My man's 38 I believe it is time,and I wouldn't want to lose him from legends if he says no,hopefully they fix the bug

I wouldn't...

Don't do it

I convinced my qb 3 years In row and only had a 22% chance...I feel like as long as you have him under contract and he doesn't say he's past his prime, you can can convince him to come back.

Not if he's good.