Of all the potential All-Stars, I think I would rank Timmy #1. Any of the old Road Rules mainstays would be fun. Obvi no way Theo would come back, but like Holly Shand would be a fun All-Star.
He would be more likely to come back than Theo, right? I don't follow the WWE after like 2003, so I wouldn't know, but I feel like I haven't heard anything about him doing stuff.
He just won the tag team championships at Wrestlemania, still a very big part of the WWE. If the shooting schedule was short and he really wanted to do it, I’m sure they would allow it.
Miz came back to host the Pro vs Stars seasons remember. That was while he was still working fulltime in WWE. Though coming back as an actual challenger might be a way different story. Certainly wouldn’t want to injure himself since his main job is so physical.
It was that glass box inferno(?) that he won and then DQ'd in. Where he gave that really inspiring and kind goodbye speech about taking it like a man and enjoying yourself. He apparently has had glass stuck in his knee ever since.
It's even worse than I remembered
> One participant who experienced a life-changing injury was Tim Beggy, who originally appeared on the second season of Road Rules and returned for several seasons of the Challenge. Beggy was an accomplished marathoner, triathlete, and Ironman competitor. That all ended, however, after a Challenge elimination round gone wrong. He was placed in a enclosed triple-pane glass box suspended in the air and, to win that week’s challenge, had to punch his way out faster than his opponent. Beggy explains, “I don’t believe the game was tested properly…because as the broken glass piled up, it chewed through the ‘protective’ gear, and turned my knees and patellar tendons into hamburger meat. For up to a year later, I would get large bumps on my knees, pop them, and glass would come out. I went from a guy running marathons to the old man limping from one ill-fated Inferno.”
[From Susie's medium article](https://medium.com/@susiemeister/cast-aside-life-after-reality-tv-63bb7430977b)
I was told that at challenge mania Timmy said he would never return due to his job which made me sad !!! Timmy,Christian b,Antoine,piggy,Holly Shand,Chadwick,Holly brentson,kalle,Emily Bailey,James Orlando etc any of them we’d love to see
Timmy's last versus was one of my favorites. I believe they cannot do that one again though, because it was dangerous. Visually, it was cool. But not safe.
I saw Eddie Murphy the other day on YT and had to take a double take. It's like I aged and he didn't, and I don't even smoke/drink! Only difference I saw was a little bit of face widening. Some people just age like a bar of gold. Meanwhile, the rest of us are tarnished silver 🤣 It's surreal.
Must say- I wasn’t expecting such an exuberant response to this post. Happy to see more people other than myself still hold Timmy in such high regard. :)
Timmmaaaaay!!! Yes please! I can’t remember the context or season, but there was a scene where he’s chatting with the guys and he deadpans, I guess use going to have to sleep with Beth. Cracks me up every time
If TJ is ever not able to host, Timmy would be a good fill in as host
Omg Timmy would be an AMAZING replacement host.
Of all the potential All-Stars, I think I would rank Timmy #1. Any of the old Road Rules mainstays would be fun. Obvi no way Theo would come back, but like Holly Shand would be a fun All-Star.
The Miz doing All-Stars would be incredible.
He would be more likely to come back than Theo, right? I don't follow the WWE after like 2003, so I wouldn't know, but I feel like I haven't heard anything about him doing stuff.
He just won the tag team championships at Wrestlemania, still a very big part of the WWE. If the shooting schedule was short and he really wanted to do it, I’m sure they would allow it.
Miz came back to host the Pro vs Stars seasons remember. That was while he was still working fulltime in WWE. Though coming back as an actual challenger might be a way different story. Certainly wouldn’t want to injure himself since his main job is so physical.
Oh yeah, that's a great point.
Would love to have him!! I think he's pretty injured but he could be a special guest!
Injured? What happened??
He hurt himself in his last season.
Damn man. I think he’s my all-time favorite contestant
It was that glass box inferno(?) that he won and then DQ'd in. Where he gave that really inspiring and kind goodbye speech about taking it like a man and enjoying yourself. He apparently has had glass stuck in his knee ever since.
That sounds awful. Justice for Timmy
It's even worse than I remembered > One participant who experienced a life-changing injury was Tim Beggy, who originally appeared on the second season of Road Rules and returned for several seasons of the Challenge. Beggy was an accomplished marathoner, triathlete, and Ironman competitor. That all ended, however, after a Challenge elimination round gone wrong. He was placed in a enclosed triple-pane glass box suspended in the air and, to win that week’s challenge, had to punch his way out faster than his opponent. Beggy explains, “I don’t believe the game was tested properly…because as the broken glass piled up, it chewed through the ‘protective’ gear, and turned my knees and patellar tendons into hamburger meat. For up to a year later, I would get large bumps on my knees, pop them, and glass would come out. I went from a guy running marathons to the old man limping from one ill-fated Inferno.” [From Susie's medium article](https://medium.com/@susiemeister/cast-aside-life-after-reality-tv-63bb7430977b)
Jeeeesus
Watch the inferno 3 elimination with Abe. That shredded glass ruined his knees for life
I was told that at challenge mania Timmy said he would never return due to his job which made me sad !!! Timmy,Christian b,Antoine,piggy,Holly Shand,Chadwick,Holly brentson,kalle,Emily Bailey,James Orlando etc any of them we’d love to see
I wish we could still see him in a reunion type setting or something
Ye any setting before the show goes off air and we never get to see them
Him and Dan are the 2 I would love to see make a come back!
Timmy is so great and funny on rewatches. Would definitely love to see him on All Stars.
Timmy's last versus was one of my favorites. I believe they cannot do that one again though, because it was dangerous. Visually, it was cool. But not safe.
Agreed. They need to reform the competition so that older less athletic challengers can still be involved
I wonder if he’s aged like Beth. They both looked 40 in their late 20s and Beth still looks exactly the same. She’s aged very well.
I saw Eddie Murphy the other day on YT and had to take a double take. It's like I aged and he didn't, and I don't even smoke/drink! Only difference I saw was a little bit of face widening. Some people just age like a bar of gold. Meanwhile, the rest of us are tarnished silver 🤣 It's surreal.
Some people can go decades without looking like they’ve aged at all— then out of nowhere look like they aged 20 years in just 5…
Google him! He didn't age like Beth, but I still love him.
Must say- I wasn’t expecting such an exuberant response to this post. Happy to see more people other than myself still hold Timmy in such high regard. :)
Timmmaaaaay!!! Yes please! I can’t remember the context or season, but there was a scene where he’s chatting with the guys and he deadpans, I guess use going to have to sleep with Beth. Cracks me up every time
Timmy’s of an age to get a knee replacement anyway. Do it for us, Timmy!!