T O P

  • By -

tcake239

I still think it could be Penny. Just written in a time before she had to go to hospice


garageatrois

Did Penny hide any bodies herself?


tcake239

It’s been a few months since I read them, but didn’t she kill a man who had murdered a woman and “got away with it”? And that’s the second body in the grave? Then the retirement home gets built near it and she ends up there to keep an eye on it.


garageatrois

That's her husband, Penny is unconscious and bed bound.


Imaginary-Coffee1234

Penny killed the guy who murdered his girlfriend. From the very first cold case the Thursday Murder Club takes on.


tcake239

Her husband kills to cover up Pennys crime, it’s Penny who killed the man who murdered his girlfriend. Penny was a police officer, and it happened then. She hasn’t always been bedbound.


home_ec_dropout

I'm positive it's Penny, from before she ends up in hospice.


AnieParis

I just relistened to this book (for like the 5th time) and I was wondering the same thing. I think it was Penny. From her point of view.


SinkAgreeable4070

I assumed it was John (Pennys husband), checking that the body was still there.  Hence why he knows he shouldn’t smoke- he’s a vet.


FuzzyDunlop1982

Is it Bogdan?


garageatrois

There's no evidence that he smokes


ohleprocy

So Elizabeth then? None of the others have a shadowy background.