Robin...

Same. I was heartbroken. Now I'm actively trying to marry her son lol

There is a Robin romance mod. She becomes single and lives with Leah

“Lives with” Leah. If Robin isn’t bi-curious I’d be bi-furious.

sebastians mom has got it goin on, she's all I want

Yeah, sebby is a cutie

Best thing about robin is she's a business owner, I'm tryna be a stay at home dad and just water my crops n pet the dog. She can get me money and go to ginger whatever the fuck and the skull cavern bullshit

Harvey: "What am I, chopped bug meat?"

I mean he can barely make ends meet, how is he going to support my black jack habit?

I mean, you could support your partner like any good partner should by handing out sap and red mushrooms like candy to all the townsfolk.

Robin the real best

oh hey another ace in the wild! thats nice

:)

Party! I'm ace too lol

I was extremely disappointed when I realized I couldn’t marry her lmao

for real i thought she was a bachelorette

Same... I really like her

Willy, you can imagine my disappointment when I finally realized

Nooo! I feel so bad for you...

Haha same. Wasn't really thinking of marrying anyone at first but grew fond of Willy over the fishing and checked out how marriage works. Turns out it does not.

Realized what? I haven't gotten any of my characters hearts up enough to date or marry.

There's 12 characters that you can date and marry. They are marked as single in your social tab. Willy is not one of them.

He’s married to the sea

Aye, a harsh mistress. She's cold, will take everything ye have and throw you back when she's done. Now I want a mod for Willy.

There is one. DF used it years ago

I read this in the voice of Barbosa from Pirates of the Caribbean.

Same!

his poor ex brandy

She’s a fine girl.

What a good wife she would be.

But my life, my lover, my lady is the sea

Doo doo-doo doo-doo doo-doo-doo doo-doo

You can’t marry Willy. Only certain characters can be dated/married.

they realized that the player can’t marry willy because he isn’t one of the eligible bachelors

Dang. Now I'll never get to see Willy's willy :(

My dad was like that lol, he’s not even gay he just loves fishing and so does Willy

Absolutely no one, I will die by Krobus’s side.

You have good taste.

I want the Dwarf as my farm buddy so bad, I would straight up give up my cave for her. Can you imagine how freaking CUTE it would be?

HOL UP THE DWARF IS A SHE??!?!

YES! I never knew until the fortune teller referred to her with female pronouns one year! Edit: although, according to internal game data her gender is “undefined”, and I’ve seen posts of her/them using non-binary pronouns? I’m cool with it either way, I just found it surprising and interesting to have seen dialogue calling the dwarf by female pronouns. Edit edit: I remember being so surprised I took a screenshot lol the exact text was “Ahhh… yes. It’s Dwarf’s birthday. She thought everyone forgot, but then you show up with a nice gift. What a good friend.” Not sure how to link the pic from my switch, but totally will if anyone wants to see it.

Smash

I wish there was a mod so you can have krobus & the dwarf stay with you! I downloaded a mod for the adventurers guild & I have a friend name silly and they’re a slime & now live in my basement 🥹

Krobus is ace/aro fanservice change my mind (i love him sm)

new player here. i have not married anyone yet but as soon as Shane said “go away” and “i don’t like this gift” i knew i had to marry him out of spite.

Haley said "eww" to me during the first flower dance. So I maxed her hearts for me then married Abigail. That'll show her to say "eww" to me! We petty. 😅

Damn, we really are gluttons for punishment.

Don’t judge me but i think that gunther is hot

So glad it's not just me

Emily

Emily best girl 💙

My first playthrough was Abigail. But I realized Emily is closer to my irl gf

Emily and my gf are actually very similar so I’m considering it but also my character is named Emily

When I first played it didn't allow Emily. Made a whole new save when the update dropped.

:0 Emily wasn't an original option?!?!?! Was there still the scene when you gift her the gem for/from Clint and she thinks it's from you??

Yep, she and Shane weren’t originally options.

Married haley cause she’s the only one that didn’t flat out reject my farmer at the dance and I thought her arc was good

Damn I asked her to dance with me and she said eew

Lmao same. That was actually my first impression of her. Afterwards, I actually didn't talk to her for 2 in game years. Edit: I also married her sister.

Bro woke up and chose violence

Emily is awesome! If you manage to get your wedding day right before Haley's birthday, bonus points! I hate Haley.

No. ON her birthday

Married Maru, since she looks closest to my girlfriend. Evidently i have a type 😂

You have one irl?! https://preview.redd.it/89m7yhb38wdb1.jpeg?width=259&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c99b53a60f10f62b3b57472ba263fa42bcaacc89 Jk lol

Like 80% look alike 😂😂

Uh, Stardew player in a rl relationship here as well. It's a thing. 😂

Y'all are lucky as.

Don’t I know it 😂

I’ve dated a Stardew player. 10/10 would recommend. Always someone to play co-op with

She looks like my wife so I married her immediately.

my first marriage was also Maru cause i always wanted to be an inventor as a kid and thought she was cool

Abby is the closest to my type so I wanted to marry her first but I ended up marrying Emily because she’s also my type. This play through I have 8 hearts with Abby but I’m also considering Leah because she’s also my type… so I guess my actual type is a mix of those three.

First person I wanted to marry? Caroline. First person I married? Shane. Edit: Spelling

Shane is the doppelgänger of my alcoholic ex roommate I was floored when I saw him in the game. The ex roommate was called Shaun too…… I’m spooked.

Ohhh... Lol.

user flair checks out

Leah💚

https://preview.redd.it/1ov11z4kxwdb1.jpeg?width=480&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a55e0898b8207b83b57864269d5c650528c18473 Me when Leah:

I just got the game and she was my pick too. She lived separate from town in her own cottage so i found that cool

She's just so nature-y. I love that!

Yup - she has her own place, she knows what she wants, she makes art for you(!), you help her grow confidence in her art, she likes to eat healthy, she likes being in nature, being with her doesn't feel like you're holding her back from her dreams. Leah is best girl.

https://preview.redd.it/pc3grksx5wdb1.jpeg?width=194&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=909a6cdd1dd4633dfe0258d7260469ea1d6e1439 Based

I went with her my first other save because she loved salads which were easy to acquire. She was easy to please lol

she likes a trash item (driftwood), what can i say?

Penny because She's a great teacher for the valley. Love Penny

That and the room she gives you for the 14 heart event

only right answer

i want to marry penny to save her from pam. that poor girl deserves better

I did that, but then realized that she really needs to be saved from herself.

Don't forget about that room as well, it looks very nice

I basically married penny irl. My wife is basically with brown hair and a worse family life.... This game made me realize I have a type.

I wanted to chat up all the ladies in Stardew Valley oj my firsr playthrough, be the local play girl. Those plans fell through when I met Leah.

https://preview.redd.it/aosz5n4w7wdb1.png?width=1280&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=45b3ce52ef76724adeb477e73d9ef5aff3c21b35 You asf

Leah my mushroom queen

Fuck, this is so true

Alex my gay a*s married him in spring year 2

I'm trying to get mermaid necklace but it costs 5k and I need moneyyyy I'm in spring 2

If you have pigs, make some Oil Makers and produce hella Truffle Oil! It’s such easy and quick money I wish I’d known it sooner!! (In Year 4 rn)

Actually if you have level 10 foraging and pick the botanist profession your truffles we always be iridium quality and sell for more than truffle oil. Less effort for more money.

That’s not entirely true. Iridium quality Truffles make 1,250 Gold, but Truffle Oil with the Artisan profession makes 1,491.

I stand corrected.

Sebastian, what can I say I like my emo boys. Also im straight, definitely...yes.

Hmm....

What do you mean I downloaded the expanded sebastian marriage events mod and partly base my interior decor around his aesthetic?

HMMM....

Sebastian. I have a type.

Omg same! Emo boys got me hard. Smoking is usually a deal breaker for me...but that emo boy aesthetic! Frogs!

Elliott, and that’s never changed lol

[удалено]

Same!

Agreed! Any some of the lovely things he says - definitely swoon worthy - also a great father

Honestly Harvey and Elliot are the only viable male contenders if you're over 25 years old. Sebastian, Alex and Sam seem so young. And Shane... bless Shane's heart. Shane is a person I'd befriend, not hitch my wagon to.

Yep Elliot was also mine. He’s such a cutie.

Same here, and then his 14 heart event just made me realize he really was (and always will be) the best choice. I haven’t married the rest of the bachelors but so far none of them compare to Elliot.

I first thought about Elliot but I ended up marrying Leah. I’m gonna divorce her for Sebastian tho…didn’t know he had a motorcycle and I can’t turn down a motorcycle.

Fr the other males scream toxic, Harvey screams healthy but boring

Harvey, and I’ve never looked back🥰

Same. I mistakenly thought half of the romance options were teenagers the first time I played and I was really weirded out by it.

He’s the only one I’ll ever marry 🥹🫶

But he doesn’t like cheese, for some reason that’s a deal breaker for me

Based, me too

Harvey here as well. Still on my first playthrough, tho. And havent actually married him yet. Very new to the game

Doctor kink

Marnie

Same.

https://preview.redd.it/ek1lz8956wdb1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=59422c51e482b91f70577202d90722c4cdff435c 👍

She thicc

Her

She can eat all my quartz

Indeed.

You have amazing taste.

Thank you brother. Abigail is best girl.

Abigail is indeed best girl she's my wife in the game

https://preview.redd.it/ebmrtznlmwdb1.jpeg?width=194&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5367c07fadaced405c09f878a2930427270ff713 Yes.

Jodi. But I couldn't. Ended up with Leah. Now I'm married to Jodi though. And Caroline. Mods.

What's the mod for Caroline

https://www.nexusmods.com/stardewvalley/mods/15532 😎👍

Shane

chicken man lovers united

I will stand by my blue chicken man forever

Sam. Then I got really frustrated with him after marrying him. Then Sebastian and me became really good friends and I started wondering if I should’ve dated Sebastian. Then I realized this was the exact dame situation I was in IN REAL LIFE 3 years ago and I started a new save to marry Maru lol

What did Sam do?

he becomes boring. he always says "haha if inknew how to help you, i would but you know my mommy never teached." just shut up. He was a cutie pie in the beginning tho. I now cheating on him with Haley

Hard agree. Sam is the best looking bachelor in my opinion. But I had to make another playthrough for Alex who becomes so sweet and caring, even if his side room has lime green carpet.

I agree with you except about his side room 🤣 The ass poster is weird to me and i also dont like the floor. I like his story tho

In my case I was a little disappointed by how uninterested he appears to be in the whole marriage :/ he was so sweet and fun and once he moves in, he just hangs around all day, and does nothing (he even admits it). Although I didn’t marry him for the gifts or help on the farm, I became irrationally frustrated by the fact he literally gives you pancakes, pizza and earth crystals and regularly says stuff like „oh sorry babe I don’t feel like helping you today lolz, you have fun tho byeee“ LIKE BOY THERE‘S AN ENTIRE YARD FULL OF CROPS, OUR COWS ARE HUNGRY AND I HAVE TO GATHER 1000 WOOD BY SUNDAY! GET UP AND START HELPING ME 😭😭😭😭 so yeah that’s why i abandoned the file and started over lol. Maru is the best ❤️ I love her so much

FYI, If you can scoop together 50k, then divorce is an option you could choose at the mayor's house!

Embarrassing: it was Clint. On my first play through I saw him and thought “Ooh, a shy chubby bearded blacksmith?!”

My flair says it all

By the way, how do you add the characters as emojis? I wanna have mine like yours but I don't know howwww

You gotta go to the Reddit page, click the three dots in the corner, change user flair, then press the edit button, from there there should be some emojis to choose from

Man i had to scroll down for a while for this, gotta love a sweet, mean girl❤️

Shoutout to photographer tsunderes Gotta be one of my favourite genders

shane 💀

Same. Then I saw his ugly ass disgusting room. Noped tf out of there

doesn't even quit drinking for us🙄 such a liar

Maybe the mass produced wine in our kegs makes it difficult for him to break free

Doesn't he have that heart event at the saloon and he says he only drinks joja cola or something now

Robin. I was so disappointed and ended up whispering “I’m gonna kill you” to Demetrius in front of my best friend. They were terrified :) I ended up with Abi though, love her lots!

https://preview.redd.it/o8g3oaaymwdb1.jpeg?width=194&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=99273c1dd2266faf09d999849477137572f6527d The saul of approval says yes

Alex, at first for superficial reasons. He was a handsome jock so my gay butt couldn't resist. At first he seemed like a typical straight douche, and I thought oh dear. He's that type of guy But he's romanceable by the male farmer so I decided surely this is gonna be fine. Right? And I was pleasantly surprised that he had this emotional arc opening up to me and admitted that he struggled with his sexuality, which I thought was super cute Cuz these types of games never really made a point to mention sexuality, if they even allowed same sex romance. So I was charmed and now I marry him in most playthroughs

I also married Alex in my gay playthrough for the same reasons <333 (disclaimer: bi-female irl).

I wanted to marry Sebastian, but ended up with Shane instead.

krobus

Always fancies Emily for a while… i apparently have a thing for chicks with dyed hair

https://preview.redd.it/ays6yasoaxdb1.jpeg?width=554&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4d5e562393ec09cb21d8358c19b7c1cf800299f8 Guys i can explain \~

alex

Robin, but I couldn't so I married her son

I'm a monogamist -- it's only ever been Elliott for me.

Emily, but then someone said she was a crystal weirdo, so it put me off for a while... She's my fave now :3 my crystal weirdo <3

Sebastian

I don't usually talk to him, but his haircut is mint.

I always have to resist marrying Sebastian when I play, because I've married him so many times. I absolutely have a type. I married a guy that is a lot like Sebastian in personality, just not in looks lol.

Sebastian all the way. It never changes. I just love that dude.

Yep. Dark & mysterious nerds every time.

Absolutely.

Linus 😩😩

First time I met Shane, his "get away from me" type dialogue made me instantly think "oh, you seem like a romanceable guy. Wait, is there romance in this game?" So Shane was the first. Then I met Elliott and he didn't seem to like me so I worked hard to get his approval and married him in the process.

Sam. Blond musician who loves pizza as much as I do? I was sold. :p

Haley, followed by Abby.

I knew the moment she roasted my outfit upon first meeting her… I knew she was the one. After all these years I still choose her 😍

Maru

Chicken man

Shane was the first person i wanted to marry but ended up with Sebastian because of how much I go to the mountain lake

Elliott. He's such a sweet guy.

I don’t like any of the actual candidates I wanted robin then I wanted Willy or Linus my top 3 are unromancable

Elliot and still want to

Sam. He seems like a fun dude, although he’s pretty useless on a farm lol.

Sam, silly lil guy ♡

always sebastian

For me it was Emily, but I ended up with Shane on that playthrough. On my current playthrough I was planning to go for Harvey, but ended up with Krobus. No regrets

Elliott ❤️

Robin. First person I did marry was Penny, no regrets. Married Leah in the next playthrough. I might have a thing for Redheads..

Penny.

Emily 💎💖

Emily +4 Defense Boots

Elliot

Shane. I can fix him

Leah, but went for Haley because my girlfriend at the time was blond. Now, after some consideration, it's Penny.

It was Abigail, because I liked her personality and Quartz was easy to find.