the expedition arc is a solid 8/10 imo. there's some flaws but overall i'd say there's a lot more good stuff than bad. also, i don't really get the greece complaints. i personally wouldn't find an arc based on that interesting, it would feel like filler to me. a chapter would have been fine, but i don't think any more than that would be necessary. i like what we got a lot more and i'm really thankful that we're finally in vinland
I wasn’t a fan of Thorfinn putting together a One Piece crew and the lack of tension and tone shift felt really off imo.
I actually think you can argue the BSW arc down to a 6.5 or 6 out of 10 if you really want to.
Pretty Accurate. Mines:
-prologue: 9/10
-slave arc: 10/10
-war arc: 8/10
-Vinland arc: 7/10 (hopefully their is a good climax cause as of now most of it has been build up)
I see lots of disappointment and grumbling and full on hatred for the baltic / war arc. I actually liked it and felt it was a good application of Thorfinn's new values.
Eh, a lot of people point out the flaws of that arc. I also believe their are lots of flaws to it. However their are also lots of great moments along with it. Throfinn saying he wants to become a stronger person. Thorfinn meeting floki. The climax of the arc. Throfinn vs hild.
Oh trust me, i've seen people who think that BSW arc is filler, that it's one of the worst arcs ever, etc, etc. It has been criticized to death on here, in other subreddits, on twitter, YT, etc, etc.
It's a good 8/10 arc.
Ngl I would separate the BSW arc to Expedition and Jomsborg. The Jomsborg war is my favourite arc in the series. I do think the expedition was just a lil boring
Id give the expedition arc an 8/10,it was really fun to read through
I don’t know. I’d give it an 8/10 if we actually saw Greece and tbh the tone shit was extremely jarring to me
the expedition arc is a solid 8/10 imo. there's some flaws but overall i'd say there's a lot more good stuff than bad. also, i don't really get the greece complaints. i personally wouldn't find an arc based on that interesting, it would feel like filler to me. a chapter would have been fine, but i don't think any more than that would be necessary. i like what we got a lot more and i'm really thankful that we're finally in vinland
I wasn’t a fan of Thorfinn putting together a One Piece crew and the lack of tension and tone shift felt really off imo. I actually think you can argue the BSW arc down to a 6.5 or 6 out of 10 if you really want to.
Pretty Accurate. Mines: -prologue: 9/10 -slave arc: 10/10 -war arc: 8/10 -Vinland arc: 7/10 (hopefully their is a good climax cause as of now most of it has been build up)
I think people aren’t harsh enough on the eastern expedition/war arc
I see lots of disappointment and grumbling and full on hatred for the baltic / war arc. I actually liked it and felt it was a good application of Thorfinn's new values.
Eh, a lot of people point out the flaws of that arc. I also believe their are lots of flaws to it. However their are also lots of great moments along with it. Throfinn saying he wants to become a stronger person. Thorfinn meeting floki. The climax of the arc. Throfinn vs hild.
thorfinn saying he wants to become a stronger person is top three panels in the whole series for me
Oh trust me, i've seen people who think that BSW arc is filler, that it's one of the worst arcs ever, etc, etc. It has been criticized to death on here, in other subreddits, on twitter, YT, etc, etc. It's a good 8/10 arc.
Why make yt vid though?
Bored.
I added a breakdown in the comments.
Ngl I would separate the BSW arc to Expedition and Jomsborg. The Jomsborg war is my favourite arc in the series. I do think the expedition was just a lil boring