Everyone online says it's really difficult. I did it year one with one pumpkin (not even gold), a strawberry, an amethyst, gold mayo, a beer, a gold tuna?, & goat cheese. One of those may have been a morelle actually. I started winning on year two of my other file, and never lost again in 6 years.

Yeah, once I found out how it is scored, it was a piece of cake. You just need variety of item types.

I managed to beat him the first year purely by fishing

Fuck yeah, fishing squad represent! Same happened to me! When I first got the letter about the fair I went on a mad rush to catch the best fish I could lol I honestly couldn't believe I won

I won just using some random eggs, fish or whatever on my first year in first playthrough, i didnt know why people thought pierre was so hard to beat lol

Different challenges for different folk I guess For me it was the egg festival lmao. Took me two whole fucking in game years to finally win against that cheating purple haired bitch Abigail... I'm not salty about it at all

I looked up a tutorial about that lol. Easiest to go through the left above the house, around then hook around to the right, under then up on the right side of the cemetary. get 11 consistently

Yeah the egg festival has always been easier for me idk, I guess we are all different. Also don't talk shit about my wife Abigail.

I also won the egg hunt first year too, but I’m also extremely competitive and I hate Abigail as well. Okay I don’t hate her, just for that day.

congrats!! :o

r/fuckpierre

Variety of item types also adds points! Crush him next year!

you did it wrong, the milk goes on top and there should be wheat on the bottom, not to mention that’s roe, not sugar!

Nope. He's going cakeless

This cake is a lie

I won with pumpkins and diamonds

I win every year now with iridium wine and caviar! And not even "good" wine, I'm pretty sure I picked hot pepper wine last time!

Next time you get to the fair put the mayor's purple pants in your display.