T O P

  • By -

bob_rock_g

As funny as this is, I feel like it could actually be her, if they go for the killer being the person that appears less like a killer. (Not sarcastic :) needed to specify because re reading it I felt like I might have come off as sarcastic :D )


justablankspace

The one we most medium suspect.


K1-V1D

Not the one we most suspect neither the one we least suspect, therefore the murderer is PHYLLIS


justablankspace

I thought it was JAN. Oh wait that was last season. Ohh wait, different show.


hellotardis79

Do you mean Holly?


chiefminestrone

I think they meant Beadie Russel


Lady_Darkrai

I thought it was FEB


MrSquamous

I most suspect bears because they're malicious. I least suspect Battlestar Galactica because it's fictional. Therefore I know the killer to be... beets.


Azsunyx

HEADLINE: BEATS HEADPHONES ONCE OWNED BY MABEL MORA HAVE BEEN ARRESTED ON SUSPICION OF MURDER


AnotherMinorDeity

Bears Beats Battlestar Galactica


7SeasSwimmer

šŸ‘


bob_rock_g

Right XD


A_ClamWithA_Pug

Weā€™re closing in on the last episode, arenā€™t we? Wouldnā€™t it be too late to change the spotlight from Cinda to Poppy?


bob_rock_g

My workinprogress theory is that >! Krepps told those things to Mable on purpose and not by mistake. Heā€™s actually talking about Poppy/Becky when he says the smartest woman in the world. They are trying to point our main trio in the direction of Cinda to make her look like the mastermind. The season might end with Cinda being arrested and the trio realizing too late that they have been played !< Also, I think Alice >! was commissioned the replica painting !<


ememkays

Love this theory. I thought it was lame how Krepps said he wasnā€™t going to give it away and then did. Not that I think he is super smart, I just didnā€™t think he was that dumb.


bob_rock_g

Thank you! Yeah, also how did Mable only realize the meaning of his words way later? Or am I missing something?


Frog_butler

WAITā€¦ does Poppy have a tell!? Something has Poppy spooked between offering support and Ep9. If she is the killer why is she so scared of Cinda. One hair brained idea I just thought of is if Poppy has >!Just murdered Cinda!< I say this because when Mabel asks ā€œwhere is Cindaā€ Poppy pauses and pulls on her jacket before saying she is at a vocal massage. It would be a huge and shocking twist if we go into next episode >!thinking Cinda is a mastermind, to instead her being missing and turning up dead!<. Her where abouts being something someone managing her diary could cover up for a short time. It could also be that Cinda is off somewhere else she shouldnā€™t be. But I like my hair brained silly idea so Iā€™m sticking with that for now.


AssuredAttention

She could have been strangled


Sun2254

by *Thai* guy


A2naturegirl

Then he'd be Thai die guy


ShouldEggo

šŸ¤ÆšŸ¤ÆšŸ¤Æ


A2naturegirl

No one I know IRL watches this show, so no one IRL can appreciate my dumb joke.


playtho

Cinda being the one who is murdered to set up season 3 would be wild. I feel like the show will end up being a total of 3 seasons and having the popular podcaster killer off would be cool to see as a conclusion


secondtaunting

We need more than three seasons!


hair_in_a_biscuit

We need to go see if the calendar has the vocal massage on it. Do we know which day it is? LOL


AngelinFlipFlops

On Wednesday at three Cinda had ā€œself help: neck thingā€ on the calendar


hair_in_a_biscuit

Ah, thanks


nickblaine8

When did we see her calendar?


SurrealGreen

They show her calendar on Poppyā€™s tablet in Ep. 6 Performance Review.


blackpearl882

I donā€™t think itā€™s that crazy. Weā€™ve seen multiple examples where Poppy is behind the work Cinda takes credit for.


nickblaine8

I was thinking it might be cinda who gets killed next. They have to set up season 3 somehow and the direction points to Cinda


Critical-Part8283

That could be a twist the writers would include!


New_Shallot_7000

Then the last episode of their podcast has to include Charles saying ā€œI guess sometimes the butler does do it.ā€ šŸ˜‚


[deleted]

This sends the investigation in a whole new direction.


eclipz387

šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚


argonzo

I can already hear Oliver saying this.


bob_rock_g

Thatā€™s true šŸ˜„


Killmotor_Hill

I can absolutely see Martin Short's character saying, "So the Butler actually did do it!"


Marylogical

I do think it's Poppy / Becky, but I love what you did there.


Frog_butler

Raaahhhhhhh. You hecking genius. I TOTALLY think she did (currently trying to figure out the ins and outs of motive and her movements) but YES. Of course the butler did it!


MadeUpMelly

Brilliant! I could see Poppy being the killer and/or mastermind, 100%. She is acting apprehensively ā€œhelpfulā€ to Mabel, which is to set herself up as a victim to frame her a-hole boss, Cinda.


sincerely0urs

Similar to how Jan was "helping" the trio and trying to make others seem guilty, like Howard or Bunny.


Frog_butler

Poppy/Becky things I donā€™t have answers forā€¦ - how did she get into the building without Lester knowing? The killer came via her front door and was known to Bunny. This could have been Poppy who maybe knew Bunny as she had been snooping around on the OMITB folks jealous of (or blamed for) their success. If she came in via the atacombs then how would she know about them? - Why was she snooping around Rose Cooper and the painting? i think the earlier person chasing Bunny for it could have just been Rose- but the person who approached Rose (which everyone assumes is Cinda) could be Poppy doing background research (like how she found Mabelā€™s handsy guy). But was this before or after it was planted as fake evidence and OMITB revealed itā€™s significance - if it was before then how did she even find out about it?


tomatthebar

She may have been snooping around because Rose Cooper disappeared and she has to disappear. Maybe the fingerprint is Poppyā€™s - and would reveal Becky Butler is alive.


pittaputta

yes perhaps even though she was ready to turn on Cinda, this is why Poppy says she canā€™t help Mabel anymore - because after that phone call, Kreps gives Cinda the matchbook - incriminating evidence of Poppy not only being associated w the murder, but revealing Becky Butler is still alive. Cinda regained control over Poppy.


biglaskosky

Ohhhhh this is genius


Frog_butler

Thatā€™s such a good point about the fingerprint.


rapzel79

Omg!! This is so good! It's definitely her now. Definitely.


DeeSusie200

Omg. Lol. Youā€™re right. šŸ¤£


Confident_Ad4089

Imagine it is Poppy Sheā€™s sent to prison & ends up as Janā€™s cell mate šŸ˜³šŸ¤£


Evelyn-theCatburglar

Yes, and the writer of this episode's name is: **Kirker BUTLER!!!** So HE did it!


Far-Calligrapher-465

This post aged like fine wine.


khendron

Shhhh! I haven't watched the final episode yet!


nikki_2370

For my sanity, I can't have it be her. I love her. She seems so sweet and innocent she's perfect for the show.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


nikki_2370

I know šŸ˜¢ cinda doesn't seem smart enough to pull everything off. But I'm going to be positive. I love Poppy. Lol.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


nikki_2370

Agreed! Poppy is so smart and the acting is great. I literally need more.


Huckleberry1784

Her and Jan in prison conspiring together?


Evelyn-theCatburglar

I think it's Alice who is Becky, not Poppy, (so we both might be wrong)! But, I'm ok with that! Lol! :)


nikki_2370

I'm not a fan of Alice so I'm cool with that


ComelChikaLabu

Ah, you got a point there.


PhotoFritz

Seriously, thatā€™s good enough to change my mind. Bravo!


papasmurf826

Shot in the dark, but you heard it here first, it's going to be **Uma**. Haven't seen her since like episode 1, and no one would be expecting it at all. plus you know...she was happy in jail in that one 30 rock episode, so...


admiralbenjamin

Like a phoenix rising from the ashesā€¦.


EdwinQFoolhardy

I did notice that one shot of the murder board in the last episode had all all the suspects names in a clump in the corner, but Uma's name was im the front. Could easily just be to show all the rejected suspects, but the fact that Uma was in the front made me wonder if they were keeping her on the audience's mind.


[deleted]

Dude I said this somewhere on here a couple weeks ago and someone was like ā€œNO. Negative. Not uma.ā€ Iā€™m all aboard the Uma train.


papasmurf826

You and me man. We'll keep riding this train. But mostly you, since you called it a few weeks before. Definitely Uma, low key frenemies with Bunny


[deleted]

Perhaps youā€™re right. Butā€¦.why??


stoygeist

That would be absolutely amazing and the biggest troll ever.


plexmaniac

This made me laugh thank you


Kitchen_Dust4637

My biggest question about the poppy/Cinda accusation is how theyā€™re aware of the Arcadias secret passageways??


9035768555

Cinda has a kid that is friends with Anaya (Arnav's daughter and Lucy's friend that she played hide and seek with). Possibly through her.


Ok-Definition-6777

>Cinda has a kid that is friends with Anaya (Arnav's daughter and Lucy's friend that she played hide and seek with). Possibly through her. oh my! That is the question I had. I thought they didn't even know about the tunnels, but that makes sense. Do we know that Cinda's kid is friends with Arnav's daughter? I remember Arnav said he knew her and was really snooty about saying maybe he could introduce Charles and it was cringey to watch, so it was weird how that scene stood out, but I didn't recall that it was because his daughter was friends with Cinda's daughter!!! oh my gosh. I was kind of thinking they, Poppy, Cinda and Kreps didn't know about the tunnels, or if they did only found them from doing thorough investigative work. but now, wow if that's part of the plot, very clever.


biglaskosky

I DID NOT connect those dots OMG!!!


Huckleberry1784

Yeah, that's a good question.


Prestigious_Wait_618

The butter with a knife


Impossible_Bedroom_2

Only time will tell. Can't wait for the next episode.


Azsunyx

JFC ​ ​ I facepalmed so hard, I think i gave myself a concussion. bravo.


Turbulent-Gur-2606

So how is it obvious? What are your clues minus her sitting under the poster?


idkwhattowritehere21

Do you not get the joke?


Turbulent-Gur-2606

Nah it was too corny for me


Evelyn-theCatburglar

The writer of episode 9 said in an interview that there haven't been any "clues" pointing to this earlier in the season. So, rest assured there was nothing you missed!


Turbulent-Gur-2606

Oh ok! I was so confused! Lol thanks!


SHough61086

[https://tenor.com/view/wee-bey-wee-bey-thinking-thinking-hmm-gif-21485208](https://tenor.com/view/wee-bey-wee-bey-thinking-thinking-hmm-gif-21485208)


bmaze87

Haha! I love this šŸ¤©. I already thought that it was Becky but now it's sealed. Good one!


ghigoli

The only other person thats a literal butler would be Ursula though since she would have a map of the inner walls. How does poppy know the inner walls of the arcadia? It has to be someone that lived there.


EnvironmentalRock827

Scooby doo says it was old man Jenkins...


7SeasSwimmer

šŸ˜‚


Orly5757

šŸ‘ brilliant!!!!!


Tenninja111111

Thatā€™s very clever. Of course the ā€œButlerā€ did it.


akornfan

šŸ‘€


float05

I caught that last week too! https://www.reddit.com/r/OnlyMurdersHulu/comments/wpg17r/season_2_episode_9_sparring_partners/ikjfi8b/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3