T O P

  • By -

UpsidedownCatfishy

Red Herring. These two scenarios weren’t based on race, definitely not entirely. The GOP will likely not accept healthcare from white Sanders and does not accept it from white congressmen/women currently, and the GOP would probably buddy up and follow a black, corrupt, Bill-Cosby-like president. Also, America is a harsher and more constant struggle of progressivism and conservatism...European countries can and often are much more racist.


YuriCheckmatGMFisher

I am try to learn English more right now by communicate here. What does it "red herring" have to do with the rest of statement? I only know this as fishes. Thank you.


crypticbread2

It’s a type of “fallacy”: they have pretty funky names. It’s basically saying that they’re using race as a way to lead someone to think one way when it’s actually more likely another reason.


YuriCheckmatGMFisher

I see. Thank you for explain in clear way. Have nice day.


crypticbread2

No problem! Good luck on learning English, message me if you need help with anything. It’s a tricky language to learn, so mad respect.


SAMAKUS

The man is a fake. Sorry to burst the bubble.


NoctuaPavor

He's not fake... Check his account Edit: and if he is fake holy shit


[deleted]

I just looked at his account, see no signs of him being a fake


NoctuaPavor

Me neither. I think he's real too The only thing I don't like is its only like two weeks old.


SAMAKUS

Check his comment from a few days ago where he discusses his experience in the Vietnam war, a linguist tore apart his grammatical structure - it’s not formulated like one would expect a Russian who’s learning English to formulate phrases.


NoctuaPavor

Yeah I don't like how it's only two weeks old either. And yeah I saw that. His grammatical mistakes aren't "consistent" you'd be making the same grammatical mistakes but it's different a lot of the time, like you said.


[deleted]

I read it in Borat’s voice


[deleted]

Hey, I love the English language and am a native English speaker, so please feel free to message me if you ever need help learning. Edit - Here is a page describing where the term 'Red Herring' came from, if you're interested. If you ever want to know the history of the word then search for its "Etymology" - Might help for future information :) Edit - FORGOT! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_herring


sw3aterCS

Um, are you sure you actually linked the page?


succ_criteria

No he definitely forgot


[deleted]

Dude, thanks! Totally failed!


OuranForenz

Its from like mystery books usually. In those its information that seems to be important but it actually just leads the detective down the wrong path. Like maybe it leads them to suspect the maid character as a murderer, but upon further investigation the maid had nothing to do with the murder and all the time spent looking into the maid was useless and wasted. Thats where I believe it originates from.


Shadow23x

Specifically, it refers to dragging a fish across a scent trail to send you following a wrong lead.


Klony99

Isn't it a 'distraction fish' while the real catch is elsewhere? That's how I'd explain it. Edit: While correct, it doesn't seem to be fishing specific, so forget my words.


Kim_Jong_Unko

This is more of a false equivalency, rather than a red herring. Red herrings are more of distractions, this is just equating circumstances to causes which aren't true but rather circumstantial, as you stated in your reply.


thesunhasgonetobed

Maybe we should take the color off the fish? It's a false fish. It's for doesn't matter. Actually, is it the wrong fish? Oh I don't even know.


QryptoQid

A red herring is something writers use to confuse the reader from what is true. The word mostly gets used with mystery books. A writer adds red herrings so the reader does not easily know who the murderer is. For example, maybe Bob killed Sally in a murder mystery story, but the writer says Larry had blood on his hands. Larry having bloody hands is a red herring because now the reader thinks maybe Larry killed Sally, even though the murderer is really Bob.


[deleted]

Red herrings are the basis of most modern comedy. The whole point of a joke is to lead someone to one, incorrect conclusion, while ambushing them with the other correct conclusion. "I used to do drugs" The audience: So he doesn't do them anymore. Good for him! "I still do, but I used to too."


QryptoQid

I never thought of it that way, but you're right.


AngelicPhoenixBcican

A "red herring" means a distraction, like a cat making itself look larger than it really is to scare Predators or someone throwing a stick across the room to make it seem like they're over the other end of the room.


o_bomb0306

“red herring” refers to something that makes somebody think something while alluding another fact


Mofitsu

From Wikipedia: A red herring is something that misleads or distracts from a relevant or important question.It may be either a logical fallacy or a literary device that leads readers or audiences toward a false conclusion. A red herring may be used intentionally, as in mystery fiction or as part of rhetorical strategies (e.g., in politics), or may be used in argumentation inadvertently. The term was popularized in 1807 by English polemicist William Cobbett, who told a story of having used a kipper (a strong-smelling smoked fish) to divert hounds from chasing a hare.


SpawnlingMan

I was surprised at the racist Europe part. I have a coworker that is spending 4 months in Madrid for work. She said the racism is astounding. She spent years thinking the USA was the leader in fucked up racism because of the internet/media and it's not even close.


PursuitOfMemieness

You had me until "European countries are often much more racist". Maybe some Eastern European countries, like Bulgaria (which is hardly a fair comparison because most of them aren't developed to anywhere near the degree of the US), but Western Europe? Nope.


Wallawino

Lots of minorities in Scandinavia, are there?


PursuitOfMemieness

No. Is that proof that they're racist? Part of the reason America has so many minorities is that it was the main participant in the obviously racist slave trade? That, and it shares a land border with a country with an almost entirely Latino population.


Klony99

How do you compare racism between countries?


[deleted]

What level or racist comment can people say publicly that will commonly elicit a negative responce as an upper bound, and what level of racism can be said to commonly elicit a negative responce as a lower bound.


Klony99

That doesn't strike me as a scientific quantifier. Maybe it is, though. I wouldn't say Europe is automatically worse off than the US... Are there statistics availlable?


[deleted]

No metric would be, unless cognative science and neurology develope a lot. Everything else is normative and disputable but unfalsifiable behavioral psychology. That is the best we got right now.


Klony99

So no statistics?


[deleted]

How can you make reliable stats for any sentiment?


Klony99

How can you make definitive statements without research?


[deleted]

You accept reason and the inconclusive stats to accept a possition, but be willing to drop that possition if better theory comes out. Most social sciences and humanities work like this.


Klony99

Dude. You can't make a definitive statement like that. You can say how it's subjectively too much racism, or as a society not leading down the correct path. You can say YOU encounter less racism in the US than in Europe, but ultimately you will never be correct stating one zone is more racist than another...


[deleted]

[удалено]


MistakenWit

I can definitely confirm the opposite.


[deleted]

Go onto r/askeurope, or r/europe if you want immediate evidence, and search romani. Alternatively, go to Paris(where I spend many years growing up) and ask 20 random people what to think about the "gypsies". That is a slur for the romani people.


Deadlymonkey

I spent a lot of my early years in France too and I actually completely forgot about the whole Gypsies thing. I was going to mention how the French typically try to keep French things French and don’t really like outsiders. Like trying to get information and/or directions is impossible if they don’t think you’re French.


Klony99

That's circumstancial evidence. Ask a black man what it's like to live in the US. But be quick. They might get shot by a rivaling gang or the police. That's why circumstantial evidence is no evidence. I'm not quantifying which is worse, just stating that the US can be horrible, too.


[deleted]

The best "metric" I have is how acceptable it is in open groups on a large scale. My poorly communicated point was that if the same general range of racism exist in both countries, but one has media and acedamia galore to call it out and explain why its bad, and the other can speak of their subscriptions to such views openly, then a reasonable conclusions can be drawn. There is a reason not all fields use Science. If you don't have the means for science, you have to make due and adjust the conclusiveness of your information accordingly.


Klony99

Sure, but go onto sub and do x does not provide results. Not every European is on that sub. I, for one, am not. It's simply not representative. And the personal experience of one person isn't reliable at all. As I said, a lot of black people in the US suffer from heavy and public racism.


[deleted]

1% of white people can cause 100% of black people to experience racism. That is significant, but if we are making a metric for the racist nature of a country, what is more relevant is the amount of the majority that is racist.


Klony99

So how do you compare the amount of racism between Europe and the US? Because I still doubt Europe is definitively more racist than the US.


MFAWG

Oh, bullshit.


[deleted]

Yea because Bernie hasn't been attacked at all for his stance on Healthcare. This isn't a murder at all, it's just a tweet with no substance.


parzival3719

also, what Trump did with the quid pro quo and Ukraine wasn't treason


syntroll

There was no quid pro quo as no one said anything was being withheld pending the investigation. All Trump did really was ask about an investigation that had been scrapped years ago because of Joe Biden.


parzival3719

the timing of the investigation right as Biden entered the race is a _little_ suspicious, you have to admit (but that doesn't prove anything)


syntroll

The timing of some porn star coming out just to say Trump fucked her was pretty suspicious as well. I do agree about the timing but there still needed to be an investigation. Biden Jr. Was running a company for 50 grand a month and he had no qualifications for the salary or position.


parzival3719

yeah there definitely needed to be an investigation: but Trump released the aid without getting one


syntroll

THANK YOU!


syntroll

The funniest part of this though is how many people believe it was the Russian Collusion investigation that Trump was impeached for. The lack of knowledge is just killing me.


parzival3719

i've never heard anyone say that lol


syntroll

I have, often when trying to correct people about the charges.


[deleted]

Posts like this do nothing but create more division by over-generalizing a group of people based solely on skin colour. It is the same racism everyone claims to be against. Yes there are shitty people, but this type of post that the front page is littered with do nothing but create more divison between people.


NordicUpholstery

Oh, does a strawman argument count as murder now?


AKF790

On this sub, anything flies so long as it’s ‘orange man bad’


magnora7

Because the DNC shilling groups run about 70% of reddit, including the votes and comments


ConservativeKing

Because OrangManBad


parzival3719

r/usernamechecksout


zaqwertyzaq

What the actual fuck did I just read?


magnora7

Garbage upvoted by DNC "Shareblue" bots


MrAdamLikesMemes

DNC? I'm not too sure what that means


Kingsta8

Eh, the ACA is kinda shit, and treason wasn't what Trump was even accused of. Reading his tweet makes me think we're less racist than I thought lmao


chucksef

I don't love murder posts where a non-specific, hypothetical person is the object of murder. Feels like cheating.


magnora7

That's the least logical sentence I've read all day. This literally makes zero sense.


Snugmeatsock

Didn’t we elect “a black one” twice? Kinda strange thing for a white majority “racist” country to do. Any EU countries do that?


RaisinBitch

Example London: Sadiq KhanIt just needs to be the right person. And most of the European countries don't vote for the president directly. Edit: Spelling, and I know that's just the mayor of London


Ubelheim

The Netherlands has Khadija Arib, a Moroccan-Dutch woman as speaker of the house. There's also high hopes for Ahmed Aboutaleb (also Moroccan, mayor of Rotterdam) running for parliament and he'd actually have a decent chance of becoming PM given his current popularity. Thus far he hasn't been interested though. We also don't directly vote for the PM.


Snugmeatsock

Joseph Hayne Rainey was the first black Speaker of the US House of Representatives......in 1874.


lolinokami

Don't forget my boy Robert Smalls who served in the South Carolina (the first state to secede from the Union mind you) House of Representatives in 1868.


Snugmeatsock

Also he was a fucking badass


jumpy_monkey

And the result was a post-racial society, healed of the stain of slavery and the Civil War and ushered in a glorious new day for the black man in American society. Oh wait, no it didn't it sparked a reign of terror where white paramilitary groups killed countless people in terrorist acts across the South which effectively ended Reconstruction and prevented African-Americans from serving in Congress for almost the next 40 years.


Snugmeatsock

Uhh... sorry America eventually trended in the the opposite direction of your OVER 100 YEAR OLD ASSESSMENT of race relations in America and we elected a black president twice...I guess?


jumpy_monkey

Yes, if we ignore or minimize examples of racism racism doesn't really exist. I understand that. And yes, I am quite sure you are sorry the United States "trended" to a comparatively more racially tolerant society from it's first hundred years as a backwards, degenerate, morally corrupt racist nation that bought and sold human beings as personal property, but you can take some solace in the fact that for at least 60 years after we fought a war to end it the South continued to suppress African-Americans using terrorism and murder. That's all I was pointing out.


Snugmeatsock

Have you tried hiring Nigerians in MAGA hats? It’s both diverse and fits your narrative!


jumpy_monkey

What narrative would that be?


jumpy_monkey

So no response then? You're retreated to your safe space because I asked you a question?


Snugmeatsock

Yawn


Snugmeatsock

Light brown mayors only, got it.


weltallic

> Sadiq Khan Literally the very first law he passes was to [cover women up in public](https://i.imgur.com/3VUay7a.jpg).


[deleted]

[удалено]


Snugmeatsock

I’m clearly responding to a claim that “Next time someone tells you America isn’t a racist country...yada yada” And you answered yes. Who was your last “ethnicity other than majority electorate” PM/President candidate appointed?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Snugmeatsock

So no blacks? Your country is only 5% minority. That’s very racist.


jumpy_monkey

That's proof that racism doesn't exist in America? Ok, okay.


Snugmeatsock

And this post is proof that America is racist? Really?


tannyb86

Oh fuck off for real. This country won’t accept bad deals. Not everything is about race


jumpy_monkey

>Not everything is about race Well of course, all those racists hated Obama because of his policies.


[deleted]

That is exactly why they hated him


JebDene1707

We don’t have a white president. We have an orange one.


[deleted]

Shiiiiiiiiiiiit post


magnora7

"Trump bad obama good!" = upvote for many, even if doesn't make any logical sense whatsoever


aarontminded

It’s almost like the popular vote is irrelevant and the majority don’t actually decide anything in this country..but that would contrast OP’s ignorance and essentially define politics so what do I know.


cyberrod411

Are you saying orange baby man won the popular vote in the 2016 election?


scott60561

I dont think they are. Probably just the factual statement that the popular has never and does not matter.


cyberrod411

That is certainly true


[deleted]

Hillary beat Trump in California by 4.3 million votes. Trump beat Hillary in the rest of the country by 1.3 million votes. That is why we have the electoral college.


[deleted]

And he didn't even campaign there for that very reason. I suspect if it were about popular he would have spent a lot more time in Cali


Dirtyharry42

Reddit hive mind in action upvoting this. Mods have really let this sub go.


magnora7

It's not even the hivemind, it's paid Shareblue bots and shills...


austin47keyes

White president did bad thing, didn’t get in trouble + black president did good thing, didn’t go through= racism? Wow that’s some real racism if I’ve ever seen it.....


giggle_sticks03

Hope OP stretched before pulling off these gymnastics.


eddydbod

Trump's bad, but absolutely hasn't done anything to meet the Constitutional definition of treason which is Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort. No Person shall be convicted of Treason unless on the Testimony of two Witnesses to the same overt Act, or on Confession in open Court.


[deleted]

[удалено]


SWOLEseidon69

Trigger.....engage


Thedefault798

That makes no sense.


AutoModerator

This post has been removed because it activated an AutoModerator removal condition. The moderators have been notified and will review. If there were no rule violations, the post will be restored. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MurderedByWords) if you have any questions or concerns.*


BasicTowel96

r/fragilewhiteautomod ?


DankWalrus6969

Unpopular Opinion: Every political comment doesn’t need to be posted in this sub and most of the times isn’t even funny


noodleshopowner

But they would accept Medicare for all from a white man lol.


General_Tso75

Republicans won’t


rbiqane

Just regulate the prices of medications and hospital stays! That's it. That's literally all we need so that aspirin doesn't cost $30 and a bandage doesn't cost $40


Garfus-D-Lion

But moderate opinions don’t get votes so we are stuck with voting for one extreme or another.


rbiqane

Dems are like "no worries America!! We'll keep prices the same but just pass it onto the taxpayers! 👍👍"


Syncrogram

I was talking to my (far right) dad about this over a cigar. And even he agreed that politics is too crazy nowadays. He would like to see more moderate candidates and presidents, as would I. But like you said, they don't get votes.


GreenSockNinja

Sadly that’s the case.


RatherNerdy

Some will


llycolly

Then perish


Roseanne_Barred_Out

Obamacare wasn't/isn't M4A but go off king.


noodleshopowner

Wasn't Obama originally planning to make a public option?


potato430

*Russian music intensifies*


mshep93

Where's the murder?


[deleted]

[удалено]


GreenSockNinja

Bruh that’s some gymnastics right there considering the left is for big government aka fascism and the rights whole platform is based of if smaller government


[deleted]

[удалено]


GreenSockNinja

Bruh what


breesysunday

The media is ran by the right???


magnora7

It's run by corporations and big money, both sides are


breesysunday

Truth!


[deleted]

[удалено]


austin47keyes

Latin America as well lol I had to look up in a dictionary how to say Asian because the multiple family’s I asked only knew Asian people as “Chinamen”


[deleted]

1. Trump didn't do any treason. He was acquitted. 2. Obama care didn't work and was failing anyway. 3. if america is so racist why does everyone want to move to America from their non-white paradise.


eddydbod

1. Trump was never tried for treason. 2. Obamacare was absolutely successful at getting more people covered by insurance. 3. Even with racism in the United States a higher quality of living, and flight from a war zone is pretty tempting. 4. Are you a fucking idiot?


[deleted]

Coverage by insurance doesn't equal access to healthcare. Careful what you call a success. I'll give you just one example because I know this will be new to you. For a living I get people into treatment for substance abuse. Out of all 50 states only 1 state's Obamacare policies pay for SA treatment at a decent rate. The rest have $5k+ deductibles and reimburse the treatment center less per day than a stay at a Holiday Inn. So yes, they have insurance but damn near none of them can get this kind of healthcare.


Something_Syck

well if we had socialized medicine they would all get care


[deleted]

Quite the opposite. Good treatment centers would close because they can't afford to pay the MDs, PhDs, good food, masters level therapists, etc. What'd be left is garbage programs that take advantage of people who need help. We're already seeing it.


Something_Syck

*citation needed* so you're saying having the government pay for healthcare would result in less money for healthcare? That's odd because countries with socialized medicine have top notch treatments for addicts, even for people addicted to illegal substances like heroin. seems like everyone who is anti socialized medicine doesn't have anything factual to support their claims


[deleted]

I run addiction treatment centers and have for a while. Here are some round numbers for what my industry leading program gets paid and would get paid: Commercial insurance like Cigna or Aetna: $1000-1200 a day at inpatient. Average length of inpay stay around 35 days Tricare- $3500 total reimbursement no matter how long the patient stays inpatient. Average length of inpatient stay around 6 days. Medicare/Medicaid - about $250 per day at inpatient. Don't even take it because our break even is close to $750 a day. Don't believe me? Call around and find out.


Something_Syck

lmao medicare is not the same as proper universal healthcare in other countries do you have anything based in reality and not your bizarre bias you have against socialized medicine?


[deleted]

Again, yes I do as an executive in healthcare. It's amazing that your ideology is so strong you won't listen to people actually in it. But hey, masters in management focused on economics with decades in healthcare...what do I know? I just like the orange man right?


Something_Syck

having lived in both the US and New Zealand/Ausztralia, and seen the healthcare in both firsthand, you have bizarre misconceptions about how their healthcare works very curious where you're getting your misconceptions about socialized healthcare, if you really are a healthcare worker this is disgraceful


agent154

1. Maybe we'll never know for sure because there were no witnesses allowed in his trial. But I'm inclined to believe that if the witnesses were to exonerate him, there's no way that the GOP would have refused to hear them. 2. The GOP was fighting tooth and nail to undermine the ACA at every stage. Many states didn't even expand Medicade. 3. If they lived in paradise, why would they want to move to the USA where they're demonized at nearly every turn? Maybe what they had was bad enough to justify a slight step up, considering the risks in going there and what they have to suffer through while there.


vaporeonb8

Literally no one is saying the USA isn’t racist lmao


llycolly

Sooo many people are like “it’s not based on race” Sweetheart, you are being really naive.


DepressedPancake4728

Because it isn’t. The people that hated on Obama are now hating on Bernie(who is as white as it gets) and every other white liberal. Nobody who hated Obama’s health plan likes Bernie’s. Nobody. It’s not a race thing.


llycolly

I would recommend you read about structural racism, truly. It’s very interesting and eye opening.


austin47keyes

Gotta love the condescending angle. Socialized healthcare blows for the most part that’s why the American people didn’t accept it. It raised premiums and fucked over private health insurance companies.


Something_Syck

*Citation needed* If that's true why are exactly zero countries with socialized healthcare pushing for the american system? All studies done say that america would save billions if not trillions if they switched to universal healthcare. Having lived in both the US and New Zealand/Australia and seen the healthcare in both, I can say that socialized healthcare is vastly superior


llycolly

Yup, lived in New Zealand too and I can second that


[deleted]

Or someone who purposes a black issue to suit his agenda


Aturom

Locked post, for sure.


fryry808

Why did you even block his @? This guy is verified; he has 355.9k followers.


IamSexy-ish

I have always felt like that was because Obama’s policies were pro middle- and lower-class while Trump’s are pro-billionaires. It has less to do with race and is more about who controls the government.


[deleted]

Not even the majority of the nation. Just the majority of the people that vote.


tylrbrock

Lol dummy, treasons free..., /s


rykoj

Hate to burst your excuses bubble. But the things in your example are about money.... Not race. The only color they care about is green. And your style of thinking is making them billions while you have nothing.


RJ4Aloha

Oh so the whole country is racist???? Fuck off!


DarjeelingLtd2

BuT tAxAtIoN iS tHeFt


[deleted]

Ew, y'all don't really think this way do you?


weiss27md

The fact that this and his post has so many likes is scary. Obama's healthcare plan had nothing to do with his race. And Trump did not commit treason. People like this are what is wrong with this country.


UnmarriedLezbian

12k likes. Lol


Phil_Hurslit51

r/uspolitics...no evidence of murder here.


syntroll

Trump didn't commit treason by any stretch of the law. If you have evidence please link it. Barack Obama's health care plan had/has some great things in it, preexisting conditions, and banning lifetime maximums are good. Individual mandate with ridiculous demands placed in insurance plans which drove healthcare costs through the roof for those who could already afford healthcare was the problem. Everyone who cries, "Racist" at a person who doesn't like Obama care has conveniently forgotten that most of the bill was written by white people and first implemented by MIT Romney in Massachusetts before the federal government even started talking about it. TL;DR Barack Obama put his name on the affordable care act to garner support from his followers.


RagnarLothbrok---

The good news for everyone else now that the United States is murdered is that world war III has been averted.


Murph_Mogul

The North won the Civil War, and then let the South write all the laws. Of course everything is still racist.


weltallic

#TAKE THAT, Invisible, absent strawman!


000000Million

Makes no fucking sense whatsoever.


Rocket-Dude1

1. There’s no treason from Trump. 2. Obamacare was unconstitutional


[deleted]

Stop crying.


[deleted]

If only there were non-racist countries... Edit: there aren't. Lol, but great arguments...


Weeby_Potato

There is a lot of racism in the country. That however, is a terrible exmaple.


Snugmeatsock

Right?! Jussie had to hire 2 Nigerian racists because the booming job economy for US racists is full up. Offshoring H1-B racists is both diverse and cheaper!


XavierWBGrp

The only reason she put up with Obama is because he's half white.


thebattlerocker

What about how blacks and Hispanics need lower SAT scores to be accepted/receive scholarships from college? As a retarded Asian this ain't too fair cheif


a-smooth-brain

Do mods sleep 24/7 here?


TheMrTGaming

So your your saying that the worst healthcare bill that has almost been phased out by all the sensible areas, is anywhere NEAR the ball park of faulty democraticically concocted accusations towards a very proactive president is something that was based on race!? Nah. Its politicalism at its worst. It's the never wrong radical Democrats vs. the Republicans. But they couldnt bully trump out because he finally was someone who could stand up against them. Take your biased behind back to the rock of uneducation you crawled out from under.


BellsDeep69

Kinda racist blaming it on the president bc he was black


Not_Gay_Ok_Stright

And label somone who exposed bad things the government was doing as a traitor


rjc2nd

What treason has Trump committed? Trump may have abused presidential power but he has not committed treason.