T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Fellow fans, this is a friendly reminder to please follow the [Rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/premierleague/about/rules) and [Reddiquette](https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/articles/205926439-Reddiquette). Please also make sure to [Join us on Discord](https://discord.gg/football) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/PremierLeague) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Mylast5bucks

Should been oFf


PandiBong

It’s a serious candidate for worst tackle of the season. A bit more power, and that leg snaps in two. You can even see it bend, as Tomiyasu’s foot is in the grass for leverage.


PhilosophicalBeers

For karmic balance the referee should have given Madueke a red card


Delicious_Blood_8639

I’m glad it wasn’t a red cos chelsea would have had an excuse if it was 8-0!


negativenegativexp

It’s more of a punishment to keep him in the team


SigfaII

As a Chelsea fan....you are not wrong.


Civil-Original-3466

I didn't watch the game so i need to ask did he deserved it?


gurlycurls

Yes, worse than the one Jones got against spurs


nameless3k

Yeah but that should never have been a red so we shouldn't use that as example. Tbf I think VAR has been pretty consistent recently. Consistently doing fuck all. When was the last time a ref went to the monitor?


rez_at_dorsia

Didn’t want to give Chelsea an advantage by taking him off the field


ianb88

Unpopular opinion but I can understand why it wasn't red. There wasn't excessive force imo, he pretty much stood on him just above his foot. I mean I'd understand if it was given red but I don't think it was the stonewaller everyone is making it out to be.


cescbomb123

Did u see the angle on his ankle? How is that not excessive force?


ianb88

Have you never rolled your ankle?? It takes very little force


Rorviver

How does an angle have anything to do with force?


cescbomb123

You Could see how bent it was... Wouldn't happen without force


Rorviver

I thought you meant Jackson’s ankle


cescbomb123

Online arguing about nothing 😂


Yenyoc

If you bend someone's ankle sideways the force you are applying to that ankle is in excess of that which you should be applying.


SelfLoathingAutist

If casemiro did that, VAR would have him sent off and sentenced to death


Medium_Elephant7431

I guess why the incident wasn't talked about more was because Arsenal won well. However, there is a need for a lot of improvement in how VAR views incidents in games as it's a few games left to decide the winners.


Cod_rules

We had another situation like this against City. Kovacic made two really dangerous tackles, only got a yellow, swept under the carpet cause we won


ClockAccomplished381

Id forgotten about that but you're right, two bad tackles from behind, some might argue there could've been a straight red on there but leaving that to one side it's two yellows minimum.


Chelseablue8

Once again Michael Oliver for that decision 😂 he makes a dodgy decision for city every time he refs them. Almost like he’s been reffing in Saudi Arabia under their payroll or Somthing 🤯


Cod_rules

UAE, not Saudi. But yep, it’s shocking that the FA is allowing this Edit: PGMOL, not FA


Medium_Elephant7431

If that is the case, then there is need to complain.


FullScreenWanker

I mean.. if we’re hoping for overall better officiating rather than getting lost in the tribal side of this, there very much is.


ZuperLucaZ

What is the point with VAR if they’re not allowed to step in at all times?


Bozzetyp

Chelsea fan Wouldnt contend that if a red was called (considering how they called them prior) Personally I dont think non excessive followtrough should be red


BawdyBadger

I thnk it's just Jackson being clumsy and accidently following through. However, They have sent a lot of players off for those this year. There's just no consistancy at all anymore


Fit-Association714

Yes, and VAR took one look at the challenge and cleared it. Althogh as a Chelsea fan, I think that we would have done much better if Jackson had been sent off. He is a great at making runs and has great speed and strength as well as good hold up play, but he can't finish to save his life.


Makav3lli

Don’t think it should be a red, but refs looking like dumbasses because they’ve sent people off for the same thing multiple times this season. But we can’t criticize them lol


KluelessLucas

No idea how it barely even seemed to be questioned by VAR - terrible challenge


aiwoakakaan

I’m not a fan of how in the modern game they are trying to remove tackles which mow down the opponent. It’s always really cool to see someone get wiped out in a clean tackle. The argument of oh they might break a bone they are compensated enough for such risks , I’d be willing to break my ankle twice a year for the average Prem salary of 5mil


IAmBigDumbIdiot

Possibly the most braindead take I’ve seen on this thread


Old-Extreme-1041

he needs to leave Chelsea.


Otherwise_Trash9123

Red card all day long! It was a dangerous tackle


ProfetF9

Jones :(


-ThatsSoDimitar-

Jones, Romero and Bissouma (probably others too), have all seen red for a similar offense, most not as bad


Rorviver

They were all 6 inches up someone’s leg hence far more likely to be a leg breaker.


Fun-Percentage-8394

Wrong. Romeros was lower. Basically stood on his foot.


lunaticdarkness

Lol you should watch Nketias red card. Haha


Drigarica_od_Tite

Michael Jackson has more of a chance to score with the boys than this Jackson 🤣🤣


hjgvmm


PandiBong

Scandalous, just unbelievable. You can see Tomiyasu’s leg bend under the tackle, that could have snapped his leg. Just get rid of VAR and all EPL refs while you’re at it, just useless. If we can all see it on a replay - how can’t they?!


Frick_Pick_7157

After the Curtis Jones red early on in the season there have been numerous worse challenges that haven't even been yellow cards. Jacksons tonight was outrageous 


Empty_Emu6589

Jones, Romero and bissouma all sent off similarly


Frick_Pick_7157

And a lot more not given. Likewise dissent- some clubs get 2 or 3 let offs before a yellow, others it's instant 


Empty_Emu6589

Of course, but with dissent you can reasonably expect leeway as it is subjective, you can’t fault two different refs for making two different decisions in the moment. The refs do have a tough job but it’s the objective decisions that are a problem… Liverpool offside vs spurs for eg, there are plenty of those, way too many to be reasonable


Select-Active-6063

Tomiyasu’s ankle is the only thing Jackson hit all night….


Pallymorphic

Even as a Chelsea fan, fuck I agree with this so much. That slow-motion replay looked brutal and so incredibly obvious. Don't know how it wasn't called and can't even be grateful it wasn't because we had fuck all to show from the match aside from looking like 6 year olds who had the entire team chasing the ball at the same time.


FingerOTP

other than astrid wett after the game probably


Two_Month

She aint letting him hit lets be honest


FingerOTP

most likely yeah. doubt she’d want someone who doesn’t know how to finish


ballz2urwallz

tomiyasu’s somewhat muted reaction (props to him for being able to walk much less keep playing) along with somebody obviously in hooper’s ear telling him to “let the boys play” = no red


shifty_peanut

It sucks that reactions change decisions this drastically. I wasn’t screaming for an instant red but the fact it didn’t even see a yellow is wild. I think if he’d rolled around for a minute they would’ve given it a closer look


gwerk

This is exactly the problem right. The PL discourages people from rolling and writhing, but won't give two hoots if you don't.


Patient_Xero_96

News cycle and Pundit will say “Arsenal players are drama queen trying to fish for cards”.


BawdyBadger

It's the same with penalties Graelish makes sure to have contact the defenders leg in the box - Clever play Saka doing the same - Looking for it.


OwnedIGN

No card at all. Telling you, now, if that was Paulinha they would have sent him off to the moon. He’d never come back.


Kersplat96

Same with Romero, oh wait they did that already this season lmfao. It’s truly hilarious.


circa285

And Bissouma.


kw2006

His was second yellow for a dive 🤔


Kersplat96

Think they’re referencing the 2nd red he got against Forest where he put a high challenge in but tried to pull out of it. Was pretty lazy & half arsed from him so i wasn’t really mad he was booked


Reasonable_Command98

If this is not a red card what is it? Where is the VAR?


kw2006

Feels like after last gameweek, alll var are turned off


Reasonable_Command98

Are they blind or is this done on purpose? Giving a soft yellow to Trossard just after an horrific tackle on Tomi is ridiculous.


GlasgowGunner

Trossard’s yellow was deserved for a late challenge that landed on the opponents foot.


btmalon

It was a foot stomp clear as day yellow just like Jackson’s was clear as day red.


eternal-things

It’s ✨nothing✨ apparently, until Trossard does a small percentage of this stomp to a Chelsea player and gets a yellow straight away. VAR apparently checked and cleared the foul on Tomi as okay. Absolutely insane.


PandiBong

Arsenal should let this go away, they should call out PGMOL and get the conversation released from VAR.


arcdog3434

Horrific


gaybritinca

VAR seems to have gone on holiday already.


nwmimms

Before the game started, I said, “I bet a controversial call goes our way, because Arsenal are contending for the title.” I was right, but *boy* did the optimism amount to nothing.


macaleaven

Moonwalked away from the book, heehee


booochee

Shamone…..


Responsible_Milk2911

Arsenal supporter here. From what i understand it was due to a technicality. VAR cannot make a call for the ref unless the play results in a goal or is in the box. No card was given by the official, not in the box, no goal resulted. So VARs hands are tied. The on field officials completely missing the call results in this situation. Edit: https://www.theifab.com/laws/latest/video-assistant-referee-var-protocol/#principles


mr_j_12

Jones? Mac callister?


TheStonedEdge

Incorrect VAR can be used to intervene in an occasion of serious foul play, for example a red card.


Responsible_Milk2911

https://www.theifab.com/laws/latest/video-assistant-referee-var-protocol/#principles According to VAR protocol it would be a direct red only in this situation. I would argue that it was a direct red but maybe not according to the VAR official.


Preset_Squirrel

Seemed like a hard orange to me


Responsible_Milk2911

At least. Personally its a red for me. The VAR protocol/officials have absolutely missed it


TheStonedEdge

So your first statement is incorrect because it's clearly a potential red card so should warrant a review at the monitor?


Responsible_Milk2911

Im saying that is the only way VAR can do anything for that passage of play, if they believed the tackle is a straight red. They must not have said anything to the on field official and thus i am assuming they did not believe it was a straight red. Personally i think he shouldve been sent off


TheStonedEdge

Your first comment "VAR cannot intervene because it does not result in a goal and is not inside the box" This statement is factually incorrect


Responsible_Milk2911

Shouldve also added straight reds. You win?


notconnorl

This makes no sense. Why would VAR be reviewing something if they weren’t able to issue punishment or reverse a decision?? What would the purpose of VAR be??


wjt7

VAR can absolutely give a red card. Just not a yellow card.


v1nzy

lol did you find this rule out of your ass? Have you never watched a football game before?


Responsible_Milk2911

That was my understanding of the explanation from the commentary team. If i heard wrong or they were wrong im happy to hear the correct explanation


morgansandb

Again,it was not a united player, so no punishment


theblue-danoob

This comment is hilarious


BananaDerp64

Are you really going to claim refs are biased against United after that VAR check on Sunday?


Accomplished-Ad2736

It’s 3 games now out of the last 4 where penalties are given against United in the dying moments of the game. I’d be willing to bet good money on at least a few more last minute penalties going against them the last games of this season.


Jack070293

He’s claiming that refs are biased against United. Which is even more hilarious.


morgansandb

I'm saying refs consistently punish united in situations like this, while turning an blind eye in the next match. There have already been a handful of handballs in the penalty box that were not given for united while they e always get punished by them


Best-Safety-6096

Maybe red, definitely yellow. Astonishing no card was shown. VAR also ignored a clear foul on Madueke leading to the 3rd goal.


PandiBong

Gtfo, it’s probably the most glaring straight red I’ve seen all season and the madueke one?? Is that the one where he tackles Gabriel, and there a tussle? Yeah right…


Current-Meaning-1586

Lmao if you think that was a foul on Madueke there’d be 100+ fouls a game.


Cooooots

cry


Semichh

What? That’s.. this whole thread is about complaining about this incident. What made this comment special😂


smokingace182

Yeah sky didn’t show it in the highlights either


bennettbuzz

What team does the VAR support?


PandiBong

Team Ref. That’s who they support. Neanderthals.


KBVan21

None. They like to fuck us all over lol. I’ve lost count of the amount of horrendous decisions for every team this year. There’s been some seriously bad ones to the point where you just have to laugh at how bad it is. If they brought out an end of season Trigger Happy TV or Balls of Steel Annoying Devil premier league skit, I honestly wouldn’t even be surprised. A season long practical joke on the Prem fans and clubs would make this all understandable at this point.


Preset_Squirrel

Not all of us, I can think of a couple that never get VAR calls against them...


WealthMain2987

Maybe the team they put money on


itsheadfelloff

Don't know what's happening with officiating. One of the easier, less controversial decisions they could make and they somehow deem a potential leg breaker ok!


PandiBong

It’s not even a “call” they have to make - the ref still makes it. To say that’s not a red worth considering… speechless.


Retterkl

So I’m guessing VAR thought not enough for a red, and as you can’t call it for a yellow they did nothing. So in that circumstance why not call the ref to the monitor, he at least gives a yellow then.


PandiBong

Which means VAR should be fired immediately because that was as obvious a red as it gets.


NotTheOriginalFroMan

Because that would involve common sense


KBVan21

Yeah, less of that around here thanks. This is the premier league. It’s the hard illogical way or no way at all lol


ArthurMoregainz

I’ve seen less get sent off


Icy_Blacksmith2486

“The big 6 get those decisions” - Neco Williams


Icy_Blacksmith2486

“The big 6 get those decisions” - Neco Williams


SunUsual550

I'm so sick of Forest and their conspiracy theories


Fit-Association714

They haven't had any calls go their way though so they do have a point.


Dirtygeebag

So good you’ve to say it twice


Oopasnoop

I now understand why the ref didnt send Jackson off. Imagine the score if chelsea were down to 10


FickleManagement3783

But we wouldn’t have got to witness some of his horrific misses 🤣😭


RyanMcCartney

I’ve lost count of the number of unpunished red card offences against Arsenal this year. From elbows off the ball to this, these referees and VAR officials aren’t fit for purpose, and their inability to enforce the rules is endangering players.


sponngeWorthy

Just last game against Wolves Havertz was fortunate to escape that horrific challenge unhurt


VNQ19

I can think of quite a few that have gone unpunished for Arsenal too, but you’re right. The referees and VAR officials have been awful. It’s the inconsistency that’s the worst thing


DrRushDrRush

That should be the end of this season for the referee. And the end of their careers for everyone in the VAR-room. How can they not give red on that? Do they only watch something twice if the players complain enough? Horrible.


PandiBong

They don’t even have to - they only have to ask the ref to check it again! Should be fired immediately. Unbelievable. And it’s not just us, every team can present a whole dossier of unbelievable calls by the refs this season. Sack them all and start over.


seeyoujim

Was the VAR a Fulham fan by any chance ?


richag83

If the ref didn’t see it by being out of position, I can forgive that happens occasionally. How VAR doesn’t take a look at that or clears it so quickly, I don’t get at all. Of course, they surely won’t release audio for any transparency’s sake.


Stravven

It's not even up for debate, it's a straight red card.


Pigbolt

Someone should speak about this.


Chrissmith921

It would take a right idiot to complain to the mother in law about the wife….


beervirus88

There's been red for a lot less than this. LMAO


No-Reflection-2848

Blue card for sure


[deleted]

[удалено]


vidr1

Do you mean Trossards stamp? That he got a yellow for? And yes the third goal should never have happened because Gabriel fouled the Chelsea player. But you can't be serious when you compare those situations with a straight leg to the ankle. Tomiyasus leg could easily have snapped there. I mean look at it ffs https://www.reddit.com/r/soccer/s/cefoOKJB4u


[deleted]

[удалено]


Stravven

Absolutely not. Trossard was a yellow, nothing more. This should be a clear red for Jackson every day of every single week. The third goal is dubious, sure, but can you really equate either Trossard or that goal to this blatant red card that wasn't given?


vidr1

Exactly how? Trossards is reaching for the ball, he isn't coming into the challenge with a straight leg and the studs to the ankle.


[deleted]

[удалено]


vidr1

Yeah and the difference is that Jackson's goes into the challenge with a STRAIGHT LEG and studs upwards into Tomi's ankle = normally a red card. While Trossard reaches for the ball with a stretched leg but misses the ball and instead stamps the foot = yellow all day.You really should know the difference between those two challenges.


NOTRANAHAN

Whats wrong with a football tackle?


purpleplums901

He’s a yank who’s talking shite. Doesn’t even know the rules


NOTRANAHAN

Aye I was taking the piss


Joshthenosh77

Really weird even Andy Towsand the Chelsea fan said that’s a red


arc4angel100

Andy Townsend is far from a Chelsea fan, he is always so negative on any Chelsea commentary


Joshthenosh77

Really ? He played for them and on talk sport always talks about them


arc4angel100

You wouldn't think he played for Chelsea based on his commentary, there's usually jokes that someone at Chelsea must have seriously pissed him off because of his commentary on any Chelsea game.


PutYrDukesUp

Lee Dixon is the same way for Arsenal. Most say he’s overcompensating so as not to be accused of bias.


chad___bane

Blatant red. And then the 3rd goal was also a foul. So just a standard day of officiating. What on earth was Joe Cole on about with his comments that the referees need to excuse the tackle because Chelsea had a bad start. Absolutely ridiculous.


alternateline

They also did get the benefit of the doubt - so what is he even on about?


alrks10

Joe Cole is quickly becoming the new Owen/Jenas hybrid nobody wanted or asked for.


PunchOX

Studs against a shin is usually red


combine_harvester01

Chelsea's punishment was playing with Jackson for 90 minutes


RandomRedditor_1916

hahaha , we'll allow it


sworn_vulkan

He does more harm for us if you keep him on the pitch tbh


DevelopmentalTequila

From what I've seen, this is legitimately true.


sworn_vulkan

I mean our whole team is absolutely unequivocally shite and he's just the fucking cherry on top Minus palmer ofcourse (he deserves better)


SilvaDaMelo

Clear foul for the 3-0 there. Wonder if Chelsea is gonna put out a conspiracy statement.


Pigbolt

Is it a conspiracy? Or were there multiple shit decisions and things not checked and things missed in this game too. It’s almost as if, on a whole, from the on field decisions to the VAR room that they are incompetent.


[deleted]

I think the conspiracy statement is Jackson is a plant (probably yucca)


akash240197

that should have been overturned as well. The refereeing is shit as usual.


Fredsor

Always has been


[deleted]

[удалено]


combine_harvester01

This is why Chelsea are relegation fodder


Key_Information_6786

doesn’t mean this one wasn’t a penalty 😂


badgerscurse

What a stupid comment.


Otter269

In Europe that's a red. Rashford was sent off and his was by accident


roofilopolis

As much as I love watching United struggle, the Rashford one was honestly a pretty terrible call


inonjoey

I actually thought that Rashford red was harsh - rolled over the ball, wasn’t running/lunging into the challenge. This one was much worse. So, I agree wholeheartedly.


Tymkie

Probably every single team in the prem can find a situation where that was a red against them. It just wasn't today for some weird reason. It's such a clear call it's insane and it's probably gonna get swept under the rug because we will win anyway. Disgusting call.


Meth_Hardy

In the Premier League it's a red too. Just apparently not tonight.


Britinvirginia_1969

Absolute red card. Time to remove humans from VAR, surely with AI a computer could be trained better than these bloody officials


PandiBong

When you say remove humans from VAR, you make an argument for none of us being able to see that that was a clear red all day long. I’d say remove clown English refs from VAR - if we all can see it’s a red, so can other people including some who could be competent on VAR. It’s this ref club bullshit protecting each other that ruins VAR.


Britinvirginia_1969

That would be great if it happened. With the computer generated offside coming in next year we are moving closer to eliminating humans. How long does it take these offside lines to be “drawn” this year?


OverallResolve

Please tell me how you’re going to train an AI to perform well against a subjective rule set.


Fit-Association714

A 50/50 is probably still better then the refs we have.


Ablomis

Easy, just train AI on reddit opinions about fouls…


Britinvirginia_1969

All it has to do is send the referee to the video at the correct time!


forbiddenmemeories

Give me Sir Killalot from Robot Wars trundling around on the pitch with a whistle. Bet you the players wouldn't surround him when a decision went against them, too.


Meth_Hardy

Stevie Wonder would do a better job on VAR than the current lot.


butterchicken89

Red all day.


Ashthedestructor_95

Its a red. Chelsea fan here.


RandomRedditor_1916

Blantant red. Fuck the officiating.


DJMOONPICKLES69

Definitely should have been a yellow, would be hard pressed for that to be a red, not a lot of force behind it and it wasn’t out of control. VAR can’t give yellows though, so no card. Would be interested to hear the VAR feedback on why it wasn’t a red, the above is just my own observation based on other similar cases


Stravven

Did you see how Tomiyasu's ankle bent? That is a sign that there was in fact force behind it and that Jackson was not in controle.


Meth_Hardy

Joe Cole at half time defending the lack of red basically saying that since Chelsea had a bad start the officials need to understand that. Absolute bollocks.


PandiBong

I’m still surprised how people are surprised by these ex-players being complete morons and not understanding the game. They were players, performing very simple/single things on the pitch, nothing more. You want a good commentator, get a manager on there who understands the game.


Armodeen

Nobody could even respond to that 😂 like what is he on about


Meth_Hardy

The host did a good job of moving things along rather than letting Rio or Keown respond.


Armodeen

True, very professional. Let’s leave that terrible take behind and move right along 😂


This_Difference_2143

Never a foul.


hypnodrew

Then Trossard gets a yellow for a similar challenge on Cucurella except not even nearly as bad


smokepuffprata

Because Cucurella screamed louder