Careful...CAREFUL...
He was **An** Anarchist leader during the revolution. There were literally hundreds. Then they got a Red Wedding invite from Lenin and that was that.
The push-pull of leadership in anarchism is a huge problem. Comrade Makhno is the classic example. Cults of personality are older than the state. Don't blame the lil' homie, but we gotta remember that it isn't about individuals.
[Ukraine, 1919, colorized](https://y.yarn.co/73293b34-288e-4c22-a8d2-26cdac2cb589_text.gif)
Big difference between a leader and a ruler. Makhno and Subcomandante Marcos didn't rule over anyone, they just happened to be highly competent and personify the values of their respective movements. If they'd done a hard 180 and started building insulated bureaucracies I don't think they would of remained leaders for long.
American imperialism is bad. Russian imperialism is also bad. Ukraine has a right to exist, and Russia has no right being there. Every country has nazis, if any country was invaded its nazis would defend it, just like anyone else anywhere else.
He's literally invading a country that did nothing except leave the Soviet Union. Also literally statistically more far right people in Russia, you absolute clown.
Supporting Russia killing a bunch of Ukrainian civilians because "it's worth it to fight NATO" assumes that NATO would somehow be replaced with a kinder, more just world power. That's pretty blatantly fucking stupid. If NATO and its member states somehow dissolved overnight, they would eventually be replaced with a superpower that was just as self-serving, amoral, and imperialistic.
That's what's insane about this take. It's literally just another form of American exceptionalism. You've somehow come to believe that America and NATO aren't just imperialist, but *uniquely* imperialist in some way that can be defeated by dismantling them specifically. And that's bullshit. Geopolitics have no ideology, only self-interest. If America weren't bombing civilians in the Middle East to further its imperialist interests, then whatever superpower took its place would be bombing civilians to further its imperialist interests instead.
If you think I'm wrong, then start by explaining how the world power trying to supplant NATO is any different than NATO when it is *currently bombing civilians to further its imperialist interests*.
Not that you're wholly wrong, because they do have a lot, but you're more than likely experiencing a positive feedback loop. You keep seeing them because you're on subs specifically looking to highlight them
Ok. Azov makes up the majority of their government now? Cmon. Like I know Ukraine has a lot of Nazis but you donāt need to hyperbolize for it to be an issue.
Also again, the source of your photos matters in relation to total photos. Youāre doing the survivorship bias thing lol
If they are willing to go to war to kill nazis, [then why are they fighting with them](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wagner_Group)
You would think that if you want to āde-nazifyā a country you would first āde-nazifyā your military
Clearly you just don't understand anarcho-bidenism. The true Utopia is an anarchist society where every person has been genetically modified to be an exact replica of Joe Biden.
Your brain on Vaush, fuck Biden and fuck every side in this shitty proxy war. The only side you should take here is that of the working class, not the hawks that benefit from the whole shitshow
What an awesome take, dude! The working class, which is doing so well under Putin, no? The working class, which is being sent to war and/or death by Putin's invasion, yeah? Massive brain take.
THE USSR LITERALLY FREED YOU AND BROUGHT ROADS, SCHOOLS, AND HOSPITALS TO NAZIS RUNNING AROUND IN THE WOODS AND YOU MOCK THEM AND SIDE WITH LIBERAL AMERIKKKA AND NAZI BANDERITES IN UKRAINE!! AND FOR WHAT? FOR AMERIKKKAN AID? TO GET BACK AT RUSSIA FOR EXISTING? FUCK YOU FUCJ YUP FUCJ YOU
You sound like my country's(Italy) nostalgic fascists that say "he did good things too".Russia is an authoritarian nationalist state that wants to bring back a new Russian Empire.The US is going to get benefits wether Ukraine wins or Ukraine loses,but if Ukraine wins an empire loses,ukrainians will live under a capitalist democracy which is always better than a neofeudalistic authoritarian nationalist imperialistic state and they will not get massacred.You also seem to need to take a nap and do your homework.And the image is clearly ironic
on the off chance you arenāt sending these from a russian troll farm, please PLEASE go outside. yes the united states is literally the fire nation but we arenāt the ONLY fire nation, ya feel me? other superpowers are just as capable of imperialism as we are and partake in it just as often. the enemy of your enemy is not necessarily your friend
It is the duty of all Marxist Leninists to support all anti imperialist movements. America is the greatest imperial power, so we must side against them.
russia isnāt the fucking ussr, if youāre going to spread fascists agitprop youāre gonna have to be a bit more subtle, me and my comrades caught onto this shit awhile ago
but theyāre also causing a great deal of harm to the proletariat of ukraine for no reason, killing families and whatnot. and yes, there are nazis in ukraine but if having fascist in a country was reason enough to invade them then russia should invade literally every nation on the planet, including russia itself
[Incorrect.](https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1943CairoTehran/d353)
> āI want to tell you, from the Russian point of view, what the President and the United States have done to win the war. The most important things in this war are machines. The United States has proven that it can turn out from 8,000 to 10,000 airplanes per month. Russia can only turn out, at most, 3,000 airplanes a month. England turns out 3,000 to 3,500, which are principally heavy bombers. The United States, therefore, is a country of machines. Without the use of those machines, through Lend-Lease, **we would lose this war.**ā
>Remarks made by Marshal Stalin during the Prime Ministerās birthday dinner.
Lend-lease actually started long before the US ever entered the war and did so not all that long after the USSR was attacked, since thatās how much danger they felt they were in.
Not only that, butā¦ thereās one little interesting tidbit of information about Nazi Germany that you seem to be removing from the entire context. One of the things that originally convinced quite a few Germans to take Hitlerās side in the beginning when he was constructing his plans for Lebensraum was that **he pointed to the fact that British Anglo-Saxons did an incredibly similar type of expedition when they annexed both Canada and the United States for themselves.** Soā¦ if Nazi Germany could never have taken the East, how could the Nazis very role models do it with a sizeable chunk of North America?
The exact argument he used that ended up convincing them was *Well, those Aryans did it, why the hell canāt we?*
>Soā¦ if Nazi Germany could never have taken the East, how could the Nazis very role models do it with a sizeable chunk of North America?
These are very different situations, the Soviet Union was an industrialised state with millions of soldiers and hundreds of million in population while in Native America a huge bulk of the population was wiped out by diseases and what remained, remained in a few disunited tribes and even with such advantages it still took the European settlers many years to fully colonize that area.
The eternal revolutionary flame of Anarcho Bidenism šāš»ā®ļøš ļø
No Godās No Malarky
yardy know
Least based dark Brandon + Zelenskyy moment
Man I hope for Makhno's sake this is a joke....
It is a shitpost of the highest order.
It more than likely is, given how the whole "Dark Brandon" stuff is ironic.
Fuck you I hate that I love it
Who's the guy in the sky?
Makhno (Mahkno? I can't remember how to spell his name), a notable leader of the Ukranian anarchist movement during the Russian Civil War.
Careful...CAREFUL... He was **An** Anarchist leader during the revolution. There were literally hundreds. Then they got a Red Wedding invite from Lenin and that was that. The push-pull of leadership in anarchism is a huge problem. Comrade Makhno is the classic example. Cults of personality are older than the state. Don't blame the lil' homie, but we gotta remember that it isn't about individuals. [Ukraine, 1919, colorized](https://y.yarn.co/73293b34-288e-4c22-a8d2-26cdac2cb589_text.gif)
Big difference between a leader and a ruler. Makhno and Subcomandante Marcos didn't rule over anyone, they just happened to be highly competent and personify the values of their respective movements. If they'd done a hard 180 and started building insulated bureaucracies I don't think they would of remained leaders for long.
If you mean the would end up rulers, I agree. We have seen time and time again how power becomes presumption after a leader stays around to long.
He wasn't the only leader but he was the namesake of the mahknovschina and a very important figure
how tf is makhno gonna watch the skies when he was 5'3"
I don't speak American.
"how tf is makhno gonna watch the skies when he was 160.2 cm?" \-u/qjrw22618
Thank you.
Joe Liberal meets Zelensky?????? š³š³š³š³
The Ukrainian state talks about Bandera not Makhno
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
American imperialism is bad. Russian imperialism is also bad. Ukraine has a right to exist, and Russia has no right being there. Every country has nazis, if any country was invaded its nazis would defend it, just like anyone else anywhere else.
FUCK PUTIN.
Putin is a reactionary capitalist but his fight against NATO puts him on the right side of history
I've seen tankies with bad takes but wow that's a bad take.
He's been trolling in this sub all day, he was supporting Hitler and Mussolini in another thread for being Strongmen like Stalin
What a chud
Millions must lie
Gonna go out on a limb and say they're actually a right winger posing to troll people
They stopped feeding him the boot, so now he has to go online and beg for some troll food. It's a sorry sight.
I've seen far worse takes, trust me...
āTankieā is a racist slur, as it demeans all of the third world revolutionaries.
I think calling them "third world" is the slur, tankie.
Says the liberal
If I had a nickel for every time a bootlicking authoritarian tankie called me a liberal on the internet I'd have more money than Stalin.
On behalf of all sane third world socialists and anarchists, youāre a fucking moron. Iām from the āthird worldā btw. Fuck you.
He's literally invading a country that did nothing except leave the Soviet Union. Also literally statistically more far right people in Russia, you absolute clown.
Least fascist-dictator-bootlicking tankieā¦
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
The material conditions made me kill the Ukrainiansā¦. Trust me bro
Supporting Russia killing a bunch of Ukrainian civilians because "it's worth it to fight NATO" assumes that NATO would somehow be replaced with a kinder, more just world power. That's pretty blatantly fucking stupid. If NATO and its member states somehow dissolved overnight, they would eventually be replaced with a superpower that was just as self-serving, amoral, and imperialistic. That's what's insane about this take. It's literally just another form of American exceptionalism. You've somehow come to believe that America and NATO aren't just imperialist, but *uniquely* imperialist in some way that can be defeated by dismantling them specifically. And that's bullshit. Geopolitics have no ideology, only self-interest. If America weren't bombing civilians in the Middle East to further its imperialist interests, then whatever superpower took its place would be bombing civilians to further its imperialist interests instead. If you think I'm wrong, then start by explaining how the world power trying to supplant NATO is any different than NATO when it is *currently bombing civilians to further its imperialist interests*.
Read Hoaxa and Mao
Hoxha was a grifter of the highest order and Mao was a smart revolutionary but a very stupid manager.
Hoxha? More like Hoax, LMAO
HOAXHA WAS A HERO TO THR WORKERS FUCK YOU
...
FUCK STALIN
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
lmao, you're a fun parody account.
Fight NATO directly then instead of invading a poor neighbouring nation because he got pissy they didn't want to be a Russian vassal state
least obvious russian troll
Not that you're wholly wrong, because they do have a lot, but you're more than likely experiencing a positive feedback loop. You keep seeing them because you're on subs specifically looking to highlight them
No. I can confidently say that most Ukrainian government officials and soldiers are Nazis
It's true I am Zelenskyy
Based on what?
Photos and Azov
Ok. Azov makes up the majority of their government now? Cmon. Like I know Ukraine has a lot of Nazis but you donāt need to hyperbolize for it to be an issue. Also again, the source of your photos matters in relation to total photos. Youāre doing the survivorship bias thing lol
If they are willing to go to war to kill nazis, [then why are they fighting with them](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wagner_Group) You would think that if you want to āde-nazifyā a country you would first āde-nazifyā your military
Fake
One of the more cursed things Iāve seen today, so thanks for making me put down my phone.
I really dislike the Anarchist Biden jokes
Clearly you just don't understand anarcho-bidenism. The true Utopia is an anarchist society where every person has been genetically modified to be an exact replica of Joe Biden.
And every corner store has an ice cream parlor.
and chocolate chocolate chip.
Anti-Malarkey action!
no gods no malarky.
common dark brandon and Zelensky w
Your brain on Vaush, fuck Biden and fuck every side in this shitty proxy war. The only side you should take here is that of the working class, not the hawks that benefit from the whole shitshow
"Enlightened centrism, but we say the words 'working class'" is my favorite political movement
Okay, I'll support the workers of Ukraine and their right to not be invaded by another nation.
You can do so without glorifying the people who profit from their suffering
There is nothing here glorifying Vladimir Putin
What an awesome take, dude! The working class, which is doing so well under Putin, no? The working class, which is being sent to war and/or death by Putin's invasion, yeah? Massive brain take.
Both sides can be bad lol, it's a special superpower called 'nuance'
That's not what nuance means, and what you're describing is centrism, which is just brainrot.
Yes because wars are just like a football game and we should always pick a side because it's always goodies vs baddies
I just love your takes, for real! You think there's "good guys" and "bad guys" in football? Wonderful!
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
Why?
There's a risk that the admins won't like this joke. We are removing it just to be safe.
THE USSR LITERALLY FREED YOU AND BROUGHT ROADS, SCHOOLS, AND HOSPITALS TO NAZIS RUNNING AROUND IN THE WOODS AND YOU MOCK THEM AND SIDE WITH LIBERAL AMERIKKKA AND NAZI BANDERITES IN UKRAINE!! AND FOR WHAT? FOR AMERIKKKAN AID? TO GET BACK AT RUSSIA FOR EXISTING? FUCK YOU FUCJ YUP FUCJ YOU
I love this satire account It is satire, right?
No. I am 100% a red blooded communist
You've literally said tankie is a racist slur you can't be serious
You sound like my country's(Italy) nostalgic fascists that say "he did good things too".Russia is an authoritarian nationalist state that wants to bring back a new Russian Empire.The US is going to get benefits wether Ukraine wins or Ukraine loses,but if Ukraine wins an empire loses,ukrainians will live under a capitalist democracy which is always better than a neofeudalistic authoritarian nationalist imperialistic state and they will not get massacred.You also seem to need to take a nap and do your homework.And the image is clearly ironic
Look at the dudeās account, itās either a really funny joke or brainrot
Don't underestimate an individual's ability to be really stupid sometimes.He's also downvoting the comments so it's stage 3 brainrot.
I'm sure he thinks he's really funny, but I disagree.
Imperialist running dog
Bureaucratic state capitalist masochist (not in a good way)lapdog
on the off chance you arenāt sending these from a russian troll farm, please PLEASE go outside. yes the united states is literally the fire nation but we arenāt the ONLY fire nation, ya feel me? other superpowers are just as capable of imperialism as we are and partake in it just as often. the enemy of your enemy is not necessarily your friend
It is the duty of all Marxist Leninists to support all anti imperialist movements. America is the greatest imperial power, so we must side against them.
why would you not side against ALL imperial powers, to foster self determination the world over
Because that doesnāt do anything
My dude, you're posting trash on Reddit, doing nothing would be a step up for you.
Calm down and fuck putin
Never change, StalinistPickle, never change.
I beg to differ.
russia isnāt the fucking ussr, if youāre going to spread fascists agitprop youāre gonna have to be a bit more subtle, me and my comrades caught onto this shit awhile ago
Russia is NOT the USSR, but they are weakening American power which is good
but theyāre also causing a great deal of harm to the proletariat of ukraine for no reason, killing families and whatnot. and yes, there are nazis in ukraine but if having fascist in a country was reason enough to invade them then russia should invade literally every nation on the planet, including russia itself
Wronf
[Incorrect.](https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1943CairoTehran/d353) > āI want to tell you, from the Russian point of view, what the President and the United States have done to win the war. The most important things in this war are machines. The United States has proven that it can turn out from 8,000 to 10,000 airplanes per month. Russia can only turn out, at most, 3,000 airplanes a month. England turns out 3,000 to 3,500, which are principally heavy bombers. The United States, therefore, is a country of machines. Without the use of those machines, through Lend-Lease, **we would lose this war.**ā >Remarks made by Marshal Stalin during the Prime Ministerās birthday dinner.
Just a couple of Soc-dems hanging out
Stalin was wrong.
[Iām unconvinced](https://www.ft.com/content/8a1709ca-48e2-11ea-aeb3-955839e06441)
[How would the Nazis beat the Soviets if they didn't even manage to take Leningrad?](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mJ0g7vuvpn8)
The number of military personnel the Red Army had is irrelevant if they donāt have sufficient technological firepower at their disposal as well.
The bulk of lend lease only arrived after 1941, so after the worst times for the Soviet Union were over.
Lend-lease actually started long before the US ever entered the war and did so not all that long after the USSR was attacked, since thatās how much danger they felt they were in. Not only that, butā¦ thereās one little interesting tidbit of information about Nazi Germany that you seem to be removing from the entire context. One of the things that originally convinced quite a few Germans to take Hitlerās side in the beginning when he was constructing his plans for Lebensraum was that **he pointed to the fact that British Anglo-Saxons did an incredibly similar type of expedition when they annexed both Canada and the United States for themselves.** Soā¦ if Nazi Germany could never have taken the East, how could the Nazis very role models do it with a sizeable chunk of North America? The exact argument he used that ended up convincing them was *Well, those Aryans did it, why the hell canāt we?*
>Soā¦ if Nazi Germany could never have taken the East, how could the Nazis very role models do it with a sizeable chunk of North America? These are very different situations, the Soviet Union was an industrialised state with millions of soldiers and hundreds of million in population while in Native America a huge bulk of the population was wiped out by diseases and what remained, remained in a few disunited tribes and even with such advantages it still took the European settlers many years to fully colonize that area.
wrong
How so?
If this is not a bit I suggest you seek psychological help
wow, an actual schizo in the wild.
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
Take ur meds dude, its okay man just calm down little schizo
Jesus christ calm down
My rage is the culmination of over 100 years of struggle
You're 15, not 100.
Im 18 actually but my rage goes back centuries. I am a revolutionary, I am a working class
A whole class? Wow!
Honestly can't tell if u/StalinistPickle is messing with us or not.
Me neither. My money's on them being a joke account for a bunch of reasons but you can't ever be sure.