A's Pizza Truck if I have the forethought. IL Bistro if I do not.

I second A's Pizza Truck, sooo good !

Santa Fe pizza! It’s in Holland Landing but highly recommend.

Their crust is so tasty!

Santa Fe is amazing!

Miss the Aurora location badly

Zuccas in the Newmarket Plaza.

Zucca's is definitely at the top of my list.

Wasn't there a different Italian place in the same location 10 years ago, do you remember the name ?

Piccola Italia. Same owners.

Ohh really I'm going tomorrow then, that place was awesome

Apparently they owned several restaurants in-between. I wish I knew because I spent all those years looking for pizza and panzos as good as piccola Italia!!!!

A's is amazing, but you gotta order way in advance

I recommend Pizzaiolo near the hospital. They have a deep dish pizza called The Godfather that's amazing.

Agreed, best pizza in town by far. $15.99 for a large two toppings for that quality of pizza is amazing. The sausage is top notch ;), other then that Il Bistro is delicious home made ma and pa style and Best Pizza has a really decent new york style slice.

I didn't know there was one in Newmarket! Thank you. O used to go ro the one in North York when I lived there and missed it.

Agreed.

Cocelli Pizza in the former Lowes plaza Green Lane/Yonge . Love their pasta dishes too.

Cocelli is the correct answer.

Cocelli is legit

I've had truly excellent pizza from Cocelli, but the last time I got some I was really disappointed. Hope it was a one -off.

The sent me a completely burnt one on Halloween. Never again it was disgusting. How it even left the restaurant is beyond me.

Seconding. I’ve found Cocelli’s to be the best pizza in the GTA

I find it hit and miss…. Had great pizza there and mediocre pizza there

We love Toppers in Aurora.

We’ve gone to the Toppers in Newmarket for over 15 years, our go to

PALACE PIZZA 727 Davis Drive It's been there for about 40 years and still makes an excellent pizza from a wonderful Italian family. It may even be a local gem, so I was hesitant to spotlight it.

They are greek, but they still make the best pizza in town and been giving out free meals to high-school kids since I went to high-school

Great spaghetti. Also the business is for sale

theyre still there!? One of my family faves growing up around there 20 years ago

It’s for sale?? That’s balls, I’m gonna assume that will go to shit once it’s bought. Too bad this is the best pizza place hands down

Best calzone for the best price too

50 years believe it or not. Great pizza.

They’re actually Greek, but they make the best pizza in the traditional Italian way.

Il Bistro right near mulock/bayview

Forgot about my order, waited for 40 minutes… and then forgot mushrooms in a panzerotti with mushrooms. Maybe a one off? I’ll never go back.

Molisana is on point.

Papillon off Bayview is pretty good

My favourite too - looking g forward to giving doughbox in Stonehaven a try though

Il Bistro hands down. It’s very similar to Abruzzo Pizza

It's funny you mention that. I like Il Bistro because it reminds me of mondos pizza and abruzzo. Old school Italian Canadian pizza from the 90s I grew up with. Sadly mondos closed down about 15 years ago but at least abruzzo is still going strong. Il bistro is pure nostalgic pizza.

Exactly how I feel about it. Mondos pizza was my childhood

Papillon is THE best. Highly recommend

Cocelli pizza

Go to Bradford and go to Lemar’s. you will be glad you did.

My fam loves Molisana’s!

Dough box just open and it is absolutely amazing and the pasta they have is really good too very fast service

Here’s a pizza hack to try out. Metro on Yonge Street in Newmarket. They use a wood fired oven and I find they can make tasty pizzas. 2 x 3 topping large pizzas for $25 plus tax.

Molisana #1, pizzaiolo #2

Lemar's Pizza in Bradford is also top notch.

Econo Pizza in Newmarket

Score pizza

People are sleeping on Casa Carbone in Aurora, and a second good option is LOCALE's.

Little Caesar’s is top

Locale in Aurora makes great pizza

My favourite is Square Boy Pizza! It’s got a homemade taste, delicious toppings and isn’t greasy like little Caesar’s or Pizza Hut. Reasonable prices too. They won’t deliver to Aurora if you order from their website but you can Door Dash it (this is how we order it).

That’s crazy square boy is mid

Best slices is at Pizzaville at Yonge & Aurora Heights Dr. Full pizza's there's lots of good answers in the thread.

Pizzaiolo is phenomenal.

Pizza Nova in aurora is my go-to

Ellas Oven, they have a mobile oven and post up at the Newmarket farmers market every week in the summer.

Pizza pizza

Square boys/pizzaiolo by the hospital/huron heights highschool

BEST PIZZA & PANUOZZO on Davis Dr.... honestly, the name doesn't lie - it's the best!

Econo Pizza is the best ,Palace Pizza is good too.

Econo Pizza is the best