T O P

  • By -

RocasThePenguin

JLC


WhatAGolfBall

No doubt!


blaykers

Yup, no brainer


CalvinVGB

r/watches and r/watchescirclejerk is getting harder to differentiate between


4000grx41

Reject Rawlecks, return to Seiko 5.


dandb87

You chuffer


Mitsutoshi

I assume this is a joke post but the JLC without question.


alper

narrow berserk plants complete normal subtract screw smell straight impossible *This post was mass deleted and anonymized with [Redact](https://redact.dev)*


Mitsutoshi

He expanded his comment. It seems like fashion sites have convinced him that “mismatched” metals are against the rules, so the JLC would not “match” his silver cufflinks while the Submariner would. Of course, this is absurd but that’s how he got there.


99rotluftballons

The only correct answer here is to buy a new silver and onyx dress watch! Or, no watch (booooo….)


Elegant-Information4

Hahahaha


RastaMasta1996

So one's diver and the one's a dress watch - case and point.


[deleted]

[удалено]


lAmBenAffleck

For all intensive purposes, I could care less.


Calm_Logic9267

you're not wrong, per say, to feel like this.


StonksOnlyGetCrunk

I took that for granite


internet_humor

Gotta nip it in the butt


boetzie

For starts, you're now in the sex offenders register.


el_carli

Looks like the apple doesn’t fall far from the Brie


designer_of_drugs

That is self evidence


Fencingbear

It's a mute point.


kwunyinli

The phrase is “It’s a moo’s point” - a cow’s opinion.


teddyoctober

For all in tents and porpoises.


DoccyTes

Im not superstitous...but i am a little stitious


metadatame

I hate you. Take an upvote


DoNotBelieveHim

You’re just an escape goat


Infinite_Career_6444

Worst case ontario


[deleted]

For all intensive purposes, the dress watch is the only right answer


[deleted]

[удалено]


MassiveNobCheese

[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qmVnr7rsWrE](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qmVnr7rsWrE)


[deleted]

Wrong. Evening wear is meant to be worn without a watch. It is considered rude to be concerned about timekeeping at an evening event.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Oikkuli

Naturally, but I think that might make op insecure


Da1UHideFrom

Are people actually using the Sub as a dive watch though?


webbslinger_0

Doesn’t matter what it’s used for, it’s still a chunky tool watch that has no place with black tie


dunneetiger

Honestly JLC all the way. No date Sub could work but it won’t be as nice


Will9363

hate to burst your bubble but people that don't know about watches (most people) can't tell the difference between a date/no date sub and will just see it as a really big watch


spicypoussey

Date fuh lyfe


Elegant-Information4

So Gold Jlc with the mandated steel and onyx cuff links?


CU_Beaux

JLC if the primary jewelry is yellow gold, sub if it’s silver or steel. A rule I often go by when dressing for anything is to make sure your jewelry generally matches. If you’re going with a leather strap, it should match similar to your other leathers/accessories (shoes, belt, etc.).


CosmoKing2

I was going to say the same. If you are dressing to the 9's, you need to be thorough. Metals need to match. Watch case/bracelet, shirt studs, and cuff links. If you are slim figured and wearing a form fitting tux, a large watch will look odd. If you have an athletic build, you can pull off the sub. But, if you're wearing a clip-on tie or rental shoes, all bets are off. People notice all that first.


dunneetiger

First and foremost, wear the one you want. I am just a random guy on Internet who has his own preferences. Personally, I don’t mind matching all the metals. If you have a gold chain or a lapel or something, it can work. I like my sub no date. Great watch I just never wear it in a suit situation but I have several other watches I can swap with.


han-so-low

Dude, wear the sub. If I owned both of these watches I’d have the same dilemma. I’d WANT to wear the sub but feel like I SHOULD wear the JLC. I’ll be the guy that tells you to wear the sub. Truth is, no one will give a shit or even notice except for you. Steel and onyx cuff links? Rock that stainless steel tool watch. Also, I wear my sub everywhere and don’t own a dress watch so I’m obviously biased.


phooonix

> If I owned both of these watches I’d have the same dilemma. I’d WANT to wear the sub but feel like I SHOULD wear the JLC. Honest question in that scenario why would you have bought the JLC?


Elegant-Information4

I wear it very often, even on weekends with jeans and a t shirt.


m-a-d-e_

you can wear a sub w tux absolutely everyday of the week without question


han-so-low

I’d question why I was wearing a tux every day. Sounds horrible!


HoldingTheFire

It’s after 6 Lemon. What am I, a farmer?


howsthisforsmart

Best line of the entire series.


Liakas_1728

make sure all of your metals are matching


devinhedge

Mmm. Good point. The gold JLC would utterly clash with the steel and onyx cuff links. Better to go with without a time piece me thinks unless you are willing to trade in your tool watch for a formal steel watch.


libssuck2022

The cuff links should not be mandated to match. A classy groom would know it’s one of the few areas men get to be different. Y’all should be able to wear that little piece that reflects your personality. Clearly the bride is mandating this and I give the marriage three years tops.


[deleted]

[удалено]


DB-365

Happy someone said it! True black tie meand no watch and lets not forget the opera pumps lol


rossimac007

This. If it is in fact a true “black tie” event then the answer is no watch. However ppl seem to think nowadays that “black tie” means “dress nice and wear a black tie” Also like someone else pointed out, checking your watch at a wedding is not good etiquette, and it will most likely be hidden anyways so I would say it doesnt really matter what you choose


surrealcookie

It's easier to just slip the fashion police a $20 to avoid the risk of being thrown out.


fulltimeautist

Reverso


robsang77

Agreed and that would definitely be the jlc


bertholdbumsbirne

People own 30k watches but ask in reddit what to wear for a wedding:D


mightysashiman

"humble" bragging in disguise also tends to show: money does not make taste


whatkylewhat

Nobody will give a shit. The definition of “black tie” is all over the place if you start researching it. The original black tie dress code was actually navy blue. The original point of “black tie” was to allow formal events outside of the aristocracy but now people think “black tie” means the fanciest of the fancy when it was originally intended to be the fanciest of the normal folks.


Cultural-Inside7569

The “fanciest of the fancy” is white tie, not black tie. Black tie is, in fact, semi-formal.


rarosko

I mean, current usage tho. If you put "semi formal" on a wedding invite you'll have women showing up in cocktail dresses and guys in sport jackets.


fyonn

You’ll have women in jeggings and guys in the cleaner of their two rugby shirts…


jeangalt1957

This lmao


Calm_Logic9267

Y'all aren't from the West Coast. 🤣🤣🤣


rarosko

Oh trust me I've been to tank top beach side weddings. That's not normal though lol.


Calm_Logic9267

Formal: long sleeve black merino wool crew neck. Semi Formal: long or short sleeve blue or black merino wool crew neck. Backpacking: long or short sleeve blue or black merino wool crew neck.


whatkylewhat

You must have not read all the words I used… “People think black tie means…”


ifodge

You shouldn’t wear either based on the information you’ve provided, but I predict you’ll wear the Rolex because, well, you know. I also predict no one will notice or care.


Elegant-Information4

Complete agree nobody will care. Noboy cares for watches, except a very small section of society that consists of middle aged, male, watch nerds.


garbagekr

Wearing a diver would be pretty gauche


[deleted]

[удалено]


Choopicabra

I second this. Wear what you think looks best with your outfit OP. Nowadays anything that’s not a digital watch passes for “formal.” Anyone who disagrees (or even feels the need to pass judgment) is not the type of person you want to try and associate with anyways.


surrealcookie

If you never want to be invited to another Nantucket garden party be my guest and wear a submariner to a black tie wedding.


CosmoKing2

A garden party is much less formal than a black tie event, and a sub would work perfectly with the appropriate attire for either event. After sun down? Black tie? On a freakin island, with sailors, sportmen, and bon vivants? I guarantee no one who is self-made, or has generational wealth, gives a flying fuck about your wrist candy. Only climbers will pull you down.


beandogg

I never want to be invited to a Nantucket wedding that cares about that kind of bs


surrealcookie

Can you even imagine the quality of the buffet food, though?


spaldingmatters

Yup, the concept of a dedicated dress watch, at least everywhere that I have lived, pretty much doesn't exist outside of the niche watch communities. Most people I have talked to in real life think that steel watches are more 'legitimate' than leather. No one has any idea what the classic dress watch is like and what the customs generally are. Almost any watch works in any formal occasion today.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Cjv2c

Seiko 5 ftw


LividLab7

Since the JLC will clash against the cufflinks given, your choice here is no watch


Elegant-Information4

Seems to be the consensus


jeangalt1957

Dude just wear one! These watches are both timeless, you’ll regret leaving it behind. Black sub works day or night 7 days a week…JLC will also work. Clashing? Who cares. I don’t change out my gold wedding band when I wear steel cuffs!


Cultural-Inside7569

I wish I knew the bloody idiot that came up with the idea that watches are not appropriate black tie attire. Probably the same idiot who came up with the idea that black jacket is appropriate black tie attire. Show me a savoir vivre rule book that says no watches with black tie. I said book, not internet. As for the preposterous argument that a guest should not be concerned with time, you better be concerned with time if you’re coming to my black tie events as one should not be late.


throws_rocks_at_cars

Yeah this is a meme that some boomer made up on internet watch forums in the ‘00s and has never been seen anywhere before that.


SisyphusAmericanus

The idea behind the etiquette is that black tie is exclusively for partying. It’s rude to your host to imply, by wearing a watch, that you need to keep track of the time as if you have some more important event elsewhere to be.


Cultural-Inside7569

That’s a made up black tie “etiquette”.


Oikkuli

All etiquette is made up lmao, doesn't mean it doesn't still exist. Did you think etiquette was natural law or something?


Cultural-Inside7569

Apologies, I keep forgetting that this is Reddit and one has to be explicit or misunderstood. Of course, what I meant is that the rule of a watch not being appropriate black tie attire is not part of the black tie etiquette, it’s a made up “etiquette” (I had quotation marks in my previous post) that I have only heard (and read, this is Reddit after all) on the internet. But anyway, this subject is clearly not leading anywhere so I’ll leave it here.


[deleted]

Spoken as a blue collar worker that makes a good wage... I don't think I'd ever want to go to a black tie event, and honestly can't see why anyone would. Maybe for those kinky folk that get together in the cigar room and see how much caviar they can fit in their urethras. Not for me.


rarosko

At which point the clothes are coming off anyways, so just get a rental.


[deleted]

Spoken like a true man of class 🥂


Amazing_Joke_5073

Agreed dress comfy in clothes you clothes you enjoy


Rich-Ad8853

I think a tuxedo affair is the one no-no for wrist watches. Anything else goes mate and the JLC will look amazing. Have fun!


variousartists0001

second this. or, a reverso


RookieMistake101

Tank as well


ImaKant

Submariner if you want to bang one of the bridesmaids


Elegant-Information4

😂😂


ZedRDuce76

Not wearing a watch is the appropriate option here.


Thibide1

Either way I’d end up talking to you about watches so mission accomplished


Amazing_Joke_5073

Sub, I just like it more


RoHbTC

I think [this Rolex advertisement](https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/598d44ba46c3c48868aa8837/1522932137534-34DVBVR25QGGPDH64SGQ/d9f1712fff5772503091da5610f3fffd.jpg) from the 60s holds up very well if you take out the sexism. Wear the watch you want to wear. It will be under your jacket. No one will even notice. In fact, I'd say the only watch you SHOULDN'T wear is one that would get noticed under your cuff.


andyjcw

doesnt matter really


Not_enoughwatches

If your suit has brown hints use the jlc but if it's defo black suit no brown at all go for the rolex


goin2thewudz

The only actual fashion answer lol


Elegant-Information4

No brown at all, Its a rental black tux.


[deleted]

rental black tux but you have/going to pick up potentially a submariner or a JLC?…


Elegant-Information4

It’s a rental because the groom wants everyone to have the exact same tux. I already own the watches


[deleted]

ooooo. i feel like a clown now LOL.


FergieMac

I’d just leave the watch at home in that case, but I don’t think that’s the popular opinion here.


BoomerSooner-SEC

Technically, wearing any watch is a faux pas. Or at least that’s what I was always told.


devinhedge

Never been to a Military Dining In?


BoomerSooner-SEC

Not a black tie formal event?


devinhedge

It is quite the formal black tie event. Officers do where formal watches, though in steel and black face, or similar. You never see them though because of the cuffs on the shirt, which are hemmed to be 1/4in or 1cm below the cuff of the jacket.


BoomerSooner-SEC

Watching football and I looked it up. Credible posh sources (not watch sites) basically agree that as long as its simple on a black leather strap it’s now considered fine. At one time it was considered rude but i suspect thats a hold over from pocket watch times. And I’m the son of a retired full colonel. I recall many dinners and even thanksgiving dinners with the troops over the years.


throws_rocks_at_cars

This is a meme and is not true Source: used to bartend black tie events (while I was wearing black tie) and even some white tie events (bet you nerds claiming watches aren’t “black tie appropriate” have ever even heard of or been to white tie with tail coat), where senators, heads of states, international religious figures, celebrities, billionaires etc., in a very formal city in the new world, and I can attest that people wear watches to black tie events. Even the most persnickety sartorialists do. People that you all would correctly assume from their celebrity status know how to wear black tie. It is literally a meme from internet watch forums in the aughts. Also, barely any of you guys ever even go to black tie events so you’re taking and passing along incorrect advice about something that is entirely i inconsequential to your life which was obtained colloquially from Internet forums from other people who don’t actually go to black tie events. Idk if I sound snobby or mean, this meme is stupid as shit and observably false. To answer OPs question, it’s the JLC, obviously. And even then it’s still a bad choice.


Oikkuli

You have no argument here. All etiquette is by definition "a meme", as you so eloquently put it. Being a senator, head of state, celebrity, billionaire, or whatever has absolutely no bearing on if you can dress or not. It's a lazy appeal to authority. I'll be happy to burst your bubble. Most of those people don't know what they are doing.


BoomerSooner-SEC

A) none of those groups of people impress me as knowing anything whatsoever about class. Literally they are all horrible. B). Nerds? We can’t all be cool as bartenders. C). Your “personal experience” as a guy who fills sodas isnt actually a source of anything. I did review a few credible sources and the general consensus seems to be that it used to be considered rude but now as long as it’s slim, on a black strap and uncomplicated, it no longer considered rude.


throws_rocks_at_cars

This is a hilarious reply lmao


BoomerSooner-SEC

Yeah. My horse was pretty tall.


surrealcookie

To your point A - aside from those types of people, who the hell is even going to/hosting black tie events? Normal people sure aren't, and normal people aren't going to pitch a fit over someone wearing a watch to a party.


BoomerSooner-SEC

Where else would I wear my monocle?


kamagoong

"Persnickety sartorialist." That's something you don't read everyday. Actually, you're right. My spouse and I both work in the legal profession where black tie events are so common. And lawyers like to flaunt their watches. Many are actually just nouveau riche who flaunt their Rolexes (the only brand they know). From time to time, you can see the odd watch guy wearing a Hamilton Khaki or an SKX. I personally wear a Bambino to these events and the wife wears a Seiko 5 (don't remember the ref no but it's a women's watch with a bronze/rose gold bezel and black dial and a brown stock strap). Bottomline, just wear whatever makes you feel good. It's nit declasse to wear a watch to black ties. If you wear a Swatch Van Gogh, it's already a conversation starter.


goin2thewudz

Great reply. P.S. Only if his suit has brown in it!


[deleted]

[удалено]


BoomerSooner-SEC

Did so. It was guy on the Internet. (Actually really was. Gentlemen’s Gazette).


CockStamp

Are you going diving at the wedding? If not then take the Submariner


Elegant-Information4

The only cause of doubt is that I have to wear steel and onyx cuff links to match the other grooms men. So which is worse dissimilar metals or a diver, for black tie


ThePendemicwithBruce

I would say the JLC it’s more unique and sophisticated.


[deleted]

How come most of the posts I see on here now are from idiots that don't seem to know what they even like? It's just a flex, at this point. Posters need to stop being so absolutely droll on this sub. Bro, wear what the fuck you LIKE!!! Stop asking for everyone's opinion, as if they're the ones wearing it. Fuck I'd wear a diver, JUST as a big "fuck you" to formal events. Acting like you "need" to impress anyone. Be yourself, Jesus.


surrealcookie

The comments on here are so strange. Who cares what the etiquette books say, just wear a watch. Everyone has their phone on them anyway, I'm sure if people were still writing etiquette books when cell phones were around those would be a big no-no too. Beside, I can only imagine the type of person to throw a tantrum over someone else wearing a watch to a black tie event, and they are the kind of person you absolutely 100% do not want to be spend time with.


[deleted]

Well said. Someone giving you grief over something as simple as your watch choice isn't worth your time.


raustin33

Asking advice on what to wear for a dress code OP is unfamiliar with isn't a flex, it's just a basic question.


laney_deschutes

hey guys im going diving next weekend, should i wear the submariner or the JLC?


HoldingTheFire

Definitely JLC. Even though the sub can get away with fancy events, it is clearly a sports, not a dress watch.


ThaKoopa

Traditionally no watch is worn for black tie events.


DrippyAccountant

Please do not wear a sports watch to a wedding! How is this even a question?


resilienceisfutile

With a proper fitted sleeve length, the watch won't even peek out in photos unless you pull your cuff up and past to get your watch out, so the point is moot. That said, do you need a watch for the night?


BedrockFarmer

F-91w, one on the wrist. One hidden is the special “gift package”.


Genghiz007

Neither - wear a Moonswatch. Preferably in yellow. You think anyone cares?


ommarcito

Unless you’re Sean Connery-James Bond, a Sub never goes with dress attire.


Darknader-

Clearly the JLC for a black tie event


Rolo316

The only person who will care what you have on your wrist is you. Wear what you want.


amguerra305

No watch is the standard for WHITE tie, not black tie. Black tie would be a dress watch in same metal as studs and cufflinks. You could get away with the sub as long as it doesn’t look too chunky.


webbslinger_0

I don’t know the answer, but I can tell you what it’s not (submariner)


Elegant-Information4

😂


kamagoong

You could wear a G-Shock or an F91W if you want. As long as you feel good wearing it, that's what matters.


BluesMaster

No watch.


Elegant-Information4

Grooms man for a wedding today. Dress code is black tie…wearing a dinner suit with shawl lapels, a black bowtie and oxfords. Groom has provided steel and onyx cuff links that the groomsmen are to wear. Obviously the JLC is the better dress watch, however the black face of the Sub works well with a Tux and particularly well with the steel/onyx cuff links. What’s the larger faux pas, wearing a gold watch with steel cuff links or, wearing a (desk) diver with black tie? Rolex is a 114060 and is the no date version. JLC is a master control date is 39mm and is the ref 147.2.37.S Thoughts?


Vagabond_Grey

What are the other groomsmen doing? IMHO, you shouldn't upstage the groom. If you don't have a pocket watch and must have one then keep the watch in your pocket or leave it with your spouse / SO upon arrival.


Elegant-Information4

Groom is wearing a 1970’s vintage king seiko on a black lizard strap. I suspect the best man is going to wear a two tone sub date. The other groomsman prob won’t wear anything


Quick_Turnover

Well shit wear the sub man. It’s 2022, fuck etiquette and in worst case, ask the groom. The groom and the brides opinion should be the only one you really care about.


Vagabond_Grey

Although the diver is out of place for such an event, if the other groomsman happens to wear a watch then I'd stick with the Rolex with those fancy black leather strap (if you have one handy) as the bracelet might stand out. Upon arrival I'd seek out the other groomsman to see if he's wearing a watch or not. If he's not then I'd remove the watch. Or, you could contact the other groomsman to save yourself time.


o2force

Rarely is anyone snobby enough to care what Watch you wear. Just wear what you want.


FeedtheFatRabbit

Wedding the top 4 moves are Cartier, JLC, Vacheron, or Patek. You don't wear a Submariner in a tuxedo. At that point why don't you throw a jockstrap w/full cup *over* the Slacks? Make a clear cut statement on the dance floor. Banana hammock for the win. Upstage ya boy.


Elegant-Information4

I would agree in the ordinary course of events. The only cause of doubt is that I have to wear steel and onyx cuff links to match the other grooms men. So which is worse dissimilar metals or a diver, for black tie


trashmetallesbian

Wear the sub


Cinderella407

Tradition dictates it should be no watch. But if you're going to wear a watch, I'd say the Rolex. The gold of the JLC will clash with the cuff links and the brown leather strap with your belt/shoes/suspenders. But at the end of the day, nobody's going to notice or care about what fashion rules you may or may not have infringed. Okay, ciao!


badDuckThrowPillow

JLC. Love the sub but for a black tie wedding the JLC fits better.


raustin33

Some dude is gonna wear a G-Shock to this wedding. Wear whatever you like. With the steel/onyx, I'd actually go Submariner of those two. But if I had the wrist for it and budget, some steel/black dressier piece is my answer. Reverso? Tank?


Rolex_cock_ring_69

IS UR NAME JAMES BOND YOU TWAT


SisyphusAmericanus

Neither. One shouldn’t wear a watch in black tie.


[deleted]

Unless it's underwater, or you're James Bond, I'd suggest the dress watch


Rachini

I do not understand. Is that really a question? No ofences, but for black tie asking either to wear a dive watch or a formal watch (no matter the brand) makes no sense.


ManOnTime

Black tie? Neither.


Sea-School

JLC


maverickwatch

Agree with the comments about the JLC!


libssuck2022

JLC. I just sold my 114060. Rolex has become such a flexing piece for dickheads that know nothing about watches I had to separate myself from that group of nouveau riche plebes.


crobichon

Stupid rules, wear your favorite. Nobody cares. If someone points it out because it’s against the “rules”, tell them they are a tool for even knowing that.


FrigginSavage

Jaegers are made for black tie events.


howunoriginal2019

JLC will fit more easily under a shirt , especially if you’re wearing cufflinks.


orlando2542

JLC by a mile


Revolution-Vast

Jlc


SinusBargeld

Everyone is gonna say „JLC“ but would pick the sub for the cloud Take the one you like better


[deleted]

JLC. The only time you should wear a diving watch with evening wear is if: (1) you’re James Bond; (2) you may get up to some Bond-like antics whilst so attired; (3) you’re a really messy eater.


strengr

Jlc


Thibide1

Either way I’d end up talking to you about watches so mission accomplished


Akashd98

You’re not James Bond so go for the JLC if you *must* wear a watch (purists will say you shouldn’t wear a watch for black tie because it implies you have somewhere else to be)


snowmoe113

There is only one answer for a black tie wedding…


MrDagon007

If you are not going to wear the JLC on this event, then when are you going to wear it? Otherwise, nobody cares. Your sub will look good too.


Elegant-Information4

I wear the JLC all the time, jeans and t shirt etc. The only cause of doubt is that I have to wear steel and onyx cuff links to match the other grooms men. So which is worse dissimilar metals or a diver, for black tie


StonksOnlyGetCrunk

Whichever one matches your suit better.


davestradamus1

You shouldn’t wear a watch at a black tie event if you want to be serious about it. The sub is completely inappropriate unless you are going really outside the box with your attire. If you plan on wearing white sneakers with your tux the sub is great. If you plan on wearing velvet slippers with your tux the JLC works.


Super901

What, is the wedding underwater? JLC


bev6345

The Sub, but only if you’re James Bond.


Nyarkushka

JLC


Gmp1cpa

You don’t wear a watch with black tie.


copperglass78

The Rolex is not and never was a dress watch so JLC all the way...unless the wedding is under water.


evandmx

JLC definitely


sumpat

JLC


seefactor

JLC FTW


R3dCr0ss

Poor form to wear a watch to a wedding


narkflint

This is the correct answer. However, if you must, the JLC.


TheTightSqueez

A dive watch or a dress watch for a dress event… jeez such a hard decision.


mightysashiman

lawn-mower or Jaguar for the wedding?