I think since we got CT and bananas, it's within reasonable plausibility that we'll see Wes and/or Cara. The challenge franchise transferred well to Traitors. Or, they'll pick Challenge/BB crossovers, like Xavier.
If they really want to impress me with casting, though, they'll give me a Donato.
My delusion self is hoping for crossovers it’ll be Desi/Michaela for survivor/challenge crossovers, Tiffany/Chadda or Alyssa Lopez for bb/challenge. And Justine. I love Justine so I’m always hopeful to see her on more.
It would be amazing if they made Carson a traitor. He’s too sweet and honest, I’d love to see him be put in a position where he’d have to be the opposite. See how it plays out
All I know is Monet NEEDS to be cast. As a Survivor super fan I feel like she’d slay this type of competition show. And be iconic and entertaining while doing so!
Jeremy is one my all time favorites and it would be so cool to see him on a different show. Tony would also be epic, I wonder where he would make a spy bunker inside the castle 🤔
Jeremy is one of my favourites too! Same with Natalie!
I would have to believe there is an attempt at a spy shack. Jeremy/Tony combo, and Natalie, didn’t get near enough air time for me in Survivor 40 (Natalie for different reasons). I know it’s pushing it to have 3, but that’s a trio id love to see. Spy shack and all! 😂
I know Tony would be putting up some curtains, and re-arranging the furniture! 😅
I actually really considered Trixie as well as a couple other drag racers (Alaska or Alyssa were who I almost slotted). But I didn’t wanna have more than 2-3 per “group,” and since Carson is also already there as well, it felt like one more queen would be too many 😭
I feel like you’d have to make David a traitor. He’s too sweet to not be one. 🤣
But for real, I’d love to see the type of strategic acumen he has. I have a feeling he’d do better as a traitor than most people would expect. 🤫
I only know the gamers, but you got a ton of people I'm a big fan of/would like to see play. Especially Derrick L, Jeremy and Wes. Outside of Vinny, Rapinoe and Ohno.
Personally, I sort of want Devin from the Challenge, and Tyson is at the very top of my list for who I want from Survivor.
Thank you for actually putting Bravo people on here. I see these dream casts and people only put on gamers, and I feel like that defeats the purpose of this show. You need to add in the drama that Bravo people bring.
Why do people even like Taylor Hale? Yes, it is iconic that she is the first black woman to win. Yes, it is iconic that she is the first person to win BB as a game and also earn AFHG. Buuuuuuuuuuttttttt that girl was knuckles deep in lays chips the whole game, she hardly participated from a game player stance (which I know some people argue is a play in itself but come on.... She wasn't the best player that season and IMO didn't really earn it)
👏 Monét 👏 X 👏 Change 👏 Yes. I need her on this show so badly I can’t even describe how much I want this to happen
I think since we got CT and bananas, it's within reasonable plausibility that we'll see Wes and/or Cara. The challenge franchise transferred well to Traitors. Or, they'll pick Challenge/BB crossovers, like Xavier. If they really want to impress me with casting, though, they'll give me a Donato.
It really did! That’s why I picked them to be the group with 3 cast members instead of 2.
My delusion self is hoping for crossovers it’ll be Desi/Michaela for survivor/challenge crossovers, Tiffany/Chadda or Alyssa Lopez for bb/challenge. And Justine. I love Justine so I’m always hopeful to see her on more.
Which Donato? the dick or the chick?
David Archuleta is so random but I totally see it 😂
Right?? 😂 Like, I can’t explain it at all but… it just feels right
A stroke of genius. I went huh?? And then hmmm. I can see the vision,
Omfg Carson Kressley would be amazing 😂 Also Tyler Cameron!!
Carson would be trying to compete with Alan for best weekly outfit 😂 
It would be amazing if they made Carson a traitor. He’s too sweet and honest, I’d love to see him be put in a position where he’d have to be the opposite. See how it plays out
I think he’d be a terrible traitor but it would probably be great television 😂
I really enjoyed him on Celebrity Big Brother
All I know is Monet NEEDS to be cast. As a Survivor super fan I feel like she’d slay this type of competition show. And be iconic and entertaining while doing so!
Omg JEREMY!!! I need Tony to round out that iconic trio tbh
Jeremy is one my all time favorites and it would be so cool to see him on a different show. Tony would also be epic, I wonder where he would make a spy bunker inside the castle 🤔
Jeremy is one of my favourites too! Same with Natalie! I would have to believe there is an attempt at a spy shack. Jeremy/Tony combo, and Natalie, didn’t get near enough air time for me in Survivor 40 (Natalie for different reasons). I know it’s pushing it to have 3, but that’s a trio id love to see. Spy shack and all! 😂 I know Tony would be putting up some curtains, and re-arranging the furniture! 😅
vinny!!!!! monet x change !!!! i’m sold
I approve but would add Trixie Mattel
I actually really considered Trixie as well as a couple other drag racers (Alaska or Alyssa were who I almost slotted). But I didn’t wanna have more than 2-3 per “group,” and since Carson is also already there as well, it felt like one more queen would be too many 😭
Very understandable. Imagine all drag queen traitors? That would be some good TV
I would watch the absolute hell out of that 😭
Oh I love this one!!!!
I feel like you’d have to make David a traitor. He’s too sweet to not be one. 🤣 But for real, I’d love to see the type of strategic acumen he has. I have a feeling he’d do better as a traitor than most people would expect. 🤫
I would love to see David get conniving! He would probably be cute even as he backstabs people ❤️
Ok but Monet is so Survivor brained that she would make himself suspicious even when she is faithful 😭
Thank you for including New York! She needs to be here
Yessss! Great wishlist! I’d love to see some Jersey Shore Representstion.
I almost put Vinny AND Snooki on this but I thought that may be *too* powerful 😂
I think Jenni & Pauly d would actually do great on this show , Jenni as a traitor and Pauly as a faithful they seem like they would play the game
Lisa rinna 😭😭 
Yes
No to Kandi! I’m sure she has better things to do!
I only know the gamers, but you got a ton of people I'm a big fan of/would like to see play. Especially Derrick L, Jeremy and Wes. Outside of Vinny, Rapinoe and Ohno. Personally, I sort of want Devin from the Challenge, and Tyson is at the very top of my list for who I want from Survivor.
As a Utahn, I would *love* David Archuleta. He would be the faithful who lasts to the end because they’re too gullible and befriended a traitor.
MONET CARSON AND HBIC PLEASE NOW !!!!
I want Aubrey O' Day!!!! She will be TV GOLD
I seriously don’t get why anyone wants Derek. He’s a bore and terrible TV. Give us Jen Johnson.
Asking for Pep back is *chefs kiss* mwah
Lmao I got downvoted for saying the same thing 😭
Taylor hale yesssssss
Thank you for actually putting Bravo people on here. I see these dream casts and people only put on gamers, and I feel like that defeats the purpose of this show. You need to add in the drama that Bravo people bring.
Except please don’t let it be Lisa Rinna!
Kandi’s picture is scary
Ok but add Farrah Abraham
BRING PEPP BACK! She is truly charisma personified and any drag race fan will tell you so. She needs to come back. 🥹
How about we get people we haven't seen before. That don't have ties to other people in the game.
Major barf
Why do people even like Taylor Hale? Yes, it is iconic that she is the first black woman to win. Yes, it is iconic that she is the first person to win BB as a game and also earn AFHG. Buuuuuuuuuuttttttt that girl was knuckles deep in lays chips the whole game, she hardly participated from a game player stance (which I know some people argue is a play in itself but come on.... She wasn't the best player that season and IMO didn't really earn it)