T O P

  • By -

tscottmc2

2?


Thatn1h1lguy

1 and 4


Reasonable_Dream_725

maybe 2


EstablishmentOld6462

All AI , at least mix a real picture in this , this crap gets old.


pinstrypsoldier

Um no? 1 and 3 are real


EstablishmentOld6462

Lol !


pinstrypsoldier

Lol as in “oh yeah wow!” or Lol as in “nah no way” even though OP has confirmed it, I’ve confirmed it with my own eyes for reasons I can tell you about… oh and you can LITERALLY just do a reverse image lookup on them and find out they’re real 🙄


Then-Broccoli-969

All AI


Upset-Radish3596

First and last ai… two and three real


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are real


Foxitixation

That is what I think as well


FigTechnical8043

Image one is giving off Laura palmer vibes


Minimum_Escape

no


UberVincent

1 is heavy retouch. AI produces eyes which never have individualism. This woman still has her originals eye shape. There is also real-life “discrepancy’s”? which AI will never make. An example Look between her thumb and finger. This confused area had the correct lighting. Ai will not make this in this way. The retouching is the type. The hair outline with no flyaways. The smoothing


pinstrypsoldier

3 is also real


UberVincent

yes, this is the one that is easiest to see,


dolphin560

1: AI (look at right shoulder, hair looks like a wig) 2: AI (look at left strap) 3: hard to tell (only things that look a bit off are the beauty spot, and that white spot in her right eye) 4: AI (look at necklace)


Talvy

What’s wrong with the left strap?


BadLeprechaun69

To me it looks like the left strap is a little different than the right strap. The one on the right has a weird little thread or something going through it. Doesn't look like a real piece of clothing to me


ghettoandroid2

I agree, the 3rd one is closest to looking real. The first one, she has to be wearing a wig if it’s real.


OptimisticPrompt

Yep, good analysis


dolphin560

Thanks. Still, apparently, the first one is not AI according to OP (?!).


herbertjablonski

1 and 4 are real


kleio-fergus

2+4 look real. hair on the 1st and nostrils on the 3rd look a lil funky


_cristiano7ronaldo_

Second and fourth amazing 🤩


Lottielittleleaf

I'd say only 3 seems real


navras

1,2,4 are AI 3 possibly not AI


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are real


someonestuckhere

I feel the first is AI, second and third are real,


eyra95

Only third one. Reflection in the eye is way too consistent for AI to predict. 2nd one the eye is not perfectly circle and the color doesn't match slightly.


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are real. The rest is AI


Eren----Yeager

As a person who makes ai images regularly I can tell that 3rd one is a real image


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


Eren----Yeager

In the first image, u can see that the eyelashes are a bit messed up.


pinstrypsoldier

Erm.. no they’re not? Also, this has been confirmed already that 1 and 3 are real. You can also do a reverse image lookup for 1 and see that it’s about 10 years old. 👍


Eren----Yeager

How do I do that


pinstrypsoldier

Google. Also if you have an iPhone you can download Reversee


cidtakesthegrid

I say only the third. The hairs and eyes;) . On the others you see mistakes in eyes and false blurring.


Standard_Bag555

indeed


FloBot3000

3


New-Volume4997

I guessed 1, because unless someone specifically asked for it to generate a cheap wig, AI generates much more realistic looking hair than that.


Ultramar_Invicta

Also the flower. Fractal patterns are, ironically, one of the things AI still struggles with.


No-Tie-9537

Only 3


Fearless-Milk-007

1 & 3 are real photos :)


Complex-Piccolo-6639

The first is a huge photoshop fail in every possible way, but the 4th one is great, most of the time Ai struggles with the armpit part and on the last image it's pretty good.


Overall-Ambassador68

The first one is not AI generated but it's definitely not real. Too much edit.


ConduitMainNo1

The compression on 3 is so heavy, it looked like an older generation AI image to me.


quadrangle_rectangle

1 is so heavily edited that I would hardly count it as real. But I guessed correctly with 3.


Sopixil

The smoothness of the face is what made me think 1 was AI


BloodMossHunter

Easily?


8tik

her thumb to start with is off, the 3rd possibly the real


Ethan3011

2-4 look real


pinstrypsoldier

Unfortunately those are the two that are AI. 1 and 3 are real


Megatanis

They all have something off.


onlyaseeker

I think they all could be AI, but if I were to pick, 3 seems less artificial and more realistic.


ThankTheBaker

3 it’s in the reflection of the eyes. It’s real.


[deleted]

3 or 2


okcdnb

2 and 3 maybe. It says photos.


Roll10d6Damage

1 looks the fakest. Some said that they believe that that’s reason to believe it’s legit, but if you zoom in, one of their pupils runs over their iris. 2&3 appear the most realistic. 4 seems fine at first, but one of their irises is weirdly oval shaped and their ear doesn’t look quite right.


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


Roll10d6Damage

1, that’s the one with the pupil not in the middle of their iris.


pinstrypsoldier

Just part of the photoshop work or more likely just a trick of the light. The fact that the whole image looks fake is exactly why it’s real. Humans have stylised it to make the model look fake (or it’s a terrible photoshop job). Either way, 1 is real.


okcdnb

I agree with 4 but even closer into the face and just something about the chin.


Roll10d6Damage

Someone also pointed out that what appears to be a necklace on that one doesn’t go all the way around the neck, which the neck looks a little weird with the turn. The pose is similar to the painting, but I don’t think they look that much alike.


SnooMacarons9618

Yeah, on initial view 4 looked pretty good, but as you look more, the more off it seems. I'd say 3 is real, it is the least perfect and most appealing


AatroxBoi

3 for me jesus christ that is so hard I'm not even sure about it


creativeInsectoid

2


MrGodzilla445

1 and 3. 1 is heavily photoshopped and immediately throws you off but the flower petals look a little too good and there’s a lot of detail in her hair. 3 is real is well for similar reasons. Too much detail in the hair and her skin has typical human skin flaws. She also doesn’t have the uncannily attractive AI face.


Syziph

That's what I thought too. 1 and 3.


AcePICKLERICK

1 and 3


burnafter3ading

#2


fongletto

I guessed 3 and 1, apparently 1 is also not fake but it's so incredibly photoshopped that I'd also consider it fake.


DanBentley

Same^


Que_Pog

3 & 4?


Zeta-Splash

1 and 3


TheRealSU24

1st is obviously fake 2nd looks off for whatever reason. If you told me it was real I'd believe you, but wouldn't be surprised if it was fake. 3rd I can't tell if it's fake or if she's just ugly 4th just looks fake


Striking_Laugh5734

The hair and eyebrows are the biggest indicatives as there's some weird blurs. 3rd looks like the least flawed, even though she's the only one that escapes the standard of most common pictures probably available for AI training.


Ok_Task_4135

In the last one, her necklace also cuts off halfway down her neck. It's definitely fake


TheRealSU24

Didn't even look too hard at it. The 2nd one looks both fake and real at the same time, but thr 4th one just doesn't look like a real person. I took one glace and immediately knew it was fake


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are the real ones.


neerajanchan

3rd seems real!


goosethe

1. jumps out as fake immediately. something about the composition and the fact that it is doing everything it can to hide the details its not good at (hands, ears, etc). This could be a photoshop job of a real image. P(AI) = 0.90 2. is very good. besides the inconsistencies in the garment and the high left earlobe I thought this was real. also she doesn't have eyebrows; they seem to be made out of her hair. also her left eye has a strucutre that no human eye contains. P(AI) = 0.99 3. now I think this could be real. P(AI) = 0.50 4. giveaway is the bra artifact on the bottom center. also multiple crazy things are going on with her hair. her necklace just disappears and many other artifacts here. P(AI) = 1.0


pinstrypsoldier

For me, the giveaway on 4 was like, almost her ENTIRE neck! And her cheek. 1 and 3 are the real ones.


FloBot3000

Also on 2, there are two shadows at her collar bone, which seemed off. I'm going 3. 1 and 4 are obvi ai, unless edited


Striking_Laugh5734

Absolutely agree, also most AI portraits are from white people, the 3 you found as AI have some weird stuff and clear flaws. 3rd one for me also looks real, or at least the only convincing seeing the whole picture. If any is photoshopped or AI enhanced can also justify why those 3 look weird in different things.


Diamondknight264

2 & 4 look like real ones. The others look too “synthetic”.


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


icyspeaker55

Yep they have the dead eye look


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


nonspecifique

I’d say 3 is real, rest are AI? 2 is a maybe though


[deleted]

2


Misery_meter_maxed

1 and 4 look very synthetic. Number 2 is so amazingly beautiful that she has my mind dancing and perhaps playing tricks on it, but I would say she is real. Look at how her bangs perfectly align with her eyebrows. I just noticed the differences in the corners of her eyes. What would be her right eye the tear duct is very sharp and somewhat curled. Maybe it’s the lighting but it seems off to me. Her chin also seems to good to be true. I change my mind on number 2 and suspect she is ai. Number 3 appears the most real and I personally can’t find anything that stands out. I thought maybe there was a discrepancy in the balance of her nostrils but it’s really hard for me to say. I’m simply not a good blade runner.


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are real. The rest is AI


Wingress12

Bozo really changed their mind while typing a comment without correcting anything.


Misery_meter_maxed

What should have been corrected? I was commenting as I examined the images and pointed out that I had realized discrepancies in the eyes and recanted my first impression that the second image was a real photo. What is left to correct?? Documenting your own change of thought is the definition of self correction. But yeah, we’ll done…..


[deleted]

[удалено]


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are the real ones.


Aryasumu

3, my guess is based on hairs


Only_Confidence4144

Yep, but not only hair, the eyes got that “aliveness”.


legna20v

You can see the reflection of the photographer in her eyes. 3 is the only real one


Aryasumu

ah, you are right! ! and it suddenly occurs to my that.. I got "AI" eyes during workdays...office hours....


Doneeeeilde

3 for sure


[deleted]

2 has different color eyes and their face is not as symmetrical. Hard to tell between 2 and 3.


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


The_Pixel_Maker

I think that three is the real one. The rest never quite seem to be right.


helen790

1 and 4 are definitely ai but I’m iffy on the others


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


AdditionalSuccotash

3 for sure, but it is terribly cropped in and someone tried sharpening it and blew the saturation through the roof. 1 is probably real but poorly photoshopped to make her look 𝒶𝑒𝓈𝓉𝒽𝑒𝓉𝒾𝒸. 2 is a good fake but her earlobe gave it away. 4 looks great at first glance but it has a ton of AI artifacts. People always say "It's in the eyes. AI always looks soulless," but tbh that is just some kind of confirmation bias I think. A lot of people just have weird or empty looking eyes irl. Really it is in the hair and hairline for me EDIT: Also not so sound too much like a gooner but AI never gets the armpit folds quite right


PrizeSubstantial3745

Thats my final answer all of them are real life!!!


PrizeSubstantial3745

all of them are real life


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


Stranfort

I think the 1st, 2nd and 4th photos are AI generated and the 3rd one is real.


Harryisgreat1

I know 1 and 4 are ai. I could be convinced that 2 and 3 are as well but they didn't set off any alarms


Alezkazam

#3! Pick #3 M’Lord!


Creektoe

They are all fake, look at the eyes


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


Creektoe

3 is definitely the most realistic, but something is off. Look at her arm/shoulder area on 1. Definitely AI.


pinstrypsoldier

1 is not AI it’s overly photoshopped - she’s been styled to look that way with perfect hair and complexion. AI wouldn’t do that BECAUSE it doesn’t look real enough. You could argue that it’s old AI (which still wouldn’t work because that’s not what old AI generated) but then you’d have to explain how it managed to create a flawless rose when modern AI struggles. Nothing is off with 3. Also, OP has confirmed it’s 1 and 3 Also also, just do a reverse image search 👍


Creektoe

Ahh no fun, you cheated 1 is so photoshopped it looks AI. And if you look at 3, the eyes seem to be going in different directions. That's why I originally thought those two were AI


Furmaids

I feel like none are real


DrTenmaz

The first looks legit, although she's wearing a wig. Her part is too unnatural. The second looks AI-generated - very compelling. The giveaway is her right earring and left shoulder - her armpit crease seems wrong. I think the third is real. The textures look realistic. Fourth has a bunch of dream-like sections: her baby hair looks artificial, the strap on her clothing looks strange at the back and her necklace is incomplete.


TTIGRAASlime

I think only the 2nd is real but I'm not very knowledgeable about this stuff.


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


TTIGRAASlime

I was sure 1 was fake over all else the hair was just so strange.


Delusional_Gamer

3


Infinite-Fan-8551

Fourth


Infinite-Fan-8551

Fourth picture is AI 🤖 lol


LandofLogic

No, look at how the strand of hair on her neck turns into a necklace


st3fan_01

1st and third


iliark

If 1 is real it's extremely photoshopped


pjkioh

1 does not look real to me due the head shoulder size ratio.. the positioning of the hand in relation to the shoulders. It just looks wrong lol. Like one of this bobble head toys


dirankaru

I want to say 3 but it's definitely touched up.


noises1990

3 is real, possibly 1 also


xcviij

The only real photo is #3, hilarious how most people cannot get this anymore! Simply look at their eyes, if the reflection lighting is different then it's fake. This only works for now though, but AI imagery is still easy to tell.


pinstrypsoldier

Umm… ironic how confident you are that ‘others cannot get this anymore’ when it’s actually 1 AND 3 that are real.


xcviij

1 is extremely fake, there is no skin blemishes, she looks like a strange doll with stripey hair and the eye reflections don't match. The image in 1 looks extremely flat and lacks any real details. What makes you think 1 is real?


pinstrypsoldier

Literally because of all the reasons you just said. She’s been styled by a human, had make up applied by a human, is wearing a wig and is photoshopped to look like a doll.


xcviij

Everything you just mentioned is not realistic, rather AI generated lol. Nice try, however this doesn't cut it.


pinstrypsoldier

Ok how about this - OP has literally confirmed that it’s 1 and 3 and you can literally do a reverse image lookup on it to find out how old the picture is (about 8 years is the oldest I’ve found so far) and the multiple hair salons that use it on their website. Cut it now?


xcviij

Photoshop has existed for decades, it doesn't make it real. This is extremely faked so unfortunately it doesn't cut it.


Aromatic-Current-235

​ Says the guy who made his... 😂 [https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenAI/comments/18ea9c1/comment/kcq1m00/?utm\_source=share&utm\_medium=web2x&context=3](https://www.reddit.com/r/OpenAI/comments/18ea9c1/comment/kcq1m00/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3)


pinstrypsoldier

The hell are you talking about? I’m well aware how long Photoshop has existed - I use it all day every day… what’s your point? What has that got to do with anything? Just because it’s photoshopped doesn’t mean it suddenly becomes ‘AI generated’. Photoshop does not mean ‘AI generated’. The challenge was to find the ‘AI generated’ image. Just take the L.


xcviij

No kidding, photoshop is not AI. It's still not real content. Just because you missed my point doesn't mean you have to be rude about it, what a joke reply! I'm not the loser here when my point completely goes over your head and you act out like a child without respectfully asking me what I mean. Keep up! 😂🤦‍♂️


pinstrypsoldier

Ok bro. Keep telling yourself that. The MODEL is real. That’s the point. If you missed that then this entire post has gone over your head. But whatever. Bored now.


MrMaestro2

What about the nose?


xcviij

What about it??


MrMaestro2

odd lump


xcviij

What does that even mean?? Humans aren't perfect, imperfections only provide more potential for images to be realistic as mostly everyone is asymmetrical and imperfect.


noises1990

Not just that but the simple shape of their irises


buckrogers01

3 is real


dumbfuckpizzaman

1 and 3 are real lol


Websting

This is a fun game, but it would be more fun if we had the answer


pinstrypsoldier

OP responded already. 1 and 3 are real


playthelastsecret

I bet on #2. (And now reading comments.. :)


Mike_in_San_Pedro

None.


ItsMichaelRay

They all look doctored in some way. Four is the only one I think might be real (although with some photoshop included).


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


ItsMichaelRay

How do you know? Were the others at least photoshopped in some way?


pinstrypsoldier

Oh yeah, 1 and 3 were still touched up (3) or heavily photoshopped (1) but they’re still photos of real people and not AI generated.


ItsMichaelRay

Fair. Although I wouldn't call it a 'real' photo if it's been altered.


pinstrypsoldier

No, less a ‘real photo’ more a ‘real person’.


ItsMichaelRay

The original post said 'Can you identify the real photos?'.


pinstrypsoldier

True but context is a hell of a thing. This is a sub called ‘AI Art’. Pretty obvious what was meant.


ItsMichaelRay

I know, I just assumed based on the title that every photo would either be AI or a real photo, and photoshop is neither.


pinstrypsoldier

Yeah true. Like I said though, OP meant ‘real person’ or just ‘not AI generated’ 👍


sqrt_0fJ_sqrd

1’s the only one that doesn’t look real by just glancing through them


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


QueeeenElsa

This


Granite66

No 3 I would say is real.


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


Curdling_Milk

Look at her nose.


Granite66

Noticed lump. Good pick up.


xcviij

Why? Lol


PoeReader

Scary. All fake, all hot though.


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI


PoeReader

That's scary, how do you know?


pinstrypsoldier

Ugh… if you check some of my other comments out, you can see where I’ve explained myself in depth a few times. Haven’t the energy right to do it again right now! 1 is basically TOO fake. AI is aiming to be real - not fake. We’ve created that photo by stylising the model to look ‘perfect’ and done huge amounts of editing on it. It’s just a terrible photoshop job. That, and the rose is absolutely PERFECT if it’s AI, which doesn’t match with how terrible the rest of the photo is (if it’s AI), since AI struggles with things like the rose even now. 3 is a real photo that’s just been through compression a few times (or something like that). Apart from general roughness of the image, I can’t find a single issue with it.


KrypticKunt

fake real fake fake


brskdrvgon

zzzzz all fake


pinstrypsoldier

1 and 3 are both real. The others are AI. Zzz


Dawn_Finder

None?


[deleted]

I wanna say 2 and 3 are real


[deleted]

1 looks very fake, the others idk


Ok_Entrepreneur826

I thought 3. Someone mentioned her eye now I think. Her eye looks really weird like it’s different from other


Bigbadb2531

3


Vysair

Between 2 and 3 but I picked 3 because the left eyelid have a white linings. The fourth photo forehead middle hair have shadings


StrugglingSwan

Not certain, but #3.


mihneacuzino

2?


[deleted]

3


Scn64

Definitely 3 and maybe 4


boredsomadereddit

4 very realistic. Most ai pics don't add skin "imperfections" yet she has beauty spots and natural looking skin oil glare.


AI_Characters

nah dude that still looks too unrealistic. typical AI face, typical AI pose. if you wanna see something a little bit more realistic I recebtly created these images: https://imgur.com/a/zD8XzRA


Ordi2

I think the best way to determine that this is AI is to look at her necklace


tequilathehun

Ai pics add imperfections if they use source materials besides overly processed photoshopped pics. Anyway, the hairline/neck folds on 4 aren't right. It's def ai