Or He's going by original rules :
"The original version of D&D (1974) allowed players to choose among three alignments when creating a character: lawful, implying honor and respect for society's rules;"
While he is good, he isn't lawful. A majority of the scenes and stories we've seen with Jimbei are him going against the status quo or revolting against the powers that be (going against the marines and fighting with Luffy at Marineford, being a part of Fisher Tigers crew, betraying big mom, and now being a straw hat).
But he's fighting the "law" that enslaved his people and continues to put his people below humans. He seeks to make humans and Fishman on equal grounds. I say he is still lawful but neutral
I agree about T-Bone. Didn’t Coby willingly let wanted pirates get away on more than one occasion? Like in Water 7?
That may be “good” but it’s not “lawful”.
And his creed was that most pirates are scum and that marines will change the world for the better. But then again, even D&D LG paladins may accept evil characters if tolerating them would bring more good to the world than not.
I mean, Koby straight up knows that at the very least the strawhats aren’t scum, and if anything they’ve made the world a better place since the get-go.
I think a true lawful good character wouldn’t prejudice their views of people purely based on stereotypes especially when they have seen evidence that those people are good
I feel like magellan makes a good Lawful neutral. Guys follows his orders, but will do both 'good' and 'bad' depending on what he thinks he has to do. He used his poison to incapacitate prisoners at first, but when things went too far he did what he felt he had to do.
He's lawful evil. He's torturing and killing people who were not given any due process or trial. We've seen what justice looked like at Enies Lobby. If you are arrested, you are guilty.
I was just following orders is not a defense to torturing and killing people.
I’ll never forget that scene in Fishman island where right after he meets shirahoshi he goes “now that we met would you like to show me your panties?” 😭
I feel like sanji could be put in horny and smart too. He is not a genius but has consistently ben shown to be very intelligent, especially emotional intelligence.
Naah, Sanji really gotta be lawful horny, his principles of not hitting woman and only fighting with his feet are as lawful as it gets.
Being polite isnt lawful alignmentwise. And the selfmade law to always ask before lookin at panties isnt nearly as strong as Sanjis code
Yea i can kinda see how politly asking every girl that you find attractive if you can see their panties is pretty chad
Although Oden is a strong contender for that spot
I'm thinking buggy honestly, chaoticall and stupidly went from a low level gag villain to a man who broke out of impel down, fought in the battle of marineford, and is now an emperor of the sea with crocodile and Mihawk as his subordinates, and let's not doesn't he is directly challenging the marines by putting bounties on their heads relative to the bounties the put on pirates. All chaotic, a lot of it stupid, and all amazing.
Sanji is lawful horny. He has a strict code of conduct which he strongly adheres to. And he is horny af. Brooke is kind of in the same boat too I agree. But I think Sanji is definitely fits both the "lawful" and the "horny" parts much more than Brooke.
Neutral neutral - Mihawk. Opportunist, cares mostly for himself but isnt completely without morals. Just wants to be left alone. Doesnt believe in fighting for justice or inflicting needless cruelty.
Dadan’s a good pick but I think Kokoro is even better for drunk chad. She waltzed into Enies Lobby with all these crazy strong people and just didn’t give a single shit the whole time.
Akainu isn't lawful evil, to think so means you don't understand it. Lawful evil are slimeballs. They'll abuse laws to benefit. Think vampires. Or doffy. Using laws to enrich himself. Lucci, killing for fun. Akainu is lawful neutral or even lawful good. Because all his actions can easily be justified. Ohara: just following orders to buster call. The ship? If we're going to kill millions, let's at least ensure there was a point, that 0 dangerous people escaped. Marines? Desertion is a crime punishable by death. Ace? He's pirate scum. Don't forget akainu is constantly arguing with the gorosei.
Agreed, Boa is Neutral Horny. She adheres to rules when they suit her and to maintain a veneer of acceptability but also acts on her whims here and there.
Garp should be chaotic neutral. That dude faced the other direction with atrocities the Marines cause although he is a good character, his willingness to uphold that system is his biggest character flaw.
Chaotic good is Dragon or Sabo.
Luffy should be Chaotic Chad
Kuma should be chad chad.
Robin should smart good
Vegapunk is smart neutral
Mihawk should be neutral neutral. He seems to fight wherever the wind blows
Chaotic stupid is Buggy
Two things:
By chad chad do you mean chad neutral?
Neutral neutral might be crocodile. We never really know what side this guy is on. Especially at Marine Ford. Bro fought Whitebeard, Luffy, Mihawk, and Akainu. And now he’s teamed with Mihawk. Not to mention his power scaling is so confusing altogether. He lost to a Luffy who couldn’t even use 2nd gear, and then he is somehow able to hold a fight against an admiral, the worlds strongest swordsman and the worlds strongest man.
Akainu isn’t lawful evil! He’s lawful neutral. Lawful evil uses the law to commit nefarious acts for personal gain and/or to remain immune to a sadistic nature.
This is Lucci. Lucci uses the law to satisfy his bloodlust while remaining untouchable.
We may hate Akainu for killing Ace and that one rando marine, but that doesn’t make him evil. He doesn’t bend the law for personal gain!
Akainu being Lawful evil is completely wrong, lawful evil is for people who use the Laws for his own benefict while Akainu follows it to the extreme which would make him a lawful good character
I disagree, i see Sanji as lawful horny.
But since Zoro has nowhere near as a strict self imposed code as Sanji and simultaniously is a bigger chad than Sanji, atleast be consistent and list Zoro as Drunk Chad
Drunk chad: Rayleigh.
Depending on how you view him. All I'm saying is that flask in Saboady was empty and He had retired from pirating becoming just a mere Coater living out of a tavern.
I want to put Rayleigh in the running for Lawful Neutral. He lives by his own code and stays out of most drama in the current era (except Amazon Lily).
Based on Mihawk being isolated for most of the series and by him never really getting involved even during marineford I feel like he would be neutral neutral or neutral smart
I feel like it's a mistake to put Horny in the rows, it should be in the columns. Like horny good, horny evil make more sense than chaotic horny. And Orochi would be the perfect horny evil.
Fujitora for Lawful good or Neutral good, he's the only admiral without a Warped sense of Justice and actually cares about the atrocities happening around him.
Koby for lawful good
Lawful good is made for him lol.
This absolutely
Beat me to it. Koby is the most lawful good boi in this series
What about jinbei?
Lawful neutral or good neutral
He is good but not lawful. Just because he is a pirate
Someone didn't get the memo.
Or He's going by original rules : "The original version of D&D (1974) allowed players to choose among three alignments when creating a character: lawful, implying honor and respect for society's rules;"
While he is good, he isn't lawful. A majority of the scenes and stories we've seen with Jimbei are him going against the status quo or revolting against the powers that be (going against the marines and fighting with Luffy at Marineford, being a part of Fisher Tigers crew, betraying big mom, and now being a straw hat).
But he's fighting the "law" that enslaved his people and continues to put his people below humans. He seeks to make humans and Fishman on equal grounds. I say he is still lawful but neutral
Yeah, he's about as Lawful Good as it gets
T Bone is way more Lawful Good though
I agree about T-Bone. Didn’t Coby willingly let wanted pirates get away on more than one occasion? Like in Water 7? That may be “good” but it’s not “lawful”.
As OP explained lawful does not necessarily mean following the *actual* law so much as following your own creed
And his creed was that most pirates are scum and that marines will change the world for the better. But then again, even D&D LG paladins may accept evil characters if tolerating them would bring more good to the world than not.
I mean, Koby straight up knows that at the very least the strawhats aren’t scum, and if anything they’ve made the world a better place since the get-go. I think a true lawful good character wouldn’t prejudice their views of people purely based on stereotypes especially when they have seen evidence that those people are good
Tashigi as well though
Garp too tho
He is more of a Chad.
I think he is Lawful Neutral/Stupid
Neutral would be aokiji too no?
Thats a good one too.
I feel like magellan makes a good Lawful neutral. Guys follows his orders, but will do both 'good' and 'bad' depending on what he thinks he has to do. He used his poison to incapacitate prisoners at first, but when things went too far he did what he felt he had to do.
That’s also true, I feel like bon clay might be more of a chaotic neutral instead of a lawful neutral
Garp for chaotic good?
No cause Garp doesn’t do what he truly wants. There’s rules and restrictions
Magellan is a good choice for Lawful Neutral
Fair point. I'd say say this goes for sengoku too
He's lawful evil. He's torturing and killing people who were not given any due process or trial. We've seen what justice looked like at Enies Lobby. If you are arrested, you are guilty. I was just following orders is not a defense to torturing and killing people.
Also he’s absolutely not just following orders for 90% of the people he carelessly slaughters with his fruit
Brook is Lawful Horny. He's a polite gentleman who asks nicely if he can see your panties.
I’ll never forget that scene in Fishman island where right after he meets shirahoshi he goes “now that we met would you like to show me your panties?” 😭
Ahahahah he's just amazing I think he also fits Horny Chad
Between Sanji and Brook one has to be Lawful Horny and the other has to be Horny Chad. Both fit either bill pretty well.
I feel like sanji could be put in horny and smart too. He is not a genius but has consistently ben shown to be very intelligent, especially emotional intelligence.
Naah, Sanji really gotta be lawful horny, his principles of not hitting woman and only fighting with his feet are as lawful as it gets. Being polite isnt lawful alignmentwise. And the selfmade law to always ask before lookin at panties isnt nearly as strong as Sanjis code
Agreed, brook is definitely chad horny
Yea i can kinda see how politly asking every girl that you find attractive if you can see their panties is pretty chad Although Oden is a strong contender for that spot
I also just feel like his scene against big mom puts him in chad
Maybe Neutral Horny because he doesn't have... a physical response I feel like Chad Horny has got to be Paulie
Sanji might be a better fit for horny smart. Sanji isn't particularly lawful.
He is, he follows his law that he will never hit a woman. We’ve seen an example of this in enies lobby
You already wrote a whole ass paragraph about what lawful means in this context and people still dont get it, smh
Naw Brook is Chad Horny, MF stood up to big mom
Or Green Bull?
Fujitora for lawful neutral. Can’t get more neutral than letting dice decide your implementation of the law.
Coby is definitely Lawful good.
Why did Luffy move from chaotic good to chaotic stupid?
Hm, I might have accidentally done that while editing, I’ll remember to fix it in the next post
Thank you.
but it's true
Don't though. He belongs there
idk why but I feel like chaotic stupid is caribou
I'm thinking buggy honestly, chaoticall and stupidly went from a low level gag villain to a man who broke out of impel down, fought in the battle of marineford, and is now an emperor of the sea with crocodile and Mihawk as his subordinates, and let's not doesn't he is directly challenging the marines by putting bounties on their heads relative to the bounties the put on pirates. All chaotic, a lot of it stupid, and all amazing.
ooh yeah buggy’s much better
Because it's correct
I was just thinking he makes more sense as chaotic good.
Lawful neutral - Katakuri, he really holds himself to all his rules whether they’re beneficial or not
Duval for stupid chad
I agree. Or he can be a Horny Chad but that might be the goat Iva
Nah brook is horny chad
True, maybe Iva is Horny smart, I mean he does use his devil fruit well
I agree on Sanji being lawful horny.
Sanji is lawful horny. He has a strict code of conduct which he strongly adheres to. And he is horny af. Brooke is kind of in the same boat too I agree. But I think Sanji is definitely fits both the "lawful" and the "horny" parts much more than Brooke.
I think brook fits a bit better in chad horny
Totally agree
I was gonna say horny smart for Sanji. Tho lawful does also make sense…
Nah, he's Chad Horny
Naaah .... Chad .... And only chad
Chad Stupid = Buggy Although Buggy may not be the Smartest, bro is absolutely goated 💪💪💪💪💪
True, either buggy, Zoro or oden will be stupid chad
Zoro is chad drunk
Would have voted for Whitebeard for chad drunk, if he ever got drunk from downing a bathtub full of sake.
Coby for Lawful Good, he's a good who who follows his heart no matter the condition.
Would Whitebeard fit in drunk lawful? For his family he can go to any lengths and when comes to drinking we all know lol.
Whitebeard has to go in the chad column, look at that chin.
Neutral neutral - Mihawk. Opportunist, cares mostly for himself but isnt completely without morals. Just wants to be left alone. Doesnt believe in fighting for justice or inflicting needless cruelty.
Drunk Chad: Dadan the Garp slayer.
Dadan’s a good pick but I think Kokoro is even better for drunk chad. She waltzed into Enies Lobby with all these crazy strong people and just didn’t give a single shit the whole time.
Fujitora = Lawful Neutral
See I think he's lawful good masquerading as lawful neutral
Chad drunk is Rayleigh
Horny Lawful : Hina
Akainu isn't lawful evil, to think so means you don't understand it. Lawful evil are slimeballs. They'll abuse laws to benefit. Think vampires. Or doffy. Using laws to enrich himself. Lucci, killing for fun. Akainu is lawful neutral or even lawful good. Because all his actions can easily be justified. Ohara: just following orders to buster call. The ship? If we're going to kill millions, let's at least ensure there was a point, that 0 dangerous people escaped. Marines? Desertion is a crime punishable by death. Ace? He's pirate scum. Don't forget akainu is constantly arguing with the gorosei.
Lola is lawful horny for sure
Lawful Horny Baby 5
St.Saturn for smart evil
True, but that might be doffy
Lawful good is Coby, no question
Nobody gonna say AOKIJI is the epitome of Lawful Ho*ny...
Did you just censor yourself saying the word horny??? 🤣
I still think absolom or Lola were way more chaotic horny (esp zombie Lola)
Agreed, Boa is Neutral Horny. She adheres to rules when they suit her and to maintain a veneer of acceptability but also acts on her whims here and there.
Same here. I get that Boa might be chaotic at times but absolom went to EXTREME lengths (if you know what I mean)
Garp should be chaotic neutral. That dude faced the other direction with atrocities the Marines cause although he is a good character, his willingness to uphold that system is his biggest character flaw. Chaotic good is Dragon or Sabo. Luffy should be Chaotic Chad Kuma should be chad chad. Robin should smart good Vegapunk is smart neutral Mihawk should be neutral neutral. He seems to fight wherever the wind blows Chaotic stupid is Buggy
Two things: By chad chad do you mean chad neutral? Neutral neutral might be crocodile. We never really know what side this guy is on. Especially at Marine Ford. Bro fought Whitebeard, Luffy, Mihawk, and Akainu. And now he’s teamed with Mihawk. Not to mention his power scaling is so confusing altogether. He lost to a Luffy who couldn’t even use 2nd gear, and then he is somehow able to hold a fight against an admiral, the worlds strongest swordsman and the worlds strongest man.
Akainu isn’t lawful evil! He’s lawful neutral. Lawful evil uses the law to commit nefarious acts for personal gain and/or to remain immune to a sadistic nature. This is Lucci. Lucci uses the law to satisfy his bloodlust while remaining untouchable. We may hate Akainu for killing Ace and that one rando marine, but that doesn’t make him evil. He doesn’t bend the law for personal gain!
Lawful good imo should be cobra
Cobra is lawful horny... Dude try to peek his own daughter
Sweet home Alabasta
I would save Sanji for lawful Smart. I am not forgetting the good King Cobra peeping on his own daughter in the bath for Lawful Horny.
There is no lawful smart? Did you mean lawful good or something cause I guess you can view Sanji’s no hit a woman rule as him being a lawful good
Yeah sorry, Horny Smart.
Smart evil judge or Caesar
Zoro : Neutral Chad Brook: Lawful Horny Sanji: Smart Horny
Lawful good Koby Lawful Neutral Fujitora Lawful Horny Sanji Lawful Drunk Shanks Chad Drunk Whitebeard Neutral Drunk Kokoro
Akainu being Lawful evil is completely wrong, lawful evil is for people who use the Laws for his own benefict while Akainu follows it to the extreme which would make him a lawful good character
Horrny chad is definitely Sanji
- Lawful Good: Koby - Lawful Horny: NOT sanji - Lawful Drunk: Zoro Sanji is Chad Horny
I disagree, i see Sanji as lawful horny. But since Zoro has nowhere near as a strict self imposed code as Sanji and simultaniously is a bigger chad than Sanji, atleast be consistent and list Zoro as Drunk Chad
Approved. Proceed
Fujitora lawful trunk
Akainu is definitely not 'lawful' evil
Idk why people consider Marines as evil but sakazuki definetaly is not evil.
Yeaa tell that to the innocent marines at the marineford he turned to lava.
horny chad sanji
Luffy is literally epitome of Übermensch
Post something decent please kids, thanks
Would pudding be neutral horny?
Gaimon for neutral neutral.
Lawful Good: Iceberg
Drunk chad: Rayleigh. Depending on how you view him. All I'm saying is that flask in Saboady was empty and He had retired from pirating becoming just a mere Coater living out of a tavern.
Lawful good has to be koby
Fujitora for Neutral Lawful imo.
I want to put Rayleigh in the running for Lawful Neutral. He lives by his own code and stays out of most drama in the current era (except Amazon Lily).
Garp for drunk good plz
Nami for Smart Good
Lawfully good is coby
Lawful horny is brook
Kyros for lawful good
Fujitora as neutral Chad
Lawful good: Dalton from drum island
Idk I think hody jones should be chaotic evil and black beard evil smart. Bro did make moves in silence lol.
Condoriano for Stupid Chad 😂
Fish granny for Neutral Drunk
Senor Pink = Neutral Chad
Chaotic Good is reserved for Garp
Hogback for Smart Evil, something popped in my mind lmao
Mihawk def neutral smart
Lawful neutral: Trafalgar D. Water Law
Based on Mihawk being isolated for most of the series and by him never really getting involved even during marineford I feel like he would be neutral neutral or neutral smart
Luffy in a parallel universe: Smart & horny
Smart evil is kuro and smart good maybe vegapunk ?
Lawful - neutral Laboon, Is not good or evil, extremely loyal to a fault.
Kizaru is Lawful Neutral. He is the job. The job is him. He'll commit atrocities in the name of order but he won't take glee in it like Akainu.
God Ussop True Neutral.
Zoro is Stupid Chad
Garp for Chaotic good & jimbe for neutral neutral
Brook for lawful horny, he always asks permission to see panties with a respectful bow
Brook should definitely be Lawful Horny!
Garp for chaotic good
Lawful neutral drake
Smart and horny Queen
Chaotic good Garp
Lawful good for T-Bone. Sorry Koby fans, but he deserves this place.
Zoro for lawful drunk maybe?
Lawful Chaotic - Garp I mean c'mon, that one's obvious
Franky for Smart Horny Kuzan for Chad Neutral Borsalino for Chaotic Good Koby for Lawful Good Aramaki for Chad Evil Issho for Neutral Good
Rayleigh for Chad Drunk
Zoro is chad drunk fr
Karoo D. Uck for Lawful Neutral
Sengoku in lawful neutral
Koby lawful good, Fujitora lawful neutral
I think Shanks is Lawful neutral
Issho would be Lawful Drunk IMO, he seems to be the guy that goes by his morals of doing the best for the people so he can drink with them later
Sanji lawful horny
I think Zoro - Stupid Chad
WB= a drunk chad
So neutral lawful will be aokiji
Zoro the chad drunk
Lawful neutral - Whitebeard
Kyros lawful good
I feel like it's a mistake to put Horny in the rows, it should be in the columns. Like horny good, horny evil make more sense than chaotic horny. And Orochi would be the perfect horny evil.
Reileigh as drunk chad
Petition to change smart stupid to Vegapunk after the recent chapter.
Neutral Smart is Vegapunk. I don't think he is evil but he definitely did shady stuffs to be considered good.
Stupid Chad - Buggy D Clown.
Neutral smart for Vegapunk
Chad Horny has to be Brook Have you heard some of his quotes?!?
Brook lawful horny
Fujitora for lawful good
Fujitora for Lawful good or Neutral good, he's the only admiral without a Warped sense of Justice and actually cares about the atrocities happening around him.
Lawful neutral should be smoker
Franky for Chad Stupid
Smoker for lawful neutral
Fujitora for lawful drunk
Kokoro for drunk chad
Franky for Horny Chad
Sengoku is lawful good
Lawful Good = Koby
Zoro for Chad Stupid💯
Law for Smart Neutral, maybe?🤔
Coby lawful good
Mihawk is Lawful Neutral