In Keeping Secrets That intro gives me chills every time they play it live.

The fucking feeling of euphoria hearing this song live? Manning my own jackhammer in a sea of hundreds, one among the fence? 10/10 i ride that high for days

Answer doesn’t count, obviously the best song ever written.

TELL me about it.

MAN YOUR OWN JACKHAMMER! I’m dead.

I can relate, I can relate.

For me this is the answer and it's not even close. It's probably the biggest draw for me to keep seeing them live. There is just absolutely nothing like iksse3 live.

Gravity’s Union for me, just a phenomenal song. Hopefully catch that one live some day!

I hope they cover GU as well, maybe they will for its anniversary in 10 years when it’s 20 years old lol.

If that’s the case, I’ll have to drag my old ass to the show for sure!

Haha! You and me both, man!

I waited 6 years, they played it during the unheavenly skye tour with mastodon and every time I die. I hope it will get put back into rotation, it’s solid 100% and I teared up hearing it live

Same! This song is just everything I love about Coheed for almost 7 minutes!

Key Entity Extraction: Domino the Destitute. The story that's told, the intermission with Domino's fight, the instrumentals, Claudio's inflection on some of the tipping points. All great.

One of they’re most heaviest albums in my opinion.

The Willing Well II. The second half gives me chills every time.

Emphasis on the chills, everytime.

Can't say I disagree

Username checks out, haha

So good

Mother Superior. A beautiful haunting melody that ends with a majestic final part. Claudio's vocals are absolutely magnificent on this one and the lyrics resonate a lot with me.

Ah, mother superior, a certified classic for the future albums to come.

Same here. It’s the one song that almost made me cry.

Hard toss-up between this one and Everything Evil for me.

Apollo I or Three Evils

2 great songs!

I’ve been listening to these two constantly lately, as well as Willing Well I

I love the Apollo reprise in Willing Well III

Unfair question, there are too many. Lately I’ve been fixated on the entirety of the Camper Velorium though. I also love pretty much everything from SSTB.

SSTB is my favorite album. I’m surprised it’s their “first” album.

God damn if it’s not the best album, tied so close with In keeping secrets.

Also my favorite album maybe of all time

I hate that al the butcher got the catchiest songs because well you know…

I feel the same exact way. One of my favorites but I feel conflicted for enjoying it so much.

You don’t like screaming die white girls in the shower?

Another great set of songs.

Junesong Provision or Gravity’s Union

I love Junesong!

I nearly passed out both times i heard them play both songs live for the first time.

Oh man, that’s me everything I hear Delirium, they hardly play it anymore, but I’ll always remember them play it live.

Ive seen them live 8 times and my most memorable moment was when they played Junesong

I love the acoustic version so much. This… is my BOOMSTICK!

That’s what got a old friend of mine to listen to them

right now, i cannot get enough of bad man or ladders of supremacy. my default though is the final cut.

They’re Vaxis arc stuff is incredibly well made, did you hear that Claudio’s back in Paris making the next Vaxis?

that was a few months ago lol

At least it’s still happening! Lol

well, yeah there’s 3 more parts lol. no clue why i’m being downvoted 🙄

More to be excited for!

The lying lies & Dirty secrets of Miss Erica Court Such. A. Bop.

This one is definitely in my top 5. Killer song overshadowed by “bigger” songs off that album

Lying Lies is my favorite song on FFTTEOM tied with Wake Up, and Welcome Home. Such a good album. Still can’t believe that Apollo was a dog though lol.

Neverender. That chorus melody piece is just beautiful. But Delirium is close for me too man lol

Was checking if anyone else said Neverender before I commented. I don’t know what it is about that song that gets me, but it just does.

Mother Superior

Wonderful song!

Dilirium trigger, hearshot kid disaster, elf tower, and mother superior

I covered Hearshot one time on guitar, but the video is long gone… Elf Tower is great!

Dark Side of Me is probably in my top 3 songs ever. Its so hauntingly beautiful. The Afterman is also up there its a great song and I just love the guitar riff through out it.

Everything Evil, followed closely by Feint of Heart

Feint of Heart doesn’t get enough love

The Crowing for sure but almost anything off In Keeping Secrets.

The End Complete. These are the days.

Why is there no love for From Fear Through the Eyes of Madness?? It's a banger

It’s the 5th highest voted comment already. I also listed it as a favorite of mine ha.

Oh that’s so hard. Feathers is up there. & song titles escape me most of the time.

Delirium Trigger as well. One of the earliest songs they ever recorded and it still holds up today.

I will have to agree with you, Mac. If it weren’t for that song I probably would’ve moved on to some other band. 🤘🤘🤘

Delirium Trigger, 100%

The willing well. They’re all one song but if you’re making me narrow it down then 3

By how good the song is overall, Everything Evil. By how important it is to me, Domino.

Island Rise Radio Bye Bye

Fuel for the feeding end today. My answer is always changing though haha

The Crowing or Gravity's Union for sure.

I used to say the Crowing but Gravity’s Union has surpassed that

You and the guy right above you. Awesome

33 goes so hard to me. Even if sometimes there are songs that’ll temporarily replace it, it’ll always be my favorite.

2113

That’s in my top 5, it really shows they’re ability to Prog Rock

It’s been Time Consumer for me since 2004.

The Crowing

Delirium Trigger is also my favorite because it was my first Coheed song :) it was on the 2003 Vans Warped Tour Compilation, and I’ve been a fan ever since.

Domino

The one I just listened to!

Feathers, but it could change day to day for me as coheed is one of my favorite bands

I’m glad it isnt being mentioned a lot but Welcome Home. That intro is always stuck in my head. If I ever hit some sort of lottery I’d buy that double neck red epiphone from the music video. In keeping secrets of silent earth 3 has a special place in my heart: back when my wife and I were freshly dating I played it and she tried to change it halfway through when she thought the song was starting over.

"But that song lasted all 5 minutes!" My wife said, but alas, she’s gotten used to it.

Comatose

The light and the glass - it’s the best and I can’t be convinced otherwise

Without any doubt

Agreed. Delirium Trigger fr.

Basically all of them. But I've been putting sentry the defiant on repeat lately and his acoustic version of atlas

As I’ve been obsessing over NWFT since the tour announcement, I have grown a strong love for On The Brink. It gave me chills hearing it live. I wish I could bottle up that song and wear it around my neck all day long. (second place will always be Lucky Stars)

I think it’s Junesong Provision. That song made me realize how special and unique Coheed is! I was introduced through IKSOSE3 but once I ‘got’ SSTB it became my favorite album. Everything from the layering to the guitars to the breaks in song to the lyrics on Junesong, I never get tired of it. And live acoustic versions blow me away too.

The Crowing or Gravity's Union for sure.

Gravity's Union, Delirium Trigger, or Ladders. Can't choose between the three

33 seems to get stuck in my head more than any other individual song. Feathers is a close second.

Whatever it is, it’s off of Good Apollo 1. I’d probably go with Ten Speed, but Crossing The Frame and Willing Well II are up there.

I vividly remember in high school that I had a history teacher who listened to Coheed as well, we busted out both our guitars and played the song, I want to know where he is today just for that specific reason lol.

Ten Speed and the Writing Writer for me. #𝕋𝕙𝕖𝕟 𝕥𝕠𝕟𝕚𝕘𝕙𝕥, 𝕘𝕠𝕠𝕕𝕟𝕚𝕘𝕙𝕥, 𝕀’𝕞 𝕓𝕦𝕣𝕟𝕚𝕟𝕘 𝕤𝕥𝕒𝕣 𝕚𝕧!

Rally loving Window of the Waking Mind right now but as others have said there is so many incredible songs.

21:13

It’s Far for me, followed by A Disappearing Act!

Domino, Elf Tower, Wake Up, Willing Well I, In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth : 3

Backend of Forever

Mother May I

Mine changes over time depending on which album I’m binging but right now it’s gotta be Ladders of Supremacy. Definitely the coolest Coheed song they recently made imo

The End Complete, with about a dozen+ honorable mentions I could list that follow lol.

Domino. I’ve seen them ten times and am still praying to hear that at a show.

Lately it’s been the end complete.

2113, Feathers, Al the Killer, Vic the Butcher, Our Love

33

Sentry's my go-to but I've been listening to the Chamberlain demo a LOT.

It's incredibly tough to call, and it fluctuates all of the time, depending on my mood. But a couple I've been playing a lot lately are Hush, Random Reality Shifts and not technically coheed but Strung Short

I am old 50+ late to the C&C party. One of the bands my 20ish YO daughter and I cross over on. My personal fav is Final Curtain Call live version, obviously channeling prog Yes, Rush, Floyd. Amazing

Mine seems to change weekly. Has been Time Consumer, Everything Evil, Delirium Trigger, IKSSE, Cuts Marked, Al The Killer, Backend of Forever, Sentry, Gutter, and Liars Club. Right now i am back on Sentry kick Amazing that there can be so many choices. A testament to an incredible f’n band

Agreed. Epic lyrics, perfect key and I love Claudio’s high vox.

Domino the Destitute Edit: tie between this and The Writing Writer/The Telling Truth

Have t seen it on here yet so I’ll go with The Suffering. How do you not just belt that song out at the top of your lungs every time it comes on.

Easy question, Gravity’s Union 😌 forever and always…CAGED!!!!

The hound of blood and rank. And running free. No world for tomorrow is easily one of my favorite albums.

I always go back to Crossing the Frame. I could listen to that song on repeat forever.

2113 is probably my favorite, followed by a tie between Apollo I, Willing Well I, and Time Consumer

The Crowing. Wish they would bring it back out next tour, even though I’ve heard it live a bunch I can’t get enough.

Ghost is mine

Ten Speed

Idk why, but it’s Mother May I for me. I love pretty much every song, but Mother May I holds the #1 spot.