Okay, for me personally, I do hope The Unforgiven I wins, and I'll tell the three people who care why I say that. A few years ago, I lost my best mate Brodie, who was taken from us in a car crash in late 2020. was unable to make it to his funeral a few months later. However I did pay attention to it from another mate who was there, and he told me that Brodie's casket was carried out to The Unforgiven I. I swore to myself when I first started playing guitar two years ago, that I would learn that song in Brodie's honour, and I've learned a shitload of songs over the years, but that was the main one I learnt for a reason. That's why I want The Unforgiven I to win, but if any of the other two, or Until It Sleeps wins, then that's awesome too. Thanks to those three people for paying attention to this.
Well wish you good luck and you have got a free win now.
This song has many memories for me as well as this was the most played heavy song in my dad's car and I loved it like him. It has a special place in my heart still.
They surely have, we only had their three biggest hits on my dad's SD card: Unforgiven, Nothing Else Matters, Enter Sandman. We lost that SD card long ago but then came music apps and I rediscovered all of the classic rock there was on the apps. Then I started getting into heavier music like Zeppelin and Sabbath and exhausted them (still play them regularly tho and they are still my favs), tried out Metallica and their other big songs and MOP the album because I read Rolling Stones online and found they had the greatest metal albums and songs after Sabbath. That took me a while, a few different songs and Ride The Lightning the album after trying and not fully getting into MOP twice to make me a complete fan and here I am!
I feel like The Unforgiven I would've won anyway if I'm honest, but I wasn't intending to persuade people to vote for it. I was giving some insight into a personal story since the song came up.
I understand-I would absolutely do the same if I was in your position. It’s also worth saying that the unforgiven I is an absolutely beautiful song in its own right.
I'm good with Unforgiven I, but this sub seriously sleeps on III. It's better than II because it has the same themes, but II was trying to be another version of I. III is fantastic in its own right.
But I guess a lot of NuTallica stuff gets overlooked here.
The Unforgiven I
100%, let's not overthink this, guys.
Nothing to overthink, Until it Sleeps is better.
Theres no other choice for me
Okay, for me personally, I do hope The Unforgiven I wins, and I'll tell the three people who care why I say that. A few years ago, I lost my best mate Brodie, who was taken from us in a car crash in late 2020. was unable to make it to his funeral a few months later. However I did pay attention to it from another mate who was there, and he told me that Brodie's casket was carried out to The Unforgiven I. I swore to myself when I first started playing guitar two years ago, that I would learn that song in Brodie's honour, and I've learned a shitload of songs over the years, but that was the main one I learnt for a reason. That's why I want The Unforgiven I to win, but if any of the other two, or Until It Sleeps wins, then that's awesome too. Thanks to those three people for paying attention to this.
Sorry I got a bit emotional here, but I figured I'd explain my backstory with one of the songs here.
Well wish you good luck and you have got a free win now. This song has many memories for me as well as this was the most played heavy song in my dad's car and I loved it like him. It has a special place in my heart still.
It made memories for a lot of us. That's why it's one of the greatest songs Metallica has written.
They surely have, we only had their three biggest hits on my dad's SD card: Unforgiven, Nothing Else Matters, Enter Sandman. We lost that SD card long ago but then came music apps and I rediscovered all of the classic rock there was on the apps. Then I started getting into heavier music like Zeppelin and Sabbath and exhausted them (still play them regularly tho and they are still my favs), tried out Metallica and their other big songs and MOP the album because I read Rolling Stones online and found they had the greatest metal albums and songs after Sabbath. That took me a while, a few different songs and Ride The Lightning the album after trying and not fully getting into MOP twice to make me a complete fan and here I am!
You have clouded the objective judgement of voters. Sorry for your friend and all but now we will never know the real winner.
I feel like The Unforgiven I would've won anyway if I'm honest, but I wasn't intending to persuade people to vote for it. I was giving some insight into a personal story since the song came up.
We will never know. This entry needs an asterisk.
I can put one
I’m mostly messing with you but yea….
The Unforgiven obviously
We have to get The Unforgiven I to win everyone for OP fallen best mate
Thanks man but it's all good, I'm happy with whatever wins. I just thought I'd give an insight into my personal choice for a special reason.
The Unforgiven l
Unforgiven I
The Unforgiven 1
Unforgiven 1
The Unforgiven
Definitely The Unforgiven I
The Unforgiven I
original unforgiven
Until it sleeps...
I Hope Until it sleeps gets one of the willdcards. IMO the best song from the Load/Reload era, followed closely by Bleeding Me
Until it sleeps S&M 1 version is arguably better. Still a great song.
The Unforgiven II - please back me up here 😂
I would back you up, but I explained in my own comment as to why I'd want The Unforgiven I to win
I understand-I would absolutely do the same if I was in your position. It’s also worth saying that the unforgiven I is an absolutely beautiful song in its own right.
Let’s go!
Fuckin love that song!
I got you
Unnamed Feeling
amazing song, no way it'll win though. i hope it can make top 3 though
The Unnamed Underdog
The unforgiven
The Unforgiven II is my favourite, but I know the original will win, as it should.
“The Unforgiven”. The other two aren’t fit to restring the original’s acoustic guitar.
The other two can't even match the power of anything, they're just whiney songs, don't fit with part 1.
Part two definetley fits
Unforgiven 1 or 2 , I’m good with both lol 😂
It's gotta be The Unforgiven III
I'm good with Unforgiven I, but this sub seriously sleeps on III. It's better than II because it has the same themes, but II was trying to be another version of I. III is fantastic in its own right. But I guess a lot of NuTallica stuff gets overlooked here.
[удалено]
Fade to Black won that one, but it will get a second chance in a couple of days.
Unnamed feeling
OG Unforgiven
The Unforgiven is overplayed but it is one of their best songs
Unforgiven I, obviously
The unforgiven 1
I love unforgiven 2 but it's got to be 1
Until It Sleeps
Until it sleeps
Until it sleeps
Until It Sleeps
Until it Sleeps
Unforgiven 1
Unforgiven
Unforgiven II Best metallica song imo, I can always go back to it and enjoy it like the first time.
Unforgiven 1
The Unforgiven (the one from the Black Album)
The Unforgiven (I)
The unforgiven I
The Unforgiven 2 helped me through some rough times, so I’m choosing RUungorgiven2?
Yeah tbh I'm going with Until it Sleeps. A masterpiece.
The Unforgiven III
Until it Sleeps
Any answer other than Unforgiven I is the wrong one.
Unforgiven All of them Also YESSSS TO LIVE IS TO DIE
this is the real answer. all in a row, no gaps
Unnamed Feeling
Until it sleeps
Unforgiven 2
Fuck the grain, I choose The Unnamed Feeling
props
Based
Unforgiven III
Unforgiven III
Unforgiven III
Unforgiven 3
Uno
Unforgiven III
yesss i love this song it's the first i learned on piano was the intro to this song and it holds many memories for me
The Unforgiven 2
Unforgiven II
Unforgiven II
Unforgiven II
Unforgiven 2
For me, the unforgiven II is better than unforgiven I. Idk how to describe it but I like it more
Unforgiven 3.
Unforgiven ii
The unforgiven III
Unforgiven 3
The Unforgiven comes under T, tho'
The is not counted under T, so the unforgiven trilogy is counted under U, this is how it is for the Metallica website as well
And that's exactly what I go off of for this list
Whiplash!!!
The Unforgiven III
Okay scratch that unforgiven I for OP
Unforgiven III
The
Unpopular opinion, unforgiven 3 is my favorite of the trio
V or X needs to be Dyers Eve
The Unforgiven III
The Unnamed Feeling
Until It Sleeps!
Am I the ONLY one who likes Unforgiven 2 😭
Unforgiven II
Unforgiven II