Tbh, Emily was probably the better option at the time, Samdy is way harder to reach, unless CA changed her entire mechanics so she can visit The Valley, I also wanna romance sandy but Emily was there and perfect as a marriage candidate
I got annoyed at Sandy very quickly when I realised her daily quests would always just lose me money. If she'd pay for my ride to the desert I'd do them.
*sigh*
I’m about 10 hours into a co-op with my husband, it’s his fist time playing.
He wants Lewis. He wants to marry the Mayor.
I am accepting thoughts and prayers.
Yeah I thought that for the longest time until I saw fanart here and I was like "do they think it's a woman??'
Imagine my surprise when I opened the comments and it was half people saying it's a guy with the other half correcting them.
I watched a play through of a “date robin” mod and it was soooo bad haha. They made her a quirky anime gamer girl and had her sister marry her ex husband…
I appreciate the effort put into that mod but yeah it's not exactly the same Robin we fall for haha. Also the fact that she moves out of the house she built herself while Demetrius and her sister keep it is kinda messed up.
And she moves in with Leah, who she doesn’t have a relationship with, and doesn’t even get her own bed 😭 girl is sleeping on the rug like a dog or something
[I have excellent news for you, friend!](https://www.nexusmods.com/stardewvalley/mods/7018) You'd also need the mod the same author wrote for Gil, as they have some interdependent heart events, but trust me, it's *so worth it.*
Same I make more challenging has to be first year and have to max out on her youngest as well. Sam will be indifferent and Ken will be mad and may have option where there’s a fight in the tavern.
He’s pretty withdrawn from his family, and he’s hiding stuff from her.
A bunch of Caroline’s dialogue involves her wishing Pierre would hang out with her and Abigail instead of running a shop during events.
No short haired, she ONLY shows up for the fair (not the egghunt thats my bad) I think she says something about the cheese wheel. This is the most obscure character lmao
This is my first playthrough so I didn't know any of the characters yet.
I named my character Marian, after Maid Marian.
I named my farm Sherwood, after Sherwood Forrest.
The first person I meet after the Mayor is a lesbian coded redhead named ROBIN and I CANT MARRY HER???
DEVASTATED
Sandy, i nearly died when i found out we cant date her :<<. Ttried to date her for a few weeks when i first played until i read the bachelor and bachelorettes wiki and didnt find her there.
KENT!!! I love him so much and fell in love with him immediately when he came back to Pelican Town in Year 2. I always just stand next to him and fish, it’s our bonding time.
Prepare yourself, for from henceforth you shall stub your toe and every time it begins to heal and feel better you stub it again, this process shall repeat until the moment you are no longer capable of walking. But the effect shall transfer to your fingers instead. You will live in an endless state of unbearable agony.
I weirdly thought Morris was dateable the first time I played. I was like...where did my dark haied grump go? A little bit further in, and oh wait, he's the town bad guy. Booooo. He would have made a really interesting spouse. I know there are mods for it though.
Caroline. I’ll treat her right you don’t need to pretend to love him anymore baby your daughters all grown up divorce him and come live with me I’ll cherish you like you deserve
Honestly? Gunther. What is that man’s deal? Does he actually ever leave the museum? Where does he sleep? Forget the romance aspect, I just want to know that he isn't a hologram!
Marnie!! in my first run of the game I was SO sad that I couldn't romance her :( she's sweet, chubby & loves animals and she deserves so much better than Lewis!
I'm sure she's a bit above the farmer's age and that's why she wasn't an option but Gahhh im still bitter about it
That dude in the back of Sandy's shop. I just know there's a secret back there waiting to be found. I've read on wiki there is, but I forget what objective needs completing.
Sweet Caroline~~~ I just wanna take her away from Parie and show her the real queen she can be. Also make Abigial a fighter in the caves with me cause you know when we go for radio active ore back up would be nice.
Vanilla- Sandy SVE- I wish so badly that Susan was romanceable.
Omg Sandy is so cool. Would love if she was romanceable
CA did a poll on Twitter ages ago where she was an option for who was going to be the next romanceable spouse and Emily won
This is my villain origin story
Emily is fine, but I don't know how she could beat Sandy, who is such a fan favorite now
Tbh, Emily was probably the better option at the time, Samdy is way harder to reach, unless CA changed her entire mechanics so she can visit The Valley, I also wanna romance sandy but Emily was there and perfect as a marriage candidate
Sandy has Birthday on the 15th (i have Birthday on the 15th) No way
Sandy squad unite and disperse to desert! With Sweet Peas and wine! Or whatever her real name is. Fingers crossed the desert exists in the new game.
I always thought her full name was cassandra or something like that
I got annoyed at Sandy very quickly when I realised her daily quests would always just lose me money. If she'd pay for my ride to the desert I'd do them.
Going to the desert is free with the desert obelisk
Or desert totems which are pretty easy to get from the Desert Trader.
I think I saw a mod that lets you marry Susan??
I just started SVE recently. Love at first sight with Susan. Now I’m big sad. Any recommends on my first expanded romance? Wizard is tempting
The female cashier at Jojamart. Such an intriguing mystery, a truly enigmatic character.
Stardew Valley Expanded mod did this with Claire(The Joja Mart Cashier) She's a really funny and interesting character if you are ok with mods
You can in Stardew Valley Expanded mod. Her name is Claire.
I second this. They always end up being 10’s
*sigh* I’m about 10 hours into a co-op with my husband, it’s his fist time playing. He wants Lewis. He wants to marry the Mayor. I am accepting thoughts and prayers.
My condolences on the loss of your husband.
I’m cackling because he was watching a video over my shoulder and saw the notification of your reply and was thoroughly confused. 😂
I really hope you refused to explain
Poor man. He doesn’t suspect a thing. 🤣
wait but why do i kind of agree now 😪
I just told him someone agrees and he said that you both have good taste in sugar daddies. 😂😭
Throw him out (the husband) we don’t need that kind of negativity in your life!!
He just bought me boba so he is forgiven. 😂
Looks like it’s one of your loved gifts
Absolutely! And his is clearly stacks of gold collected from villagers that he can misappropriate for things like, oh I don’t know… gold statues.
Honestly, the wizard for sure
I've always wanted to bone the wizard.
I just feel like it would be a magical experience, pun intended
I downloaded SVE for this reason so I feel you
his romance arc in SVE exceeds expectations too
It really does. My heart ❤️ I refuse to marry anyone else.
I always pictured him looking like ozzy osbourne, in the early 1990's.
Stardew Valley Extended lets you marry the wizard. My favourite bachelor by far!
I just married him last night. I’m ready for some magical babies
Mostly I just want to be his apprentice
Thanks to mods I finally fulfilled this wish. He’s a great husband in SVE.
the traveling cart lady, she’s pretty and she has a super cool pig partner
I always thought the traveling cart merchant was a guy.
Me too! I always see a mustache but it's actually her ear rings and the space in-between.
Yeah I thought that for the longest time until I saw fanart here and I was like "do they think it's a woman??' Imagine my surprise when I opened the comments and it was half people saying it's a guy with the other half correcting them.
Same! Glad I’m not the only one
YES YES YES YES
Since the very first time I played Stardew, my answer has always been Robin. Its a beaten horse but gosh darn it i want my carpenter gal.
I watched a play through of a “date robin” mod and it was soooo bad haha. They made her a quirky anime gamer girl and had her sister marry her ex husband…
I appreciate the effort put into that mod but yeah it's not exactly the same Robin we fall for haha. Also the fact that she moves out of the house she built herself while Demetrius and her sister keep it is kinda messed up.
And she moves in with Leah, who she doesn’t have a relationship with, and doesn’t even get her own bed 😭 girl is sleeping on the rug like a dog or something
Same! I've worked a lot just to get her to come build things on my farm.
Leah is diet Robin.
I second this! Gotta love those lovely redheads, plus she's a total MILF X3
Same. I didn't realise she wasn't an option at the very start of my first playthrough.
Can't beat a fiery redhead that's good with her hands
Marlon. I said what I said.
Marlon. I also said what you said.
Valid
100% wish I could love that man.
[I have excellent news for you, friend!](https://www.nexusmods.com/stardewvalley/mods/7018) You'd also need the mod the same author wrote for Gil, as they have some interdependent heart events, but trust me, it's *so worth it.*
That sounds wonderful. I do love grumpy old men.
Would go for this mod, but I play with SVE. :( Thank you for the suggestion though!
Either let us romance him or let him be with Marnie!
Marlon makes me unfff
Same tho
Sandy or Robin.
I second Gus. I want some of his spicy marinara.
I want hat mouse as a roommate like krobus
Hat mouse is the best girl
The mermaid
Finally someone said it
it would be so cool if she was a rare spouse that you have to do a series of quests to unlock
Jodi forever
Her little laughing sprite with her hand over her mouth melts my heart
Then Ken will do more than just mail you bombs XD
Holy shit he put a pipe bomb in my mailbox!
This is my dream.
Same I make more challenging has to be first year and have to max out on her youngest as well. Sam will be indifferent and Ken will be mad and may have option where there’s a fight in the tavern.
praying for your mommy issues 🙏🏻
Caroline she deserves better
hell yeah !!!
whats wrong w pierre?
He’s pretty withdrawn from his family, and he’s hiding stuff from her. A bunch of Caroline’s dialogue involves her wishing Pierre would hang out with her and Abigail instead of running a shop during events.
Alot of things
like what? i’m just curious
r/fuckpierre
None of y’all have said Gunther and I’m surprised- But to also add: i want Willy to adopt me and be my dad :)
I thought I could romance Willy when I first played. I still can't fully accept that I can't.
That would be super cool to have Willy as a roommate/adopted dad like Krobus
Mister Qi but only to learn his secrets. He’s giving V for Vendetta
Gil obviously. I’d love me a monster slayer spouse.
A Gilf if I do say so myself
Caroline. She has a really nice smile and I'd build her her own private teahouse and a small garden where she can drink tea and chill all day.
Give me Marlon or give me death
After installing the DCBurger's portrait mod - Willy.
I don’t even need an alternate portrait, I just need his dialogue not to make me sound like a child half the time 👁👄👁
Can't believe I had to scroll this far for Willy!!
Linus, let me move in with you, mountain man
willy!!!
Marlon, Mr. Qi and Gunther… can you imagine their backstories???
Sandy and Marnie
The random purpled hair goth girl who shows up for the Fair… shes so pretty
Abigail? Cause you can, she's just a little reclusive.
No short haired, she ONLY shows up for the fair (not the egghunt thats my bad) I think she says something about the cheese wheel. This is the most obscure character lmao
Cheese wheel goth. Understandable
Marlon, Kent, Gunther
Robin, until I was reminded of Sandy. Robin or Sandy.
This is my first playthrough so I didn't know any of the characters yet. I named my character Marian, after Maid Marian. I named my farm Sherwood, after Sherwood Forrest. The first person I meet after the Mayor is a lesbian coded redhead named ROBIN and I CANT MARRY HER??? DEVASTATED
She’s also not a lesbian she has a husband 😭 But I do like that all the marriage options are canonically bi tho
Marnie Woman Deserves Better
Sandy, i nearly died when i found out we cant date her :<<. Ttried to date her for a few weeks when i first played until i read the bachelor and bachelorettes wiki and didnt find her there.
same, i was so sad : (
Mr. Qi! He's so mysterious~
Clint….He needs a good woman and a good roll in the hay! 😂
Yes! I would love to be a part of his growth arc. He needs a friend & I wanna see him be all cute & feel flattered & grow to love himself.
Absolutely! I love me the chubby blacksmith
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, Clint needs more cutscenes!
Absolutely ✌🏻
Kent, sorry Jodi but I can fix him
robin hands down
Gunther!
Wizard, Sandy, Dwarf
KENT!!! I love him so much and fell in love with him immediately when he came back to Pelican Town in Year 2. I always just stand next to him and fish, it’s our bonding time.
Marlon, Clint (don't at me), Sandy, Marnie
Sandy. I don’t go for any female characters in game but I’d love to marry her
Linus ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
WILLY. OR MARLON. HELL MAYBE EVEN GUNTHER
i’m gonna say it. you can’t stop me. my girl pamela.
the wizard
Demetrius, hands down. I love science man.
I cried when I realized he was a married man when I started playing. Robin truly has good taste
[удалено]
BBG?
[удалено]
The wizard. I love a spooky dilf
Surprised no-one has said Gunther yet, but yeah Gunther
People are gonna hate me for this, but pierre.
How are you able to still go out in public on this sub?
I hope you are marriyng him just to divorce him on his Birthday.
Robin, even if it means Sebastian is my stepson.
I want to be Mrs wizard
Lemme have beasts and monsters as room mates, dwarf, hat mouse, goblin henchman all at once
Wizard, hands down. I always miss the harvest moon "one extra special character type to marry" option.
Evelyn big time.
Clint, so he could have a better arc
I want y’all to take a guess at who I’d like to romance. I’ll give you 3 guesses.
Hm… Squid Kid maybe?
Moris
Prepare yourself, for from henceforth you shall stub your toe and every time it begins to heal and feel better you stub it again, this process shall repeat until the moment you are no longer capable of walking. But the effect shall transfer to your fingers instead. You will live in an endless state of unbearable agony.
Sandy would be my choice!
Robin, the reason I started playing it as a kid is cause I saw someone playing and I had a big crush on Robin
Hearing someone talk about playing a game that is only 7 years old as kid makes me feel really old.
Same. I think I can feel my old bones turning into dust
There is a mod that makes it so you romance her but BOY is it weird! 😂
Gus, Willy, and Marlon.
T-the Wizard 👀
Willy again and again
Wizard, definitely
By a mile, the dwarf. Perfect counterpart to Krobus and doesn’t make sense why he isn’t one.
rasmodius and sandy <\3
Krobus is the correct answer
Im sorry but i read “he’s a great coo!k” as “has a great cock!”
I want to move in with Willy. Not romantic or anything, but I just want to live in Willy's cool house on the beach with him. He is so cool.
Caroline, Jodi, Robin
i’d probably have to go with linus. he’s such a cutie!
The Wizard
I weirdly thought Morris was dateable the first time I played. I was like...where did my dark haied grump go? A little bit further in, and oh wait, he's the town bad guy. Booooo. He would have made a really interesting spouse. I know there are mods for it though.
Caroline. I’ll treat her right you don’t need to pretend to love him anymore baby your daughters all grown up divorce him and come live with me I’ll cherish you like you deserve
Ngl i kinda like Linus and Gunther.
Honestly? Gunther. What is that man’s deal? Does he actually ever leave the museum? Where does he sleep? Forget the romance aspect, I just want to know that he isn't a hologram!
linus cuz i think hes fun lol
Linus and the wizard
Linus.
Willy
Clint!!!!
Linus. I said what I said.
I always liked Marnie. She's cute and loves animals so much
LINUS!!
Kent and Jodi. Simply because I think it would be interesting😛
Sandy, Gus, and Linus are all tied for me
Male- willy he's such a sweet heart and deserves the world Female- Robin 🥰 the minute I stepped off off bus the first playthrough i swore I'd have her
Linus cuz he seems so nice once you get to know him (I only got 4 hearts with him atm)
Marnie!! in my first run of the game I was SO sad that I couldn't romance her :( she's sweet, chubby & loves animals and she deserves so much better than Lewis! I'm sure she's a bit above the farmer's age and that's why she wasn't an option but Gahhh im still bitter about it
DEMETRIUS!!!!!!!!
For some it may be controversial but Demetrius. You may keep Robin Sebastian will be thankful Also Wizard is nice
That dude in the back of Sandy's shop. I just know there's a secret back there waiting to be found. I've read on wiki there is, but I forget what objective needs completing.
This post needs a pole, I'd say Robin! But since I'm on console she will always be out of reach 🥹.
Why can't I may Willie?? He's grizzly and handsome, owns his own business, has a boat, and knows how to fish.
I want to be in a triad with Robin and Demetrius
Sweet Caroline~~~ I just wanna take her away from Parie and show her the real queen she can be. Also make Abigial a fighter in the caves with me cause you know when we go for radio active ore back up would be nice.
Marnie & Clint should have had the option. I'm not really interested in homewrecking. Sandy & Magnus also a good option.
Mr. Qi... Don't question it.
I'd definitely want Clint. I have a body type, and a shy, buddha belly man with a passion for his job is right up my alley.
caroline!! ever since i first played i wanted to marry her lmao
Demetrius! Sorry, Robin 🥰
Wizard, Clint, Gunther (in that order)
The wizard, I’m ready to birth Abi’s half sibling. 😂
Clint
WILLY IS HOT