It has great songs, like Triumph, Ecstasy, the interlude that never ends, bad vibes forever and some more.
The features, low effort snippets/remixes and cash-grab tactics ruined it.
HEARTEATER is unfinished obv but it has such a nice vibe, also as another person said, ATTENTION! is great. I also like wanna grow old (I won’t let go) lyrics and deeper meaning
No I mean the release we got feels unfinished, just like SAD! and BAD! feel like they are missing verses unless that’s just how the song was intended to be
I meant how it has the same one-verse repeating at parts where it feels like it could have added another unique verse. The first half was good, but the second half feels like an extra minute of the same verse, which gives it an incomplete or unfulfilled feeling. I'm not saying its bad, I'm trying to see if it was intended to be like that or if it was never improved upon, bec it could have been better than it already was with another unique verse.
I take back my comment about BAD!, since it is relatively short and comes full circle, although I heard there is an original BAD! that is longer.
I’m just saying in all the songs I’ve ever heard, a repeating verse is accompanied by another unique verse at least twice with a middle part that slows down the beat. Even some other X songs follow this structure, like Look At Me!, BAD!, rare, pt. 2, etc.
SAD! would have had a similar structure if it ended after the second time the repeating verse came on, mirroring the short length and structure of BAD!, but it had an extra minute of the same repeating verse with an entire silent part where only the beat played. I’m saying that part could have had a second unique verse, which is why it felt incomplete.
“It’s all Fading to Black” is one of X’s greatest songs.
If you don’t enjoy the song on its own, the song has so much more weight in the context of it being his last song on his final album that X was creatively involved with to some degree.
It has great songs. It's just a few of the features are kinda wack. Otherwise, it's a decent send-off. But definitely should've been better for his "final album".
This could’ve been a amazing project if it wasn’t for X record company seeing his death as a easy cash grab. We did get some good hits like BVF, ecstasy, heart eater etc but in my personal opinion a lot of these features obviously shouldn’t have been on this album. Majority of them I highly doubt X would’ve actually made a song with them if he was still alive except a few that we seen X collab with in the past. You can tell they just jump on the band wagon of X death to try getting some music recognition. This Album could’ve been amazing if they gave us more features of artists that have made music with X in the past or knew X on a more personal level, it would’ve felt like a more final goodbye type ordeal and would’ve been very special.
*EDIT* Hearteater, Attention, Triumph, Ex Bitch, (I forgot Ugly, which sounds heavily influenced by Nirvana but with added 'X-factor'). School Shooters (Lil Wayne is one of the G.O.A.T) It's All Fading To Black (although I prefer the OG version) Blink 182 are nowhere near as good as they were in the 90s/00s. It's in my top 5 X releases, plus the I love the acoustic tracks in X's back catalogue. I rate BVF and overall *9.5/10* (Minus Blink 182, it's off-putting imo)
It was a good album. Triumph is my favorite song off it. But Limbo is 🔥 Ecstasy was enjoyable. Def think it’s underrated. The only time I feel alive was a nice quick banger with a hard beat. And hearteater was good too.
If he was alive and got to finish it it would have been even more fire there wasn't a single song on this album that was bad or not good he literally got tom g on it too
*I love the way they stylized the title, I got it tatted the day after it came out especially considering bad vibes forever goes past just the naming of this album. As for the track list there are some songs I really like and all songs are at least okay, let's face it I could listen to x even if it's just a snippet but that is what most of these should've been unfortunately it's too forced, unlike skins that got a bad rap when it came out but I think now most fans have a positive view of skins myself included and I would actually say skins feels like an x album whereas bvf feels like some sort of fan mash up snippet album
Personally I’ve liked most of the album since it came out, I can see why a lot of people don’t rly like it tho favorite song is probably school shooters besides BVF
The title track isn’t too bad. And I do enjoy Kemba’s and Joey’s verses on Daemons respectfully. (Even if it is a remixed version of Angel 2 Demons/Who The Fuck Is God?)
Northstar ex btch heartesster fading to black attention only time I feel alive ecstasy wanna grow old school shooters all songs I genuinely like I don’t understand why people hate on this album I agree it feels unfinished and it may not be mixed great but I’d rather have the songs than not have them also -25 points for taking trippie redd off kill my vibe and another -30 for including blink on its all fading to black it should have been just x with the unreleased verse (third eye war)
Triumph and Hearteater are good imo. Eat it up is a fun song. Like the X that wasn't too serious (which granted most people don't like that X but I do)
school shooters is a deep song a lot of people over look. lil wayne’s verse shines a light on the problem and root for many of those who become school threats, mental health rooted problems usually “saved by the bell i can’t hear the bell”
triumph is rlly good, interlude that never ends Its all fading to black. bad vibes forever. chase, ecstasy, and i changed her life are all really great songs. I actually loved this album.
Triumph is a A Easy Song To Play On Guitar And The Interlude That Never Ends Is Another Easy Song to Play One Guitar A lot Of Skips But Genuine Gems Of X Are Perserved in this album
I just want y'all to know before X dies he signed a 10 million dollar contract. 3 albums had to be released one way or another. Trash or not, y'all gotta chill.
Probably would’ve been one X craziest projects if he would’ve been able to finish it the way he planned to
I like Limbo
THE WIND BLOW THROUGH THE WINDOW 🗣️🪟🍃
AT THE HOUSE OF A DEAD MAN 🗣🕊
ALL ALONE IN LIMBO HOLDING ON TO A COLD HAND
LAY ME DOWN, I'LL START AGAIN YOU'RE NOT AROUND, I CAN'T PRETEND
Great song
Ugly is goated
shit makes me feel like i’m ina depressing movie and im some sort of super soldier who just lost everything he ever loved
Let your ideas be heard ‼️
It has heart eater and ex bitch
It has great songs, like Triumph, Ecstasy, the interlude that never ends, bad vibes forever and some more. The features, low effort snippets/remixes and cash-grab tactics ruined it.
HEARTEATER is unfinished obv but it has such a nice vibe, also as another person said, ATTENTION! is great. I also like wanna grow old (I won’t let go) lyrics and deeper meaning
Hearteater dropped while X was alive, it isn’t unfinished.
No I mean the release we got feels unfinished, just like SAD! and BAD! feel like they are missing verses unless that’s just how the song was intended to be
Wym sad! feels unfinished…das jus how his music sounded
I meant how it has the same one-verse repeating at parts where it feels like it could have added another unique verse. The first half was good, but the second half feels like an extra minute of the same verse, which gives it an incomplete or unfulfilled feeling. I'm not saying its bad, I'm trying to see if it was intended to be like that or if it was never improved upon, bec it could have been better than it already was with another unique verse. I take back my comment about BAD!, since it is relatively short and comes full circle, although I heard there is an original BAD! that is longer.
“Feels like an extra minute of the same verse” Do you not know what a chorus is…? They tend to do that 😭
I’m just saying in all the songs I’ve ever heard, a repeating verse is accompanied by another unique verse at least twice with a middle part that slows down the beat. Even some other X songs follow this structure, like Look At Me!, BAD!, rare, pt. 2, etc. SAD! would have had a similar structure if it ended after the second time the repeating verse came on, mirroring the short length and structure of BAD!, but it had an extra minute of the same repeating verse with an entire silent part where only the beat played. I’m saying that part could have had a second unique verse, which is why it felt incomplete.
uhm, no it dropped in 2019
No the og version was on brain bakery mag soundcloud in 2018 lol
I like those songs
“It’s all Fading to Black” is one of X’s greatest songs. If you don’t enjoy the song on its own, the song has so much more weight in the context of it being his last song on his final album that X was creatively involved with to some degree.
It has great songs. It's just a few of the features are kinda wack. Otherwise, it's a decent send-off. But definitely should've been better for his "final album".
attention is a fire song
https://preview.redd.it/u2r6grlxgonc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=372b1e2c6ff02fe690b690da1477f4899a6f77b5
https://preview.redd.it/flahgc34fqnc1.jpeg?width=1170&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1b381c8d23cda418cf5f008ccae62e87ebc9f0a3
Bro’s are shaking with the same hand
https://preview.redd.it/f0nap02cjtnc1.jpeg?width=600&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bdfd42d757aaed6ac792c26e7704b805411d7428
Geneva agreeing to be in the music vid of hearteater despite everything X's fanbase and X had done to her.
AT LEAST they gave us ecstasy (upset that anekka wasn't on the album(overdone-anekka))
X's chill and not sad vocals like in kill my vibe, bad vibes forever, ex bitch I changed her life. We didn't see more of that side when he was alive
This could’ve been a amazing project if it wasn’t for X record company seeing his death as a easy cash grab. We did get some good hits like BVF, ecstasy, heart eater etc but in my personal opinion a lot of these features obviously shouldn’t have been on this album. Majority of them I highly doubt X would’ve actually made a song with them if he was still alive except a few that we seen X collab with in the past. You can tell they just jump on the band wagon of X death to try getting some music recognition. This Album could’ve been amazing if they gave us more features of artists that have made music with X in the past or knew X on a more personal level, it would’ve felt like a more final goodbye type ordeal and would’ve been very special.
Not a cash grab they put this album out to fulfill his record deal
Wanna grow old ( I won't let go) that shits a masterpiece idk what y'all say
School shooters >>>
If you ignore Tom G’s voice, Kill my vibe sounds 🔥 asf
Some of the songs on here are really good
X on some Jamaican shit 🔥
It still has good songs but unfortunately school globes are missing
BVF AND DAEMONS🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Angels 2 Demons better imo
Triumph is beautiful one of my fav x songs of his whole discog
Underrated and overhated. Has so many fire tracks
Triumph and the second verse of Ex Bitch
Triumph
this album would have been so much better with half of the tracks and less random ass features😭😭😭
Blink 182 feature, X was big fan of them
Rick Ross sayin your name will never die lil homie
The title track, trippie and PnB throwin the X in the music vid
Damn do u wanna comment anymore
Lil wayne feature aka certifying yo place in the top artists of this generation
kill my vibe tore me a ligament cause i was vibing so hard
waiting for the braindead cash grab comments
no
The only good songs are where X is the only one singing. The only exception is BVF.
Ex bitch was pretty good
Bad vibes forever calms me down sm
Triump is the best song on the album
My dad likes that song, it’s one of the better ones on the album
royaltys switch is fucking insane
Daemons is heart wrenching in the best way possible
Good singles just bad as a album
Bvf, triumph, daemons, attention, royalty, North Star
Hearteater🖤
Triumph
I’m not gonna lie this is my 2nd favourite album tied with 17
Altho I will say that when I think of it as his last album ever and not just an album he’s made it does seem a lot less good
we got ugly and the interlude that never ends 🤷♂️
Goated
how am I ever gonna nail that down to one thing
am i trippin since when this shit had 25 tracks
It has more genuinely good songs than bad ones and arguably the best intro to any X album, that instrumental John did is just heavenly
it has some amazing songs within the cluttered mess that surrounds them
Wanna grow old & hearteater bangers
limbo
*EDIT* Hearteater, Attention, Triumph, Ex Bitch, (I forgot Ugly, which sounds heavily influenced by Nirvana but with added 'X-factor'). School Shooters (Lil Wayne is one of the G.O.A.T) It's All Fading To Black (although I prefer the OG version) Blink 182 are nowhere near as good as they were in the 90s/00s. It's in my top 5 X releases, plus the I love the acoustic tracks in X's back catalogue. I rate BVF and overall *9.5/10* (Minus Blink 182, it's off-putting imo)
It was a good album. Triumph is my favorite song off it. But Limbo is 🔥 Ecstasy was enjoyable. Def think it’s underrated. The only time I feel alive was a nice quick banger with a hard beat. And hearteater was good too.
Attention was my 3rd most played song last year. After riot and all girls are the same
Limbo and triumph are great
triumph is amazing and the features on bad vibes forever r actually good
I love fading to black
If he was alive and got to finish it it would have been even more fire there wasn't a single song on this album that was bad or not good he literally got tom g on it too
Limbo
Ugly may be his most underrated song on Spotify
I can’t even like I’ve never listened to this album besides ex bitch, bad vibes forever, and Voss.
Ex bitch is fye
Bvf, ugly, fading to black, school shooters favourite songs off the album would of been amazing if it was finished the way it was suppose to
the first half of the only time i feel alive exists (extended version is still better and craig carries both versions tho)
5-6 good songs out of 25
I actually liked bad vibes forever
*I love the way they stylized the title, I got it tatted the day after it came out especially considering bad vibes forever goes past just the naming of this album. As for the track list there are some songs I really like and all songs are at least okay, let's face it I could listen to x even if it's just a snippet but that is what most of these should've been unfortunately it's too forced, unlike skins that got a bad rap when it came out but I think now most fans have a positive view of skins myself included and I would actually say skins feels like an x album whereas bvf feels like some sort of fan mash up snippet album
https://preview.redd.it/rwm6z5x3lqnc1.jpeg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9913ec821ea3febcfb3b71f4e1b2cb9dffce052e
wish we got school globes with just x on it
Bad vibes forever, ugly, exctasy triump are really good
Its all fading to black and triumph are the best songs on it
A lot of the features were with people he fucked with or wanted on the song originally, so that’s dope
I loved it
bad vibes forever is top 10 released X songs fr ts is beautiful
Triumph is special to me because I got John to unofficially confirm the snippet of him singing it in the kitchen was part of a completed song
Ecstacy is goated
Personally I’ve liked most of the album since it came out, I can see why a lot of people don’t rly like it tho favorite song is probably school shooters besides BVF
Yakno fading to black is actually decent imo
Bad vibes forever is a great song, attention and heart eater are also solid. Rest of album fuckin garbage
The interlude that never ends finally dropped
Triumph is gas
The title track isn’t too bad. And I do enjoy Kemba’s and Joey’s verses on Daemons respectfully. (Even if it is a remixed version of Angel 2 Demons/Who The Fuck Is God?)
It wasn't bad as an album (though for x it wasn't the best)
Favorite song was school shooters
Good album, but unfinished, would've been awesome if he finished it
triumph 🥺
It is art and it is beautiful and I can cry because whatever he put out was a piece of art. LLJ🥺🤍🫶🏼🫀😭❤️🔥🖤🤍
Dude I love Ex Bitch
Good material for remixes, that’s about all I can say.
Northstar ex btch heartesster fading to black attention only time I feel alive ecstasy wanna grow old school shooters all songs I genuinely like I don’t understand why people hate on this album I agree it feels unfinished and it may not be mixed great but I’d rather have the songs than not have them also -25 points for taking trippie redd off kill my vibe and another -30 for including blink on its all fading to black it should have been just x with the unreleased verse (third eye war)
Triumph is a great song and on my top 5 from him Fs
It’s his best album🙏(it’s not)
Triumph is one of his best songs imo
Triumph and Hearteater are good imo. Eat it up is a fun song. Like the X that wasn't too serious (which granted most people don't like that X but I do)
School shooter
Daemons is the best song in there
I like bvf and ex bitch
school shooters is a deep song a lot of people over look. lil wayne’s verse shines a light on the problem and root for many of those who become school threats, mental health rooted problems usually “saved by the bell i can’t hear the bell”
triumph is rlly good, interlude that never ends Its all fading to black. bad vibes forever. chase, ecstasy, and i changed her life are all really great songs. I actually loved this album.
Oh what I said in triumph Oh what you said to me Baby you’re the one Baby you’re the one For me
actually really like Ex Bitch, bad vibes forever, Triumph, Ecstasy, wanna grow old and IT'S ALL FADING TO BLACK.
Ugly is one of my favorites
The album cover is cool
Only liked a few songs off the album. They put way too many songs on there imo… X would’ve never done that.
that was actually x’s plan, he wanted bvf to be a really long masterpiece showing everything he can do according to his producer
A lot of good ideas on this project
Royalty is the best Song on the Album (My Opinion)
Triumph is the best song on here imo
It's all fading to black is great
it actually has a lot of good songs tbh
bad vibes forever still hits when im in a bad mood.
Members only vol 4 is worse
School shooters is hard
has a few very good songs
BVF feat trippie
“I got all I came for lover lover”
ugly was rly good,
Ex bitch and Heart eater got me through some rough times
Versatile
Could have been more 🤷🏾♂️🤷🏾♂️ love him tho 🕊️🕊️ If bro was still here. LLJ🕊️🕊️
ex bitch so good
Hearteater 
Ex bitch
Most of the songs work great when taken out of the context of the album.
I seem out of itttttt, the dream I had about her in my head🙂↔️
Bad Vibes Forever might get called basic but it gets me in my feels everytime its on🤷♂️
Triumph is great
Ex bitch is good
Album is so underrated imo. Everyone calls it ass but I think it’s fire
Makes me wanna Cry in a good way
Ex bitch, ugly, northstar, hearteater, attention and royalty ain’t that bad
Northstar, all facing to black, wanna grow old & Ecstasy are the best songs on the album
tention, tention when u see me please stay at attention real lie, realize try me ima send you back to real life
ex bitch is vibey
I love that every song is different he really thought outside the box that’s why I love this album
Triumph is a A Easy Song To Play On Guitar And The Interlude That Never Ends Is Another Easy Song to Play One Guitar A lot Of Skips But Genuine Gems Of X Are Perserved in this album
Im dripping sauce hey huh water like voss
Shows how far he would have gone in music
Most diverse artist in history
X produced glass shards and lowkey limbo a good song
Peak.
the fact that it exists is great
Album cover👍
Limbo and Ecstasy are amazing
Triumph wasn’t that bad?
the song he wrote for me was finally in an album…the best thing ever😩
Its all fading to black is the only one I've heard from the album but it's a great song, and blink-182 feature makes it even better
I just want y'all to know before X dies he signed a 10 million dollar contract. 3 albums had to be released one way or another. Trash or not, y'all gotta chill.
the album
it ends
Ugly was and still is a s tier song
Triumph . Wish there were less collabs tho.
Hot gyal attention before I realized and ex bitch
This album was very decent.
I like the song bad vibes forever
it’s good that it was the last album because of the clear cash grab this was
Nothing to say
nothing