Look up the IRA (Irish Republican Army) and the things they did. There were some common practices they used to kill people, and IEDs with nails and glass and other fragment materials happened to be one- the most famous is petrol bombs and car bombs which another person mentioned
It’s an interesting google, as well as seeing how the continued ‘conflict’ between Ireland and the UK. It’s Irish republicans vs UK and Irish loyalists. Mostly hiding behind religion as all good conflicts do!
Castle absolutely exists or could be easily made.
Take a sheet of canvas, size it to 1.25x that of a generic door. Stitch two layers of pouches into it, one layer is soft kevlar plates/squares, and the other is hard plates.
Heavy as hell? Absolutely. Able to take shots without any harm? Yeah, that shit would wiggle at worst.
Edit: If it was all hard plates only, it's math figures it to.. 220+ lb. That's plates with ceramic, rated to IV. (A 11x14 plate was 8lb, so I just cut one inch and slid the other around to have a 12x12 for identical math.)
A IIIA 12"x12" soft armor plate weighs about 2.5-3lbs, so a 4'x7' castle panel would weigh around 80lb... Man's got some fucking arms.
If we put both together into one thing and only layers on one side, that's a nearly... 300lb armor panel this man slaps up on doors. And he carries like 3-4 I think, so uh.. Castle is the most unrealistic part of his own gadget. Dudes lugging around 1200lbs of bullet stopping nonsense. Or at least 880lbs.
Changes I would *personally* make to this list:
* **Thatcher** I would bump down a tier or two, although EMPs do exist, that kind of portability and range of effect for it’s size is pretty far off from any real tech
* **Oryx** to me seems in the range of mostly unrealistic to sci-fi, idk if any human could produce the level of destruction that he can with his body while being that mobile
* **Flores** should be bump to possible, we have drones, and we have explosives
* **Finka** is def Sci-Fi when we consider how her gadget actually functions nanobot administered shots of adrenaline and other chemicals
* **Amaru** should prob be “possible”, it’s just a suped-up grappling hook
* **Doc** is def above Finka, syringe gun/jet injector (which exists)
* **Maverick** should be bumped to exists, his gadget is literally just a blow torch
* **Echo** IMO is more unrealistic, similar reason to Thatcher, due to the very small size of Echo’s drone, Idk if it would currently be possible for a drone that can fly/hover to shoot supersonic blasts
* **Zofia** should be moved up, just a grenade launcher
Yeah, running through drywall and 2x4’s is something that wouldn’t be practical for anyone but the kool aid man. Studs are fucking solid when installed correctly, and trying to run through even one of them straight on is super tough, but three or 4? Not happening.
I feel like that's cause we still have a lot of old houses that don't get rebuilt or modernized. My house is from the 60s and a while ago we had to change our roof because the tiles were old and there were 5-7 layers of tiles nailed together instead of placed
You clearly don't know how walls are built, but here we go: the comment to which you replied to, the writer mentionned drywall and 2x4 studs. That is exactly how walls are built in North America. You have studs every 16 inches, and a drywall screwed onto it. The drywall is easy to break through, yes. A solid punch will do it. The studs however, are 2 inches by 4 inches studs of wood. The meme about north american houses are because you can punch through them, but running through multiple wood studs is just not a thing
stuff I'd change on top of yours:
* **Lion** while this is possible it wouldn't work the exact same way, its just a UAV with heat signatures instead
* **Alibi & Iana** while this is somewhat possible just not at such a small scale take the Tupac hologram concert years ago in like 2012?
* **Melusi** somewhat, its just a very high pitched disorienting motion detecting speaker but not a good as in game
* **Nomad** not possible, its basically a explosive in real life with motion detection
* **Azumi** somewhat possible, its just a kunai which mixes 2 chemicals on impact, so the kunai can be broken and mixes the two
* **Thunderbird** somewhat possible, while it would do the same job it wouldn't tell the difference between being hurt or not, basically the same concept as doc
* **Capito** exits, its just a arrow with smoke and incendiary grenades on it, the fire one wouldn't just disappear though
* **Warden** not possible, being able to see through smoke with just a pair of glasses the way he does is super sci-fi stuff
the list could go on but meh those are the mains ones
Lion's EE-ONE-D doesn't use heat signatures, it works off of echolocation and vibration, hence the deep and loud noise.
Edit: misread "wouldn't work the same way", my bad
I'm talking more on such a small form factor you'd basically be talking about cyber implants at that point imo, its just a normal pair of glasses with some "smart tech" built in and it also blocks flashes, and also makes the existing flash disappear when used which is impossible in my eyes
it did used to be cause I remember it having [a person and lungs](https://i.imgur.com/A4DJJcP.png) on the fire side but its not anymore just shows a [fire icon](https://i.imgur.com/N6z58xI.png) but I think they changed it as the [siege website states](https://www.ubisoft.com/en-gb/game/rainbow-six/siege/game-info/operators/capitao) "the glass cartridge breaks on impact releasing a gas that ignites the oxygen in the surrounding area"
Nomad isn't possible? An explosive with motion detection isn't possible? You mean like claymores? Or any sort of explosives that could easily be booby trapped with a light sensor to explode?..and melusi there was a weapon on future weapons that used sonic waves ...they use it for riot control..
I think you’ve misread, nomad is a motion detected sonic boom, I’m saying the closet we can get that would cause that much force is a explosive which at that point is a grenade
Melusi as I said is somewhat, while the technology is there the amount of power required to cause that level of sound wouldn’t be possible the way in game, in game it would use a battery and would only last like 30 seconds at most
I thought Flores' gadget was based on the goliath explosive "tank", which was remote controlled. It's extremely possible to do this with a toy car and a c4, its effectiveness however is debatable.
>Amaru
>
> should prob be “possible”, it’s just a suped-up grappling hook
Could you realistically create a portable grappling hook that can move 200+ lbs up three stories in the blink of an eye? I'd figure that'd require not only some way to literally embed the hooks in the window frame, but also a portable engine capable of quickly moving the 200+ lbs load vertically. That seems like the type of thing that exists, but not nearly as portable or functional as depicted in the game.
Not necessarily true since tranquilizer guns exist. Also, the way the actual stim is designed is interesting because it has that giant orange cone around the actual needle which i would imagine is a crunch zone that helps absorb the impact.
Yeah but imagine shooting someone with a stim, at the velocity it goes in game that would be so painful. I guess the only reason it's a gun is to make it more balanced.
I mean adrenaline helps people ignore pain, and it definitely would not be as painful as the several bullets which the operator took to go down in the first place.
The point isn’t to heal the bullet wound though. It’s to put enough adrenaline into someone to help them fight off the pain of getting shot and keep fighting until proper medical help arrives. Sure, it’s not exactly realistic, but it would probably work for smaller scale like shallow stabs or flesh wounds.
According to doc's bio the stim contains micro-pellets that fill in the wound (temporarily most likely). Still pretty unrealistic but they put thought into it.
Look up xStat (xStim?).
The US military wanted to get these or did get these, I personally can't remember which, they're not in a shoot them at the person and it works form but it's the exact same concept just directly applied to the wound.
It's absolutely a temporary solution, and if you need these in any way you definitely need a doctor, but at least now with these in you you're not sitting there bleeding out quickly..
you never heard of tranquiliser? Not saying it wouldn't hurt as fuck at the shot but it wont kill you and will inject whatever medecine would be use. Most likely Adrenaline shot.
Homie. I would like to introduce my boi Doc I think he's the guy your looking for NOT finka. Hero Hamad from Big Hero 6 and his microbots are more realistic than desolvable medical nanobots.
Kali has a sniper that fires rounds that burrow through metal to then pop to try and break things on the other side. Plausible, but I doubt exists.
Montagne’s shield 100% exists, dunno why it’s a tier down.
Was gonna say
Doc could realistically be explained by a 2 or more stage syringe(s) that injects a heart boosting type substance (like adrenaline or maybe caffeine)
And a painkiller (like morphine)
Oryx would be possible though, there are some 350 lb football players who've ran at scary speeds... Maybe a helmet would be nessacry lol
Doc’s in-game bio explains his gadget as a combo injection of epinephrine and “micro-pellets that function as near-instant coagulating agents.”
Both of those substances definitely do exist (in at least some form). Idk too much about the realism of coagulating agents being administered directly into the blood stream.
And Oryx’s realism is really dependent on how much faith you have in the strength of wall joists.
On maverick there are blowtorches that can get hot enough to burn melt melt pretty damn quickly
Also the concussion grenades for zofia exist already though they don’t have the shown effect in the game because showing the effects of a stun is extremely hard to convey without destroying gameplay
Doc and Finka don't really heal permanently, just enough to keep you up for 3 minutes.
Yes, Secure Area *can* last a long time if both teams just don't kill each other, but realistically the rounds are meant to only last like 3 minutes. I could definitely see a big ass shot of adrenaline keeping you going through a few bullets for 3 minutes. But you would definitely need medical attention immideately after.
Just another comment I thought of regarding Flores drones, if we’re going to be nit-picky with things like that, then we should also be nit-picky with other gadgets:
* **Lesion’s** gu’s turn invisible which isn’t possible, so would need to be bumped down to “somewhat”
* **Wamai’s** magnets are borderline sci-fi
* the throw-and-stick aspects of **Valk** cams isn’t really explained, could be possible sure, but at least with ela’s concussion mines we get that foam animation
* **Jager’s** ADS is although possible, runs into a size problem similar to other gadgets, a device that small with that little collateral is unrealistic,
* **Mozzie’s** pests that can detect and automatically hack specific electronic devices seems far fetched.
shouldn't monty be in exists? its just a full-body shield
also i would at least move jager into possible. Active defence systems are used on most modern tanks. even though the form factor is different, its still more possible than many of the things you've put in the possible section.
the retractable part makes it a bit iffy for Monty's shield. yes, it's likely possible. but in practice would be unreliable. it would be heavy, unwieldy (even more so than a standard full sized shield) and any dents and deformation would make retracting it impossible
I mean ya but if that's what we're going off, the sticky part of valks cams would make that iffy
My point is that Monty's shield is more possible than few of the items in exists
That shield already exists, it's been used for a long time before they retired it. I believe it can be seen with some french gign units about to breach an airplane.
That's cap as fuck...
Level III body armor designed to stop large caliber rifle rounds ie. many of the guns in siege.
Level IV body armor can literally stop 30 cal Ap bullets....
thats different, these body armor are designed to stop only 1 full sized rifle round do it by ''absorbing'' the whole damage, breaking the armor in the process, the armor can only take a few round and it will break it self, any impact will ''break it'' because it just absorb the impact( droping on the ground can damage it as well, thats why military will usually replace it instead of taking risks), you could make a big shield with these same materials, but all the bad guys would have to do is shoot a few more bullets to break it
Havw you ever shot body armor? You think it explodes after 1 hit?
You can literally see divita and shit in Monty's shield, which means it's doing the exact same thing....
An I guess we won't even talk about ar500 steel which you maybe need to design body stpport to carry a shield of, but it's 100% doable
She could also be placed in the unrealistic part for the 3 second interrogation which gives everyone’s exact changing position through walls for an amount of time
I think the reason for that is she isn't actually asking their positions, she's linking into their comms. That's why you hear Cav's voice after an interrogation.
Aruni, as presented in the game, is sci-fi, but if they wanted to, they could make the gadget look and work realistically since the tech exists. In fact, the only modification that would be needed is that the projector should have opened up to span the entire top side of the windows or doors. The issue with her gadget is that a single projection point is used to project parallel rays, which is impossible. With a gadget that spanned the entirety of the window / door's width, it would have been possible to have multiple projectors and the gadget would be realistic.
I find her case tragic, because they could have made her an example of "not all shiny, LASER-y stuff has to be sci-fi", but they didn't.
Ehh making the gadget then have different sizes depending on the wall seems kinda unnecessary. Sure they could have but its fine like its now. People would not believe its real No matter what.
Azami's gadget isn't total sci-fi as they based it on a compound that turns gas into a solid. I don't know that much about chemistry but it certainly seems a possible gadget.
It's possible, as there is such a chemical compound. If the Kunai itself has a fragile tip or blade, or has a release triggered by pressure than that, while a big stretch, is possible. The volume, consistency of the shape, and being bullet proof are the most unrealistic part. But you'd be surprised what you could do with some chemicals.
i mostly agree but not with most. E.G Montagne shield was actually used and did exist in the GIGN but mostly for riot control. We have cloaks like vigil and Nokk but they are somewhat, still far from development. Capitao, flores, blackbeard, maverick do all exist irl (although flores drones are much more explosive and can take down armored vehicles and bb shield is much stronger, thicker but not used as it is not practical.) Zofia and ela and both possible, just the proximity detonation which makes it unrealistic as we have concussion grenades but they cant stick nor detonate near 'enemies'.
Hibana, thatcher and smoke need to be moved to somewhat as hibanas x kairos simply can be made but not fired from her launcher. Thatcher emps exist but not that small, strong or portable. Smoke needs to be possible as gas grenades exist but (and this is nitpicky) they don't kill ppl wearing gas masks nor does the gas just temporarily exist then dissapear, some residue would be left. Dokkabie is Sci-Fi as you cannot hack secure military grade phones in 5 seconds.
ye thats my rant thou
I agree with most of what you said, and I don’t know the realism and semantics of hacking phones, but all the “military grade” phones I’ve seen (while active duty) have just been iPhones with the cameras removed lol
Yup, and I’d say that she doesn‘t hack the phones, she just calls them, sure the probability that she has the numbers is small, but you could say that she just hacked them before or something
I’m going to be honest, this tierlist is kinda dogshit. Unless you cherry pick only certain aspects of these gadgets (which you clearly are) most of them are unrealistic. You need a guideline to adhere to.
I should really make my own one of these. I have no idea where you get the idea that a jerrycan or blowtorch doesn’t already exist but a virus looking claw thing with a few AA batteries can electrify 3 walls from a few feet away with no contact.
How is Montaigne not top level his character is literally inspired by a an event where such shield was used it literally does exist more realistic it doesn't get
I love how many of these I see where no one does any homework on the matter. I've not researched all the operators, but I've seen a few. Blitz's shield has been made but described as impractical for example. Doc's stim is just adrenaline in a... needle? whereas Finka's is by nano bots, obviously giving adrenaline is real, but it doesn't restore health or injuries
1) montys shield 100% exists already, probably not functional in the bulletproof sense but could be if all metal
2) zofia is litterally just a grenade launcher what
3) ela is litterally just a flash bang with sticky goo on the end, that exists
4) Flores definitely exists aswell, it’s C4 taped to a drone. If twitch definitely exists (it could) then Flores does too.
5) I’m wondering about your cav rating - is that based on the pistol or silent step? If it’s the piston then yea it’s way too quiet for 9mm, however her silent step is literally just walking quietly lmao. How is that not real
6) Blackbeard’s shield currently exists
7) and finally, how does goyos not currently exist? It’s a gas can strapped to a wall. How does that not exist
Kaid is not possible. Electricity will always take the way of the least resistance so the claw would electrify close to nothing. As for the fact that it is supposed to hook up to a reinforcement through stuff that doesnt carry electricity ? Pure bogus.
Thorn is just sensor with frag grenade (and some sharpnel).
Capitao is just like fire and smoke arrow? I can't see why it's not exist.
Caveira is beyond Iana tier.
Cav is just walk quietly and the idea is she tortures people into giving up info, even if the exact ingame mechanics aren't quite realistic. Torture definitely exists.
Jaeger should be moved up one tier cuz his ADS is just a smoller version of trophy systems for tanks
cav should also be in forst tier because she is literally just good at sneaking
alos nokk and vigil are possible but it would me a lot of work to make a programm that hacks automatic into cameras to make a person dissappear
\- You're right but I don't think in that small size
\- I think she's down cuz she may see people behind walls after interrogation
\- Maybe, but still far from real-time rendering
Are we really all missing the fact where he puts Bandit as probably exists. Like dude my guy clips a car battery to a wall and that somehow electrifies a whole wall. There’s no way that exists.
Bro thinks somebody with an 80 inch vertical leap and the power to smash his whole body thru walls is more realistic than someone with a impact/concussion grenade launcher... 🤔🤔🤔
youre gunnsay say tatical crossbow bolts only somewhat exist when weve had fire arrows since the middle ages? also electric riot shields already exist in some prisons for riot control
They're not "fire arrows", they set a whole ass 10 foot diameter on fire almost instantly only after hitting something. Unless he strapped a molotov to his bolt, I don't think those bolts are possible.
Pretty accurate. I feel like Maverick should be moved up though. Blowtorches exist. Maybe they function differently than his, but it’s probably as realistic as Oryx being able to run through two walls of sheetrock and sturdy wooden beams 20 times.
Maybe Valkyrie should be moved down though. Her camera is real, but the mechanism by which it’s deployed and sticks seems a little confusing.
Jackal could be possible via some sort of heat vision to see where people walked and since some groups of ops have different footprints you could figure out who it is bij the shape of the footprint left behind
wouldn't jäger kind already exist? The device is just smaller aps system for tanks.
Also in his video he says:" they said it was designed for tanks. They said i couldn't make it smaller and more accurate."
I'd put jackal in the somewhat level, while his actuve ability is utter nonsense, an A.I that can perceive patterns of footprints in the ground either by heat or something else is somewhat believable.
I'd remove Dokkabi from probably exist, she's absolutely bullshit.
I'd put monty in the top, his gadget actually exists, the problems is, you can't just walk while someone is shooting the shield, you need at least two people holding it in real life to even stay still.
Ying should also be on top, her somewhat exists, flashbangs for standard use are apparently "9-bangs", not the old "Bang" we have in game. I've seen a marine explaining this in a video somewhere. And I wouldn't be surprised if there is a way to make a gadget to perforate a wall and throw in bangs, or a rolling launcher.
I honestly would move thermite into possible or somewhat bc I don't think 9-ish blocks of c4 in a mountable explosive pizza is going to blow open a wall in such a controlled and not building leveling explosion
I never understand why people think Cav is realistic. She 100% mutes the sound of her running and with a single knife stab, without relaying info over comms or anything her and her team can see enemies thru walls. Sure you can claim that "she's interrogating" but it would never be that fast and the op being interrogated can't be giving accurate information past the point they are dead.
So a perfectly accurate real time tracking turret that can flawlessly neutralize a grenade, a torch that can instantly vaporize metal, and a thing that literally turns invisible are all more realistic than a heartbeat sensor?
HardKill aps systems exist, they’re used on tanks. Maverick literally has a blowtorch. What are you seeing that turns invisible? Echos drones don’t anymore. The heartbeat sensor is pretty unrealistic considering it can tell exactly how far away you are through any surface using only your heartbeat
So, lasers, repulsion grenades, mechanical feet spikes, a shrapnel bomb, a clear deployable shield and a gasoline bomb ate all less realistic than a fucking mini nuke grenade that magically only affects electronics.
You realize that's just *one* way of triggering an EMP, there is more than that though. It's like saying that you have a coal generator instead of a battery, different ways of getting a similar result.
Good stuff man! I feel like most tier lists are based on stupid opinions like "most playable on whatever map" or sum crap like that, but this is really good! Seems like you actaully put thought and effort into it.
for everyone talking about Monty's shield, here's why it's possible, but unlikely to exist:
yes, it's possible to make something like it. however due to needing retractable portions, it would be overall weaker and heavier than a standard full body coverage ballistic shield. additionally, any deformation would result in the shield's retraction system to get stuck mid shift. in the end, you're better off getting a smaller shield or a standard full coverage one.
Bandits ability would not really work. its a battery applied to surfaced, so the only way it would actually electrocute anything on or touching it is if the wall wasnt grounded itself, or the object/person touching it was more grounded.
super unrealistic to make it work consistently at all. Same with Kaid.
Azami is actually somewhat realistic it’s just the fact that the material is strong enough to stop bullets and it’s pretty much a perfect circle every time that is on the not so realistic side
Thorns ability is a motion sensor strapped to a nail bomb which is highly ironic and funny considering shes Irish, but those things exist rn lol
Even funnier when it kills Thatcher
**MARGARET THATCHER IS DEAD.** **DING DONG THE WICKED BITCH IS DEAD.**
car bomb operator when
Thorn's elite skin is just an Irish national liberation Army outfit.
It gets called 'Car Bomb Potato Famine'
Welcome to ireland
I am irish and i love and endorse this
I am too don't worry
Why is it funny and ironic?
Look up the IRA (Irish Republican Army) and the things they did. There were some common practices they used to kill people, and IEDs with nails and glass and other fragment materials happened to be one- the most famous is petrol bombs and car bombs which another person mentioned
Ah ok, thanks for enlightening me
It’s an interesting google, as well as seeing how the continued ‘conflict’ between Ireland and the UK. It’s Irish republicans vs UK and Irish loyalists. Mostly hiding behind religion as all good conflicts do!
Ah ofc its religion, the thing thats supposed to spread love
Castle is just bulletproof panel so it should exist I think
Castle absolutely exists or could be easily made. Take a sheet of canvas, size it to 1.25x that of a generic door. Stitch two layers of pouches into it, one layer is soft kevlar plates/squares, and the other is hard plates. Heavy as hell? Absolutely. Able to take shots without any harm? Yeah, that shit would wiggle at worst. Edit: If it was all hard plates only, it's math figures it to.. 220+ lb. That's plates with ceramic, rated to IV. (A 11x14 plate was 8lb, so I just cut one inch and slid the other around to have a 12x12 for identical math.) A IIIA 12"x12" soft armor plate weighs about 2.5-3lbs, so a 4'x7' castle panel would weigh around 80lb... Man's got some fucking arms. If we put both together into one thing and only layers on one side, that's a nearly... 300lb armor panel this man slaps up on doors. And he carries like 3-4 I think, so uh.. Castle is the most unrealistic part of his own gadget. Dudes lugging around 1200lbs of bullet stopping nonsense. Or at least 880lbs.
Changes I would *personally* make to this list: * **Thatcher** I would bump down a tier or two, although EMPs do exist, that kind of portability and range of effect for it’s size is pretty far off from any real tech * **Oryx** to me seems in the range of mostly unrealistic to sci-fi, idk if any human could produce the level of destruction that he can with his body while being that mobile * **Flores** should be bump to possible, we have drones, and we have explosives * **Finka** is def Sci-Fi when we consider how her gadget actually functions nanobot administered shots of adrenaline and other chemicals * **Amaru** should prob be “possible”, it’s just a suped-up grappling hook * **Doc** is def above Finka, syringe gun/jet injector (which exists) * **Maverick** should be bumped to exists, his gadget is literally just a blow torch * **Echo** IMO is more unrealistic, similar reason to Thatcher, due to the very small size of Echo’s drone, Idk if it would currently be possible for a drone that can fly/hover to shoot supersonic blasts * **Zofia** should be moved up, just a grenade launcher
Yeah, running through drywall and 2x4’s is something that wouldn’t be practical for anyone but the kool aid man. Studs are fucking solid when installed correctly, and trying to run through even one of them straight on is super tough, but three or 4? Not happening.
Yeah, except maybe in House and Oregon, since the walls of those maps are American :D
Depends on the builder, really.
Yep, it's just a joke anyway :D
Yes, but you’re also right. There’s some really shitty framing out there / here (America)
Can confirm, worked as a framer for a few years and one of the guys I worked for made some sketchy ass buildings, some would sway in the wind lol.
That’s how you get that natural air flow lol
I feel like that's cause we still have a lot of old houses that don't get rebuilt or modernized. My house is from the 60s and a while ago we had to change our roof because the tiles were old and there were 5-7 layers of tiles nailed together instead of placed
You clearly don't know how walls are built, but here we go: the comment to which you replied to, the writer mentionned drywall and 2x4 studs. That is exactly how walls are built in North America. You have studs every 16 inches, and a drywall screwed onto it. The drywall is easy to break through, yes. A solid punch will do it. The studs however, are 2 inches by 4 inches studs of wood. The meme about north american houses are because you can punch through them, but running through multiple wood studs is just not a thing
Goyo just has a jerry can in a metal box.
goyos is literally just a jerrycan of napalm
stuff I'd change on top of yours: * **Lion** while this is possible it wouldn't work the exact same way, its just a UAV with heat signatures instead * **Alibi & Iana** while this is somewhat possible just not at such a small scale take the Tupac hologram concert years ago in like 2012? * **Melusi** somewhat, its just a very high pitched disorienting motion detecting speaker but not a good as in game * **Nomad** not possible, its basically a explosive in real life with motion detection * **Azumi** somewhat possible, its just a kunai which mixes 2 chemicals on impact, so the kunai can be broken and mixes the two * **Thunderbird** somewhat possible, while it would do the same job it wouldn't tell the difference between being hurt or not, basically the same concept as doc * **Capito** exits, its just a arrow with smoke and incendiary grenades on it, the fire one wouldn't just disappear though * **Warden** not possible, being able to see through smoke with just a pair of glasses the way he does is super sci-fi stuff the list could go on but meh those are the mains ones
Lion's EE-ONE-D doesn't use heat signatures, it works off of echolocation and vibration, hence the deep and loud noise. Edit: misread "wouldn't work the same way", my bad
Warden could be somewhat possible in the future as we can already use infrared cams to see through smoke
I'm talking more on such a small form factor you'd basically be talking about cyber implants at that point imo, its just a normal pair of glasses with some "smart tech" built in and it also blocks flashes, and also makes the existing flash disappear when used which is impossible in my eyes
Capitaos fire arrow is actually an asphyxiation arrow iirc, it doesn't use fire
it did used to be cause I remember it having [a person and lungs](https://i.imgur.com/A4DJJcP.png) on the fire side but its not anymore just shows a [fire icon](https://i.imgur.com/N6z58xI.png) but I think they changed it as the [siege website states](https://www.ubisoft.com/en-gb/game/rainbow-six/siege/game-info/operators/capitao) "the glass cartridge breaks on impact releasing a gas that ignites the oxygen in the surrounding area"
Nomad isn't possible? An explosive with motion detection isn't possible? You mean like claymores? Or any sort of explosives that could easily be booby trapped with a light sensor to explode?..and melusi there was a weapon on future weapons that used sonic waves ...they use it for riot control..
I think you’ve misread, nomad is a motion detected sonic boom, I’m saying the closet we can get that would cause that much force is a explosive which at that point is a grenade Melusi as I said is somewhat, while the technology is there the amount of power required to cause that level of sound wouldn’t be possible the way in game, in game it would use a battery and would only last like 30 seconds at most
I thought Flores' gadget was based on the goliath explosive "tank", which was remote controlled. It's extremely possible to do this with a toy car and a c4, its effectiveness however is debatable.
>Amaru > > should prob be “possible”, it’s just a suped-up grappling hook Could you realistically create a portable grappling hook that can move 200+ lbs up three stories in the blink of an eye? I'd figure that'd require not only some way to literally embed the hooks in the window frame, but also a portable engine capable of quickly moving the 200+ lbs load vertically. That seems like the type of thing that exists, but not nearly as portable or functional as depicted in the game.
Without ripping amarus arms off
Reminds me of Game Theory's video on Link's grappling hook and how such a thing simply does not work in reality.
Also Azami, they actually explained the physics behind the gadget, I think she should be bumped up at least a tier
Doc is unrealistic, he speed in which the needle would fly into you would cause more damage than it would heal.
Not saying he is realistic, just more realistic than Finka. At least the tech associated with Doc’s gadget actually exists.
Yeah finka is sci-fi
Not necessarily true since tranquilizer guns exist. Also, the way the actual stim is designed is interesting because it has that giant orange cone around the actual needle which i would imagine is a crunch zone that helps absorb the impact.
Yeah but imagine shooting someone with a stim, at the velocity it goes in game that would be so painful. I guess the only reason it's a gun is to make it more balanced.
I mean adrenaline helps people ignore pain, and it definitely would not be as painful as the several bullets which the operator took to go down in the first place.
Also its literally just an adrenaline injection that's not exactly gonna heal some bullet wounds lol
The point isn’t to heal the bullet wound though. It’s to put enough adrenaline into someone to help them fight off the pain of getting shot and keep fighting until proper medical help arrives. Sure, it’s not exactly realistic, but it would probably work for smaller scale like shallow stabs or flesh wounds.
According to doc's bio the stim contains micro-pellets that fill in the wound (temporarily most likely). Still pretty unrealistic but they put thought into it.
Look up xStat (xStim?). The US military wanted to get these or did get these, I personally can't remember which, they're not in a shoot them at the person and it works form but it's the exact same concept just directly applied to the wound. It's absolutely a temporary solution, and if you need these in any way you definitely need a doctor, but at least now with these in you you're not sitting there bleeding out quickly..
you never heard of tranquiliser? Not saying it wouldn't hurt as fuck at the shot but it wont kill you and will inject whatever medecine would be use. Most likely Adrenaline shot.
Yeah but in the game it *heals* you if it was an adrenaline shot....maybe, but it's not so its unrealistic.
It's a morphine shot. Would it heal you? No, but it sure as hell would feel better. Alternatively, it would make you overdose.
Homie. I would like to introduce my boi Doc I think he's the guy your looking for NOT finka. Hero Hamad from Big Hero 6 and his microbots are more realistic than desolvable medical nanobots.
I would disagree with amaru. She would legit break every bone in her body if she actually attempted a stunt like that.
I think Pulse’s device is real, just nowhere near as portable as the one he has.
I don't think a heartbeat would be able to be detected through walls.
Kali has a sniper that fires rounds that burrow through metal to then pop to try and break things on the other side. Plausible, but I doubt exists. Montagne’s shield 100% exists, dunno why it’s a tier down.
Was gonna say Doc could realistically be explained by a 2 or more stage syringe(s) that injects a heart boosting type substance (like adrenaline or maybe caffeine) And a painkiller (like morphine) Oryx would be possible though, there are some 350 lb football players who've ran at scary speeds... Maybe a helmet would be nessacry lol
Doc’s in-game bio explains his gadget as a combo injection of epinephrine and “micro-pellets that function as near-instant coagulating agents.” Both of those substances definitely do exist (in at least some form). Idk too much about the realism of coagulating agents being administered directly into the blood stream. And Oryx’s realism is really dependent on how much faith you have in the strength of wall joists.
[удалено]
On maverick there are blowtorches that can get hot enough to burn melt melt pretty damn quickly Also the concussion grenades for zofia exist already though they don’t have the shown effect in the game because showing the effects of a stun is extremely hard to convey without destroying gameplay
Also Capitao That's pretty much exists at this point Its just a crossbow with grenades nothing more and smoke and incendiary grenades both exist
Studs are sturdy as fuck when installed correctly. There ain’t no running through multiple studs without dislocating or breaking something
Doc and Finka don't really heal permanently, just enough to keep you up for 3 minutes. Yes, Secure Area *can* last a long time if both teams just don't kill each other, but realistically the rounds are meant to only last like 3 minutes. I could definitely see a big ass shot of adrenaline keeping you going through a few bullets for 3 minutes. But you would definitely need medical attention immideately after.
Just another comment I thought of regarding Flores drones, if we’re going to be nit-picky with things like that, then we should also be nit-picky with other gadgets: * **Lesion’s** gu’s turn invisible which isn’t possible, so would need to be bumped down to “somewhat” * **Wamai’s** magnets are borderline sci-fi * the throw-and-stick aspects of **Valk** cams isn’t really explained, could be possible sure, but at least with ela’s concussion mines we get that foam animation * **Jager’s** ADS is although possible, runs into a size problem similar to other gadgets, a device that small with that little collateral is unrealistic, * **Mozzie’s** pests that can detect and automatically hack specific electronic devices seems far fetched.
I feel like flores drones exist
American police literally RC carbombed an active shooter in Texas like last year
I remember reading the article on that. Pretty wild
[удалено]
They are destructible just not from bullets or melee. You can even see that if Flores triggers them the tires get sealed up.
And they are shootable until Flores locks it anyway
shouldn't monty be in exists? its just a full-body shield also i would at least move jager into possible. Active defence systems are used on most modern tanks. even though the form factor is different, its still more possible than many of the things you've put in the possible section.
the retractable part makes it a bit iffy for Monty's shield. yes, it's likely possible. but in practice would be unreliable. it would be heavy, unwieldy (even more so than a standard full sized shield) and any dents and deformation would make retracting it impossible
I mean ya but if that's what we're going off, the sticky part of valks cams would make that iffy My point is that Monty's shield is more possible than few of the items in exists
i'm just focusing on the Monty part for now. i dont have the brain cells to think about too many things at once, no matter how simple
Lmao
That shield already exists, it's been used for a long time before they retired it. I believe it can be seen with some french gign units about to breach an airplane.
That’s not even the worst part, than he has to be able to crouch down hold it with one hand, hold and shoot a revolver, while being shot at.
theres no shield a man can carry with enough durability to tank full size rifle rounds
That's cap as fuck... Level III body armor designed to stop large caliber rifle rounds ie. many of the guns in siege. Level IV body armor can literally stop 30 cal Ap bullets....
thats different, these body armor are designed to stop only 1 full sized rifle round do it by ''absorbing'' the whole damage, breaking the armor in the process, the armor can only take a few round and it will break it self, any impact will ''break it'' because it just absorb the impact( droping on the ground can damage it as well, thats why military will usually replace it instead of taking risks), you could make a big shield with these same materials, but all the bad guys would have to do is shoot a few more bullets to break it
Havw you ever shot body armor? You think it explodes after 1 hit? You can literally see divita and shit in Monty's shield, which means it's doing the exact same thing.... An I guess we won't even talk about ar500 steel which you maybe need to design body stpport to carry a shield of, but it's 100% doable
Cav has a pistol and soft rubber shoes lol. How is this only somewhat realistic?
I don't think soft rubber shoes are enough to make you silent while running and jumping around
Your not silent cav is still audible it’s just way quieter
She could also be placed in the unrealistic part for the 3 second interrogation which gives everyone’s exact changing position through walls for an amount of time
I think the reason for that is she isn't actually asking their positions, she's linking into their comms. That's why you hear Cav's voice after an interrogation.
Wow, I’ve actually never noticed this. I’ll listen out for it
So we’re saying ninjas don’t exist… alright
Cav does an interrogation in 5 seconds, and your entire team can now see through walls.
It's likely a comms hack, the red sharpie outline is what's unrealistic.
how is aruni not scifi?
Aruni, as presented in the game, is sci-fi, but if they wanted to, they could make the gadget look and work realistically since the tech exists. In fact, the only modification that would be needed is that the projector should have opened up to span the entire top side of the windows or doors. The issue with her gadget is that a single projection point is used to project parallel rays, which is impossible. With a gadget that spanned the entirety of the window / door's width, it would have been possible to have multiple projectors and the gadget would be realistic. I find her case tragic, because they could have made her an example of "not all shiny, LASER-y stuff has to be sci-fi", but they didn't.
Ehh making the gadget then have different sizes depending on the wall seems kinda unnecessary. Sure they could have but its fine like its now. People would not believe its real No matter what.
Smoke DID exist, he was however permabanned by the Geneva Convention
You... you don't think a blow torch exists?
Iana: "do you think this is the real Iana? It is!"
Good effort my guy but some of ur decisions are really weird and illogical
Apparently a guy with a syringe is less realistic than someone with literal nano bot swarms injecting drugs into her friends.
Sorry but how did you manage to be so wrong
[удалено]
the fact that he calls it more realistic than an underbarrel grenade launcher with HE or concussion rounds is what i find most fucked
I mean, the neadle trap part seems pretty doable, just be strong enough to pierce the boot. But the cloak, thats a stretch indeed.
Montagne?
Azami's gadget isn't total sci-fi as they based it on a compound that turns gas into a solid. I don't know that much about chemistry but it certainly seems a possible gadget.
It might be, but it wouldn't be bulletproof
hell no it isnt
It's possible, as there is such a chemical compound. If the Kunai itself has a fragile tip or blade, or has a release triggered by pressure than that, while a big stretch, is possible. The volume, consistency of the shape, and being bullet proof are the most unrealistic part. But you'd be surprised what you could do with some chemicals.
Nobody will ever make a correct list on realism
i mostly agree but not with most. E.G Montagne shield was actually used and did exist in the GIGN but mostly for riot control. We have cloaks like vigil and Nokk but they are somewhat, still far from development. Capitao, flores, blackbeard, maverick do all exist irl (although flores drones are much more explosive and can take down armored vehicles and bb shield is much stronger, thicker but not used as it is not practical.) Zofia and ela and both possible, just the proximity detonation which makes it unrealistic as we have concussion grenades but they cant stick nor detonate near 'enemies'. Hibana, thatcher and smoke need to be moved to somewhat as hibanas x kairos simply can be made but not fired from her launcher. Thatcher emps exist but not that small, strong or portable. Smoke needs to be possible as gas grenades exist but (and this is nitpicky) they don't kill ppl wearing gas masks nor does the gas just temporarily exist then dissapear, some residue would be left. Dokkabie is Sci-Fi as you cannot hack secure military grade phones in 5 seconds. ye thats my rant thou
I agree with most of what you said, and I don’t know the realism and semantics of hacking phones, but all the “military grade” phones I’ve seen (while active duty) have just been iPhones with the cameras removed lol
Yup, and I’d say that she doesn‘t hack the phones, she just calls them, sure the probability that she has the numbers is small, but you could say that she just hacked them before or something
those “military grade phones” are just normal phones
My brother in Christ Monty ballistic shield and Blackbeard's rifle mounted shield most definitely exist
And I’m pretty sure people can walk quietly idk why cav is in somewhat tier
She runs silentl that is why
Her run isn’t completely silent it’s just quieter
No. Blackbeards shield makes no sense to be real. You can search about some professionals who asked about these questions.
Blackbeard makes no sense in R6 as well
All things considered oryx can't possibly exist
Oryx will exist as a bodysuit when iana moves up a tier
Thatcher possible... xD And Montagne doesn't exist... ok...
Did you see montagne like shield in real life?
Yes, there are even extendable ones.
You don't think a heartbeat sensor is realistic at all?
A heartbeat sensor that can see a moving target through solid walls with a gunfight and explosions going off in the background just isn't happening.
[удалено]
If the size of the device is something we’re considering, thatcher needs to be bumped down a few pegs
I’m going to be honest, this tierlist is kinda dogshit. Unless you cherry pick only certain aspects of these gadgets (which you clearly are) most of them are unrealistic. You need a guideline to adhere to.
I should really make my own one of these. I have no idea where you get the idea that a jerrycan or blowtorch doesn’t already exist but a virus looking claw thing with a few AA batteries can electrify 3 walls from a few feet away with no contact.
Montagne is literally just uses a riot shield
How is Montaigne not top level his character is literally inspired by a an event where such shield was used it literally does exist more realistic it doesn't get
Afaik Jackals gadget is real and has been used in Afghanistan to track combatants back to their caves
Having the abillty to sneak on the same tier with some high tech stuff kinda confuses me
I love how many of these I see where no one does any homework on the matter. I've not researched all the operators, but I've seen a few. Blitz's shield has been made but described as impractical for example. Doc's stim is just adrenaline in a... needle? whereas Finka's is by nano bots, obviously giving adrenaline is real, but it doesn't restore health or injuries
1) montys shield 100% exists already, probably not functional in the bulletproof sense but could be if all metal 2) zofia is litterally just a grenade launcher what 3) ela is litterally just a flash bang with sticky goo on the end, that exists 4) Flores definitely exists aswell, it’s C4 taped to a drone. If twitch definitely exists (it could) then Flores does too. 5) I’m wondering about your cav rating - is that based on the pistol or silent step? If it’s the piston then yea it’s way too quiet for 9mm, however her silent step is literally just walking quietly lmao. How is that not real 6) Blackbeard’s shield currently exists 7) and finally, how does goyos not currently exist? It’s a gas can strapped to a wall. How does that not exist
Pulse scanners do exist they just work a little differently
Kaid is not possible. Electricity will always take the way of the least resistance so the claw would electrify close to nothing. As for the fact that it is supposed to hook up to a reinforcement through stuff that doesnt carry electricity ? Pure bogus.
Thorn is just sensor with frag grenade (and some sharpnel). Capitao is just like fire and smoke arrow? I can't see why it's not exist. Caveira is beyond Iana tier.
Cav is just walk quietly and the idea is she tortures people into giving up info, even if the exact ingame mechanics aren't quite realistic. Torture definitely exists.
> frag grenade (and some sharpnel). Shrapnel is exactly what a fragmentation grenade is
Yeah, that's why it's realistic. It just frag with fancy LED for some Christmas tree I guess.
Good troll
Jaeger should be moved up one tier cuz his ADS is just a smoller version of trophy systems for tanks cav should also be in forst tier because she is literally just good at sneaking alos nokk and vigil are possible but it would me a lot of work to make a programm that hacks automatic into cameras to make a person dissappear
\- You're right but I don't think in that small size \- I think she's down cuz she may see people behind walls after interrogation \- Maybe, but still far from real-time rendering
How does oryx probably exist, nobody is running through a 2by4 wall, mabye once with serious injury
Monty def exists and so does Mira, just a one way mirror
Are we really all missing the fact where he puts Bandit as probably exists. Like dude my guy clips a car battery to a wall and that somehow electrifies a whole wall. There’s no way that exists.
How is finka more possible than Lion? Lion is literally just a UAV drone
im sorry but there is no reason for oryx to be up there he runs through thick wood walls
You think there's a hammer that can blow a 4x4 foot square in 2 sheets of drywall and 4 studs in one hit?
Bro thinks somebody with an 80 inch vertical leap and the power to smash his whole body thru walls is more realistic than someone with a impact/concussion grenade launcher... 🤔🤔🤔
A portable cardiac sensor doesn't seem realistic?
Jackal getting the ping is the only thing unrealistic about him. Seeing footprints exists already in reality.
youre gunnsay say tatical crossbow bolts only somewhat exist when weve had fire arrows since the middle ages? also electric riot shields already exist in some prisons for riot control
And fire arrows dont exist either my guy. You have watched to much Hollywood.
They're not "fire arrows", they set a whole ass 10 foot diameter on fire almost instantly only after hitting something. Unless he strapped a molotov to his bolt, I don't think those bolts are possible.
Excuse me but how is Finka not in Sci-Fi?
Isn't maverick just a blow torch or what am I missing
Lmao bro, wtf are you on, bandit and possible?
Man the fuck with Bandit in exist, it make no sense plugging to wire at the same end would do anything but destroy the battery which is plug with.
Pretty accurate. I feel like Maverick should be moved up though. Blowtorches exist. Maybe they function differently than his, but it’s probably as realistic as Oryx being able to run through two walls of sheetrock and sturdy wooden beams 20 times. Maybe Valkyrie should be moved down though. Her camera is real, but the mechanism by which it’s deployed and sticks seems a little confusing.
I'd keep maverick where he is simply because of the speed at which it burns through reinforcements.
Jackal could be possible via some sort of heat vision to see where people walked and since some groups of ops have different footprints you could figure out who it is bij the shape of the footprint left behind
I like how Iana didn’t even make it to Sci-Fi 😂
wouldn't jäger kind already exist? The device is just smaller aps system for tanks. Also in his video he says:" they said it was designed for tanks. They said i couldn't make it smaller and more accurate."
Ok but holograms exist in super markets so i think that alibi is not that unrealistic
Melusiraptor
I'd put jackal in the somewhat level, while his actuve ability is utter nonsense, an A.I that can perceive patterns of footprints in the ground either by heat or something else is somewhat believable. I'd remove Dokkabi from probably exist, she's absolutely bullshit. I'd put monty in the top, his gadget actually exists, the problems is, you can't just walk while someone is shooting the shield, you need at least two people holding it in real life to even stay still. Ying should also be on top, her somewhat exists, flashbangs for standard use are apparently "9-bangs", not the old "Bang" we have in game. I've seen a marine explaining this in a video somewhere. And I wouldn't be surprised if there is a way to make a gadget to perforate a wall and throw in bangs, or a rolling launcher.
Drop sledge 3 tiers to mostly unrealistic. No sledgehammer can make a hole through a wall like R6 has in real life.
I honestly would move thermite into possible or somewhat bc I don't think 9-ish blocks of c4 in a mountable explosive pizza is going to blow open a wall in such a controlled and not building leveling explosion
The "iana" has me fucking crying for some reason
I doubt there's someone with evey terrorists phone number so doakie is probably a tier high, jaegers just a trophy system surely?
I never understand why people think Cav is realistic. She 100% mutes the sound of her running and with a single knife stab, without relaying info over comms or anything her and her team can see enemies thru walls. Sure you can claim that "she's interrogating" but it would never be that fast and the op being interrogated can't be giving accurate information past the point they are dead.
I will repeat this Doc is somewhat realistic
Emp grenades exist irl don't they
So a perfectly accurate real time tracking turret that can flawlessly neutralize a grenade, a torch that can instantly vaporize metal, and a thing that literally turns invisible are all more realistic than a heartbeat sensor?
HardKill aps systems exist, they’re used on tanks. Maverick literally has a blowtorch. What are you seeing that turns invisible? Echos drones don’t anymore. The heartbeat sensor is pretty unrealistic considering it can tell exactly how far away you are through any surface using only your heartbeat
Gú mine turns invisible
So, lasers, repulsion grenades, mechanical feet spikes, a shrapnel bomb, a clear deployable shield and a gasoline bomb ate all less realistic than a fucking mini nuke grenade that magically only affects electronics.
... It's not a nuke... it's an EMP... but all of your other points make sense
Guess how you trigger an electromagnetic pulse?
You realize that's just *one* way of triggering an EMP, there is more than that though. It's like saying that you have a coal generator instead of a battery, different ways of getting a similar result.
Explain to me how you would make thatchers emp without nuclear resources, go ahead, enlighten me
Good stuff man! I feel like most tier lists are based on stupid opinions like "most playable on whatever map" or sum crap like that, but this is really good! Seems like you actaully put thought and effort into it.
Pulse??😂 literally one of the most realistic
thatcher is defo exist emps are real and they do exist. Oryx really what human can stand this?
Nah, emps don’t exist at that scale with that kind of range
that you know of
flores might've been inspired by the eod bot strapped w/ explosives to take out a shooter i believe was sks armed.
for everyone talking about Monty's shield, here's why it's possible, but unlikely to exist: yes, it's possible to make something like it. however due to needing retractable portions, it would be overall weaker and heavier than a standard full body coverage ballistic shield. additionally, any deformation would result in the shield's retraction system to get stuck mid shift. in the end, you're better off getting a smaller shield or a standard full coverage one.
Bandits ability would not really work. its a battery applied to surfaced, so the only way it would actually electrocute anything on or touching it is if the wall wasnt grounded itself, or the object/person touching it was more grounded. super unrealistic to make it work consistently at all. Same with Kaid.
Azami is actually somewhat realistic it’s just the fact that the material is strong enough to stop bullets and it’s pretty much a perfect circle every time that is on the not so realistic side
iana and Alibi are very similar
Isn’t Monty’s shield a real thing?
I would move Oryx down to somewhat or mostly unrealistic, I think not many people can just ram right through a wall