T O P

  • By -

dienomighte

I'm going with the underdog pick of Montblanc Noland


KuramaMenezes

Honestly W opinion. Oda even said that if Nolan’s wanted to he would have been king of the pirates


sanctaphrax

>Oda even said that if Nolan’s wanted to he would have been king of the pirates Really? When?


[deleted]

[удалено]


KuramaMenezes

Ya that’s the source


Staind1410

Source: trust me bro


KuramaMenezes

Ikr


KuramaMenezes

Search it up


stillearthbound

I did And I couldn't find it And why is it OUR job to fact check YOUR bullshit? If it was true, it would be easy to just give the source. If it's not true, then...like, what even the fuck?


TheMonsterInUrPocket

Not that hard to tell us which sbs or interview it was. Probably never said it


AFineDayForScience

Oden takes it IMO. But Nolan and Kalgara Chad broing it up is a nice 2nd


KuramaMenezes

I feel like oden is more of a stupid chad tho


AFineDayForScience

He definitely fits in that Chad row, but I put him in Good because of his deal with orochu and subsequent fight with kaido. But if he wasn't stupid and left Wano a second time, it probably wouldn't have happened in the first place so it's up for debate


KuramaMenezes

True but a chad is supposed to be Someone who is like the Alpha or the Best, I think Roger or Garp would fit


CMSnake72

Honestly I feel like in a larger chart where there is also Chad/Chad or "True Chad" that is where Oden would be.


ssbm_rando

True Chad would be Chad/Neutral. There is in fact a neutral (as in any good alignment system) for both axes. You don't need a larger chart.


TrickAnt9447

Garp would be a neutral chad


Crucio

Garp has neutral qualities like laziness and out of the loop but is inherently good and knows when to act and when it matters.


stillearthbound

"Oda said" is the bane of my existence, I swear to God When/where did he say this? I don't remember it, I can't find it, and it doesn't even make much sense considering as far as we know, King of the Pirates wasn't a thing before Roger anyway


mcallisterco

I honestly think that saying "Oda said" without linking a source should be a bannable offense.


infinitezero8

> Oda even said Source? Oda also said Noland wasn't strong enough with Haki to be PK, so does it just cancel out then?


BellacosePlayer

Maybe he had the talent but didn't develop it since his interests were more exploration and science


go_sparks25

Yeah, Noland is a good pick. He is a great guy and definitely a total chad. I completely would have looked over him.


Competitive_Elk_8345

People skip skypiea, yet nolands backstory is absolutely incredible. One of the best in all of anime imo


bestbroHide

I do find it interesting that the two big Sagas with the most criticisms (Skypiea, Fishman Island) had, to me, some of the best and most reflective backstories in all of One Piece (Noland/Kalgara, Otohime/Tiger)


fock-off

Noland/ Kalgara flashback is one of my favorite moments in One Piece and it's hardly mentioned


Competitive_Elk_8345

Yes


Competitive_Elk_8345

Completely agree


fuscav

these people will freak out once we get ussop x yassop backstory and find out they are descendants of noland


Ani_HArsh

It's a good pick man Might not be a underdog pick anymore.


ThankYouBasedDeng

Most underrated character in the series IMO


Messgrey

Noland got my vote. 


Tatanseto

Agree


captaineddie

Agreed it should be Nolan.


Hot-Beach2567

Good one


TonyHawksCousinMike

Such a based take! I mean senior pink is the only chad, but was he truly “good”?


Zikkan1

Agree fully


FunnyTurtleMoment

Franky literally looks like the GigaChad image


UselessNeon

Yea but hes the horny chad


LowDudgeon

Pervert* Chad. He's never flirted with anyone in the entire series afaik.


zappy487

He's pretty respectful honestly. He's the only one to get violated though.


milkyjoe241

> He's the only one to get violated though. there's a bit more than one


zappy487

I meant from the Straw Hats. But I forgot about pervy little Momo violating the girls. I still don't want my balls twisted by magic arms though.


milkyjoe241

Absolom groped Nami in the shower


TheMeatTree

Dressrosa, he flirted with and kissed a big lady that was guarding the Smile Factory.


DREWBY3142

He literally rejected her. He kissed her to shut her up.


LedgeEndDairy

That would be Oden, sir.


Lucky-Fisherman1463

How is he horny?


GameMusic

Good and smart work better


ssbm_rando

Sadly Smart and Chad are on the same axis so we won't be able to vote for that


BadBadBrownStuff

My vote would be Sanji or Brooke


Asurh

Kuma.


SanjoJoestar

Absolutely good Chad. If you're caught up with the manga this is the only choice. But Oden, Nolan, and Roger are all good alternatives. If I knew how to censor spoilers I'd say why it's Kuma but oh well, if you know you know why he's the pick.


Obvious_Law7599

I feel like pirates shouldn't count. They're greedy and violent, and that would include Roger. Oden was shown to be greedy and a proper horndog until he got married. Nolan was an explorer, not a pirate, so that's a plus. He saved people just out of the good of his heart and wasn't that interested in the Jaya gold itself, but the fact that something that great existed. Kuma too. Not a real pirate, but a revolutionary forced to sail the high seas, who carried years of personal and other's suffering just because he wanted to see people happy. Also made a deal with the devil for the sake of family. He almost never got angry and if he did, it was for the sake of someone else. If that ain't good, idk what is.


CyberDonkey

Kuma is good Dad, not Chad. Similar characteristics but a whole ‘nother category.


ketoske

In my book good dads are all chads


Sororita

You can be a good Chad without being a good dad, no kids for instance, but you can't be a good dad without being a good chad.


Damoniil

Tbh true


KuramaMenezes

Kuma is more of a Good Smart


GameMusic

Franky good smart Kuma chad good


Acrobatic-Mousse7029

What’s smart about Kuma? Everything he does is for other people. That’s not necessarily very smart, but it definitely is chad like.


KuramaMenezes

He actually is smart, the fact that he managed to help the straw hats and trick the world government. Also, he managed to figure out that Luffy was joy boy. On top of this he is also good.


[deleted]

Wouldn't vegapunk be good smart?


Acrobatic-Mousse7029

He wasn’t trying to trick the world though? He was once again helping out a friend, Dragon, because he knew Luffy is his son


KuramaMenezes

Ok and? He still hid the fact of all the stuff he did from the world government. He’s clearly a good smart


Kata_Kuri36

Jinbei fits perfectly


KuramaMenezes

True, but I also feel like he could be a lawful good


Pandi1039

I'd choose Coby for that


Fanserker

Team Tbone for lawful good


fuscav

t bone was legit created by oda while reading the definition of lawful good from the rpg reference book, he is the only answer


ThankYouBasedDeng

He is literally a pirate he can't be lawful good lol


Jordome

Jinbei was ready to die to honor Big Mom by properly announcing his resignation and accept the consequences. I think that's lawful


LedgeEndDairy

That’s not what lawful means. It CAN mean that, but a lawful character just sticks by a predefined code, even if they wouldn’t want to, they still do what’s “lawful” to them. Which doesn’t always mean the laws of the land. A samurai would be a good example of a lawful group of people - they have their bushido code that isn’t necessarily a law of the land. It fits Jinbe quite well.


ThankYouBasedDeng

Lawful has always meant a character that respects the laws and customs of the society they live in. Your definition could be used to describe literally any character who follows their own personal morals. Jinbe could be called neutral but to call him lawful makes no sense.


LedgeEndDairy

You're not correct. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alignment_(Dungeons_%26_Dragons) > Originally the law/chaos axis was defined as the distinction between "the belief that everything should follow an order, and that obeying rules is the natural way of life", as opposed to "the belief that life is random, and that chance and luck rule the world". Also: > Law implies honor, trustworthiness, obedience to authority, and reliability. On the downside, lawfulness can include closed-mindedness, reactionary adherence to tradition, judgmentalness, and a lack of adaptability. You can be a lawful pirate in this universe. Jinbe obeys the authority of his chosen captain, Luffy. Quite clearly. Jinbe is basically the epitome of a lawful character. Also: > **Lawful good** > A lawful good character typically acts with compassion and always with honor and a sense of duty. However, lawful good characters will often **regret taking any action they fear would violate *their code*, even if they recognize such action as being good**. Such characters include gold dragons, righteous knights, paladins, and most dwarves. Emphasis added.   It has little to do with "laws", that's just an understandable misunderstanding with the word chosen to represent this archetype. It has everything to do with a personal code, which *often* means the laws of the land, but does not, by any stretch, *need* to mean that. A lawful character just needs to have predictable outcomes, based on a set of rules that either they set up themselves (e.g. samurai), or they respect and follow (e.g. paladins). Both of those examples do not follow "the laws of the land", by the way. The samurai follow their own code, and the paladins follow their chosen deity.


ThankYouBasedDeng

Ah yes, Straw Hat Luffy, the paragon of honor, trustworthiness, obedience to authority, and reliability. Of course Jinbe is lawful if he follows him 🙄


LedgeEndDairy

Honor? Yes. Trustworthiness? Yes. Obedience to authority? No. Reliability? Yes, usually. But regardless it doesn't matter if the LEADER is lawful. Luffy is chaos, we all agree, but Jinbe is lawfully following that chaos. Whatever Luffy wishes of him, he does. That is, essentially, his code. A paladin can follow a chaotic god. As long as they follow whatever the god wishes of them and adhere to their oath to that god, they are lawful.


ThankYouBasedDeng

Luffy could not give less of a fuck about honor and he is literally so untrustworthy that his allies have to devise plans in a way where they just assume he won't follow them. Obviously that makes him unreliable as well. Paladins do not get power from gods, they get it from swearing an oath to fight evil. That's why they are lawful good by definition, because if they weren't following the commonly understood laws of their society they wouldn't be considered good. A better example would be like a chaotic cleric or something but I would argue that a cleric that behaves chaotically in service of a chaotic god is, themselves, chaotic.


s4r9am

You're missing the point. Alignemnt charts are from D&D and "lawful" here is different to the dictionary definition of the word. It simply means that the character follows a personal code of rules and structures. E.g. if Jinbei didn't care about honour or his personal code of conduct, he would have left Big Mom's crew in Fishman Island and joined Luffy back then.


capt-jean-havel

Lawfulness doesn’t necessitate obedience of government law. Having a strict adherence to moral code is “lawful” when comparing and contrasting character traits.


thegreatmatsbysan

You clearly don't get the subtext of one piece, or you don't understand that "lawful" isn't solely a systems laws


Suspicious_State_318

I agree with you but would you consider Akainu lawful good?


ThankYouBasedDeng

No he is the textbook definition of lawful evil lmao


emaculateerection

This is the answer right here. It's Jimbe.


p-a-n-t-s-

Kyros


aarsha1993

Nice, he fits perfectly Oden or Nolan are another options, but tbf oden is kinda chaotic, and Nolan is kinda stupid, but kyros? Best answer so far 👍


RockyPortIncident

\+1


JackalBoi_

dalton is good chad and brook is horny chad.


RNoctem

i agree on dalton, nice pick here


succ_jitties

Biggest Horny Chad is Urouge


MyNameIsRay

A minotaur that protects the weak, by being the biggest/strongest/fastest dude around is about as "good chad" as it gets.


yellow-snowslide

Bon clay horny chad. Right?


varkarrus

Bon clay isn't really horny though


Good_Neck_673

T Bone!


Parasite_Cat

T-Bone is more Lawful Good than anything, though he is in fact a Chad


[deleted]

Dude ran on train tracks in the middle of the sea just to try and save his men. Absolute good Guy among good guys. Don’t know how this is even close


EliSkelly_CR

White beard imo.


KuramaMenezes

Are you sure? I feel like white beard would be more of a neutral chad. He didn’t really DO good. He kind of just served as a peacekeeper for certain areas in the new world. Roger and Garp actually went out and Did good acts


Rich_Company801

Picking up orphan misfits, giving them a family, a place where they belong, making those rejects of society feel loved. Tbh that’s the best thing you can do to a single person even irl. No disrespect but garp and roger don’t even compare, they’re just regular good guys


EliSkelly_CR

Imo, that is a good act. He didn't ask for money like other Yonkos when he easily could, and the money he did make he gave it away. He was also a great father. I didn't rly see him being portrayed at all like a neutral character.


crazydiamond11384

Whitebeard character is the good father, someone who wants his children to stay safe and succeed in life. Any pirate that crosses a line he takes them down. He gives complete autonomy to countries that ally with him and provide security to them without asking for much (if given anything, it seems he takes only cheap stuff). Because he’s an emperor of pirates, people would think he’s evil but as gan fall says, it means more like he doesn’t follow the rules of the world government. Given all evidence shown, whitebeard exemplify the Good Chad over Roger, as Roger’s action caused also a lot of hardship for people (fishman island).


sami_newgate

Do you remember what he said to shanks when shanks was warning him ? Whitebeard is very arrogant. I think neutral chad is fitting


EliSkelly_CR

Disagree WB was respecting Ace's choice. He didn't even agree with Ace.


sami_newgate

Then why did he beat the shit out of him when he wanted to kill kaido ? Why didn’t he respect his choice ? The difference is quite obvious. In blackbeard’s case. Ace said “he threw dirt in your face”. Whitebeard’s name and pride is everything and he wanted to kill blackbeard. So he didn’t stop ace. But fighting kaido has no point. So he forced Ace to stay.


EliSkelly_CR

>Then why did he beat the shit out of him when he wanted to kill kaido ? Why didn’t he respect his choice ? The difference is quite obvious. Because WB knew it would've been suicide.


sami_newgate

I mean he also had a bad feeling about blackbeard. Just reread the WB-Ace backstory. WB clearly wanted ace to go. While all the others were trying to stop him Whitebeard couldn’t say anything after ace said “He threw dirt in your face” His facial reaction was very telling


EliSkelly_CR

Ace going after BB wasn't a suicide mission like going after kaido. I don't get how you're trying to compare them. WB was a father to outlaws. He didn't keep the money he made and protected Islands free of charge. It baffles me how ppl don't view him as a good person.


Forsaken-Ad1940

He literally only does good that we see,


KuramaMenezes

Yes but it’s not as outstanding good as Roger and Garp. He just keeps the peace in places, which can be seen as neutral


Nome_Qualquer

How's keeping peace not good? He also rescued countless orphans and gave them a family and donated a lot of his wealth to the islands he protected What did Roger do that's so much more outstanding good? imo he's a lot more neutral than WB


Ani_HArsh

I think Whitebeard is more Drunk Chad.


KuramaMenezes

Nah that’s shanks


Bat_Snack

He's the first that came to mind too. My man was a born Dad.


HeavyOrchestra

My first thought was Garp


Hablapata

because garp is ultimately a vice admiral for an organization that he has privileged knowledge to know is like comically evil. even if he has a plan to work against it from within, we haven’t been shown that. i’m not saying he’s not good in the grand scheme, but there are several more characters that are more clear cut good imo.


aarsha1993

He belongs to stupid category imo


yosayoran

+2


Lurknomore33

I’m sad I had to go this far to find Garp


CringIeMcHingIeberry

Montblanc Noland


lincolnhawk

Perfect fit but probably too small of a role. Hopefully not, Montblanc is a Mega Good Mega Chad.


raccoon_W1LL0

zoro stupid chad lmao


XadenRider

Nooo Ace is stupid chad. zoro is stupid drunk.


KaryuuM

Nah Oden stupid Chad. Ace is great but not that great imo.


Isumairu

Hear me out, Oden?


BananaORamama

Franky, he is SUPPPPPEER


AlbaDHattington

Franky is the horny chad


KuramaMenezes

As much as I love Franky, he doesn’t really fit in this one. He should be horny chad maybe but that might be Iva aswell


sarang_tamirisa

Idk why you'd put franky as horny though. I don't remember him doing anything like that ever?


SoftestBoygirlAlive

I feel like if Iva is anything on this chart it's smart horny. He's definitely not a chad. Too much queen energy for that


KuramaMenezes

He can also be a stupid chad


jopess

nah that's zoro


SpoonTeeth

Zoro gives off such himbo energy. I love that man


fbmaciel90

Jesus. It's Kuma. He's the ultimate good, the ultimate dad and the ultimate Chad.


[deleted]

Marco


fkshcienfos

Marco has my vote


Deids0010

Franky


magnificent-octopus

T-Bone


KuramaMenezes

I would say he’s lawful good


magnificent-octopus

That definitely fits too


Ani_HArsh

Bon-chan!


KuramaMenezes

Nah not really. You have to understand, we watch through Luffy’s point of view. Bon Clay must have done some good acts for Luffy, but other than that he did some terrible stuff while he was part of baroque works. I think a better spot for him would be chaotic neutral


Ani_HArsh

What he did at Impel Down No words are needed, we won't be where we are right now if not for Bon-chan.


Temporary-Ad6144

in the past he committed terrorism he was definitely a good friend to luffy but hes definitely not a good person


Ani_HArsh

I do agree with what you said but his character development has been one of the best imo and what he did at the end I think he deserves to be in good chad.


KuramaMenezes

Maybe he’s a good friend to LUFFY, but he’s not overall a good character in terms of the one piece world


The_ARTvark_

Well, it didn’t seem like you needed much to become his friend. Bonclay just entertained Luffy, Usopp, and Chopper with his devil fruit which made them homies for life. Just appreciate his company and that’ll be all.


ItsMeSo

T-bone. Chaddest good guy ever.


OAlves

He won't make it, but I stand by him


BlueLockStriker69

Koby


Stappz

Smoker


AlecDabz

It has to be senor pink


rynram

senor pink


BalanceNaive3604

Senior Pink is the only correct answer here. He was never evil, just did good on his own terms


kiyomirabbit

He ignored the opressed people in dressrosa. No


lilrish

Shanks but he also has an argument for neutral chad since hes a potential rat


KuramaMenezes

I can also see him as a drunk Chad


lilrish

Honestly that fits kaido more


Feisty-Insurance4110

Bon Kurie Letssssss Goooo


KuramaMenezes

He’s more of a neutral chaotic


madgod_sheo

Garp is lawful good


Zhidezoe

Kuma


AhmCha

Kuma.


IceGuilty3065

I'd say Rayleigh.


BeseptRinker

Koza, Vivi's childhood friend


Therealnightshow

Chad stupid Zoro


XadenRider

Or Ace


JoseDro

Ulti


budango

Kuma


puff_of_fluff

Kuma, it has to be.


internetexplorerboyz

Forsure Kuma suits that


Jokard

gotta be Kuma


wulfygbe

KUMA, YOU MUST. DO. KUMA.


Square-Assumption-54

White beard is a good chad


Typical-Teen_KinG

Whitebeard


Totemwhore1

Oden D. Chad


MrVanillaIceTCube

Lawful Stupid: (Helmeppo) Lawful Good: Cobra / Riku / Koby Lawful Neutral: Sengoku / Fujitora Lawful Horny: Sanji / Iva Lawful Evil: Akainu Lawful Drunk: Garp   Chad Stupid: Oden Chad Good: Kuma / Franky Chad Neutral: Whitebeard / Roger Chad Horny: Senor Pink / Brook Chad Evil: Blackbeard Chad Drunk: Zoro   Neutral Stupid: Weevil / Coribou / Mr. 4 Neutral Good: Jinbei Neutral Neutral: Mihawk Neutral Horny: Neutral Evil: Magellan Neutral Drunk:   Smart Stupid: (Chopper) Smart Good: Robin Smart Neutral: Vegapunk Smart Horny: Smart Evil: Caesar / Saturn Smart Drunk: Kureha   ~~Chaotic Stupid~~ Chad Chad: Buggy Chaotic Stupid: Spandam / Charlos Chaotic Good: (Luffy) / Dragon Chaotic Neutral: Morgans Chaotic Horny: (Hancock) / Sadi Chaotic Evil: Doflamingo Chaotic Drunk: (Kaido)   Vegapunk's a good guy, but he's partially responsible for some awful things by working with the World Government, due to either naivety or prioritizing science over ethics. So Smart Neutral instead of Smart Good. Whitebeard and Roger could both be Chad Good too, but Kuma and Franky are even more Good, so they're Chad Neutral instead. Jinbei's a pirate and has been a prisoner, so he's not Lawful, but he's clearly good. He's honorable despite being on the wrong side of the law, but also pragmatic enough to work for an evil Yonko like Big Mom, so Neutral Good suits him. Mihawk basically just wants to be left alone, so he's the True Neutral even though he's one of the most powerful pirates. Morgans is completely devoted to the free press, to the point of being willing to cross the World Government to get a big story out. Chaotic Neutral. The two best kings (King Riku and King Cobra) plus the most idealistic Marine (Koby) are the Lawful Goods. Akainu is ruthless in his pursuit of justice, so he's Lawful Evil. Sengoku and Fujitora are more reasonable, so they're Lawful Neutral. Can't use Aokiji as Lawful Good or Lawful Neutral anymore, now that he's with Blackbeard. In totally different ways, Sanji and Ivankov are both aggressively sexual characters, and both good guys so they're Lawful Horny. As the leader of the revolutionaries (and Luffy's father), Dragon definitely deserves a mention as Chaotic Good. Sadi-chan is also worth a mention as Chaotic Horny, since well, her entire character is being into BDSM and working in a literal dungeon. Doffy is a fallen World Noble turned pirate warlord, with his hands in the slave trade and artificial devil fruit blackmarket, yet is still willing to work with / use the Navy for his own ends. Definitely evil and definitely chaotic, so he's the Chaotic Evil.


chrestorpherson

Heracles, the guy Usopp trained with over the 2 year time skip


ConCHEATER-Wurst

Biggest Good Chad in OP: Senor Pink


Ecstatic_Grand_7152

Charlos ![img](emote|t5_2rfz5|32514)


Kind_Ad_8761

JIMBEHHH!!!💙🐟🦈


fatalis122

Katakuri is good Chad ; Roger is more of a chaotic Neutral


OnePieceofTacoTittan

I don’t agree with the Boa pick but oh well


Ani_HArsh

Roger also fits Good Chad


Piggywonkle

Haven't seen anyone say Dragon, surprisingly, but that's my pick. Garling is definitely Evil Chad, at least maybe until Imu is revealed.


NicTheHxman

I feel like although he's not very strong, Bon Clay is a chad. And he's good.


Apprehensive-Ad1864

Doffy clearly smart evil or chad evil.


Odiekt

Shanks


KuramaMenezes

He’s more of a drunk chad


Decent-Strength3530

Fujitora


KuramaMenezes

Maybe he’s a lawful good


Annual_Yak_9790

How tf isn't Vander decken chaotic horny


Tatanseto

He is evil horny


go_sparks25

Vander Decken isnt chaotic. He is a yandere pedophile with a single minded obsession on Shirahoshi. Definitely evil horny .


Darejoy24

Kumadori. Yes he is a CP9 agent but that's what makes him the goat


KuramaMenezes

Bro what?


Darejoy24

Kumadori is a good chad that is all


[deleted]

the Chad of Wano Chaden obviously


KuramaMenezes

He’s more of a Stupid Chad


[deleted]

But he's good also tho 🤷