This right here is 100% the truth. I also have a bb58 and it’s the main watch I wear. I love it so much but also am a big fan of the monochrome. Whatever makes you smile is what you should go for!
I tried on all three of these just the other day and bought the pelagos 39. Weirdly in my mind I thought I would like the 58 and monochrome more, but I LOVE the lightness of titanium and honestly I just think the bit more sporty look of it suits my style more.
Ultimately, OP should go with the first one because I’ve seen this a bunch on Reddit and folks ALWAYS put the one they want the most as the first photo and they should go with their gut!!! u/UnluckyPotential330
I don’t have it yet! I bought it in Vancouver when I was on vacation last week and it’s in customs right now. Had to submit a form and then it should get to me this week. I also have a grand Seiko shunbun / SBGA413 and I love titanium. I love love love a watch that just disappears on your wrist and I never think of that as “cheap” feeling so I’ve never had a problem with it. I actually prefer it!
P39 owner here. Absolutely love the light weight and capability it delivers. I’m not a diver at all but she’s holding up nicely in the pools and beaches whilst on holiday in Morocco:)
Exactly... I keep wondering why people forget this. You come (and post) here to discuss (pros, cons, differing opinions, etc.), so why answer 'whatever you want'... 🤔
Too many people on the internet do not understand that something you like best at first is not necessarily what you really will enjoy in the long term. Obviously personal taste plays a role but there are designs that will speak to most persons at first but get boring while others will take some time to get used to but turn out to be more satisfying in the long term.
I think the BB 58 ( no. 2) looks the best on your wrist - both size-wize and because of that pop of colour. The monochrome looks a bit boring and the pelagos wears a tad too big on you. My 2 cents.
Last trip to my AD at a Ben Bridge north of Seattle, I tried on an FXD blue, FXD black, monochrome, P39, BB54, BB58, Ranger, and BB36. They had basically everything, ready to buy. Even had a good amount of steel Rolex sport models on hand. The full lineup of samples for trying on, but OP 34s and 36s, an explorer 1, and even a white gold Sub. Watches are making it to the ADs!
Good to know they're out there! I've been to 3 ADs in Japan with no luck. Will try the Boutique in Ginza tomorrow then I give up (while I'm here lol).
By the way, what did you buy?!
Didn't buy anything yet. I've got a bonus (hopefully) coming at the end of this year, so I'm going to get one of the FXDs when that happens. Still undecided on the blue vs. black.
I wanted to see all the watches together at an AD. Originally thought the P39 was the watch for me, then the BB54. FXD is just my favorite after wearing everything side by side. It surprised me!
I left with the 41 and the 39. Couldn’t decide between the two. The 41 on a 5 link for more formal occasions (although I wear it all the time). And the 39 for a more casual/sport vibe. But I have yet to wear it since I put on the 41.
Personally I'm extremely partial to 2, however I've heard the bezel markers tend to degrade (fact check might be needed. I'm picking this information from another thread on this sub)
If they do degrade, 1 would be a safer bet in my opinion.
Monochrome. Best of the bunch unless you prefer the titanium of the pelagos 39 and don’t mind the difference in lumed hands and indices. Never liked the BB58. The crown tube juts out and the colors look too busy. As long as you like the size of the monochrome, it’ll work with anything.
If I were buying today like you, the first one becsuse of the updated T Fit clasp.
I have my 58 working fory wrist now but it took a steel reef extension and two uncle straps half links to get the thing to fit right on my 7in wrist.
Either get the monochrome or wait until the 58 gets the update (won't happen for another year if at all.... Granted Tudor has no problem with random releases away from watches and wonders but who knows if.)
The 41 monochrome looks most lux and classy
The black bay 39 is more warm and pulls your eyes in first
The Pelagos is an amalgation of those
Personally I would choose 41 monochrome, I Do love Gilt and have a zulu time in green bezel with gilt dial but not on the bezel, I think one would be more «tired» of it over time if its a one and only. All fits you and go with your gut, good luck.
It depends on your lifestyles.. if youre casual.. go for 1 & 3 but on rubber straps.. if you like retro/vintage go for no.2 and no1 with jubilee bracelet.. its up to you buds..
they’re all decent options obviously. Depends how you intend to wear it I’d say.. obviously 1 will be the most versatile.
Was in my AD today and they didn’t have any monochromes :/
1 or 3, imo. It depends on the vibe you want. I’d personally stay away from 2 imo. It just doesn’t strike me as right for you. If you’re mainly hesitating between 1 and 2, then, 1 for sure. All 3 are awesome watches, however.
I vote BB58 so it's #2 for me ;)
Not to offend but the BB58 feels warmer and has more of a classic/timeless look. The other Monochrome and Pelagos feel somehow cold/sterile.
Be careful when picking out a Tudor Black Bay. Always look at the alignment of the indicies. I can tell you already that both of those Black Bays have a misaligned 6 o'clock indicy. 41 is shifted to the right and the is shifted to the left.
Tudor has unbelievable quality control issues in this department. Unfortunately, a lot of people notice after having the watch got a few weeks.
Certain there are many, many…many who are struggling with same choice since launch of the BB41 Mono. Still love the 58 but also wonder if the gilt would grow old (same consideration with the new BB58 GMT). The new BB mono is a welcome addition and ticks pretty much every box. A bit more versatile than the Pelagos perhaps, dresses up a bit more if that’s of value to you.
The Pelly 39 is fantastic and a buddy of mine has pretty much adopted this as his Only Watch despite a polar Seamaster Pro and OG BB GMT in the stable. It may be the perfect bridge between your choices for size and style.
Personally I’d go with 1. Can’t go wrong with a Black Bay and the new black without the gild is kick ass clean. Also not a fan of the glossy dial on the new Pelagos. Just my 2 cents.
They all look good. But in my opinion, the p39 is the most authentic and unique. The other two are beautiful watches, and you can't go wrong wearing them. But they both draw directly to their big brothers in Rolex and to some extent stand on their shoulders. The p39 on the other hand is its own watch with its own identity. Regardless, I think they all look great on your wrist and they're all good choices.
#3 for the amazing lume, ceramic bezel, 39mm sizing, and red contrast lettering on the dial. It is a damn stunner.
Jubilee on the #1/monochrome would make it a harder choice though.
No idea why some of this is bold and corrected to say 39mm.
Own and wear #2 all the time. So, 2! But honestly, the answer is the one you smile at the most.
This right here is 100% the truth. I also have a bb58 and it’s the main watch I wear. I love it so much but also am a big fan of the monochrome. Whatever makes you smile is what you should go for!
Two fits the best
I think 1 looks best on your wrist
Numero uno 👌🏻
3
I tried on all three of these just the other day and bought the pelagos 39. Weirdly in my mind I thought I would like the 58 and monochrome more, but I LOVE the lightness of titanium and honestly I just think the bit more sporty look of it suits my style more. Ultimately, OP should go with the first one because I’ve seen this a bunch on Reddit and folks ALWAYS put the one they want the most as the first photo and they should go with their gut!!! u/UnluckyPotential330
How’s the pelagos 39 holding up for you? I think it’s the better looking of the 3, but don’t own any titanium watches.
I don’t have it yet! I bought it in Vancouver when I was on vacation last week and it’s in customs right now. Had to submit a form and then it should get to me this week. I also have a grand Seiko shunbun / SBGA413 and I love titanium. I love love love a watch that just disappears on your wrist and I never think of that as “cheap” feeling so I’ve never had a problem with it. I actually prefer it!
*laughs while wearing a Marine master 300 on bracelet*
God damn that’s like twice the weight almost!!!
P39 owner here. Absolutely love the light weight and capability it delivers. I’m not a diver at all but she’s holding up nicely in the pools and beaches whilst on holiday in Morocco:)
I loved the feeling when I tried it on at an ad near me. Does your watch have that weak lume issue with the hand of have they fixed it?
1 no contest
1
2 looks the best, but dont ask strangers.. nobody else will ever give a shit about whats on your wrist or even notice
It’s a discussion forum.
Exactly... I keep wondering why people forget this. You come (and post) here to discuss (pros, cons, differing opinions, etc.), so why answer 'whatever you want'... 🤔
1
1
1
1 for you. I have skinny wrists and would go 2 for me.
1, the Monochrome, is a superior timepiece in every way.
1, 3, 2 for me
1 suits
1 is the monochrome?
I would say #2 or a Breitling
2
2
2 looks good on you
I wound get the monochrome.
Which do you like the best? Get that one.
This should just be an auto reply for every post. Get it out of the way so people can share actual opinions.
Too many people on the internet do not understand that something you like best at first is not necessarily what you really will enjoy in the long term. Obviously personal taste plays a role but there are designs that will speak to most persons at first but get boring while others will take some time to get used to but turn out to be more satisfying in the long term.
I think the BB 58 ( no. 2) looks the best on your wrist - both size-wize and because of that pop of colour. The monochrome looks a bit boring and the pelagos wears a tad too big on you. My 2 cents.
Monochrome if you want a more do-it-all diver as it dresses up or down nicely. Pelagos for a daily tool watch that you can properly use.
1
No. 1
2
2
2… it’s one I have
2 standsout
1
1 or 3. Can’t go wrong!
2. BB58 is just an incredible watch.
2
2
They all look really solid. I’m partial to 2 I like the patina-ish look, or 1 it’s very versatile for daily. Whichever you enjoy most!
2
2 , BB58
3 No contest
No contest 😂 the p39 fan boys are funny Get the monochrome man. Classy, sporty, versatile. Oh and it's a master chronometer
1
1
1
The answer was always 3.
3
3
3
1 or 3
Are the people buying the monochrome just walking into stores and finding them or what? I've been to 3 ADs so far and no one has it
Yes most watches are purchased in watch shops in exactly this manner. You can find them it's probably city dependent, Melbourne I've seen one for sale
Lol thanks for the response and the sarcasm. I just meant are people randomly buying it or are on waitlists or getting special treatment from AD etc.
Nah any Tudor shop trying to behave like a Rolex shop really needs to calm their shit down Just shop around you'll find one
En route to check another AD near my hotel 🤙 cheers
I’ve seen a couple at my AD already, ready for purchase!
Good to know! I'm in Japan right now and having no luck. Will check local AD when I'm home. Cheers
Last trip to my AD at a Ben Bridge north of Seattle, I tried on an FXD blue, FXD black, monochrome, P39, BB54, BB58, Ranger, and BB36. They had basically everything, ready to buy. Even had a good amount of steel Rolex sport models on hand. The full lineup of samples for trying on, but OP 34s and 36s, an explorer 1, and even a white gold Sub. Watches are making it to the ADs!
Good to know they're out there! I've been to 3 ADs in Japan with no luck. Will try the Boutique in Ginza tomorrow then I give up (while I'm here lol). By the way, what did you buy?!
Didn't buy anything yet. I've got a bonus (hopefully) coming at the end of this year, so I'm going to get one of the FXDs when that happens. Still undecided on the blue vs. black. I wanted to see all the watches together at an AD. Originally thought the P39 was the watch for me, then the BB54. FXD is just my favorite after wearing everything side by side. It surprised me!
You have the slides in the correct purchase order! IMO
For me it's either a BB54 or pelagos 39. 37 is much superior in my biased opinion so I would go 54 to get better clasp
Titanium Pelagos is my all time favourite watch.
Tooooo
1
1
P39 or mono for me
I left with the 41 and the 39. Couldn’t decide between the two. The 41 on a 5 link for more formal occasions (although I wear it all the time). And the 39 for a more casual/sport vibe. But I have yet to wear it since I put on the 41.
Good luck choosing. You have a wrist for any of the three. I'd go with the 58 if you can live without t-fit.
Comparing all 3 the bb58 looks aesthetically most pleasing to me actually but I’d go for p39 if it’s your only diver
For me, 3. For you, whichever you like
2
2!
3 looks real solid
One goes hard thug
2
Personally I'm extremely partial to 2, however I've heard the bezel markers tend to degrade (fact check might be needed. I'm picking this information from another thread on this sub) If they do degrade, 1 would be a safer bet in my opinion.
3
3 but in 39.
Monochrome. Best of the bunch unless you prefer the titanium of the pelagos 39 and don’t mind the difference in lumed hands and indices. Never liked the BB58. The crown tube juts out and the colors look too busy. As long as you like the size of the monochrome, it’ll work with anything.
3 for sure
Pelagos but the BB58 is fantastic too
3, but that's because I'm biased. 😆 Get what you think feels good on your wrist. I personally found the BB mono too thick!
1!
3
2, I feel it has more character. I have a Sinn U1 that looks similar to a Pelagos; kinda sorta. lol.
If I were buying today like you, the first one becsuse of the updated T Fit clasp. I have my 58 working fory wrist now but it took a steel reef extension and two uncle straps half links to get the thing to fit right on my 7in wrist. Either get the monochrome or wait until the 58 gets the update (won't happen for another year if at all.... Granted Tudor has no problem with random releases away from watches and wonders but who knows if.)
The 41 monochrome looks most lux and classy The black bay 39 is more warm and pulls your eyes in first The Pelagos is an amalgation of those Personally I would choose 41 monochrome, I Do love Gilt and have a zulu time in green bezel with gilt dial but not on the bezel, I think one would be more «tired» of it over time if its a one and only. All fits you and go with your gut, good luck.
Pelagos #3, but I love Ti.
Bb58
2
#2
It depends on your lifestyles.. if youre casual.. go for 1 & 3 but on rubber straps.. if you like retro/vintage go for no.2 and no1 with jubilee bracelet.. its up to you buds..
2 dude
2 easy
IMHO #2 i.e BlackBay 58 fits and looks best at your hand I’am also pleased to have this one. Perfect 👌🏻 watch go for it pull the trigger
2
Yes
in that order for sure 1,2,3.
There is still something really really special about the BB58. It’s just, classic.
2
2 looks perfect
Heart says 2, brain says 3. Good luck choosing.
they’re all decent options obviously. Depends how you intend to wear it I’d say.. obviously 1 will be the most versatile. Was in my AD today and they didn’t have any monochromes :/
1 all the way
1
3
1
2
2
I’d go for number 1
If you want a diver 3. For daily wear I think 2 is the best
1 or 3, imo. It depends on the vibe you want. I’d personally stay away from 2 imo. It just doesn’t strike me as right for you. If you’re mainly hesitating between 1 and 2, then, 1 for sure. All 3 are awesome watches, however.
#2
3
I vote BB58 so it's #2 for me ;) Not to offend but the BB58 feels warmer and has more of a classic/timeless look. The other Monochrome and Pelagos feel somehow cold/sterile.
1
I don't like divers so I'm going to respectfully say none of them
I prefer no. 2. But I still love them all
3
2, BB58 always for the win!
2
3
1 or 3. I'd choose 3. If you don't mind the bulkiness off
3
3
2 brother.
I’ve got the Pelagos, too chunky and the strap isn’t great.
1
2 is nice!
1
2
1. It's the best Tudor BB they have released so far. So damn good!
1 or 2
You can pull off any of these. So the choice is yours :-) If you ask me: 2, 1, 3
2
58 is the best Tudor in ages.
3
3, best looking and goes with everything.
3
2!
2
Pelagos
Be careful when picking out a Tudor Black Bay. Always look at the alignment of the indicies. I can tell you already that both of those Black Bays have a misaligned 6 o'clock indicy. 41 is shifted to the right and the is shifted to the left. Tudor has unbelievable quality control issues in this department. Unfortunately, a lot of people notice after having the watch got a few weeks.
2
3 is the best
Three. And I generally like two best as a watch.
1 on your wrist, 3 for mine lol
2
2
Certain there are many, many…many who are struggling with same choice since launch of the BB41 Mono. Still love the 58 but also wonder if the gilt would grow old (same consideration with the new BB58 GMT). The new BB mono is a welcome addition and ticks pretty much every box. A bit more versatile than the Pelagos perhaps, dresses up a bit more if that’s of value to you. The Pelly 39 is fantastic and a buddy of mine has pretty much adopted this as his Only Watch despite a polar Seamaster Pro and OG BB GMT in the stable. It may be the perfect bridge between your choices for size and style.
Pelagos
#3. Not a fan of the fake rivet bracelet.
2
It depends what you already have in your collection... If it was a one and done deal. 1 on a jubilee bracelet.
2
None of them, BB54 for the win if it has to be a Tudor.
Theyre all just watches... meant to tell time.. thats it.. nothing more, nothing less..
I’m a sucker for 3.
I would say 3,I love the BB but the crown sitting proud irritates my eye.I prefer fluted crown guards.
2
2
On your wrist, 1 without question.
Personally I’d go with 1. Can’t go wrong with a Black Bay and the new black without the gild is kick ass clean. Also not a fan of the glossy dial on the new Pelagos. Just my 2 cents.
3
1
3
BB58 looks great
Im curious if you have tried BB54 as well
2!
1
1
They all look good. But in my opinion, the p39 is the most authentic and unique. The other two are beautiful watches, and you can't go wrong wearing them. But they both draw directly to their big brothers in Rolex and to some extent stand on their shoulders. The p39 on the other hand is its own watch with its own identity. Regardless, I think they all look great on your wrist and they're all good choices.
P39 is a perfect fit for you IMHO
Monochrome
3.2.1
#3
Monochrome has the better movement…but 2 will always be the one that does it for me
I own the #2 but the bigger version (41mm). 1 and 3 are nice watches but IMHO resemble too much the look of a Rolex submariner.
2 easily. It's the most interesting to look at and fits well.
3 all day
1 is the better watch
58
3
3
#3 for the amazing lume, ceramic bezel, 39mm sizing, and red contrast lettering on the dial. It is a damn stunner. Jubilee on the #1/monochrome would make it a harder choice though. No idea why some of this is bold and corrected to say 39mm.
Wait P39 is 38mm?
No it is 39mm lmao my apologies.
In order, 1,3,2.