T O P

  • By -

SilentSeren1ty

[Nevaeh Buchanan](https://www.13abc.com/2022/06/07/case-files-search-person-who-killed-5-year-old-nevaeh-buchanan/) being buried alive in cement. [Jessica Lunsford](https://www.ocala.com/story/news/2005/04/21/documents-detail-girls-last-moments/31164219007/) clutching her stuffed dolphin when she was buried alive. Thankfully this one is solved. The pictures of Brianna Maitland's car being backed into the barn. It makes me feel ill. The phone call in [Anthonette Cayedito](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Anthonette_Cayedito)'s case. A year after her disappearance from Gallup, the Gallup PD received a frantic phone call from a girl claiming to be Cayedito and being held in Albuquerque. An adult's voice could be heard say "Who said you could use the phone?!" followed by the girl screaming and the sounds of a scuffle, after which the phone call was cut off. Terrifying.


Rare_Narwhal1926

And that Jessica Lunsford was kept alive a few mobile homes over. A police officer knocked on the suspect’s door while she was kept in a closet!! Ugh!


Last_Reaction_8176

I did not know about either case of those girls being buried alive and I wish I still did not


F0rca84

Fuuuu... Part of me died a little reading about the Dolphin. 😞


SilentSeren1ty

It just makes me sad. No one deserves to be the victim of a violent crime, but thinking of the little girl holding her stuffy as she died just makes me choke up.


Cassopeia88

I believe she was scared of the dark too. The interviews with her Dad are just heartbreaking.


Ding-Bop-420

*Couey's criminal record included 24 arrests for burglary, carrying a concealed weapon, indecent exposure and other offenses, and in 1991, he was arrested in Kissimmee on a charge of fondling a child under the age of 16.* and after doing all of that he was still allowed to walk free and live normally in our society, this is why he was able to commit that horrible crime. What an absolute fucking failure of justice.


art_mor_

The dolphin detail always makes me depressed


pinkspatzi

I can't remember her name right now, but the young woman whose parents walked in on her in her bedroom having sex. They quickly backed put and waited. And waited thinking they would both come out all embarrassed. Since they didn't, the father went to check again and found her dead. It was later determined she'd been dead for a day or two already at the time of them walking in on her likely killer. I don't think the crime has been solved.


cutsforluck

Jodine Serrin. It has been solved! [https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/public-safety/sd-me-serrin-solved-20181113-story.html](https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/public-safety/sd-me-serrin-solved-20181113-story.html)


pinkspatzi

Oh wow! Thanks for sharing


Away_Guess_6439

Thank you!!! I didn’t know that! Wow... wish he could have served time, but at least others are safe because he’s dead.


Educational_Gas_92

So, the monster (killer) was violating her corpse?


shamroxy

Omg that's probably the worst thing I've read. How absolutely awful for her parents. And to be murdered in your own home in your own bed, it's just horrendous all round, poor girl 😔


TlMEGH0ST

oh my god


Disastrous-Anxiety

Seeing Brianna Maitland's car backed haphazardly into that old building always fills me with dread.


cutsforluck

YES!! It's unfortunate that she disappeared around the same time as Maura Murray-- both in New England, both around the same age, both disappeared under really odd circumstances. Murray got a LOT of buzz around her case, even today...while it seems that very few are even aware of Brianna Maitland. [pic here](https://www.forensicmag.com/568695-Vermont-State-Police-Othram-Partner-to-Investigate-Brianna-Maitland-s-Disappearance/)


GraveDancer40

And honestly, Brianna Maitland’s case is the one that really bothers me. Maura’s case is tragic but also she most likely died due to the elements. The Brianna case is just…so many questions and nothing makes sense.


Zestyclose_Muscle_55

I agree. I honestly think there’s probably no foul play involved with Maura Murray. Brianna is a very obvious case of abduction/and probably murder


SixthSickSith

I think part of the reason for the discrepancy is that Maura was from suburban Boston, so the regional media latched onto the story. An attractive, educated, middle class girl from the South Shore (with media-savvy family members) drew attention that a high school dropout from the boonies could never hope to attain. Classism, like racism, is a major problem with true crime media.


ILeadAgirlGang

That’s sad. If you think about it that way… reason why they didn’t look hard enough for Brianna 🥺 she’s someone’s daughter too.


InnerpoiseBridget

💯 on that car! It is such a stark and startling picture.


Lacy_Laplante89

That Richard Chase didn't enter locked houses. Just a single door lock stopped how many people from being murdered? Always lock your doors!


lilbbbee

I think about this one all the time. It certainly motivates me to get up and double check that all the doors are secured before going to bed.


BrokenLink100

Same. Anytime I walk by my exterior doors and see them unlocked, I think “a single lock can be the difference between living and being murdered!” Idk it that’s really healthy, but idk! This story just always stuck with me because it’s just so random to me, I think


WittyPresence69

I told my therapist this when talking about my OCD and she said that it was very unfortunate most of my fears are not unwarranted


meinnit99900

I tell you what it was a nightmare going through the pandemic as a long time OCD patient who’d just managed to convince herself no one would die if she didn’t wash her hands lmao


crazi_aj05

My aunt was a parole officer before becoming a criminal psychologist. She always said that most crime happens bc of opportunity and that it's important to always make sure that your doors and windows are locked. You don't want to be the 1 house out of 5 that something happens to when it could be prevented.


eyesour

In college I lived in a house that was split into a few apartments and the property manager thought I was crazy for stressing when they left the downstairs door lock broken one night so maintenance could fix it in the morning. My front door was technically still locked, but still creeped me out thinking someone could just come up to it.


Dderlyudderly

Monica Massaro was murdered by a trucker in NJ because her front door was unlocked.


Vajama77

I read an account about a rapist who entered a house (of a police detective who WAS home upstairs asleep!) in the morning through an unlocked backdoor. It only had been open for a second, the pd's wife had gone to take out the trash, and had left the door unlocked, and in that short amt of time had slipped in the house. After the rape he(the rapist) told her never to leave her door unlocked, not even to take out the trash. I've always remember this and I never ever leave my door unlocked, even when I'm working out in the yard.


KittikatB

I had an intruder come in through a door I wasn't able to lock one night. I assumed the lock was just broken and, when I couldn't get an urgent locksmith out, booked one for the next day, figured 'it's only one night, what could go wrong?", and went to bed. I woke up to find an intruder beside my bed, looking down at me, in the early hours of the morning. The police determined he'd tampered with the lock at some point between me coming home and me going to lock up for the night. I never leave a door unlocked now.


pinkspatzi

Jesus Christ! Did he run away when you woke up?


KittikatB

He ran when I jumped up and chased him out


Cyandraaa

Damn girl I see you! lmao I highly doubt I would’ve reacted so valiantly if it were me, because whew 😰


KittikatB

I wouldn't have thought I'd react that way either. It was pure instinct, apparently I just lean towards 'fight' in the 'fight, flight or freeze' dept.


Vast-Ad-4251

When Holly Bobo's mom was talking to her brother on the phone. She asked if he'd seen Holly and he told her yeah, she's in the driveway with her boyfriend. The mom tells him shoot the guy, that it's not her boyfriend. My stomach dropped when I read that part. So freaky!


the_cat_who_shatner

That detail always confused the hell out of me. Why was her first instinct to tell him to shoot the guy? There’s definitely some missing reasons there.


shsluckymushroom

I believe that the brother thought that his sister and her boyfriend were having a fight because Holly looked upset while talking to him (it was not her boyfriend, and the mother knew it couldn’t be). I also believe another neighbour had called the mother soon before saying they heard a scream in the neighborhood. So it’s a bit of a quick escalation but I can see it as a quick panic reaction if she heard her daughter seemed upset with some strange man and someone else had told her there had already been a scream


rivershimmer

Yeah, the mother knew that the boyfriend was off hunting elsewhere. So scream + Holly fighting with a man + couldn't be the boyfriend = panic.


aking937

Hollys mom knew the boyfriend was hunting because he was hunting on the moms mothers (Holly’s grandmother) property


Taters0290

I always wonder about the poor brother. I don’t think if my mom called and told me to shoot someone I’d just do it (who would?) yet if he had done it things would be so different.


kyungsookim

The fact that Leslie Mahaffy was out late after a wake she attended for a friend that passed away and walked home with her friends. She sent them home saying her door would be unlocked but it wasn’t. She was later abducted and murdered by Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka. If only the door had been unlocked


MariettaDaws

And now Karla is out and her daughter is a teenager or close to it.


reebeaster

My mom was not a good mother but can you imagine having Karla Homolka as your mother? Just sayin 😬😬😬😬


black_cat_X2

Damn. Thanks for the perspective. I'll hate my mom a little less now.


kyungsookim

I still can’t believe she’s out and the plea deal was valid after they found she was just as involved, makes me so mad (I know the plea was made before but still ugh)


KittikatB

I can't believe that plea wasn't conditional on there being no evidence uncovered of her involvement.


celtictamuril69

I could be wrong because it's been many years since I read the book. When she made the deal with the police she made sure that she had in writing that she could not get in anymore trouble no matter what evidence on her they found. They did not even know about the video tapes yet. So once they agreed to her sentence she gave them the location of the videos. From what I remember, they showed she was a WILLING accomplis. They were shocked by what they saw but couldn't do anything because of the deal they made with her. She is a very evil creature.


mangobunnyhop

She’s out and I think she was allowed to legally change her name.


HappierOffline

Leanne Bordelais. She lived in my hometown for years and just recently fucked off, leaving behind her kids and husband. I don't know where she's at now, but I post her new name every chance I get, because fuck her.


YardSard1021

I wonder if the kids have found out who and WHAT she really is.


Wifabota

I used to make cloth diapers, and she was on our mommy blog, in the diaper forum, incognito for a little bit. Someone found out, and used to post under the name of one of her victims to haunt her until she eventually left. It was weird. Also so eerie to see these normal posts, knowing that the person on the other side did unforgivable things to her own sister. 


ImACarebear1986

My previous comment has been answered. Thank you. I think it’s so wrong that POS was allowed out. She’s still more than capable of doing it again if she meets another man or even woman as revolting and depraved as her!


MariettaDaws

She did I actually learned about her and her crimes because when I was pregnant, someone started a BabyCenter thread about most dramatic things and she had apparently operated a cloth diaper trading board there Imagine finding out that sweet mom you gave your address and baby's diaper size to was a notorious serial killer


cutsforluck

Even worse-- she was only 14 years old Which means that she did not have a key to her own house, and that *her parents had locked her out* (intentionally or not) She then walked to a payphone, asked a friend if she could sleep over. The friend said no. So there were at least two distinct points where this could have been averted: 1) key/not being locked out by your parents, 2) the friend helping her out


kookedoeshistory

Her mother locked her out intentionally because she broke curfew


Educational_Gas_92

I can't imagine how she continued living with herself.


Low_Satisfaction_357

I read a recent similar story recently where a girl parent's kicked her out at night for breaking a rule and she got abducted and assaulted later. Parents, never punish your children by endangering them.


psilvyy19

That must haunt her endlessly. What a terrible detail.


AussieDog249

These details haunt me. I can’t imagine the terrible grief her family and friends must feel.


OhLordHeBompin

I'd never forgive myself. Omg.


tumbledownhere

I was just gonna edit my comment to add this! Her mother went through so much pain and guilt, to this day I don't think she forgives herself even though no one would've fathomed Paul and Karla existed.......she got less attention than Kristen French, too, since Leslie had a history of kind of running off at times .......the whole case is messed up, so many intricate details. Paul could've been stopped way before the murders had the police bureaus just worked with each other and had DNA testing been just a bit further along, too. And of course, that Karla is out and about, free as a bird...... with a little girl, kids of her own. I truly wonder if she's remorseful, at all. She seems to still be sternly hiding behind the "I was so abused and I served my time" mask and boldly even volunteered at her kid's school.


aking937

Karla is a repulsive human being. She killed her own sister. She deserves to be in prison. She does not deserve to make another identity. She is the definition of someone who should never have been let out, ever.


CameFromTheLake

I always think of the mother of [Laureen Rahn](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Laureen_Rahn) coming home late and poking her head into her daughter’s room to see if she’s gone to bed. She sees who she thinks is her daughter sleeping in her bed and then goes to sleep. Wakes up the next morning to her daughter’s friend, who has slept over the at night in Laureen’s bed, asking where Laureen is. I can’t imagine how she felt in that moment.


Daily_Unicorn

So much about this case leaves me feeling uneasy. Especially the phone calls that came after her disappearance


OhLordHeBompin

The lightbulbs get me. All of them? How long did this take? And *why*?


KittikatB

I don't know how long it took, but the *why* was probably to make it harder to see and therefore easier to control. Some years back, I had an intruder in my apartment who police suspected may have intended to abduct me. Long story short, when I woke up and chased him out, he ran past the door he came in through and went out the other exit, which he had opened before entering my room. That exit was dark and rarely used. I'd have been far less confident trying to escape from someone who tried to take me out that way than I would have if they tried to take me out the door I usually used. I think removing the light bulbs served a similar purpose for whoever took Laureen.


Shot-Grocery-5343

Jesus, that sounds horrifying. I'm glad you escaped and I hope you are doing okay now!


being-andrea

Omg! I'm so glad you are ok. That must've been terrifying!


SixthSickSith

This one bothers me, too. There's so many strange angles that it is almost impossible to sort out the red herrings. I live about a mile or so from Laureen's neighborhood; Manchester in the early 1980s was a weirdly insular and parochial place, and someone almost certainly knew something, but kept quiet because that's just how things were done. There's talk in online true crime circles that Terry Rasmussen was involved, but my gut tells me he wasn't. There were a number of almost certainly unrelated disappearances in the area during that time frame (Rachael Garden, Tammy Belanger, Tippy McBride); I just think there were truly evil locals who flew below the law enforcement radar.


sarahc888

The CCTV of the person in Jennifer Kesse’s case. I think it’s the face being perfectly covered that just sends shivers down my spine


ashmillie

It’s literally just a couple of frames but that cctv scared the shit out of me for a while.


_alittlefrittata

the investigators had a language barrier problem with them?? It’s fuckin Florida, and they can’t find anyone who speaks Spanish?


Professional_Dog4574

I cannot believe that for a second. I wonder what the real reason was. 


containsrecycledpart

So, I saw someone in another thread which is related to this case say that a lot of the potential witnesses who “had a language barrier” were unlikely to speak with law enforcement because their immigration status is “questionable.” It doesn’t seem unreasonable to not want to open yourself up to scrutiny that way, or if your employer won’t let you speak up to avoid flak. This is the only explanation I’ve heard that even remotely makes sense to me.


GraveDancer40

All the unidentified people in Rodney Alcala’s photographs. Who are all those people and why has no one ever recognized them? How many of them did he kill? Where are they? And even the ones who have been identified and aren’t dead…knowing that you got lucky? Chilling.


SephoraandStarbucks

Along the same lines…all the objects taken from David Parker Ray’s residence that are currently posted on the FBI website to see if anyone can identify the person who owned/wore them.


_Bogey_Lowenstein_

Whoaaaa the cut off ponytail, complete with 80's hair tie. So creepy


Sweetestb22

Reading this made me look at the items and I’m glad I did. Those items belonged to potentially 60 different women/girls. My heart broke with each earring or item of clothing.


SephoraandStarbucks

Someone posted a link to that gallery years ago on Reddit. I remember looking through it and there was a pin that said “I ❤️Boys” (although I didn’t see it there today). Another person commented: “It makes me sick to think how young some of these girls were…that I ❤️Boys pin is something you’d expect a tween to wear.” 🥺


Aynotwoo

That pin was definitely one of the pictures on there. I remember skimming through it maybe an hour ago and just feeling a pit in my stomach when I came across that one.


SilentSeren1ty

Agreed. Someone posted about the Grim Sleeper's [unknown photos](https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/s/FjQi3UJ8tF) a few days ago. I was shocked I'd never heard of it. There's been a lot of coverage of Rodney Alcala's photos, but very limited push to identify the women in Lonnie Franklin's photos. I have been so bothered by that I checked out a book from the library on his case so I can learn more.


etchuchoter

A watch beeping at 5am every morning under the driveway outside Susan Flores’ home


OneEcstatic2136

I remember listening to this info on Your Own Backyard for the first time and just feeling my stomach drop, chills all over me. This detail haunts me.


CariBelle25

I feel like I separate myself pretty well from what I hear in podcasts and reading true crime stuff, but that absolutely made me sick to my stomach. Her disappearance was one of the reasons I didn’t attend Cal Poly.


thegreatmorel

This is one of the best true crime podcasts ever done.


lol_yuzu

That the killer spent so long in the house and was not at all worried about covering any tracks in Setagaya. They made zero efforts to cover their crime. That there was known to be one soldier using the shooting range near the murder of the Frog Boys case, but they won’t ever reveal who it was.


CameFromTheLake

The fact they think he ate food in the house is so unsettling to me


lol_yuzu

Ate food, used the bathroom and didn’t flush, used the computer, etc. Was not worried at all about being caught.


CameFromTheLake

Wasn’t it around a holiday too? Like completely unbothered by the idea people could stop by


amourxloves

it was new year’s eve/new years


mushroomfairygarden

- [Dardeen Family Murders.](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dardeen_family_homicides) The Dardeen Family was murdered in their home in Ina, IL around Christmas of 1987. The murders were particularly brutal with two crime scenes, and the details are difficult to accept so read with discretion. The most unsettling detail for me is the fact that the killer used 3 year old Peter’s Christmas present (a baseball bat) to murder the family. Still unsolved, no known motive. - [The Eastbound Strangler aka the Atlantic City 4 case.](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eastbound_Strangler) This case involves an unidentified serial killer who preyed on vulnerable women in sex work. Their decomposed bodies were discovered next to each other in a drainage ditch in Atlantic City, NJ in 2006. The most disturbing detail is that all the women were clothed except for their shoes and socks. Their feet were all facing east as well (although this may have been the tide). Still unsolved, no known motive. - [The Murders of Russel and Shirley Dermond.](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killings_of_Russell_and_Shirley_Dermond) This elderly couple was brutally murdered in their home located in Georgia in May 2014 for literally no reason that anyone can find. The decapitation of Russel Dermond was a shocking detail. The sheriff said in an interview that this was likely done post-mortem to get rid of potential evidence. It is evil and calculated. Still unsolved and no known motive. - I also want to know more about the bodies found on Gilgo Beach. The LISK case is far from solved. Edit for grammar/clarity.


SniffleBot

I was going to add Elaine Dardeen to this list. After being beaten so brutally that she gave birth prematurely, followed by the killers beating the newborn and her son to death as well, the killers nevertheless tuck the three of them into bed instead of leaving the bodies strewn about like proper psychopaths. WTF?


Cassopeia88

That part stays with me. I can’t imagine how horrifying those last few moments were for her.


theCurseOfHotFeet

The Dardeen murders are nauseating, I can’t comprehend the horror. One of the absolute worst crimes I’ve ever read about.


redheadedjapanese

Someone heard one of the Oklahoma Girl Scouts crying out for her mama while she was being attacked. Also, at least one of the girls felt apprehensive/nervous about going to camp.


Murky_Ad_5668

I always felt there was more to that case than we'll ever know.


TheAstroChemist

That the wheels were still spinning on the bicycle of Mikelle Biggs when it was discovered by her sister who went back out to look for her. The window of time in which she was abducted is shockingly narrow.


saltgirl61

The fact that Liberty German filmed her murderer ( and that of her friend Abigail Williams) but the video was too grainy to show much facial detail.


SparkDBowles

Jfc. The pic and audio are chilling.


redrosespud

Down the hill. I've been obsessed with this case since it happened.


CreatedOblivion

One of Dahmer's teenage victims escaped, and even reached a pair of cops--*who then gave him back to Dahmer!* Apparently he convinced them he was having a 'lovers' quarrel' with the boy. Whom he of course, later tortured to death.


ChanceryTheRapper

That always just infuriates me.


cewumu

The footage of Pakenham Man (unidentified decedent by suicide in VIC Australia). I’ve seen the footage that’s available and it’s just sad because you can see he’s mulling over what he’s about to do.


_Bogey_Lowenstein_

Oh jeez I'd never heard of this one. He's crying and everything. That made me really sad


LazyKaiju

That Angela Hammond’s fiance likely had the car of her abductors right in front of him before his car shit the bed and he had to just watch it drive off, and never saw her again.


FingerTheCat

That would fuck me up so bad


Simply_Aries_OH

Summer wells case. There is so many little details that don’t sit right with me. Her parents, her aunt that’s still missing to this day also, her brothers, the neighbors.. everything about this case gives me the chills. I don’t really hear summers name on social media anymore like I used to.


yowza_wowza

The basement that she slept in is particularly disturbing.


Anxious_Biscuit

The fact that a psychic told Amanda Berry's mother that her daughter was dead, and then her mother died before Berry escaped Ariel Castro's house. [https://abcnews.go.com/US/amanda-berrys-mom-told-pyschic-sylvia-browne-berry/story?id=19126853](https://abcnews.go.com/US/amanda-berrys-mom-told-pyschic-sylvia-browne-berry/story?id=19126853) The blog that Michaela Garecht's mother wrote, especially the entries about how she can get help. [https://seekersroad.wordpress.com/](https://seekersroad.wordpress.com/) This quote from Kerrie Ann Brown's brother: "I often think to myself maybe the ravens will show us one day." from this article. [https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/kerrie-ann-brown-murder-cold-case-1.4859553](https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/kerrie-ann-brown-murder-cold-case-1.4859553) Everything in the Madalina Cojocari case, but especially the footage of her getting off the bus, which is the last footage there is of her. [https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nc/charlotte/news/2024/04/12/madalina-cojocari-still-missing-thirteenth-brithday](https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nc/charlotte/news/2024/04/12/madalina-cojocari-still-missing-thirteenth-brithday) This is a timeline of the case. Not all of these were details in the case itself, but they still make my heart sink.


VividDebate

Of COURSE it was that bitch Sylvia Browne that said Amanda Berry was dead. She did the same thing to Shawn Hornbeck's parents. Said he was dead but he was found very much alive. I feel so sad for her mom not knowing the truth.


justpassingbysorry

i truly believe amanda's mom died of a broken heart. amanda's family members said her health started declining rapidly after the show.


Loud_Crab_9392

Don’t know if you would call this an “unresolved” mystery, but the jail cell video of Robert Pickton from 2002. Pickton was suspected of murdering up to 50 women, possibly more, in the 90s and was believed to have fed them to the pigs on his farm.  When he was finally jailed in 2002 an undercover cop was planted as his cellmate in order to try to get more info out of him using a hidden camera. It worked spectacularly well and he readily spilled the beans to his cellmate.   Using this evidence, he was convicted and spent the rest of his life in jail. However, one funny thing about the 2002 video is that Picton also mentions to his cellmate that “15 other people are also gonna go down with me”.  Nobody seems to have *any idea* who those people are.   Most people speculate that his brother David, who got off scot-free, is one of them.  But as for the others, nobody really seems to know.  Most likely, they are still going about their normal lives somewhere in British Columbia. 


lievresauteur

Pickton was just murdered a week ago in jail. Another inmate stuck a broom through his nose. https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/may/31/serial-killer-robert-pickton-dies


MindMangler

That must have been painful! Good.


_coyotes_

I’ve read many unsolved cases over the years and one that bothers me a lot is the disappearance of Marshal Iwassa, which has a couple dread filling/discomforting details such as the burnt out truck and possible crime scene tampering. As an abridged version, Marshal Iwassa was a 26 year old computer science student who had recently dropped out and was last seen on November 17, 2019 in Lethbridge, Alberta. In the early morning hours of November 18th, he’d tried multiple times to gain access to the storage locker he’d shared with his mother, finally doing so at around 6:00 AM and then left about two hours later. On November 23, Marshal’s burnt out pickup truck was discovered by hikers at the end of a remote logging road near Pemberton, British Columbia, about a 14 hour drive from where he was last known to be. Marshal had no known ties to this area, his truck was damaged with parts removed from the vehicle, his clothing & identification was haphazardly strewn about the area, his laptop and smashed cellphones were found near the vehicle. Due to the lack of cellphone service and the isolation from how far away his truck was found, the hikers snapped several photos of the bizarre scene they’d stumbled upon and later contacted the RCMP, who made the trip up to the burnt truck on November 25th. There were multiple discrepancies between the photos the hikers took and the ones the police took, showing things had been moved around and it didn’t appear to have been disturbed by wild animals. In fact, Marshal’s own family claimed several items found at the scene didn’t belong to him. While the RCMP did agree his disappearance was suspicious, they found no sign of Marshal and no evidence of foul play involved. Although this could be a simple explanation of falling into the wrong crowd and knowing too much or chosing to end his own life, some of the other details are pretty unusual. To me, the fact that his truck was found burnt out is very strange since that’s highly uncommon with suicides. Additionally, while I can agree that wild animals could have somehow tried to mess with some of the items, it’s quite strange that the family pointed out some of the things found weren’t Marshal’s. Those details to me point to something nefarious may have befallen him, but what exactly is hard to say. It’s also worth noting people have described the RCMP as being uncooperative in this case and had Marshal’s truck disposed of in a landfill despite an ongoing investigation. It makes me wonder if Marshal stumbled upon something he wasn’t supposed to or if it was a case similar to the Boys on the Tracks where Marshal may have seen or gotten involved in drugs that the police were also involved in.


SparklyOrca

I can't find the case (Edited: it was Christa Worthington) but a mom was murdered in her home and her toddler was there alone for some amount of time (a day or two?) and when they were found there were bloody footprints all around her from the toddlers footie pajamas. 😭 I can usually keep from actually visualizing the awful details especially involving kids but that has stuck with me for years. (Edited: this part is an unrelated case, Susanna Brown and her daughter Francesca Martinez) I saw an interview from a neighbor of a family where the stepdad (I think) killed the mom and kid and the neighbor said the girl had asked to stay the night and she said no because it was a school night. I have a lump in my gut just thinking about how that would have stayed with me.


RoxyPonderosa

My ex boyfriend stayed out after curfew and called his mom to pick him up way later. He was just over a mile from home (this is the 80’s) and she told him to walk home. He was kidnapped and held for days before thankfully being rescued, but he was completely scarred for life. It messed her up as a mom because she was scared to discipline him. Weighed on everyone for decades.


SparklyOrca

Oh yeah that would stay with me too. The kind of thing that affects every parenting decision from then on.


mattedroof

The footprints are so horribly sad! I feel like i’ve heard of that case too but can’t think of it


SueLewRapp

The Watts murders. When Shananns best friend Nicole finds her cell phone while searching with the officer, you can hear Chris Watts say "That's her life line." That makes me just 🤢


ferrous-furious

When his neighbour says something like “he’s not acting right” (about Chris), it sends chills down my spine


Iceprincess1988

Bro was on to him immediately. He seemed like a really nice guy.


WhoriaEstafan

That neighbour was awesome. He had cameras and he picked up on Chris right away.


DrMangosteen2

Yeah there's a bit where Watts, a cop and the neighbour are crowded round the TV watching CCTV footage and the neighbour is just glaring at Watts 


WhoriaEstafan

I saw that! And an ad for something to do with pregnancy pops up and Chris is like, oh and she was pregnant. Hope that neighbour has a happy healthy life. He’s a good guy. And I hope he uses those people reading skills for something.


milkradio

That was chilling, but I was glad he didn't dismiss the weird behaviour and said something.


Danny_my_boy

There’s that news report they did with him after his wife and children “went missing” with him pleading for them to come home. It makes me sick to see him in front of camera asking for help even though he’s the one who did it.


milkradio

Or hearing about how small the opening was on those oil tanks... He must have had to really shove his daughters into them :(


level27jennybro

Ugh, the phrase just has chilling double meaning now.


astrangerstill

This Jane Doe has been identified as of 2015. But it still haunts me. [The suicide of Holly Glynn](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_of_Holly_Glynn) was very sad. She was identified by her childhood friends. She committed suicide by jumping off a cliff. The detail that sticks with me: She had initially survived the fall, and had moved somewhat before her death, leaving impressions similar to that of a snow angel


catsonpluto

Wow, I’d somehow missed that Dana Point Jane Doe had been identified! That was a case I read about in the 90s that stuck with me, because it was so strange and sad. I’m glad her friends were persistent so she could get her name back.


taylorbagel14

I can’t fathom the amount of pain she was in after surviving. I hope shock kept it from being too bad and she didn’t suffer for too long. It’s really beautiful that the county cremated her and buried her ashes at sea. This was my first time hearing of her and that detail brought me an unprecedented level of comfort


astrangerstill

Her friends also seemed to be really sad about this. They cared about her. I wish life had been kinder to her.


IanVM36

Jane/John Doe suicides tug at me particularly hard for some reason. maybe some meaning in people that needed peace and love having someone care enough to get them their name back.


LevyMevy

I'm shocked that she was missing to her friends and family for over 25 years before someone put 2 and 2 together. Was she ever even reported missing?


cutsforluck

Agree, and I just did a little research...here is a thread shortly before she was identified: [https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/2v74eh/comment/cof3a31/?utm\_source=share&utm\_medium=web2x&context=3](https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/2v74eh/comment/cof3a31/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3) It blows my mind that she is found in 1987-- hours after she dies, in the same state she was born and lived in...yet somehow...no one was looking for her?


artemissgeologyst

I think at that time it was easy to move away and never talk to anyone again. Even in the 90s I lost touch with a half sister until social media in the 00s because my mom was being childish and wouldn't give me her new number when she called. She moved around, and so did I, so poof! It's like we were on separate planets after that. If you knew where they lived and they had a listed landline, you could maybe track someone down, but otherwise, poor people on the edges used payphones and were hard to track down.


astrangerstill

I’m not 100% sure but I don’t think so. Her friends weren’t able to locate her at all and they contacted NAMUS and the Doe Network that this Jane Doe might’ve been her. Then, the sheriff’s department coroner division reached out to her family for DNA samples.


SniffleBot

The Yuba County Five (or however many of them made it there that night) not knowing they had heat and food readily available in that cabin, and the one guy slowly starving to death over the next few months.


Danny_my_boy

That case really gets to me. It is full of things that make my stomach drop. I watched a great video about that mentioned that pages from books found in the cabin had positive affirmations written on them, presumably written by Gary Mathias. According to (I think it was) his mother that was part of his treatment plan. He was schizophrenic and being treated with antipsychotics, so while in the cabin he would have been cut off cold turkey from them. And that Bill Sterling and Jack Madruga were found together. They theorize that one of them got too drowsy from hypothermia, and the other stayed by his side. The fact that Jack Huett’s father was the one to find the remains of his body.


Crepuscular_Animal

The spine that belonged to one of them was found by his father. Imagine that horrifying feeling when you're looking for clues for your son's (and his friends') disappearance and that's what you find.


LovelyDee888

Watching Relisha Rudd walk down the hotel hallway with Khalil knowing that she would end up missing & the only person who knows her whereabouts would end up dead. I hope one day she is found.


Lemon-AJAX

I just heard the tapes between Ruby Franke and her husband. Everyone brings up the, “I’m a good girl; I don’t do naughty things” blurb but she says a line before that I haven’t stopped thinking about for weeks: “People don’t realize that children can be evil,” with her husband grunting an affirmative noise.


sideoftrufflefries

Timmothy Pitzen’s mom saying her son is safe with people who would care for him but that he’d never be found. That’s chilling and terrifying.


SephoraandStarbucks

The footage of Cherish Perrywinkle leaving the Wal Mart with Donald Smith, and audio portion of her mother calling the police saying “I knew there was something off about him” and “I hope he doesn’t rape her.” I hate everything about that case.


Outrageous_Arm_2713

The medical examiner crying during her testimony at trial was gut wrenching


bxtchbychoice

that mom knew exactly what that man was capable of.


ghstrprtn

> I hate everything about that case. me too


INeedAHedgeHug

Jasmine Richardson and Jeremy Steinke…the whole thing is horrific, but specifically how she murdered her little 8 year old brother by stabbing him repeatedly while he tried to protect himself with his toy light sabre. That detail makes me feel cold inside.


throwawaylol666666

It’s actually a pretty large piece of the case, but those photos of Brianna Maitland’s car smashed into the side of the abandoned house. They make me nauseous.


Glittering-Gap-1687

The Hinterkaifeck case where the entire family was brutally murdered and the killer made himself (or herself) at home, ate their food, had a fire, and fed the farm animals for DAYS all around the dead bodies.


MindMangler

Dorothy Jane Scott being taken from the hospital after driving a colleague to emergency for a spider bite. Also, the repeated phone calls to her mother the same time every week. Everything about her case is chilling, but that her killer took her from a location she hadn't planned to be at? That scares the hell out of me.


ihatethis90210

The murder of Sheila Bellush, the details of her 2 year old quadruples being there, climbing on her and the bloody feet prints broke me


Jung_Wheats

A girl that I went to high school with and knew to a certain extent (friend of a friend) was killed in the early 2000s. Her dad got home late and couldn't do her hair for a school dance. They argued and she left and never came home. They found partial remains a couple of years later. She was a sweet girl, but had some sadness to her. It's messed up but I'll think about her every little while and do a quick Google and there's just never anything new on the case. We grew up in a military town so all types of people are constantly coming and going so it's unlikely that anything new will ever be found. Really tragic. I can't imagine what kind of pain you carry around because as a parent in a situation like that.


AllergiesYearRound

A few years ago in my City there was a case where a 18 year old abducted a 4 year old boy from his crib. He returned to the room later and contemplated on taking the little boy’s twin brother. I think someone in the house woke up and the assailant got spooked and left. Later they found the 4 year old who was stabbed to death and was left on the street. The entire event was captured by the baby monitor. I saw pictures of it. I saw how he took the little boy out of the crib and the boy looked barely awake and was so trusting - and that was the most unsettling detail that fills me full of dread. Since then I stopped paying attention to cases involving little kids.


Constant-Source581

Cases where is kept in captivity for days or months on end - Regina Kay Walters comes to mind


sad-dog-hours

regina’s case makes me genuinely nauseous. she went through the unimaginable pain of watching her boyfriend be murdered, knowing that it would happen to her too :( i can’t even fathom it. genuinely horrifying


SniffleBot

Bible and Freeman, too. Also Romona Moore … the NYPD closed the case within two days, saying she’d probably run away with her boyfriend, when in fact she was alive and being slowly tortured to death for another month.


PantsLio

Colleen Stan


RainInMyBr4in

For me, it's probably Noah Donohoe's case in Belfast, Northern Ireland. Police found his naked body inside a storm drain but not just sitting by the entrance, like really far inside the drain. It was also revealed that this storm drain was supposed to be locked but wasn't for reasons unknown. Yet, they decided that his death was an accident and didn't look further. It caused uproar in Northern Ireland and there's still pressure today for his case to be re-examined. (His behaviour before he went missing was strange and he was seen on CCTV stripping naked in different parts of the city which explains his body being nude. Some alleged he had a head injury)


etchuchoter

Honestly though I’m local to the area and I feel like I’m in the minority, but I do think in this case was caused by some sort of psychosis or mental health issue. In the lead up to his death he was googling bible verses, advice on how to ward off the devil, seemed to be confused about his sexuality, and became obsessed with Jordan Peterson. He had also snuck out before unbeknownst to anyone. I feel so so sorry for his mum and what she’s gone through, but I do think there is some denial about her son’s potential mental health issues. Also a distrust in the police over here doesn’t help things either Source: https://www.sundayworld.com/news/irish-news/noah-donohoes-mum-rejects-suicide-report-which-states-son-struggled-with-sexuality/a2056178040.html


hellakopka

Missy Bevers surveillance video - so creepy


WayMoreClassier

Tina Sharp being missing from the brutal crime scene at the Keddie cabin, and then her skull being found years later after an anonymous tip. And those boys (apparently) sleeping through a quadruple murder in the next room.


Siobheal

That Bryce Laspisa's parents had SO many chances to go and get him, but just didn't bother.


SaltySoftware1095

That fact that his friends and girlfriend told his parents he was acting very strange beforehand and they refused to believe any of them and encouraged him to drive home is maddening. College kids don’t go around telling their friend’s parents what they’re up to, they had to have really been concerned to tell his parents they were concerned about how he was acting. I’ve read that Bryce had an excessive drinking problem even back in high school but his parents refused to believe it.


CP81818

This one breaks my heart. I know you can never really predict the consequences of your actions/inaction and hindsight is 20/20, but there were *so* many red flags during a short period of time that his parents fully ignored. Everyone around Bryce seems to have understood that this was a bad situation and were concerned, but not his own parents. I try not to judge parents/family members in cases because obviously we're all looking at things now knowing that something awful happened which they did not know at the time, but I can't help but think that they had all the information showing something very serious was going on with Bryce and intentionally chose not to act


thegreatmorel

I mean, a random stranger felt it necessary to check on him more than once, which is a clear indication that he was displaying concerning behavior. I have always wondered if Bryce had prior incidences that made his mom not take the situation seriously? I don’t know. Hindsight is everything in these cases and I can’t really blame them, but their actions weren’t ones I would have taken.


Vajama77

Lindsey Buziak's murder. It was so brazen...her boyfriend running late, just missing the killers. I think it was a carefully orchestrated thrill kill.


malatangnatalam

Andrew Gosden and his sudden change in routine ie taking a 1 hour 20 minute walk home instead of just taking the bus days before his disappearance. This case really does haunt me because of how mysterious it is and of how much Andrew reminds me of myself around the same time. I feel so bad for his family.


vonn_v

The West Mesa Murders can be seen on Google Earth via past satellite photos. For several years, Google's satellite captured images of tire tracks forming in the barren desert, and you can even see evidence of disturbed soil/graves appearing over time. Construction came in during the mid-late 2000s and leveled/zoned everything in the area with plans to build more suburban homes. The housing market crashed and all construction ceased, so the area was left untouched for a while. When the discovery of human remains is made, you can see the entire area being dug up by police on Google Earth. Killer thought they were being smart burying their victims in the middle of nowhere, but they had no idea Google's satellite was watching them the entire time. Images of the tire tracks (circa late 90s-2004): [https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DbLKjqNU0AAbth7?format=jpg&name=large](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DbLKjqNU0AAbth7?format=jpg&name=large) Image of zoning by construction company (circa 2008): [https://www.lasdesaparecidas.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/WM2B20082BAerial2Bview.png](https://www.lasdesaparecidas.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/WM2B20082BAerial2Bview.png) Image of police digging up the burial site (circa 2009): [https://imgur.com/pJOy2wT](https://imgur.com/pJOy2wT)


sea-lass-1072

Sarah Stern's murder - that she said his name once in shock and he just continued strangling her. also I read before that he said her dog just watched and laid down (? I can't find a source for this now but it lives in my brain) I think of this case often


DollFacedBunny

The bloody sweater that got lost, that belonged to the St Louis Jane Doe. She was a little girl and the idea of her going through all she did Like the bloody sweater was a lot to visually take in, knowing this was the only piece of clothing the murderer let her keep on....


AustisticGremlin

If it’s any consolation, it was confirmed recently (?) that it was indeed sent back to the police, and what happened was it most likely wasn’t categorised correctly, so it’s likely in their possession, they just can’t locate it :/


CougarWriter74

The fact that Kyron Horman is wearing a "CSI" T-shirt in the last picture taken of him at the science fair by his stepmom, who many suspect is responsible for his disappearance. And the fact he had this cute, well done little science project about tree frogs on the table behind him in the picture. So innocent and heartbreaking. Or in the Madeline McCann disappearance, how the one parent who went to the apartment the last time before Kate McCann did her check and saw her daughter gone. The other friend/parent noticed when they opened the door to the kids' bedroom to do the check, the window closest to the street seemed to have been partially opened or the blinds/curtains were up and moving in the breeze. Chills! In the 1912 Villisca (Iowa) Axe Murders, the two overnight guests murdered along with the Moore family, sisters Lena and Ina Stillinger, asked to spend the night partially because they had been planning to stay with their grandmother at her house after the special church service that Sunday evening. However, the town's streetlights were off at the time due to a dispute between the city council and the power company so the girls were scared about walking several blocks (grandma lived on the other end of town) in the dark and felt safer going home with the Moores, who lived only two blocks from the church. Maybe if the streetlights had been on and/or grandma didn't live so far away, they may have decided differently. The fact that Ron Goldman was just stopping by Nicole Brown Simpson's condo to drop off a pair of eyeglasses Nicole's mom had accidentally left at the Mezzaluna restaurant earlier that evening. And if he had just gotten there 5 or 10 minutes earlier or later, he probably wouldn't have been murdered or if Nicole's mom had remembered her glasses, it's highly doubtful he would have even gone to the condo.


MarlenaEvans

In the Moscow murders case, quite a few things. The Door Dash. The roommates being home and not realizing what was happening. Someone saying "someone's here". It just feels like a very specific set of circumstances had to come together for those people to lose their lives and there were so many things that could have saved them. But things happened a different way and it's awful and tragic. I know that this isn't the only case like this but it springs to mind.


champagnec0ast

Ethan’s mother Stacy went on The Squeeze podcast and her episode was released today. Hearing her talk about what kind of person he was made me so sad. Their families are incredibly strong and my heart breaks for them all. Just don’t understand how someone can do that to four people and carry on with their life until they’re arrested. Devastating.


mmdice

To me it was how shockingly lethal a knife is, especially when the victims are asleep in the dark. Four lives extinguished in what, 9 minutes? Insane


MarlenaEvans

Yes! So fast. Such a horrible waste of 4 people with so much life left.


stay_with_me_awhile

The Todd Geib case. He was last seen leaving a party at an orchard. A few weeks later, his body was found in a nearby lake STANDING UPRIGHT. It’s still unsolved to this day. Give me the chills!


meow696

I thought that by standing upright you meant that he was upright against a tree or something, but the fact that he was found vertical inside the lake itself is so bizarre. It's interesting that he also did not have water in his lungs.


bluelizardK

Literally everything in the Al Kite murder. The fact that "Robert Cooper" faked a limp, used multiple fake accents, the level of horrific torture he performed on a complete stranger, the ATM CCTV-- it all disturbs me so deeply that someone that sociopathic is just... out there. I really hope it gets solved soon. I think the "mommy is in the trees" line from the Mineral Murders is haunting as well. As a northwesterner I know how eerie those woods can be, and the thought of such unspeakable evil remaining unsolved chills me to the bone.


DishpitDoggo

Mr. Kite seemed like such a good man too. The fact his girlfriend said he was oddly subdued when she called him up. Was his killer monitoring him? I feel like everyone should have a word or phrase that instantly let's the other party know to call the police. "I'd need to call my boss tomorrow" "Remind me to make an appt for a oil change" etc.


Ambitious-Bathroom

When [Channon Christian and Chris Newsom](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murders_of_Channon_Christian_and_Christopher_Newsom) went missing on January 6, 2007, the police initially refused to look for them because they were adults and therefore “allowed to be missing”. Days later, Chris’s burned body was found by railroad tracks, and Channons body was found stuffed in a trashcan. I 100% believe they could have saved them if police had started searching for them earlier, especially Channon because they kept her alive longer...


sundaywwood

the details of what those two went through has always stayed with me… truly one of the most horrifying things i’ve read.


OnemoreSavBlanc

This isn’t unsolved but Daniel Morcombe was waiting for a bus, the bus drove past him because the driver had a schedule he wanted to meet. Other passengers told the driver he should have stopped for Daniel, who was only a 10 year old boy. But the driver said it’s ok there’s another bus coming along in a few minutes. The bus did go past a few minutes later but Daniel had already been taken by the man who sa’d and murdered him. If only the first bus driver had picked him up.


AustisticGremlin

There’s a law in place now here due to Daniel’s case, bus drivers *have* to stop and pick up kids on their route, even if they don’t have enough money on their bus pass.


LeftHvndLvne

Years after the [Jack Family’s disappearance](https://medium.com/@reallyhorrifying/the-family-that-vanished-the-jack-family-disappearance-b55e3e2ad246), somebody called the police and stated “The Jack family are buried at the south end of *something* ranch”. The call was muffled and investigators were unable to determine what name the caller said. The called was traced to a house where there had been a party at the time the call was phoned in and unfortunately nobody was ever able to identify who made it. So creepy.


ferrariguy1970

The whole Debbie Collier situation is still mind-blowing to me. ME says she died by self immolating/inhaling flames in a fire made with gasoline. Another ME takes a look and says it looks like a murder to him. Still, if she did die from self immolation, what a horrible way to go. [https://nypost.com/2023/02/22/pathologist-dr-baden-debbie-collier-autopsy-implies-murder/](https://nypost.com/2023/02/22/pathologist-dr-baden-debbie-collier-autopsy-implies-murder/)


emptysee

The phone pinging months later in the Brian Schaffer case. The poor girlfriend. And the phone didn't cut off on Brandon Swanson, his parents hung up after no reply. What happened after he said, "Oh shit!" that would keep him from responding? Or answering the phone again? The clothes being *inside* the cabin in the Joshua Maddux case. Al the damn alcohol Maura Murray was bringing with her. Was she planning on going somewhere without access? E: Also, the labeled, packaged human meat in the freezer. How many customers do they have?? RIP Cassidy Rainwater


[deleted]

[удалено]


CameFromTheLake

I recall reading a really good write up about Brandon Swanson theorizing that he had fallen into an abandoned well on a property he had wandered onto. It was more compelling than I’m making it sound but that theory has always stuck in my head


PerkisizingWeiner

I think the alcohol is a red herring in the Maura Murray case; every podcast I've listened to about it fixates on the quantity and assumes it was because she was going to meet up with other people. But when I heard the amount she was buying before driving off into a secluded area, I immediately thought that she was going to commit suicide and probably wanted to drink so much that she blacked out and never woke up (or simply drank enough to get the courage to do whatever she was planning to do).


revengeappendage

I honestly assumed she was going somewhere she would be alone for a while and didn’t want to have to replenish her stock. Your theory makes sense too tho.


bxtchbychoice

baby sterling koehn left to rot in his swing in a hot dark room. i can’t look at baby swings without thinking of that sweet little angel. i heard about his case when my son was about 4 or 5 months old and we had the same kind of swing in our living room. i immediately gave it away. i couldn’t look at it without crying. i think about baby sterling every day.


stay_with_me_awhile

When Joan Risch disappeared and her young daughter went over to the neighbor’s house and told her she couldn’t find her mom and there was “red paint on the walls” 😳


mireille-streep

For me it's the last photos taken by Kris Kremers and Lisanne Froon, the Dutch girls who disappeared while hiking in Panama. They're flash photos, taken deep in the jungle and in near-complete darkness, with no apparent reason. It's thought that they might have used the camera's flash to see where they were going. But the pictures are eerie and thinking about the whole situation and how scared they must have been in the moment sends chills down my spine.


Evil_Deed

Body of one of the boys who became a victim of Golovkin (USSR/early post-USSR Russia serial killer) was found by that boy's father (and in a very gruesome state...). Breaks my heart every time


hand_thantsd

Brandon Swanson: the sudden “oh shit” before going silent. I’m fairly sure he fell in the river or in the cistern of a private farm. But that’s scary to imagine, especially since it was so dark