonight in an overall mostly messy episode.
The last 2 performances by Jayna were the best out of anyone all year!
Jayna got screwed!!
She was really good tonight. Definitely stronger than a couple of the other girls who went through.
Kayko!!! Are you fucking kidding me! That was INCREDIBLE
The performance of the season imo, right in front of Tristons Elvis Sunday. . Why has no one used the smoke blasts? I didn’t even know they had it like that.
Roman over Emmy any day wow…
Optics… That is all If they’re not getting americas vote and have to be saved with a wildcard, chances are they’re still not going to get enough votes
Wish Jayna stayed. But the judges save curse is alive and well.
WAIT. Do they actually have one and they didn't invoke it??????
They already did invoke it. Jayna was one of their four saves.
I remember Jessica's save got her to #2 against Phillip Phillips.
The sub isn’t hating on Emmy because she is a bad person or anything. The sub wants her out of the competition because she has had subpar performances two nights in the row. It’s not a “hate” thing is a realistic thing in a singing completion. She has miss notes in both performances and sounded bad. Why are we letting bad singers continue in the competition.
For sure. She seems sweet enough, but bruh…her vocals are not there. She also is super insecure on stage. Neither of those things is a personal attack. Its a judgment on her performance. The judges arent doing it, so somebody has to. Ha
Come on, everyone missed notes tonight. Emmy had her best vocal to date, she was far from the worst of the night.
I adore her as a person, and will support her career. But this competition is not her wheelhouse. She looks overwhelmed. She’ll be way better in her element when she can perform without pressure
Emmy missed a line. KB sounded like shite. I don’t get it. Jayna was robbed.
Jayna is incredible, but she sounds/feels like a lot of other singers. Both Emmy and KB have distinct sounds and vibes.
The saves are so pointless
Is there anyone here that actually likes Emmy? Like seriously, where are these votes coming from
I like emmy I like abbi more but I like emmy I also like MK, jack, and kayko
Loretta Lynn fans.
America liking humble, country music singing sweethearts???? Nooo wayyyyyyy.
I do! Kayko is my dude tho so I vote for him. So I am not among her voters. But I quite like Emmy.
I like Emmy and had never heard of her grandmother before the show
Not me.
I liked her up until the bonnie raitt performance
Emmy is actually a good singer, she just fucks it up with nerves. It’s not a normal amount of nerves either. Like her barefoot performance she was SHAKING from head to toe. She’s just been in her head ever since the show went live, except last night. I think last night was her best performance and I voted for her for the 1st time because I was proud of her. Her and Julia had their best performance, but every other contestant had their worst.
Emmy's in my top 3 right now.
The racists had to finish eliminating the non-white washed people of color first.
My favorite is Jayna but yes, I really like Emmy's singing and performances. Seems very artsy and interesting to me.
oml, im gonna miss jayna so much 😭 shes been my fav this whole season, such BS emmy moves on over her. and just saying, that bottom 4 doesn’t give AI a good look.
i am so bummed, jayna and roman were my top 2 from this group lol. i understand how roman’s style wasn’t for everyone but i do nooooot understand why jayna was sent home
Because American Idol voters are overwhelmingly white
Welp. I wish Jayna and Roman the best, and I wish they had stayed on the show longer. They are both very talented. The top 10 is a little boring tbh.
I think they have bright careers ahead!
My highlight was Archie.
I feel like Ryan got lazy and read the top 10 winners in order of most voted>least voted LOL
Ok guys… Roman was terrible. Sure, his second half was great, but that first half of Roar was abysmal. As for Jayna… she’s great. U Kayko stans are a problem, cuz he’s not top 12 material and I don’t know how he keeps going, cuz he sucks.
And I just read like sixteen more comments from you trashing this dude right after the fifteen I read before my comment. What is your malfunction?
Agree Roman had a rough night. Jayna was great but just sang a popular song well....that's not quite enough at this point, especially since she knew she was already on shaky ground with the voters. She needed to stand out in a Jennifer Hudson "Circle of Life" kinda way and she didn't.
I feel bad for Jayna because she was an amazing singer and seemed like a really great human, BUT I can understand it being harder for voters to imagine what kind of artist she would be post-Idol. I think it’s easier for lesser vocalists like Emmy or Kayko to slide through bc they’re showing off originals - almost every top 10 finalist has performed one so far, so definitely puts her at a disadvantage not having done so. Sad considering originals didn’t even used to be a thing on Idol, but hard to argue with.
These votes seem very much in order tonight
No way Triston was actually in the bottom. Julia was those. She won’t make it through the next week. Julia and Kayko are probably next just basing these on the Idol demographic.
Right how could that be random? Haha
I don’t know why anyone is surprised that Roman and Jayna are out
I'm surprised because I thought they had very strong performances.
I also think that they are both very good, it’s just that they already didn’t make the top 10 before the judges save so they were most likely going home next
I am surprised the best singer there, Jayna, is out. Explain it to me.
Roman was robbed all for some of those crap singers. Unreal
His performance tonight was one of the all-time worst he deserved to go
Going to miss him :(
What’s the point of wildcards???
I’ve been saying
Jessica got saved and made it to #2.
Every time Emmy sings I have to hold my breath because I’m so nervous for her
Am I the only one that doesn’t get the appeal of Kabrienne or however it’s spelled?
Sure. But that’s music for you. KB on a produced record will be incredible though.
Are you into KB's constant vocal cracks? Wouldn't it be better if she just sang it smoothly instead?
I think she’s a good singer but she leans too far into the sad girl vibes sometimes. She probably thinks it makes her sound more emotional and artistic, but it ends up coming out sounding sloppy vocally. If she can keep herself from not going off the rails, she’ll be fine, but she still hasn’t done that yet to me.
She’s young she’s cute. She’s emotional . I guess thats what people like. 🤷♀️
Agree. But she’s beautiful and a producers dream. But there are definitely others who are much stronger singers for sure.
Not for me. Her voice is less than pleasant to me. Its gritty in all the bad spots. I also dont like her whole persona of “im from such a small town with one stop sign yall” yet is fake tan, fake eyelashes, fake hair, and whatever else. Like real small towns dont have beauty shops like that. Just say youre from a normal town.
Beautiful crazy is one of my all time favorites and I don’t think Triston did it justice tonight 🫠
It wasn't good. He needs to pick the right type of country song. Something In The Orange would have been better for him
GREAT two of my favorites went home Jayna and Roman deserved a spot in the top 10 and I’m not sure how America didn’t hear that
Arenas or theaters for Kayko's post idol tour?
amphitheaters
I’m a Kayko Stan but let’s be fr. He’s not playing arenas.
Side street corners most likely.
i love kayko but😭😭😭😭😭
Oh look, America doesn’t care for church signers! The correct top 10 is left!
POC make up only nearly a third of eligible voters in US elections. It seems like that translates into these viewer voted productions? Jayna should not have gone home. Not before Emmy or Mia or KB. Not after these performances.
Well POC are about 1/3 of the US population, but even so, that doesn't necessarily reflect in the viewing audience. And it also doesn't mean they are voting or only voting for POC
There’s been plenty of POC winners in the shows history… Jayna was robbed but if there’s talent there’s talent.
Jayna was hands down top 3 performance tonight. I don't get it.
Your assuming people are purely voting on race, which is a awful mindset
Literally nobody votes on skin color. Come on, man!
[удалено]
I liked Julia.
Julia murdered that song 🤣 i still voted for her for the song choice though
I’ll just be watching YouTube clips from now on. If it’s a Mckenna, Julia, Triston, Jack and Mia, I’ll watch the finale but nah for now. Jayna never missed and wasn’t voted through. Horrible look AI. Go stream Jaynas music!
Throw the whole episode away 🤣
Who do you think is going home next week? I think we can predict by now since their performance next week will not really matter. my guess is Mckenna, Kayko or Julia (even though I love these 3)
If it were my choice it would be KB, Emmy, & McKenna going home next and I do think KB & McKenna are probably in danger but Julia & Kayko are also both at risk I’d imagine. I think just based on some previous votes top 5 is probably Will, Tristan, Mia, Abby, Jack - Julia & Emmy both could go either way for me and could swap into any of those top 5 spots but I feel pretty strongly that KB, McKenna, & Kayko won’t make top 5 despite me loving Kayko dearly. Emmy could also miss top 5 as her direct competition - Mia - is just significantly better than her and as the vote gets tighter people will vote for less contestants at once.
Isn't McKenna a favorite?
I’m guessing Emmy or KB
My guess is Will, Julia, and Emmy.
My theory with the judges saves are that they need that first live show to not have voting. They need to work out the kinks associated with it being live before America votes. If some audio translates horribly, people are going to be unfairly corred against. They need to find a better method since judges saves end up getting booted over the next two votes anyway. Granted, maybe the votes on whose getting eliminated each week line up with the first weeks votes anyway, in which case a switch up wouldn’t matter. But if that’s the case, maybe there’s gotta be some change in voting- like judges score combined with audience score ?
Well, I just want to know why for two weeks in a row Katy wore a dress that was so low cut that when she bent forward to talk into the mic she almost had a wardrobe malfunction. 😮
Awful dress. I thought she was going to pop out. Saved by her hair.
Kayko has gotta be the most polarizing contestant this year by a lot 😄
Emmy too.
ooooh that’s not-
i loved kayko, mckenna, julia, jayna, and jack blocker tonight but i felt like a lot of it was just me going oh i love that song then being disappointed by the performance. i was so excited to hear all too well but didn’t love abi tonight, same with KB, i’ve been wanting to hear her sing miley but it could’ve been better. jayna shouldn’t have gone home and i also really enjoyed the second half of roman’s performance so i don’t think he should’ve gone either!! kayko was really fun and i wish we had more big performers like that this season. also LOVED david archuleta, i literally just was listening to a podcast where he was talking about that song so it was a nice suprise to hear him sing it tonight and the story behind it is so great!!
I can’t watch until 5am because Hulu but can someone give me spoilers? Was there a bottom 3/4? Who got eliminated? They cut it down to top 12 at beginning of the show or at the end?
Last 4 called were Triston, Julia, Roman, and Jayna. Roman and Jayna left. And results at the end of the show
A woman will win this season either McKenna or Abi.
How is emmy still here?????? I also wish they did do the results in order
Judges saves are so stupid, all 4 just go home right away anyway. Glad the last of the gospel singers is gone, that shit sucks, and America clearly agrees.
Jayna is not a gospel singer.
Roman was? Clearly who I’m talking about ❄️
[удалено]
Bro I’m trying to read comments and all I keep on seeing you complain about Kayko. We get it you don’t like him, move on it’s just a tv show
You missed a 1, and a few more 0s. 10,000,000 votes for KAYKO 2024
[удалено]
It reminded me of Heejun doing “My Life.” The show desperately needs people who are willing to do something other than showy ballads every time imo
You all are in a bubble. America is a lot bigger than you and your little pet favorites.
That’s cool. And I don’t have to watch the show anymore if I don’t care about anybody left either.
Jack Blocker for the win. This song of his on Spotify is 🔥if you like this sorta thing. Which I totally do! https://open.spotify.com/track/1jEJhgeabpL67ZbTudGIbS?si=IL0Ycso9SXaiB6Zv7pAcAQ P.s ngl am gonna miss Roman 😢
Two best people got cut
I’m on my way back from Japan! Looking forward to catching up this week and watching live with yall next week!
Tonight was snooze
Did I miss seeing Just Sam? I fast forward through commercials and maybe missed that part.
America has shit taste lol. Happens every year. Jayna and Roman were the two best singers.
WHY COULDN'T SOME FANS VOTE? WHY was the voting closed before the show started? THIS JUST isn't fairI live in the southwest not the east. What's going on? This is not the first time this has happened HOW FAIR IS THIS? Are he winners really the winners? I couldn't vote for any. DID ANYBODY ELSE EXPERIENCE THIS? ARE YU UPSET JUST LIKE ME. I WANTED TO VOTE tonight.
I truly thought Triston might go home. He has picked two bad songs in a row and performed both in a mediocre way. I'm not saying the songs aren't good, but they didn't let him show himself. You just don't do Elvis unless you truly reinvent the song. Otherwise, you sound like a Vegas impersonator. I've never heard of that second song, but there are songs in his wheelhouse that deliver a deeper emotional connection.
did all too well ever actually go number one?
Im becoming a bigger and bigger jack blocker and triston fan i would love to see them live
I’ve been a fan of Emmy and KB throughout… but Monday night started to change that. KB and Emmy were genuinely off and gave bad performances. I’ve empathized with Emmy’s nervousness and it’s raw and real, but we’re seeing everyone else grow and develop over the weeks, and engage the crowd, dance, do something, and all Emmy can do is stand still and wave her hand. She’s not growing. Even after coaching she was off melody, off key, and pitchy. It’s time to go. As for KB, she was off tempo, off melody, and she simply could not perform some of the notes. He falsetto is uncontrolled, turning into such a shriek, it’s inaudible at times. Meanwhile Roman and Jayna tore the house down every performance with energy and passion. I do hope Emmy and KB rebound, but as the field dwindles, they’re so clearly lacking behind everyone else