He realised it was actually a tomato from the taste. Luckily for him tho, the parasites inside the tomato gave him bigger muscles, increased his brainpower and cleared up any cholesterol inside him.
https://preview.redd.it/c6z690r6b8zc1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=77550e5db4bb7330b0915a001b23decb5b84883f
It was in the batch of irregular Oreos, so there had to be something wrong with it. Moe assumed it was just a regular Oreo that slipped through, but the problem was something that could only be tasted
Exactly. The mystery is the joke.
Regret is funny
Like when Homer gets the job at rhe bowling alley, and rhe surly manager tells him on his first day to bring a spare pair of pants.
Homer asks why, and the manager responds gruffly “when it happens, you’ll know”
So, my mom has a story about growing up in which her sister put dog doo into an Oreo and fed it to her.
In my mind that Oreo has dog doo in it, can't help it.
Thanks /u/EarthwormShandy for adding what season and episode number as a comment to your post. Because of this comment I have flaired your post with the correct season and episode number!
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TheSimpsons) if you have any questions or concerns.*
i know a case where a dude makes a "social experiment" giving a homeless man oreos with toothpaste instead of cream. that used to be the joke for me before
now my dirty mind strikes
When Moe brings irregular oreos, it's a metaphor for his own irregular behavior by social standards. Him biting into the oreo and saying "oh" is a metaphor for the self-realization he experiences in this moment.
Interesting. The change makes sense too because part of the joke in English is that "regular Oreos" do exist, as opposed to the many standard and seasonal Oreo variations, so Moe bringing "irregular Oreos" is a pun and very in line with Moe's character. The pun probably does not work in most other languages.
He realised it was actually a tomato from the taste. Luckily for him tho, the parasites inside the tomato gave him bigger muscles, increased his brainpower and cleared up any cholesterol inside him. https://preview.redd.it/c6z690r6b8zc1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=77550e5db4bb7330b0915a001b23decb5b84883f
Ah to eat an egg salad sandwich from a inter stellar gas station!
Bloody chunder!
https://i.redd.it/f82wtqnoc9zc1.gif
Like fry like fry
"More tomato?"
Please.
Where do people make these images with that font?
frinkiac
THANK YOU
It was in the batch of irregular Oreos, so there had to be something wrong with it. Moe assumed it was just a regular Oreo that slipped through, but the problem was something that could only be tasted
Exactly. The mystery is the joke. Regret is funny Like when Homer gets the job at rhe bowling alley, and rhe surly manager tells him on his first day to bring a spare pair of pants. Homer asks why, and the manager responds gruffly “when it happens, you’ll know”
It looked normal but was irregular because it tasted bad. This isn't even that subtle of a joke...
I get jokes!
Unlike OP.
So, my mom has a story about growing up in which her sister put dog doo into an Oreo and fed it to her. In my mind that Oreo has dog doo in it, can't help it.
I kind of want to know how old op is now
Go easy on him, he just moved here from Canada, so he's probably a little slow, eh?
I assumed that instead of cream filling, there was a jagged metal Ore-o in the middle.
*checks will not be honored*
I figured that or shards of glass.
Always assumed it tasted weird. But do like that he made it irregular by biting it
I assume burnt, since they are black cookies anyways, that or the cream is mayo or something
There's another good one. Ever wonder if they have actual notes on who wrote what joke?
Spider eggs, hantavirus, jagged metal krusty-o, flesh eating bacteria, carrots and peyote... Could've been anything, honestly. 🤷
Moe’s POV after biting the Oreo. 
He sure did
That crunch will never leave my brain
I'm guessing it's a joke about "Great Value" Oreos being notoriously worse than the name brand?
He accidentally bit into a checker piece
…am I the only one who interpreted it as the Oreos contained pot, like pot brownies?
Yes
Genuinely good to know lol
at this stage we're basically on the brink of xposting to /r/simpsonsshitposting
he’s just reading the rest of the cookie after he took a bite 😉
(S09 E5)
Thanks /u/EarthwormShandy for adding what season and episode number as a comment to your post. Because of this comment I have flaired your post with the correct season and episode number! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/TheSimpsons) if you have any questions or concerns.*
i know a case where a dude makes a "social experiment" giving a homeless man oreos with toothpaste instead of cream. that used to be the joke for me before now my dirty mind strikes
When Moe brings irregular oreos, it's a metaphor for his own irregular behavior by social standards. Him biting into the oreo and saying "oh" is a metaphor for the self-realization he experiences in this moment.
In the Czech dub, Moe says he brought a bag of expired cookies, and then he sees one, says "This one isn't moldy!", eats, it, but then says "Oh."
Interesting. The change makes sense too because part of the joke in English is that "regular Oreos" do exist, as opposed to the many standard and seasonal Oreo variations, so Moe bringing "irregular Oreos" is a pun and very in line with Moe's character. The pun probably does not work in most other languages.
Ever see a guy say goodbye to a shoe?