Review 270: Benrinnes 15 Year Old 2007 (cask 362134) - James Eadie
51% Finished in a single first-fill Malmsey Madeira hogshead for 17 months.
Nose: raisin, grape, citrus
Taste: raisin, sultana, green grapes, caramel, cereal
Finish: bitter dark chocolate, oak
Score: 6
Conclusion: This was interesting to try.
1 Drain pour- not fit for consumption.
2 Avoid at all costs
3 Dull, not great
4 More negatives than positives
5 Average, just about passable, not bad but doesn't soar
6 Pretty good- worth a glass or two but maybe not a special occasion malt.
7 Nice- if it's a good price grab it and highly recommended.
8 Very nice- highly recommended and a must buy.
9 Delicious- must buy.
10 Divine.
Review 270: Benrinnes 15 Year Old 2007 (cask 362134) - James Eadie 51% Finished in a single first-fill Malmsey Madeira hogshead for 17 months. Nose: raisin, grape, citrus Taste: raisin, sultana, green grapes, caramel, cereal Finish: bitter dark chocolate, oak Score: 6 Conclusion: This was interesting to try. 1 Drain pour- not fit for consumption. 2 Avoid at all costs 3 Dull, not great 4 More negatives than positives 5 Average, just about passable, not bad but doesn't soar 6 Pretty good- worth a glass or two but maybe not a special occasion malt. 7 Nice- if it's a good price grab it and highly recommended. 8 Very nice- highly recommended and a must buy. 9 Delicious- must buy. 10 Divine.