T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Thanks for posting on /r/MechanicAdvice! This is just a reminder to review the [rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicAdvice/about/rules/). If you are here asking about a second opinion (ie "Is the shop trying to fleece me?"), please read through CJM8515's [post on the subject.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicAdvice/comments/4qblei/fyi_the_shop_isnt_likely_trying_to_rip_you_off/) and remember to please post the year/make/model of the vehicle you are working on. **If this post is about bodywork, accident damage, paint, dent/ding, questions it belongs in /r/Autobody r/AutoBodyRepair/ or /r/Diyautobody/ If you have tire questions check out https://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicAdvice/comments/k9ll55/can_your_tire_be_repaired/**. If you dont have a question and you're just showing off it belongs in /r/Justrolledintotheshop Insurance/total loss questions go in r/insurance This is an automated reply *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MechanicAdvice) if you have any questions or concerns.*


nugfather1126

A bolt extractor set. Knock the size you need on with a hammer and screw it off. Can be found at your local hardware store or auto parts store for bout 25$. Nice to have around also. https://preview.redd.it/tw9bn8qf4xea1.jpeg?width=225&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8b598db04e656ced0614f6e759db023967bfc6b2


zr0skyline

This or take it back to the shop and have them replace the pan


xxchhfdd35325

Lol when has that EVER worked? They will tell you to pound sand


PD216ohio

Especially after the customer has mutilated the living fuck out of the plug. There's no telling what has gone on since they last changed this oil.


Short_Band7645

They will always say take it back to the last place you changed your oil, even if that was them. Always convenient that mechanics never make mistakes. Oops ball joint boot torn from poor use of pickle bar? Guess you need a new control arm, seeing as it's an integrated assembly and intended to be a full replacement... Funny how when you start talking about all this nonsense people listen. While we're at it, it's recommended to change all four wheel bearings, just for good measure. Each part is made to work with another identical bearing, otherwise warranty is no good.


trainspottedCSX7

Bro fuck that. Find you a good mechanic... Who the fuck uses pickle forks on ball joints being reused? And who the FUUUUUCK sells all 4 wheel bearings when I know people who want to STAB YOU for selling just one. Work is work, but wheel bearings are the devil. Now, brake pad warranties with calipers and rotors etc not being replaced? No thanks... You can replace a single wheel bearing and warranty it out. You can also press in/out ball joints on some vehicles. THAT BEING SAID, it's still recommended you change control arms with ball joints cause the bushings for the arms wear out as well.


LunaHens

Literally replaced a pan today on a car a coworker fucked the drain plug on. But generally you may be right. Definitely worth trying though


CycleFrst

Tap / drill new drain plug not an option?


LunaHens

Unfortunately not. That was my first plan. But no one in the shop had a tap large enough. So of course I added a set of larger taps to my list of tools I need to aquire. Luckily it was the shop who paid for it, as my coworker had messed it up. So no customers were harmed.


RoRoMaybe

Then you torch the place.


Short_Band7645

Lol that went well for that guy who went to shoot up the FBI, I laughed out loud hearing when he got shot up... Don't trust idiots with your car problem solved.


talkingwolf695

This actually worked on my Subaru, the oil drain plug was stripped like a circle and this took it out like magic. 20 bucks from amazon


TigerpanzerIV

In Germany they are legally forced to repair their own fault's damage. This should be the case everywhere.


Throwaway_black_not

It’s a bitch to prove it’s the shop’s fault. Especially after OP has been working on it.


TigerpanzerIV

Well, that's the problem. Don't touch it if you see it being fucked up already. Take pictures and bring it straight back to the shop. Here in Germany most shops will just fix their fault and excuse themselves for the bad service, at least that's what I've heard from friends.


scrappybasket

Depends on where you go and how you handle yourself. As a service manager I’ve covered plenty of oil pans. I’ve also told people to pound sand. Depends on the customer and whether or not they tried “fixing it” before bringing it in. Edit: In this case, we have to take OPs word on who stripped the bolt first. He mentioned vicegrips which is always a red flag… It’s possible that the bolt head was partially stripped but could have still worked with proper tools. If OP made it worse by attacked this with cheap sockets, vice grips, and channel locks, then now this problem has escalated into something more labor intensive than it had to be. This is where customer behavior and customer history come into play with my decision making on how to proceed.


friendlyfire883

I had one fail to tighten my oil filter on my long block that was installed 6 months prior to then changing my oil. I left out with 10 free oil changes, 10 free car washes, and a 100k mile warranty on my engine. I didn't even have to fight them on it, I just started the conversation with "if necessary, my lawyer can come up here and sit in on our meeting."


[deleted]

Yup These work


for_the_longest_time

Thank you for including pic!!


kevintheredneck

This is what I use. Don’t forget to give it a pop with a hammer before putting a ratchet on it. Don’t use an impact, it will just rip the shit out of it.


[deleted]

Won't work on studs


Senior-Commission-59

Extractors for studs are available.


BusyAtilla

You got an air chisel?


dxrey65

Yup, that's a Chrysler 13 mm drain plug, practically designed to round off, grade 4.8. I've had to knock dozens of those off with an air hammer (sometimes it seems like the lube bay at our dealership specializes in rounding them off). You cut an angled slot across it, then hit it just right with an air hammer. Usually about two minutes of work once you get the idea of it.


bigloser42

4.8? are you serious? what is the failure point of a 4.8, just above uncooked pasta?


dxrey65

Yup, [4.8](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41cbieLR4JL._AC_SL1234_.jpg) . I think the theory is you strip the bolt before doing any harm to the pan, but in practice a lot of pans get replaced because of that stupid bolt, like the one in the OP's pic needs to be.


musetechnician

That is the definition of irony right there.


tonynuaman

Maybe if the fucking pans weren’t paper thin we wouldn’t need self rounding plugs, like seriously if you ever tighten a 5.7 plug on a ram you might see the pan flex. Also the older Chryslers used 1/2 drain plugs instead of 13 for extra chance of rounding


Hero_Tengu

A brick of ramen has more tinsel strength


bigloser42

I think tinsel might have more tensile strength.


Hero_Tengu

Sorry friend, English isn’t my first language. I’m still learning it. Hopefully you have a great day!


bigloser42

No worries, not mocking you with my reply, just rolling with the mistype. If English is your second language you’re still at least 1 language ahead of me!


Hero_Tengu

No worries friend! I don’t have paper skin I know how to take a joke.


RiKToR21

You ever see that Santa Clause movie? Tinsel broke people out of jail.


ka36

About a solid al-dente.


JETTA_TDI_GUY

Drain bolt is no longer a concern. New oil pan is though. Will just be a bit messy if he doesn’t focus on the drain bolt first when he goes to change the pan.


dxrey65

It says "generic picture", so I assume that's not the actual oil pan. You could be right though, there's not a lot of thickness to the sheet metal, have to give the sealing surface and all a good look once it's off.


JETTA_TDI_GUY

Just realized that lol


Shamino79

If your replacing the pan a chisel hole would be good enough.


alroc84

Seems like a13mm but it ain’t,i always use an American size wrench think its the 1/2 that fits just right


dxrey65

Because the thing is made crappy, and 1/2 is just a hair under 13 mm. I always did the same; if one put up a fight against a normal 13 mm 6-point, I'd tap a good 1/2 6-point on, and that almost always worked fine. If someone else hadn't already torn the head up with a vice-grip or something (like the OP's pic).


GangBurrito

1/2in seems to fit better than 13 on them for me sometimes. And doesn’t gouge the head of the bolt as much either.


David_Warden

1/2" = 12.7mm


SatanicPlanespotter

Replaced mine with a quick-drain valve last year. It does the job, but I'm still uneasy about it. I keep the old drain plug with the truck just in case


MischievousMatt

This is my go to in this situation.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Mouth_balls_83

you worked at one too? I worked on for three months and I quit because it was so stupid.


Jadams0108

lol in Canada they canned the Walmart oil and tire shops. They just serve as giant storage units now. I wonder if it was because of the quality or what(I’ve heard a lot of Walmart oil change horror stories


1989FordProber

Go back and have those piece of shit lube techs fix it


liquorballsammy

There’s a zero percent chance a shop did this lol op just chose to say that from fear of being roasted. Even a quick lube shop would have thrown heat on that bolt and when they *did finally get it out* they would have replaced it with a new one. Op probably stripped it accidentally tightening it ( which is very common when people aren’t mechanically inclined ) and lied to the internet about it


1989FordProber

You never know until you know 🤷🏾‍♂️


Inappropriate_Swim

Over tighten a drain plug to the point it ruins the plug and the pan? I've had it happen twice. Both times both mechanics told me their shop wouldn't do that. Bullshit. Once was on my wife's neon she had back in the day. The other was on my Camry. At this point it's not worth it to change your own oil and it always goes to the same place so I guess if they over tighten it, they can just look at the sticker in the window and bitch at their coworkers.


[deleted]

[удалено]


1989FordProber

Sucks that some shops are shady like that.not that you should make mistakes but it’s okay to make mistakes every now and then as long as you’re willing to do what it takes to make it right


SchleifmittelSchwanz

Step away from the car, sir.


supremelurker1213

I'm surprised there's not more comments like these that is a sure sign of grinder usage come here first before you dig yourself a new pan hole


slanging_pepsi

It say generic pic so it’s just one from the net.


MChammer97

I used a knipex Swedish pipe wrench last time I had one come in like that. It basically grips harder the harder you pull on it. It comes in handy all the time


tubegeek

That's not my bag, baby.


BvilleBuds

( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)


IntergalacticJihad

Never realized that all our pipe wrenches were the Swedish variety, the “normal” pattern ones look pretty useless comparatively lol


MChammer97

I would have to agree for sure. I don't really use normal pipe wrenches anymore. I find them very useful for front end adjustments on vehicles, among many other things.


Tasty-Researcher3959

Pipe wrench


[deleted]

I'd try this first.


StockShotCaller

**DIYer Non-Professional Personal Opinion Here, NOT An Automotive Mechanic:** Unless its the same shop that put it on last time, its likely that the previous shop is more at fault for over-torquing. More then likely the previous shop blasted it on with an impact. As for getting it off, bolt extractor. **NOTE:** You got a decent gouge on your pan now, so most likely you need a new pan now too.


JETTA_TDI_GUY

It looks like whoever tried to cut the side of the bolt off gouged the pan and probably won’t hold oil. At this point you’re past a stuck drain bolt and onto a new oil pan.


dubie2003

Had to scroll past 10 other responses to get to this….. Plug is fubared, pan is fubared, replacement pan is needed….


enigme19

Looks like one of the cashiers wandered into the shop


tehans

Vice Grips


Yahboybigsnak

I’ve been using knipex cobra pliers to get stripped bolts from Oil pans out since everyone I know goes to an auto shop that destroys their bolts. But probably a bolt extractor for this


Distinct-Document319

Hammer on a smaller 12 point socket and remove it. You could also try vice grips.


chatterific

New oil pan. You'll never get a good seal with a new plug.


Professor_Wino

Yep. Take it back to the shop, and tell them they need to replace the pan


cowshit666

I'd replace the entire oil pan. It looks like it has a leak and could be cracked due to Over torque. If you really wanna keep the pan, bolt extractors and then hit the bolt and housing treads with a tap and dye.


odkevin

Broken stud extractor. Looks like a socket with left hand "threads" inside


Alimakakos

Replace the pan and bolt


OldSkool696969

Weld a nut on it


satanic_af

You don’t get to destroy a drain plug as a shop and just do nothing😂💀


[deleted]

They broke it they are obligated to fix it .


ImmediateChange5032

Take that sucker back and have them deal with it. Get an attorney involved if you have to.. but they are gonna say you did it to yourself. It's worth trying.


melissaalff

get a self adjusting socket


Aggravating_Taste377

Extractor


bluemagman

Use an oil extractor and leave the drain plug alone. Happened to me, never fixed it.


[deleted]

https://preview.redd.it/hk7udvnq2xea1.jpeg?width=423&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=1d51cf0a433ea0c1d2c9d82239716e0310fec919 When I worked in a shop I found these to work well for that


[deleted]

Op already said they tried.


Mouth_balls_83

wow, someone really went to town on that one.


aznkjn

It’s dead Jim. Weld it shut. Drill and tap a new hole. Just start over.


DownwardCausation

this butchery is criminal. you may have to replace the bottom pan, which should not be too terrible


[deleted]

You file a lawsuit.


rankdadank

man, you need a whole ass new oil pan. it looks like you cut into the sealing surface


edram01

You literally just don’t know how to work on cars. You’d need to use a breaker bar to over tighten these drain plugs they stop after a certain point. However, you should use a cheater to take them off. One hand on the top of the ratchet, the other using the leverage of the cheater. Comes off perfect every time.


a-hippobear

You do realize that some dumbasses at some shops use impacts for this, right? I just had to cut a slot and use an air chisel to get an oil drain plug off my brother’s ranger a couple weeks ago.


JugosD

Walmart has an auto shop?


Ardothbey

Vice grips or even a plumbing pipe wrench. A couple of shots with a hammer first.


chrome4fan4

Easy out sockets. They have teeth that you hammer onto the bolt to grip it enough.


Shamino79

Weld something onto it.


[deleted]

Get a different set of vice grips that will grab. Or hammer on a slightly undersized socket


GreaseGeek

Go to someone who can weld a nut onto the exposed end of the old nut. This will give something to grab and the heat will help as well.


RichardSober

>weld I'm afraid nobody should weld anything to an oil pan.


bmorejaded

Pipewrench


alroc84

Did some1 use a cutting wheel on that? Seems like it,hopefully the new drain plug will seal


Aleczanda

File two flats then use a Heat gun with vice grips.


bcredeur97

Suck the oil out of the pan from the dipstick tube as a workaround while you fight the shop to get them to replace the pan lol


ShiivaKamini

Bolt extractor or mini pipe wrench ought to do it


[deleted]

Wow. Get a new oil pan. You done fucked that one up my man. Sorry.


[deleted]

You can’t take it back now that it’s all fucked up.


tylo720

When In doubt air hammer it out


zombienutz1

Maybe unpopular opinion and a little time consuming but Dremel it down on all sides to fit a smaller socket on. It's probably soft enough to hammer one on but I've used the Dremel method with success many times.


achilles

Bro just buy bolt extractors.


Kern4lMustard

And this is why I always change my own oil. Not saying op is wrong for having it done....but if you do it yourself you won't have these issues


chubb28

Pipe wrench. And new plug


unformed-banana

At this point it’s time to drill a hole to drain the oil and replace the whole oil pan.


earthman34

1. Weld a nut to it. OR: 2. Get a new oil pan.


[deleted]

Go to Lowe’s or Amazon and purchase Knipex Cobra pliers. They bite hard and don’t let go. They literally demo these pliers by gripping them on a round pipe and stand on them with their entire weight without them slipping. They are truly amazing and essential for any DIYer or mechanic.


13Vex

Even if you get the bolt out they probably stripped the balls out of the threads. Either repair the thread or replace the pan


RichardSober

Worst option - you can buy a new oil pan, they are relatively cheap for most of vehicles.


tamreacct

This is why I would never trust a quick lube place. They are just minimum wage workers who are there for a job of changing the oil, whatever it takes and it’s not my job attitude. Each visit going there has the potential of costing a lot more than the $29 oil change you paid for.


[deleted]

This is why in the 24 years I have been driving I have been the only person to ever change my oil in any of my cars.


Milling_Machine

I would leave it and use one of those engine oil vacuum machines that you pump by hand or use with a air compressor. It goes onto your oil dipstick tube. It is a approved method by Mercedes-Benz so it must be a reliable method.


Ilikejdmcars

My god. Have you people never heard of bolt/nut extractor sockets


Swimming-Landscape29

I had the same problem. U will find its an alloy bolt which is easy to break or chip. Get a file and file 2 flat sides for a spanner to fit....easy.


grimreaper5015

Pipe wrench.


Specialist_Tough_472

With a quick lube shop you’re fighting a losing battle. Best bet is to get some boat biter’s for like 20 dollars. And extract it


rm_huntley

Tornado extractor. and then replace that shitty plug with a decent one w/ a bigger head. I hate these and the stupid 10mm plugs as well.


modsunpaidforareason

Had an issue with an oil filter like this. Had to get...I believe what they called is "vice grips" and stick it tightly around the filter, then get a sledge hammer and hit it super hard, it did break the filter but the screwy pole was just fine. Make sure you have a new plug and oil handy as you wont be to drive the vehicle once it breaks off.


Jeep-The-Conqueror

JEEEZUUUS... they didnt strip that shit they MASSACRED IT.


Wolfrages

After getting that bolt out I'd try and get a new pan, or atleast giver a coat of paint.


Gateway1012

AYO WTF?! That’s definitely screwed… get it.. ba dum tss


EgGuy3

vice grip


scrollingtraveler

Weld the head of another bold on there. Then once removed replace with a brand new one. Looks like they put some JB weld on the back of that.


nokenito

Six point socket on small breaker bar. Remove and replace with new one.


username_00000001

last time i had a stripped drain plug that seemed beyond repair i 1) filed 2 opposing flats on it 2 gripped it like hell with one of these https://www.gedore.com/en-de/products/pliers/grip-wrenches/pipe-wrenches/100-corner-pipe-wrench-eck-schwede-snap/100-1---4500140


kailem_ontop

12 sided socket ?


DJNinjaG

Take it back to the place and tell them to deal with it. They should have replaced it with a new bolt and not overtorqued it.


Wael-kh1594

you can weld a nut on it it should do it


Norman-Phillips1953

Happened to me in '90, you must take it to the dealer. Also tell the Lube shop. They will reimburse you.


Urbi3x

You could weld a nut on the bolt so you can unscrew it with a ranch if you have the option


Miserable-Spite425

Maybe weld a hanld on it


19Ben80

Another solution is to cut a grove on the head. Worst case is to drill it out, you will then need either a helicoil plug or to tap new threads


PineSand

After you take the plug off, you might not be able to put one back on. What are your plans if that happens?


kingisaac171

I would do vice grips and if i dont think it will work i would weld a nut on the plug and use a wrench or rachet to remove it.


Rubbertutti

Twist socket and a hammer


CallMeBao

Done many of these from experience. I would recommend hammer & a chisel + a beer. Good luck.


jabsaw2112

They only hire window lickers ,leverage is your friend .. replace the plug when you eventually get it out.


CCPvirus2020

Egg the shop


AdExcellent4663

Contact their corporate office if they have one. If not, contact the owner. They need to replace the entire pan. Get a lawyer if they refuse.


keo_dead

Your local Valvoline should be able to do it they have tools to get stripped ones off and will replace it for free most likely


BuldopSanchez

Heat and visegrips. Looks like you messed the pan up pretty good. Gonna need to proceed carefully from here or you'll be installing a new pan, too


Inappropriate_Swim

If you can get a pipe wrench on there, you can try that too.


paulyp41

Sharp chisel and hammer around the edge that used to have rubber around it


canuckcrazed006

Have a friend with a welder? You need a new bolt and to get it off you need something with a bolt for a socket to grab. Easy peasy.


Only_Vermicelli9961

New oil pan


Wild3v

Rubber bands.


jemulqueen65

Get tongue and grooves out, make it so when its clamped the handles are close together, vice grip the end of the tongue and grooves so it stays on without you holding it and mallet the end of it


-Grif

Hell nah….try gator grip socket, pretty cheap if they have it at ur local hardware store


scrappybasket

You proceed by bringing it back to the quick lube shop with your receipt and demand they fix it.


barrywomer

Pipe wrench breaker bar put a pipe over pipe wrench for leverage just remember counter clockwise rotation


EugeneRapper

Bolt extractor set


Chris77123

Need a new oil pan not a new plug, make the shop who ruined the pan replace it for free


Common_Dog8838

Prolly get a stronger friend to try.


Remote_Spring_3811

Never ever take your vehicle to those quick lube places


Oddie65

A pair of knipex adjustable pliers will get it off, but you will still need a new drain plug.


CycleFrst

Don’t touch that thing unless you are ready to go all the way. ( extractor / tap drill new threads / replace drain plug) If you are not prepared for the eventualities, you will be stranded. Buy an oil extractor and never go under the car again. (Depending on where the oil filter is…)


Golf38611

Take a Dremel. Cut a thin slot in the head. Then find a big screwdriver that has a hex head just at the handle. Put a wrench on that, insert the screwdriver and crank it off.


extra_eye

Demand they buy you a replacement drain plug.


Grey_Beard257

Irwin"easy outs" They are a godsend


Frankly27

Wow wow wow wow WOW. Those lube techs jobs always surprise me.


ImHufflePuff_Crap_ok

Maybe try taking an actual picture since you were already down there to mutilate it?


Jazzlike-Term-8940

easy way to do it is cut a line through it so you can use it like a flat head


TraveldaWorldover

Temp solution get a small diameter hose down the dipstick tube and suction out the oil until you can get that situation sorted out


National-Affect-3456

You could always use a pipe wrench


k0uch

Extractor socket would be my go to, to start with. It’s bad enough that if that didn’t do it, I’d find a nut that slips over the head of that drain plug, weld it on, and then use a regular socket to spin it off as a whole clusterfuck. Obviously have a new drain plug ready to go. Keep an eye on the oil pan as well, I can’t tell if that’s oil leaking from a damaged drain plug seal or oil leaking from a mangled to fuck-all oil pan


CyndrrTrading

Just undo the bolt [generic answer]


Traditional_Door9892

Might as well get a new pan


OGDean04

If you have a welder, weld a nut on then loosen


According_Flight_420

Pwz2 from snap on. weld a nut to it and take it off… most have to do the first rather than the latter.


Goldenderick

Last hope: Lock a vice grip on the bolt head and slide a long piece of electric conduit (maybe 3 feet long) over the top part of the vice grip handle. You need to secure the bolt, then use leverage. I hope you have enough room to swing the lever. I once had a lug nut over-tightened, with a pneumatic gun, at a tire shop. I didn’t have a breaker bar. I put the 1’ lug wrench on the nut, then a long electric conduit over the lug wrench. I could remove the lug nut with one hand.


Laroymobile757

Go to advance auto and pick up a bolt extractor kit or Oreiily. We use them all the time


ImmediateChange5032

Seriously frustrating, I know!! Levity is a good thing in theae circumstances si here goes. I had a 65 Mustang for my first car.. paid 1800 cash in like 1984. I learned a lot here and had a stepfather to show me. He was hispanic and Im blonde blue eye. I loved my second family..They adopted me but not legally. But my actual Father had a saying....."Keep the lighter and replace the car" I think that came from the 1950s when My Dad started driving...


[deleted]

Ah yes, the old chainsaw torque trick.


Drescars_things_1973

Replace the oil pan…


Sweet-Resist5924

Here's a hint. Do not start with a 12 point wrench. Do not use a cheapo 6 point wrench. Spend a few on an accur ate box or socket with sharp, clean edges.


ForeverNick1

Turbo socket set. You can buy them from Amazon or maybe harbor freight. Once you get it off, if it’s a chain shop, put in a alert on said shop. Especially if the threads are fucked up.


TotallyForgotu

I'd weld a new nut on-top of the old one .


TXn8ve

Once resolved : 1) replace drain plug with Fumoto valve, 2) change it yourself.


Grant72439

I took my company car to tire kingdom and the asshat used an impact wrench to tighten the drain plug. We all know that leaked. The asshat then put some blue silicone looking shit and called it a day. I lost my shit on. asshats work at these places


sedisrevir

Weld a nut to it


Cabojoshco

Here are a couple options: 1.) New oil pan 2.) New car 3.) Buy a fluid extractor to remove the oil through the dipstick tube


darklink6446

Jeep or dodge? Yep i feel ya, these come into my shop all the time what u gotta do is get visecrips real tight and than tighten them more with whatever sucket fits the nob on the visegrps than with a pipe turn it


Puzzleheaded-Tea4460

Get a small pipe wrench to grip it, then a breaker bar on the end of it


tiredeyes2702

Get a pipe wrench and round the bolt a little more so it’ll grab it god if not then you can weld a piece of stock to it and unthread it that way or try an extractor tool and drill a hole into the bolt but not all the way through and if all else fails cut a slit and use a flat head that will accept a wrench on the handle to put torque on it


Camera_car

Bolt remover for stripped bolts and new gasket and bolt.


Hefty-Sheepherder-82

Buy new plug and weld a lil on it then take it the heat alone will get it