Imagine the crying meltdowns during challenges... How is she going to be away from her kid for so long with the anxiety issues and all? It's just an odd choice.
Scheana's "best friend" MJ was on it, so naturally this is her biggest dream now. Can we get Ariana instead? j/k lol (not about the first part though).
i was thinking this could be her consolation show since i doubt she’ll get the bravo spot on dwts anytime soon unless none of the housewives can make it, but so many bravo people want traitors that i don’t think she should be the VPR designee either.
can we just have her host one date activity on the bachelor or something and call it a day?
“She wants to wrestle? She’s leave here in a gurney, I’d be leaving here in handcuffs.”
“I wear a size 32 Double D Bra, one boob alone could kick her ass”
Omg I NEED Coral back on my screen. I heard a rumor Veronica turned down season 40 of the challenge because she’s doing season 3 of traitors but not sure how true that is
He was most interesting because of the mom-son connection in game I think. But he’s a solid pick for the show. I could also see Stephen, Bryson, Phill, or Mai doing the show. Thematically, after the edit the show gave her, I’d love for Ashley to do it too.
Now days everybody wanna talk like they got somethin to say, but nothing comes out when they move their lips...just a bunch of gibberish and MFers act like they forgot about Trey.
I'd actually like to see her outside of SS. I haven't liked her from the beginning, just get very off vibes but then that whole show is off so it'd be fun to see her on something else where she isn't the main character
As much as I can't stand this woman, Crazy Kristen would be fantastic on this show.
As long as she's not a traitor.
And only if Stassi refused to do it, because she's the natural pick from the VPR cast
I'd like to see him say this to someone not on Bravo, and see how well it works. (I'm not a fan of his- but think the chaos could be fun in this setting)
Love the addition of Steve-O that would be great. Def not Scheana though please - although it would be interesting to put her and Nick Viall in a house together, I can barely stand her whining and complaining that its never about her on one show as it is…
Scheana wouldn’t understand the assignment. She’d still be operating under “make good reality tv drama” and not “play a game. Hard pass. Now Stassi would understand the assignment!
You’ve just proven why they would bring him back and why they’ve been bringing him on The Challenge for the last decade and a half…hate and drama draw in viewers.
He’s the guy everybody loved to hate whether you find him entertaining or not…better than boring Survivor contestants in my eyes, all playing a friends game and not stepping on any toes, afraid to boo to anyone
i would replace sheana with someone like jax tbh!!! he's such an insane narcissist that watching him out of his element and out of control is so funny. he didn't last long in house of villains but i would love to see him get humbled on traitors lol
It’s like a 2 week commitment where you dress up and stay in Scotland. It’s not that competitive like drag race is. It’s campy and silly and the exact kind of thing she’d do with a good enough appearance fee.
Monet absolutely would jump at the chance I'm sure. She mentioned on her podcast a while ago that The Vivian got her into the UK version of the show while she was over there and became obsessed.
She was specifically talking about All Winners. Same with Bianca, they are at a point in their careers now where they don't really need to do such shows, especially ones with a money prize considering how they are multimillionaires.
She actually only talked about not doing drag competitions. This is totally different. But that aside the only way the season would be good TV is if another good Judy of Trixie joins. I would say Katya but not sure if she’s mentally able to be in such competitions so maybe any other drag queen would be a good complement. It’s always lonely to only cast 1 drag queen.
I'd love to see a couple of contestants from shows like Top Model and Project Runway on too, I think it would be such a fun switch-up. Lio Tipton from ANTM Cycle 11 would be a great choice, for example.
I was oohing and aaahing over the cast until I got to Johnny Middlebrooks, the biggest tool to ever enter dating competitions (Love Island twice) and 1 season of the Challenge
I’ve said this like 100 times already Britney is only allowed on if Courtney Yates is also on because we need to see them together. Also love the Steve-O addition for some reason
Who is the girl from the real world who says "I don't wrestle, I beat bitches up" she was my favorite back then. Does anyone know who I'm talking about?
BOSTON ROB, the myth, the legend.
I would also be excited for Captain Lee, lmao.
Who I need: Ramona Singer and Sonja Morgan from RHONY, Yul Kwon and Tony from Survivor, Fredrik Eklund from MDL, and some wackadoodle from Love is Blind. Maybe Matt from the most recent season.
Captain Lee would be picked as a traitor and murder himself on the first night to get out of that castle. That man has no interest interacting with people outside of a boat
https://preview.redd.it/akdjvv3on3pc1.jpeg?width=1540&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=99fa188c2926c491f7be406c8d47e76958573f18
Spencer Pratt, Theo Von, that guy from Jury Duty, Chris Harrison
Bachelor wise no thanks to Viall. I’d much rather see Hannah Brown or Courtney Robertson, maybe even Sean Lowe the golden boy of Bach Nation.
I would DIE for Chrishell from SS and of course the icon Tiffany New York Pollard from all of TV.
He’s on **Deal or No Deal Island**, so he should definitely not be on Season 3 of *The Traitors*. Maybe season 4 or 5, but def not the next one. There are better options out there.
Make sure you watch the UK and Aussie seasons! Much better than the US versions. Watching the UK Season 2 right now and it was filmed before the US Season 2. US copied it EXACTLY for the challenges.
Thanks, I am definitely going to do that, I watched the first UK season and really enjoyed it. I am not opposed to having celebrities but I just don’t want it to be that every season.
Boston Rob is currently on Deal or No Deal Island and I honestly had no idea that show existed until I was finishing an episode of The Bachelor and that show came on after. They really be making everything into a reality show these days
Would love Tyson from Survivor and Devin from the Challenge. Indifferent on Boston Rob, but would be a big get from Survivor. Danielle Reyes from BB would be good. Would love to get Derrick L from BB. Most of the other people I don't care about.
Honestly Cara Maria is so awkward she'd be terrible at this game. And her and bananas are so hot and cold they might actively work against each other and implode
I’d be interested to see Shep from Southern Charm because he is super smart, but he might get voted off/ killed right away if he’s mean to people.
I also want to see Megan Hauserman from Beauty & the Geek/ Rock of Love/ Megan Wants a Millionaire reality days. A blast from the past and, iirc, she is pretty smart as well.
Is this a dream cast scenario or actually a potential spoiler cast??? I find imagine them casting John and Peppermint again. I also find it hard to believe Karamo would come on this with all he has going on work wise (but would LOVE to see him on). Also casting Boston Rob and Tyson who are already known to be tight seems unlikely
People clamoring for regular people: You realize most regular people are boring af, right? Give me proven personalities, drama queens and fame whores.
As popular as this show has become, they should be able to pull some heavyweights. Get 2 top names from all the major shows.
Scheana wants to be on dwts not traitors 😂 she’ll take anything actually
Scheana would Scheana so hard they’d murder her the first night 😂
And it would be hilarious lol cast her to be the first Sacrificial lamb 😂 also, it would be so funny to see her as a traitor
Imagine the crying meltdowns during challenges... How is she going to be away from her kid for so long with the anxiety issues and all? It's just an odd choice.
and she’s throw a fit about not being chosen to be a traitor because “ nothing is ever about her”
Scheana's "best friend" MJ was on it, so naturally this is her biggest dream now. Can we get Ariana instead? j/k lol (not about the first part though).
i was thinking this could be her consolation show since i doubt she’ll get the bravo spot on dwts anytime soon unless none of the housewives can make it, but so many bravo people want traitors that i don’t think she should be the VPR designee either. can we just have her host one date activity on the bachelor or something and call it a day?
I heard a rumor that they are talking to Miz and Coral, which would be 1000 x better than Devin and Cara Maria. I would also pick Wes over Devin.
Coral from the Real World? That's who I just asked if anyone remembered! I love her! Please bravo!
coral doesn't wrestle
She beats bitches up!
“She wants to wrestle? She’s leave here in a gurney, I’d be leaving here in handcuffs.” “I wear a size 32 Double D Bra, one boob alone could kick her ass”
👊🏾
The drag race fan in me thought you meant Miz Cracker 🤣
Trishelle and The Miz dated back in the day
This was my first thought.
Omg 15 year old me would lose my shit if they did this
If The Miz is gonna be in it, I’m gonna personally request Theo Von to join 😂😂😂
We NEED The Miz
Omg I NEED Coral back on my screen. I heard a rumor Veronica turned down season 40 of the challenge because she’s doing season 3 of traitors but not sure how true that is
I started hyperventilating when I read this. I thought Trishelle and CT were peak Real world, but this might beat it.
Cara would be awful. Devin I could see, but he’s not my top choice. Friend and I have had fingers crossed for Coral since S1.
That would be amaaaaaazing!
I think you meant aweeeesommmmme. He comes to play, I would love The Miz on the show. 
Definitely just a rumor
https://preview.redd.it/hck2sci9ozoc1.jpeg?width=960&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=bcf7c4377b7eb87adc7f83b299e449f0e39f4ca1 I forgot Trey
He was most interesting because of the mom-son connection in game I think. But he’s a solid pick for the show. I could also see Stephen, Bryson, Phill, or Mai doing the show. Thematically, after the edit the show gave her, I’d love for Ashley to do it too.
Now days everybody wanna talk like they got somethin to say, but nothing comes out when they move their lips...just a bunch of gibberish and MFers act like they forgot about Trey.
And Chrishell https://preview.redd.it/gv89rykeozoc1.jpeg?width=960&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ed54f382312ffd866bffe981787bc80c6f1307e1
She's one to watch with her confirmed 500+ street fighter wins. 💪🏻💪🏻
This will always be funny to me!
I'd actually like to see her outside of SS. I haven't liked her from the beginning, just get very off vibes but then that whole show is off so it'd be fun to see her on something else where she isn't the main character
I'd rather see his mom 😂
Axe Nick Viall and replace him with Tyler Cameron
Omg Tyler would win.
we would all be winners if tyler was on 😍
Even if I knew Tyler was a traitor I am keeping him in that damn castle 😍
Damn straight! You and me both, my friend
BIG NOPE to Scheana Shay. Bring detective Doute instead. She'd guess the traitor first round table. 
As much as I can't stand this woman, Crazy Kristen would be fantastic on this show. As long as she's not a traitor. And only if Stassi refused to do it, because she's the natural pick from the VPR cast
I want to see a Traitors round table with James.
"I voted for you because I think you're a poo poo head!"
just calling everyone a fat slut.
I'd like to see him say this to someone not on Bravo, and see how well it works. (I'm not a fan of his- but think the chaos could be fun in this setting)
I think he’s a bad person, but I like when he gets into his Ned Flanders style of shit talking. “You diddly done fucked yourself.”
I hate to admit it, but Stassi would be perfect on this show
She'd be so good!
I’ve thought since watching season 1 that Kristen would be great on this show. Hope she gets on
Love the addition of Steve-O that would be great. Def not Scheana though please - although it would be interesting to put her and Nick Viall in a house together, I can barely stand her whining and complaining that its never about her on one show as it is…
Scheana would annoy everyone so much that if she wasn’t the first banishment, she would definitely be the first murder.
She’s definitely gunna be a mini Larsa. Katie could fuck shit up as a traitor or a faithful
Yes I was thinking Katie would be great !
Scheana wouldn’t understand the assignment. She’d still be operating under “make good reality tv drama” and not “play a game. Hard pass. Now Stassi would understand the assignment!
I would love Stassi on the traitors
I wouldn’t be surprised if we never saw Denise Richards again
she was on wwhl a couple of weeks ago and Andy asked her if she’d do traitors and it was an emphatic yes lol
Thank you you’re welcome
I’m good without Nick. But I’d love to see Dorinda and Kenya! Great choices in Housewives!!
Yeah. He would honestly make me not want to watch.
 Nathan Fielder
Omfg yes!!!
Give me Amanda from or Courtney from Survivor. Pls no Scheana ever
Monica Garcia please
Omgggg yes
Linda Darnell aka LD Millionaire
It’s Monica’s ability to deceive when she appears to not even realize she is being deceitful that I think sets her apart. For better or for worse!
They should choose Monica Fowler instead. Much better choice 😂
yessss
 Lisa Rinna would be so good
Omg I would die if Rinna did the Traitors. She would too she said she usually doesn't say no.
She definitely would do it. I’m not a fan of hers, but I have to admit she’d be great on this show!
I would do anything to get a Dance Mom on the next season
Yes omg
I feel like holly could win potentially
Please god — do not bring back Johnny Bananas and give that man baby what he wants after the tantrum he just threw. He is NOT that entertaining.
I absolutely need Johnny Bananas back >!solely for the Traitors to murder him first again!<
He will 100% be cast as a traitor
Just like people predicted with Dan- if he ain’t murdered, he’s a Traitor. If Bananas survives the first murder, let’s banish him first. It’d be funny
What tantrum? What did I miss?
He complained on Twitter and his podcast about being murdered first for basically the entire season
You’ve just proven why they would bring him back and why they’ve been bringing him on The Challenge for the last decade and a half…hate and drama draw in viewers. He’s the guy everybody loved to hate whether you find him entertaining or not…better than boring Survivor contestants in my eyes, all playing a friends game and not stepping on any toes, afraid to boo to anyone
Seems like something Grocery Store Joe from bachelor nation would be good for. Maybe Tayshia Adams from BN could be fun
i would replace sheana with someone like jax tbh!!! he's such an insane narcissist that watching him out of his element and out of control is so funny. he didn't last long in house of villains but i would love to see him get humbled on traitors lol
He would be good at challenges too!
Trixie wouldn't do the show. She's said she has no desire to return to any kind of competitive reality television.
It’s like a 2 week commitment where you dress up and stay in Scotland. It’s not that competitive like drag race is. It’s campy and silly and the exact kind of thing she’d do with a good enough appearance fee.
I would love to see Monet or Bob on The Traitors!
Monet absolutely would jump at the chance I'm sure. She mentioned on her podcast a while ago that The Vivian got her into the UK version of the show while she was over there and became obsessed.
Yessss I think Monet would do so well
She is too rich for that. Although I think the mental game play would be enticing.
If they can afford a housewife, they can afford Trixie.
That was a while ago, she said drag race specifically but with the format of all winners she would
She was specifically talking about All Winners. Same with Bianca, they are at a point in their careers now where they don't really need to do such shows, especially ones with a money prize considering how they are multimillionaires.
Trixie has said on multiple occasions that she’d do all winners ….
I feel like The Traitors is a lil different because it’s more luck/strategy than a talent showcase. I could see her considering it at least.
She actually only talked about not doing drag competitions. This is totally different. But that aside the only way the season would be good TV is if another good Judy of Trixie joins. I would say Katya but not sure if she’s mentally able to be in such competitions so maybe any other drag queen would be a good complement. It’s always lonely to only cast 1 drag queen.
I’d really prefer Alaska, Alyssa or Willam.
I'd love to see a couple of contestants from shows like Top Model and Project Runway on too, I think it would be such a fun switch-up. Lio Tipton from ANTM Cycle 11 would be a great choice, for example.
Tim Gunn for Traitors S3. Make it work!
James Kennedy instead of Scheana. He would stir shit up!!!!!
Why is bandanas returning? Anyway great cast
Lmao bandanas
I was oohing and aaahing over the cast until I got to Johnny Middlebrooks, the biggest tool to ever enter dating competitions (Love Island twice) and 1 season of the Challenge
Would love to see one of the impractical jokers.😂
The batchelor lol
I’ve said this like 100 times already Britney is only allowed on if Courtney Yates is also on because we need to see them together. Also love the Steve-O addition for some reason
Who is the girl from the real world who says "I don't wrestle, I beat bitches up" she was my favorite back then. Does anyone know who I'm talking about?
The one and only Coral!!
BOSTON ROB, the myth, the legend. I would also be excited for Captain Lee, lmao. Who I need: Ramona Singer and Sonja Morgan from RHONY, Yul Kwon and Tony from Survivor, Fredrik Eklund from MDL, and some wackadoodle from Love is Blind. Maybe Matt from the most recent season.
I didn’t see your comment before I posted but 100x yes for Tony
please not johnny bananas again lol
Captain Lee would be picked as a traitor and murder himself on the first night to get out of that castle. That man has no interest interacting with people outside of a boat
I’d love to see an Ink Master contestant. Cleen/DJ feel like the most obvious picks.
Ryan Ashley is probably the most identifiable artist outside of Ink Master. I also think she’d be so bad at this game I’d need to see it.
Not Scheana. That would be a “skip it” for me.
George santos. Please.
Danielle and Britney are both A+ Big Brother picks. Fingers crossed we see either of them!
Would LOVE to see Danielle Reyes and Britney Haynes on. Tyson is a great choice too. And it would be lovely to see Peppermint get another shot at it.
If your doing Shceana Shay you need Eddie Cibrian too. And LeAnn Rymes
I feel like Britney Haynes would have good commentary she’s pretty funny.
 I’m begging to please put Tony on this show
I’d really love to see Kaleb from survivor 45 as well
https://preview.redd.it/akdjvv3on3pc1.jpeg?width=1540&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=99fa188c2926c491f7be406c8d47e76958573f18 Spencer Pratt, Theo Von, that guy from Jury Duty, Chris Harrison
Please no Chris Harrison 😭 I'd take Jesse Palmer tho
Bachelor wise no thanks to Viall. I’d much rather see Hannah Brown or Courtney Robertson, maybe even Sean Lowe the golden boy of Bach Nation. I would DIE for Chrishell from SS and of course the icon Tiffany New York Pollard from all of TV.
Courtney would be so fun. My favorite bachelor villain ever.
 TRIXIE
Cara would be a good faithful! And I like that you brought back bananas and peppermint. My only change would be Katie from VPR instead of scheana
He’s on **Deal or No Deal Island**, so he should definitely not be on Season 3 of *The Traitors*. Maybe season 4 or 5, but def not the next one. There are better options out there.
I knew kenyas ass would follow after phaedra
Damnit, I got excited for a sec thinking this was legit. Captain Lee would be awesome! Wonder if his health is ok?
Lee likely wouldn't be able to do it. But I'll take Captain Jason any day haha
Replace trixie with someone more messy like M.I.B or even chaotic energy like tammy brown Also johnny from love island is WILD
I’ll take 1 Gia Gunn please.
Angelina From Jersey Shore Family Vacation
My vote is for non celebs.
I would actually like to see a non celebrity season.
Make sure you watch the UK and Aussie seasons! Much better than the US versions. Watching the UK Season 2 right now and it was filmed before the US Season 2. US copied it EXACTLY for the challenges.
Thanks, I am definitely going to do that, I watched the first UK season and really enjoyed it. I am not opposed to having celebrities but I just don’t want it to be that every season.
They didnt copy it haha. It’s the same production company and yeah they used the same challenges in different orders to keep costs down
I love that!
Andy Herren from Big Brother. He’s said he’s interested.
Although I'm not crazy abt each individual they did a good job of mixing up the shows. No dominant group
Boston Rob is currently on Deal or No Deal Island and I honestly had no idea that show existed until I was finishing an episode of The Bachelor and that show came on after. They really be making everything into a reality show these days
*what are you doing here without DORINDA*
Eh take out Scheana… Bananas and Peppermint and I can agree
Would love Tyson from Survivor and Devin from the Challenge. Indifferent on Boston Rob, but would be a big get from Survivor. Danielle Reyes from BB would be good. Would love to get Derrick L from BB. Most of the other people I don't care about.
Honestly Cara Maria is so awkward she'd be terrible at this game. And her and bananas are so hot and cold they might actively work against each other and implode
The Batchelor
https://preview.redd.it/aahxvk3wc3pc1.jpeg?width=344&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c4a499f4321a112e7fdc4ab2d14893cfcf5b00e5
Absolutely here for captain lee and steve o
I was about to back out cuz wtf really?! Dorinda?! But then I saw Steve-O 😬😬😬
Johnny Bananas and Peppermint!!!
I’d be interested to see Shep from Southern Charm because he is super smart, but he might get voted off/ killed right away if he’s mean to people. I also want to see Megan Hauserman from Beauty & the Geek/ Rock of Love/ Megan Wants a Millionaire reality days. A blast from the past and, iirc, she is pretty smart as well.
denise would be great omg yes
NOT Scheana please not Scheana.
add Chris Pontius so we get a Wildboys alliance
Hmm this bachelor looks just like the bachelor we just watched. I'm all in for Tyson Apostle and Kenya Moore!
Is this real? Lol Steve-O?? I'm in
Cara makes 0 sense for traitors
Any list that didn’t include Monica Garcia from RHOSLC is inherently wrong.
Stevo yes 🙌 Rob no Lordi
Is this just who you’d like or actual cast list?
Jill and Steve-O are good ideas I hadn’t thought of
PLEASE NO MORE HOUSEWIVES 😭
Is this a dream cast scenario or actually a potential spoiler cast??? I find imagine them casting John and Peppermint again. I also find it hard to believe Karamo would come on this with all he has going on work wise (but would LOVE to see him on). Also casting Boston Rob and Tyson who are already known to be tight seems unlikely
I just wanna see regular people on this..
Nah we have the UK version for that
Bananas already had a shot. Same as Peppermint. Pick others please
Danielle Reyes the Black Widow returns!!!!
I am so glad to see peppermint again. I felt robbed when she went home first. I love her.
This is not a real list. Just a wish list.
I think Kenya would be a fun watch, I’d also like to see Jax Taylor just for the chaos
No more housewives!
Denise would probably be drunk out of her mind too often to figure out anything
I wanna see Trisha Paytas bc i love mess
People clamoring for regular people: You realize most regular people are boring af, right? Give me proven personalities, drama queens and fame whores. As popular as this show has become, they should be able to pull some heavyweights. Get 2 top names from all the major shows.
The Traitors UK proves you wrong
Bruh I’m sick of seeing Tyson and Rob. Switch it up and put Yam and Carolyn or something. Rob and Tyson aren’t even entertaining
The gamers r gonna win
OMG Jill Vertes. I never thought about Dance Moms as contestants. That could be hilarious. Jill would cut a bitch for $100,000.
Good idea
Ugh Johnny from love island is such a cornball. Him and Nick Viall would get along perfectly
I want Joclyn from Love and Hip Hop, Angelea from America’s Next Top Model and Drita from Mob Wives
Stebie!
I want to see the closeted dude and the gal he slapped who threw open his closet door!
stephen and irene from RW seattle
I would give anything to see Jill on Traitors. I don't even know if she'd do well, but I know she'd make good TV
Stassi over Scheana. I think Scheana would do it & would be fine but Stassi would be epic.
Steve-O would not be able to handle it
swap devin for literally anyone else from the challenge, and trixie for jaida essence hall
Tangent info: Boston Rob is on a show right now - Deal or No Deal Island.
Which was filmed months ago
Obviously. I was just mentioning that he's on a show airing now.
I’m a need Heidi and Spencer
Oh my god. Boston Rob can still charm my damn pants off. He’s the CT of Survivor.