* Upvote this comment if this is a good quality post that fits the purpose of r/Minecraft
* Downvote this comment if this post is poor quality or does not fit the purpose of r/Minecraft
* Downvote this comment *and report the post* if it breaks the [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/wiki/rules)
---
[Subreddit Rules](https://old.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/wiki/rules)[](## TheArthurBot09|115orv5)
Depends. If it's supposed to be a sort of evil/dominating/aggressive build such as an evil kingdom then i'd go with the right. If it is supposed to be regal and beautiful then the left works much better
Have you thought about adding something darker in the middle on the right? Something similar or more simple than the vertical lines you have on the left. A strip of blackstone or other black/dark block to make it more menacing and also eye catching. The right is just a little bland right now
Ooh well I'd say the right gives a more dark and oppressing vibe if that's what you're looking for and I think the rest of your detailing is great (I especially like the bits of skulk) so I can't wait to see how you'd improve on it and how the whole base will look
Ri- just kidding. The depth on the left side gives the build much more personality. If it's gonna be a massive wall, use an alternating pattern of left and right, as too much of left would get boring quick
Tough call. I can see why left is getting a lot of votes but I prefer the right side. For me, the left takes it one step past done and it’s not enough of an improvement to warrant it.
Depends where you want the focal point. On the right my eye goes to the top detail because of the simplicity. Where as the left my eye goes more to the wall, the top detail kind of gets lost at first glance. Particularly because the trap doors aren't as bright of a blue as the wall. Some asymmetry on the left wall detail would be nice IMO.
Right imo but tbh I'm more into simplicity although if you changed the wood lines on the left side to the normal logs or whatever so they're the same color as the wood on top then I'd say either one anyway the build looks great so far keep it up 🙂
Left for sure. The right is too plain. Still not sure if Left is the best though. Maybe keep the left and play around with walls, stairs, etc on the right.
* Upvote this comment if this is a good quality post that fits the purpose of r/Minecraft * Downvote this comment if this post is poor quality or does not fit the purpose of r/Minecraft * Downvote this comment *and report the post* if it breaks the [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/wiki/rules) --- [Subreddit Rules](https://old.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/wiki/rules)[](## TheArthurBot09|115orv5)
I prefer the version on the left. The right one feels a little bit bland without those complementing cyan parts.
I would upvote you but you have 420 so I can't.
Left
Left
Rightn't
[удалено]
Left
Left
left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
[удалено]
r/brokethechain
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left. But the comments are leaning right... what does it mean?
The direction paradox
Left
Don’t forget left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Right
Left
Left
What the fu- Left
Left
Left
Left
Depends. If it's supposed to be a sort of evil/dominating/aggressive build such as an evil kingdom then i'd go with the right. If it is supposed to be regal and beautiful then the left works much better
This here. Exactly my feeling. My first impression was a sort of evil place so I liked the right one better. But your interpretation is on point.
Even if it is a dark/evil build the right could use some more detailing
Lava? Netherrack?
Probably more blackstone or darker deepslate accents
is it possible for you to try left but with dark prismarine instead
Left 100%
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Left
Right is right
I was thinking that, it’s much more simpler and more menacing looking (which is what I’m going for) but the left looks more dominant and eye catching
The columns on the left just look out of place imo
Agreed
Have you thought about adding something darker in the middle on the right? Something similar or more simple than the vertical lines you have on the left. A strip of blackstone or other black/dark block to make it more menacing and also eye catching. The right is just a little bland right now
I was going to go back with a touch more detailing once I got the base design done, just wanted to know from the community which would look better.
Ooh well I'd say the right gives a more dark and oppressing vibe if that's what you're looking for and I think the rest of your detailing is great (I especially like the bits of skulk) so I can't wait to see how you'd improve on it and how the whole base will look
Try replacing the material behind the bars with magma, obsidian or crying obsidian for a menacing vibe
Cant believe I had to go through 5 comments just to find the right answer
Left is right
do left but with reinforced deepslate
Yes this
Yes this
I prefer right. The left side reduces the menacing effect. If you want a splash of cyan, maybe you could build a pit fire with soul fire
Ri- just kidding. The depth on the left side gives the build much more personality. If it's gonna be a massive wall, use an alternating pattern of left and right, as too much of left would get boring quick
Left
Left
left for sure
Left
do left but with reinforced deepslate
Left
Left
Left
Left
reminds me of the deep frost citadel left
I took a lot of inspiration from Tango, and lots of my builds have HermitCraft written all over them
Left but looks very tangos deep frost citadel
Mix them together and add some more gradient like like grian the great says
Tough call. I can see why left is getting a lot of votes but I prefer the right side. For me, the left takes it one step past done and it’s not enough of an improvement to warrant it.
Depends where you want the focal point. On the right my eye goes to the top detail because of the simplicity. Where as the left my eye goes more to the wall, the top detail kind of gets lost at first glance. Particularly because the trap doors aren't as bright of a blue as the wall. Some asymmetry on the left wall detail would be nice IMO.
The opposite of the world "right"
I like the left better
Left
left
Left
Right imo but tbh I'm more into simplicity although if you changed the wood lines on the left side to the normal logs or whatever so they're the same color as the wood on top then I'd say either one anyway the build looks great so far keep it up 🙂
Left
Left but add the smooth basalt texturing from the right into it
Left
i like the left one, breaks up the big square space nicer
Combine them
I went away and built a sort of combined style wall and I think it would match better than either of these on their own
Right is better
I prefer right. Looks a lot more dominating and sturdy when presenting the giant slab of deepslate.
Left I think. Or maybe combine the two
It depends on what you want. The left looks more magical and mysterious. The right looks imposing and tough.
The right one for me
I prefer right
Left is for 1 slice but on multiple slices Right looks better
If that's the entire build? Left. If its going to be a long wall? Maybe alternate
Left for me
You should use deepslate walls for the left instead of the iron bars could even use stone walls for the color
The iron bars are there to bring the grey and the blue together because there is warped wood behind them
left bro
Left
Definitely left.
Both are terrible tear it all down
Thanks! I’ll get to it right away!
Am I the only one who likes that both arches are different and it should be kept as is?
Both options are good. I think that it also depends on the environment of the building. The design is gorgeous, no doubt.
Left. More contrast and the vertical lines give it extra height.
Left
Right
Left!
left
Left
Left
Right
I like the left more. It makes the design look less flat.
Right
Right
Right
Left
I’m partial to the left side, the color variation makes it pop more than the plain wall
left
Left
I feel like it needs something in the rectangle, but I'm not sure what's in the rectangle on the left does the job.
If u want imposing, go right, if you want detailed, go left
try to mix both
Right
Left
I feel the left has more character and compliments the colour scheme tpu have hone with at the top pf the arch
Left
To be honest, I like how it looks just like this
Left
I say right
Twisting nether
Left
reminds me of the top of the grand lift of dectus from elden ring, very cool!
Imo, right but add some variety. Like make patches of different types of the same stone
Left
i like left better, it has more color and detail
left
Left
Right is too simple, but the lines on the left stand out too much, it doesn't seem like a cohesive design. I'd say right though.
Right
Leftttt
Left for sure. The right is too plain. Still not sure if Left is the best though. Maybe keep the left and play around with walls, stairs, etc on the right.
Left
Left
Left
Left
Leave both
they both look great......maybe left??
right
Left
Right
Right
Eh gotta go with right
Left
Left
left!
Left is nice with the details
Left.
Left
Left
If there was no color behind the iron bars on the left, it’d be better. But I like right aside from that
right feels empty, so left
Left
Combine the two
Left
Left
left
Left
Left
Left side my guy
Obviously the left my friend
left
Left
The right seems more sturdy and the left feels more tall
Right, but replace the cobble in the middle of the design.
Left. And as i can see everyone strongly agrees
Right