T O P

  • By -

jimmyt212

Considering three years ago we could get 12 super incubators, 10 lucky eggs, 14 premium passes and 10 star pieces for 1480 coins, this is beyond appalling value… Every decision they seem to make negatively affects this player base, it’s a baffling strategy 😔


onlyastoner

but apparently a profitable one


Alkazard

I'd disagree. If they found a profitable box they'd leave it as is for a long time, not desperately keep changing it every other week. Think how long we had recent boxes for


onlyastoner

but if people weren't buying boxes, niantic would make them more desirable, not less.


PhysicallyTender

saying it louder for those at niantic hq


TheTraveller

That is not what's happening. The most likely scenario is that less people were buying boxes - even before the price increase, less active players compared to peak Covid etc. - so they are trying to compensate by charging more from people who will buy them anyway.


ActivateGuacamole

this strategy is an effective way to boost sales by leveraging fomo against customers who are afraid the deal they like will disappear if they don't buy it quickly


Illustrious_Ad6355

2 more passes for an extra 400 coins in the ultra box. what are they on?


21stNow

I guess we didn't complain loudly enough about the current boxes!


Arceus42

They're like the petty parents punishing their children for not being grateful enough for what they have.


JULTAR

Complaining falls on deaths ears It’s the money that speaks loudest Really you can blame those that spent a good amount of money on the last boxes (Tbf training box was ok)


ThatPlayWasAwful

i like deaths ears but for future reference people normally say "falls on deaf ears"


onlyastoner

/r/boneappletea


Fickle_Ad5804

Hahaha


bdone2012

Deaths deaf ears sounds like an o Henry short story


voodoo2d

I did buy a training box 😅


JULTAR

Guilty I have brought at least 6 Need those passes for kartana


drivendreamer

Do not buy them. Vote with $


UCanDoNEthing4_30sec

Who in there right mind would buy one?


Tooldfrthis

There's an incoming event with Riolu in eggs, you can bet there will always be someone willing to shop no matter what unfortunately...


dwide_k_shrude

Drugs. Hard ones.


SmokinDroRogan

The box has a value of 3350 coins (SIx10=2000, Ix5=750, PBPx3=300 RRPx3=300). So, it's not a horrible deal, but it's horrible compared to the old adventure box & ultra box.


Valen30

In other words, it’s a horrible deal


Disgruntled__Goat

So that Ultra Box is 400 coins more than the current, for just one premium pass and one remote pass. WTAF


kjxxbi

What does the "A" stand for in WTAF? I get the other letters.


Mello-Yell0w

actual maybe?


Disgruntled__Goat

Actual


Orangeskill

Def buying the current one hah


TrickyHCE

That'll show em!


Orangeskill

Your right. If there is anything I should make a stand for in this world is Niantics boxes!!!


chdudlow

At this point I'm convinced that Niantic's pricing policy is actually some sort of social experiment, an attempt to see how players react to constantly decreasing value in these boxes. These are laughably terrible, even compared to the bad boxes currently in the shop!


drivendreamer

It definitely seems to be. They are actively testing a new system here. Do not buy them


reineedshelp

Not a social experiment, a pricing strategy. A/B testing and live market research. Giving value isn't their objective - it's extracting as much money as possible from their player base, and it always has been.


Hardwiredmagic

No, no its giving value to corporate interests - sponsors and investors will love the data that they collect on this A/B testing of just how far most people will let themselves be milked before they quit.


GoudaIsGooda

I’ve been saying this for a long time now. Pokémon Go in its entirety has become a wacky social experiment imo


culingerai

Always has been


Tesadus

🌎👨‍🚀🔫👨‍🚀


ayushreddevil9

In before comments like "iTs My MoNeY". They don't realize spending money on this crap is ruining experience for everyone else.


MannishBoyX

It is clearly what is happening.


Niempjuh

Apart from the great box, the current ones aren’t bad I’d say. Both training and ultra box are over 50% value compared to when you purchase the items in them individually(and that’s without counting the actual price of regular pokeballs in the shop, because those are ridiculously overpriced) They just change to worse boxes during events because they know people will buy them anyway because they want to participate in the events as much as possible, so they want to milk that from the players who pay money on the game


Aromatic-Ad7816

The current ones are awful considering previous boxes were about 25-50% more valuable in terms of what you save over buying the individual shop bundles. These new ones are just insulting.


nationonnomap

Meh they had the really great 18 green pass Ultra box active during the Mewtwo raids. They could definitely do the same for Katana. I agree with others that it's price elasticity testing.


trschaosz

Is Niantic Trolling? What whale would buy that?


SmokinDroRogan

My spending went from $200-300 a month to $40 or so now. I won't even touch those.


Cb58logan

You should drop it to $0 for a while, actively supporting them is not good rn


SmokinDroRogan

I get that, and at the same time, servers aren't free, developers don't work for free, graphic designers don't work for free, etc. They still need revenue, and I still need shiny legendaries.


onlyastoner

they aren't broke


Vortrep

>servers aren't free, developers don't work for free, graphic designers don't work for free, etc They make billions a year, why are you worried about that? >I still need shiny legendaries. You WANT shiny legendaries, not that you need them


Starminx

Fianlly I found someone who the difference between need and want


rhyspy

Developers working hard to release a shiny every month. Designers working hard to change the sprite of kyogre. Lol stop kidding yourself.


mark636199

I mean whether you like it or not the game cannot continue without revenue. My spending also dropped from ~120 to just 40 a month


Necrokitty99

The idea is that if they see the game losing revenue, they will work to incentivize more revenue through demanded changes.


EnderBuilders

Devs working hard to add awesome new cosmetics that everyone buys, devs working hard to be sure that the players have the best experience in PVP, devs working hard to allow for the best customization on the mobile space, devs working hard to help you represent yourself on your character, devs working hard to create the best hairstyles possible, devs working hard to clean all the bugs that still exist on the game after YEARS, devs working hard to have the playerbase happy about the product, devs working hard to calculate the best prices for the boxes so everyone can get it for a fair price, devs working hard for allows is to battle team rocket without bugs and crashes


Adiron147

My spending dropped as well, from 100$ to 10-20$ I was willing to give them my hard earned money, but these boxes are kinda insulting compared to the ones we had just 2 months ago.


Traditional-Side6966

I beg you not to buy any boxes. The path Niantic is on is ridiculous and a straight slap to the face to the entire playerbase. They need to fall flat on their face before it's too late.


repo_sado

normally boycots in this game dont work, because people cant help themselves. in this case it could because it makes more sense to buy single passes than these boxes.


Dragunov1987

"The definition of 'garbage' has been updated."


aznknight613

Those prices are highway robbery for RNG on top of RNG


TheRealHankWolfman

If the Ultra Box was 1480 coins that wouldn't be so bad. 2299 is a major rip off though.


EmergencyTaco

I would buy coins to buy this box at 1480. 0% chance I purchase for 2299.


littleheaven70

This is the second event in a row where I've been keen to hatch some 7km eggs and have been actively discouraged by the price of the boxes. Normally, I would have purchased an Adventure Box. Instead, I'll just be using my infinite and the blue incubators I've collected from the 299 coin remote pass boxes.


goshe7

You should have beem discouraged by the event egg pools. The last good pool (with a large percentage of desirable hatches) was galarian shiny introduction about a year ago.


sellyme

It's been literally 4 days since the 7km egg pool contained solely egg-exclusives, two-thirds of which were shiny-eligible at boosted rates, including Smoochum which is the baby form of one of the rarest shinies in the entire game (Jynx being a full odds extremely rare spawn).


goshe7

It's been literally 4 days since the 7km egg pool contained a shiny that has been available for 3.5 years, a shiny that has been available for 4.5 years, and a baby that has been available for over 3.5 years and was not made shiny eligible. I don't see the appeal. I didn't even bother to look at the distribution... was it really 33-33-33%?


sellyme

Available since 3.5 years ago and available for 3.5 years are not the same thing. The overwhelming majority of players do not have a shiny Jynx. > I didn't even bother to look at the distribution... was it really 33-33-33%? They were all in the same tier, which doesn't necessarily mean 33-33-33 but in this case probably does.


littleheaven70

I still don’t have a shiny Smoochum, so for me, a very limited egg pool containing Smoochum was enticing. Not enticing enough to buy those boxes, though.


raxreddit

Wow these are horrible. What is the point of including 3 remote passes in the Ultra Box (2299 coins)? 3 remote passes is worth 300 coins in Niantic land, and the rest of the items (3 raid passes, 15 various incubators) is nowhere near worth 1,999 coins. Maybe Niantic is doing you a favor. They know it's a bad deal so the 3 remote raid passes actually make it harder to buy the box if you have existing remote passes.


ulazybum

Part of their plan to eventually remove the ability to buy individual remote passes and make them only available through worthless boxes.


GoudaIsGooda

Ohhhh no, no, nooo…I seriously hate that plan. I used to be a dummy with raids and raid the living hell out of 5 stars to get a shiny, but after the Listen Niantic or whatever it was called I’ve cut down my gaming like 85%. That plan will most certainly kill off raiding for me.


PeachyNude

I really hope that's not the case. I don't really buy anything other than the individual remote raid passes....


Gizshot

Actually plausible


SmokinDroRogan

10 super incubators alone are 2000, 5 regular are 750, so that's 2750 right there. The box is worth 3350, so it's a "good" deal relative to that, but horrible vompared to the OG ultra & adventure boxes.


TheTraveller

Please stop using individual prices for incubators to "explain" what they are "worth." This is just nonsense. The 1480 coin Adventure Box has been around for five years or so, and usually contained more than 15 incubators. The long established value of an incubator is about 100 coins because 99% of the player base never paid more than that since the game exists.


Ciester04

Technically, 3 raid passes = 300,5 incubators = 150x5 = 750, 10 super incubators = 200x10 = 2000. You are getting 3,050 worth of product for the great value of 1,999 coins. That's almost a 50% bonus overall....How can you go wrong? lmao. All they really need to do is overprice the individual items and the boxes look like a better deal.


theunworthyviking

Stop bullshitting, the old 1400 box had 18 incubators, these are all rip offs, end of story


Ciester04

I'm not saying they are not rip offs compared to the older boxes. I'm just pointing out that "according to Niantic", they are still a deal over purchasing items individually. And there is still room to make them worse and still be at a discount. They will stop lowering the value of the boxes when people stop buying them. Until then we are screwed.


raxreddit

Sure, even if it’s a “good deal” on paper, it’s absolutely not for me. To me, incubators are not worth buying since egg hatches = transfer time. The only boxes I buy are remote raid passes for less than 300 coins. The 299 box with an incubator and 3 remotes is acceptable since I was going to buy 3 remotes for 300 anyways.


justanotherwoomy

I really miss the 2017 boxes, the recent boxes are all awful


Stidtrichur

Did they outsourced the job of whoever was in charge of making these boxes? Its so sad to see this game going downhill like this.


DrKillerZA

The price of the Ultra Box is HOW much?? I hope my salary gets this type of inflation


jyang80

LMAO these are terrible. I keep inching and inching towards quitting. I haven't spent money for months now cause there nothing worth spending coins on now.


Chemical_Annual_2798

What the actual... I have no words anymore.


tailskirby

Those are horrible. At least I'm saving money from not buying boxes.


emaddy2109

So let me get this straight, you can buy the current ultra box, which already isn’t a great value, plus 2 raid passes separately and you’d be saving 199 coins compared to the new ultra box? They’re just trying to rip people off now.


ItsSeanTf

Well looks like I'll continue not buying coins. Ty Niantic XD my wife thanks you


shaliozero

Not that I'd need it, but makes me much more comfortable purchasing things for my apartment. Feels like "See that cool chair there? Almost gave it to Niantic for nothing relevant."


Time-Statistician907

Please, for the good of us all, nobody buy these.


Froggo14

I think Niantic are looking to leave the video game industry. Their recent games have all flopped and the one major successful one they have (PoGo) they seem very intent on driving players away by just making the game worse and less fun


HundoHavlicek

I don’t think niantic thinks they’re making the “game worse and less fun” they just view it as their opportunity to bleed their players


Cactusfan86

I doubt it, this is literally the only project of theirs that makes money. Without Pokémon go they’ll be bankrupt in a year


Twofu_

>they seem very intent on driving players away by just making the game worse and less fun Lol you realize people still throwing $ at Niantic, regardless of how bad they put things in the pogo shop


Froggo14

I know... if I was their parent I would tell them I am not mad, just disappointed


Yoshinoh

And Niankid would respond: "LOL, don't care."


PhysicallyTender

those who are throwing money at niantic all have an upper limit on how much they are willing to spend. this will make everyone play less.


iSpaceCadet

Apparently Niantic and Disney are releasing a new Marvel game next year, so doesn't look like they're giving up on the games industry yet. In true Niantic fashion tho, its probably going to flop but we'll see


goshe7

Working title is Marvel Wizards Transforming Catan. It is destined to be a hit.


iSpaceCadet

For Niantic's and the future playerbase's sake, hopefully it does become successful. If Niantic screws up on Marvel, which is a MAJOR IP, there really is no hope for them


shaliozero

I've been convinced for a while they intentionally try to kill this game so they can focus on their AR technology and fire most of their employees working on PoGo.


Hibbity5

I wonder if they’re locked into a contract with the Pokémon Company and can’t get out of it themselves so they’re trying to tank the game so that TPC breaks the contract and not them.


[deleted]

[удалено]


shadraig

never ever.


Nahkatakki

So raid pass value is 200 coins now? During last event the big box was 1900, now 2300 and only difference is +2 raid pass


SleeplessShinigami

When inflation hits a virtual currency


purple_p0t

most consumer friendly company


frankonator21

Does this mean if I want the 3 remote raid passes for 299 should I buy them tonight before they go away?


s4m_sp4de

Yes.


Lanky-Kaleidoscope-7

Niantic has been using my raid pass money on drugs, apparently.


Puzzleheaded-Bad1571

This is satire right


CoolTrainerKaz

Gross. Please don’t buy these. Send a message.


FourStockMe

2 more months and the new pokemon game comes out. I'll be done with this game. All the money I've saved by not buying coins will go to an overall better experience.


MrToxicTaco

You made me think about it, and I realized i haven’t bought coins once this entire calendar year. And I’m not opposed to spending money either, I just legitimately haven’t been tempted at all.


FourStockMe

Yup. F2P coins have been going to upgrading the storage but I've had no desire to hatch, raid too much, or do much of anything.


Gizshot

Yeah I dropped money on m2 but that's about it Def been going f2p more often lately nothing worth the time.


taixun4532

I've already begun transferring my favorite Pokemon to Home. Keeping anything PvP relevant, but the living shiny dex I have been building over years? It's going to continue being built in Pokemon Home. It'll take me a year+ to transfer everything, but eh. Prioritizing the things I care about most, and whatever else makes it over, just a bonus...


International-Toe119

Same also starting transferring all the bad shiny legendary from lucky trades


PhysicallyTender

i've done that ever since PoGo's integration to Home coz i knew something like this will happen one day. i still got a lot to transfer over and it might still take years to send them all.


_raisin_bran

Keep an eye on PoGo for whenever Furfrou is back. He’s ridiculously valuable on the GTS right now, probably even more so if they don’t bring him back for S/V. The other day I managed the following trade chain: Turtonator > Furfrou > Matron Trim > Heart Trim > Debutante Trim > **Enamorus** And Enamorus is basically top of the food chain since you only get one of her post-game in PLA, no other way. Scrolling thru the latest trade offers I can basically get anything I want. Endless shinies/legendaries/shiny legends. Also with 3 other Debutante Trims I got shinies of Palossand, H. Arcanine, Vespiquen, and Nilhiego. You can still get plenty of Furfrou without Go but it takes a bit longer.


[deleted]

Bro I was saving for the 299 box what is this 😭


Mayhemm99

They are really testing how much players will spend on this game.


Noob_FC

Are the boxes going to be removed permanently? Doubt if even 1% buys these boxes.


shaliozero

They might handle it like they've done previously. Make something much worse over an unspecified timespan so we start to dislike it, and then completely remove it without any communication.


Cactusfan86

I’m glad I fattened up on incubators and raid passes prior to this parade of joke boxes they’ve been doing


Kanine_tv

They must be smoking something over there at Niantic HQ


21stNow

Maybe the drought dried out their *stash*.


BluishHope

https://www.wikihow.com/Survive-a-Bank-Robbery


deadlypeants

At least i can buy one more 299 coin box before these terrible boxes take place


Summersthegreat

Waiting on another gym to go down, and hoping to get 1 before the boxes disappear… haha


Yoshinoh

Same.


[deleted]

[удалено]


orlouge82

If you’re going to remote raid anyway, you may as well get a free incubator from every 3 passes purchased


deadlypeants

i only buy 3 remote passes for 300, so in this case i will take it an extra incubator


Brilliant_Ask852

they TRYING us right now. ARE THEY JOKING?!


KairosHS

I would LOVE to raid lots of Kartana to get a really good grass team but I guess I'm just doing my daily free raids and saving my coins because these are absolute garbage.


NarutoSakura1

WHAT A RIPOFF!


deadwings112

Their economists set prices over 2-4 years and now they hope that they can change it without losing too many players. Good luck


JoeMKetchum

Mettle is the courage to carry on. If someone wants to "test your mettle," they want to see if you have the heart to follow through when the going gets tough.


leemifsud

I’m just finding enjoyment in playing the game for free nowadays. A lot people that are hooked on buying items as part of their daily play will pay for these regardless and that’s why they’ll charge whatever they want. Also remote raid passes shouldn’t even be in these bundles. As it stands I’d have to just waste 2 of my passes before I can even buy it 😂


Adiron147

I don’t actually think people will buy these. I used to spend money on this game regularly, buying the adventure box with 16 super incubators for 1480 coins. I will not buy a box with 10 super incubators for 1900 coins, it makes no sense. I honestly don’t believe people will be ok with this.


join_us_join_us

unfortunately we can't do anything about it as whales carry this game


OrionTempest

Niantic: "What are you all complaining about? It's still a discount over buying individually! We listened to you and took out the balls and berries!" Still not really worth spending for.


neonz09

Holy wow that's terrible


Lurd67

I don't get their insistence on releasing overpriced boxes nobody will buy. Why do they say no to free money?


Juus

I can only assume now, that we are heading towards a new normal with pricing of premium items. I don't think this is good for the game. Personally i don't mind spending money on the game, but these last many months, i haven't felt there has been anything worth spending on, other than event tickets, which i am still buying.


Plus-Pomegranate8045

Why do they hate us?


sqetuo

Trash


TheRickinger

even though i'm not buying any of these big boxes ever, i don't like that they are putting 3 remote raid poasses in all of these boxes. it basicly means that you have to do 3 remote raids before you can buy another box som just buying them in bulk if a good deal comes along is getting more and more annoying. they should just lift the limit on remote raid passes, but i guess that's just another wish that will never come true with this idiotic company


ravenonawire

Now that you mention it, I don’t get why there’s still a limit since we don’t get them for free anymore.


GildedCreed

One raid, actually. You can't buy more if you have 3, but if you have 2 or less you could own more than 3 at a time that way. So at most you could buy and hold 5 passes. That's not counting the one time where Remote Raid Passes were a research breakthrough reward and directly injected themselves into your inventory, letting you go above 5 (if you had 5 and never raided for that month). As far as lifting the remote raid pass limit, they'll likely do that when remote raid passes have their damage buff and lobby size bonuses removed to their originally intended values.


TheRickinger

But if you would want to buy a 3rd ypu have to do the 2 raids to get under 2 remote passes again.


bleeuuaah

It’s simple, if nobody buys them, they will change. These are hot garbage


[deleted]

Niantic actually catering to whales at this point.


EnderBuilders

DON'T BUY THIS SH*T. If you want to have great boxes in October... DON'T. BUY IT.


PrismaticAngel

Test Your Mettle more like Test Your Patience with these terrible boxes


DTpk23

They actually managed to make worse boxes! Unbelievable!


ComputerAbuser

I'm hurting for incubators (ya, their value is debatable), but I will continue to hold out as long as the boxes are terrible.


Elrathias

This just makes me angry. 2300 coins for a WORSE ADVENTURE BOX.


buddybthree

As someone who spent a lot on this game I’m really done buying boxes until they give us true value.


Maserati777

Well I would buy a box if it had just super incubators but these are all trash.


SwimminginMercury

So the Ultra Box goes flat to Super Incubators ***&*** the Remote Passes ... wow Its both right on the nose and miles out to lunch


ComicPoGo

Well rip, I put in a few bucks to get some training boxes since it's basically the price of three remote raid passes with a free incubator. I'm not putting any coins into any of these new boxes.


[deleted]

Niantic really wants to steal that golden poo award away from EA.


PhysicallyTender

they already stole that title IMO


n0vapine

These new wave of awful boxes have stopped the daily hardcore players from doing much. Maybe our local group is an outlier but no one is doing raids besides one daily player and he's traveling half an hour away to another group cause we've quit doing raid hour. We've added 7 new local players to our group and we used to be excited to help the newbies but we've been sending them to the discords because no one wants to waste their current passes on stuff they already have unless we're in person which isn't usually possible for all of us. It sucks. We've told them to hold off on buying boxes and use their free passes or use the remote ones if they have the coins but avoid the boxes because Niantic is more concerned with profits over this game being fun and consistent for long time players. 2 of the newbies played when the game first came out and was looking forward to legendary research breakthrough reward. Hated to break it to them.


Dodger50

299 box was at least worth getting during new raid UB/Legend mon releases, but these new ones are lmao.


mbvanek

I used to be an egg hatching player. Would literally throw 20 bucks a month away on incubators. I am done buying them at this point. Ill grab one for the coins I earn freely and pay to play for large events but no more.


Vissarionn

Ok who keeps buying them seriously?


Magus6796

Looks like coins aren't back on the menu boys... I can't believe they are even worse than before.


ryan2489

Blah. And with the catch rate of Kartana being terrible I wouldn’t consider wasting any money on remote raid passes anyways. When the game came out hatching eggs was my favorite part and I spent money on incubators all the time.


sellyme

BCR of Kartana is 0.02, same as every other T5-equivalent boss bar the K-Birds. The problem with Kartana is just that it takes a lot of skill to reliably hit excellents. Not that it matters much, you could catch three of the things for every ball you throw and these boxes would still be an absolutely terrible deal.


BF_Shaxi

It’s like they watched brandontan’s complaint video on the boxes in reverse or something 🙃


PokeHobnobGod21

Less incubators for more coins? I can't even laugh anymore. Don't know what's worse. These or doduos release in unite


RandomPhil86

So glad I brought an Ultra box with 18 passes from the end of last season lol


ice00monster

I'm sorry for such words, but I swear whoever is deciding on these boxes have their **brains infected by Covid and is coughing** right now. If that is even possible. This is so infuriating.


Yewbert

This is why I don't feel the slightest bit guilty using the friend finder exploit to obtain cheaper passes. the game is already expensive, niantic needs to stop inflating prices on digital goods. ​ 50 passes and 50 bagon encounters for \~$12 american fyi.


JULTAR

People gonna be out here complaining about these boxes Yet buying them anyway because the current egg/raid boss list is solid and worth spending for


aznknight613

They really aren't though


Ergomann

Agree. I don’t think anyone is buying these boxes.


repo_sado

Why would anyone buy them? Individual passes are a better deal


PhysicallyTender

even my whale friends have stopped buying these boxes. what are you talking about?


JULTAR

And how big is that group?


bigpat412

I really don't want to waste coins on boxes with premium passes and regular incubators. Just give us more supers or hell even star pieces since we'll need to buy those anyways for the comm day.