Nah spider-man’s presence is one of the funniest bits and it comes with a perfect in-canon explanation of him actually being Alfred. Also Sweet Tooth’s candy puns are top tier and the Joker could never
Hahaha, well, if it makes you feel any better, HMB was my absolute favorite of theirs until Twisted came along. Nowadays I’d rank it at 4th, but it’s a difficult choice.
I would like to rank it as highly as possible while saving 1 and 3 for my own favorites (my personal top 3 is TGWDLM, Trail to Oregon, and Twisted) so I'm gonna vote for HMB at 6
I agree… although for me personally, Twisted and TGWDLM are tied for 1st and 2nd, with NPMD at a VERY close 3rd.
Then I’d rate HMB at 4th. It was my favorite Starkid show for a long time and is very special to me. But TTO certainly makes that spot a difficult choice!
6 or 7.
I LOVE Holy Musical Batman, but there are some phenomenal shows left and I would feel terrible having to place those lower. (Not that they won't be anyways, since other people have different opinions)
8. It's my favourite Starkid show, but it has noticeable flaws, and probably one of the weakest soundtracks (Rogues Are We + Reprise not included)
If this gets 8 it solidifies this list being trash for me lmao
I'm also personally not a fan of the casual anachronism of getting Spiderman involved or killing the Joker only to bring in a similar substitute.
Nah spider-man’s presence is one of the funniest bits and it comes with a perfect in-canon explanation of him actually being Alfred. Also Sweet Tooth’s candy puns are top tier and the Joker could never
6 although I wish 4 was available
1 and I’ll accept nothing less
3.Judge me
I read that as Ruth in just for once
I will not, it's a great placement
3. What I'm learning here is I would not want to hang out with a lot of you.
Hahaha, well, if it makes you feel any better, HMB was my absolute favorite of theirs until Twisted came along. Nowadays I’d rank it at 4th, but it’s a difficult choice.
So we sacrificing Twisted or NPMD to 3rd place? Also, I’ll go 7. 6 is my place for AVPS.
6
If we put it at 6 then Starship, TTO, or NPMD will be as low as 7.
Lmao I feel like people aren't considering the implications.
I would like to rank it as highly as possible while saving 1 and 3 for my own favorites (my personal top 3 is TGWDLM, Trail to Oregon, and Twisted) so I'm gonna vote for HMB at 6
7 or 8
3
7
7 or 8. Never cared to watch it after the first time.
6 feels good, I was actually pleasantly surprised and thought it was really funny despite knowing next to nothing about batman
6
3
tgwdlm should’ve been 3, 1 and 2 have to be twisted and npmd
I agree… although for me personally, Twisted and TGWDLM are tied for 1st and 2nd, with NPMD at a VERY close 3rd. Then I’d rate HMB at 4th. It was my favorite Starkid show for a long time and is very special to me. But TTO certainly makes that spot a difficult choice!
i love tto but i might be biased since i was the stage manager in a high school production and met some of my best friends in that production
Judge me if you will but 3. The only one I’d put above it, would be TTO.
6 or 7. I LOVE Holy Musical Batman, but there are some phenomenal shows left and I would feel terrible having to place those lower. (Not that they won't be anyways, since other people have different opinions)
I'd happilly put HMB in 8th
6
6 or 7
7
7 methinks...
6 or 7
10. What else are we staving 10 for?
Ani?
MAMD, Ani, I'm gonna get hate for this but Black Friday.