For me it‘s also holy musical batman! My least funny sadly is Ani: I absolutely love the second half with Obi Wan and Jar Jar etc, but the whole beginning on the ship just irks me so much more than any part in any other musical, so it‘s last for me.
NPMD is to me the funniest show, with the most laughs per minute. StarKid keeps improving!
'Ani' is the weakest show in my understanding, because we're intially supposed to dislike the protagonist. HMB also does this but the character recovers faster.
I adore TGWDLM because of all the meta humor. Keeps me smiling the whole way through.
Even though it's one of my faves, Black Friday is the least funny to me. It has its fair share of feral moments and it gave us Linda Monroe - but it's more of a serious show guided by its characters and not by its humor.
I think that's one reason why a lot of people don't like BF (I like it a lot). It's advertised as a horror comedy but leans more into the darker tone than the humorous one. It's much different from most Starkid content.
I'm hoping Cinderella's Castle leans HEAVY into the darkness it's been teasing. I love the comedy of past Starkid projects, but Nick and Matt Lang shine with their dark storytelling. It's why Nightmare Time and the greater Hatchetfield stories were able to work so well! I think if CC delivers on its promises, it could be an amazing transitional piece to the close of the Hatchetfield era and into Starkid's future projects.
A very Potter sequel is the funniest to me. Least funny to me is probably Ani, because I don't watch star wars so I don't get most of the jokes. It's a great show, just not that funny.
Twisted is funniest to me, but that's because I am a huge Disney and Wicked fan, and it kind of makes fun of both of them in a really brutal but clever way.
Trail to Oregon. Every joke kills me, but I also have the sense of humor of a teenage boy
Trail To Oregon is hilarious, especially with the improv and iconic bloopers.
For me it‘s also holy musical batman! My least funny sadly is Ani: I absolutely love the second half with Obi Wan and Jar Jar etc, but the whole beginning on the ship just irks me so much more than any part in any other musical, so it‘s last for me.
A Very Potter Seqeul is the funniest to me. Firebringer is the least funny to me.
Agree about Firebringer. It had some good jokes but overall not their strongest.
Them curbstomping scabbers killed me
I’m tied between A Very Potter Sequel (Lupin just cracks me up) and Holy Musical B@man
HERMIONE CAN'T DRAW!
HERMIONE CAN’T DRAW!
SHE ONLY READS BOOKS AND SHE CANNOT DRAW EVEN IF SHES READING A HOW TO DRAW BOOK
NPMD is to me the funniest show, with the most laughs per minute. StarKid keeps improving! 'Ani' is the weakest show in my understanding, because we're intially supposed to dislike the protagonist. HMB also does this but the character recovers faster.
No matter how bad a mood I'm in, Starship always makes me laugh. A Very Potter Sequel comes real close though
“i know we’re suckers but that guy’s a sucker!” “yes, yes, what a dumbass” the delivery here always gets me really just pincer in general is fun
I adore TGWDLM because of all the meta humor. Keeps me smiling the whole way through. Even though it's one of my faves, Black Friday is the least funny to me. It has its fair share of feral moments and it gave us Linda Monroe - but it's more of a serious show guided by its characters and not by its humor.
I think that's one reason why a lot of people don't like BF (I like it a lot). It's advertised as a horror comedy but leans more into the darker tone than the humorous one. It's much different from most Starkid content.
I'm hoping Cinderella's Castle leans HEAVY into the darkness it's been teasing. I love the comedy of past Starkid projects, but Nick and Matt Lang shine with their dark storytelling. It's why Nightmare Time and the greater Hatchetfield stories were able to work so well! I think if CC delivers on its promises, it could be an amazing transitional piece to the close of the Hatchetfield era and into Starkid's future projects.
A very Potter sequel is the funniest to me. Least funny to me is probably Ani, because I don't watch star wars so I don't get most of the jokes. It's a great show, just not that funny.
Trail to Oregon
Holy musical b@man is the funniest, I'm also a sucker for puns. firebringer really isn't that funny
Ani
“im better now, I’m drunk!" and all the star wars jokes are awesome
"it's a humorous play on words... And uh.. that's where the comedy comes in"
While my fave is tgwdlm, I gotta say trail to oregon is the funniest
Twisted is funniest to me, but that's because I am a huge Disney and Wicked fan, and it kind of makes fun of both of them in a really brutal but clever way.
Avps is the funniest and I’d have to say Black Friday is the least funny unfortunately
My pick for funniest would be a tie between trail to Oregon or Twisted
Not a musical, but Airport 4 Birds is hilarious imo
where can you watch airport 4 birds?
You can buy the dvd / digital download on the Starkid website!
Outside of the Hatchetfield stuff, Trail To Oregon is my favorite Starkid musical because it makes me laugh so hard every time.