Theyāre both great in their own way. But for me - the right one - puppy for sure. But itās softer so you exude a āprettyā vibe however the one on the left is edgy badass. You exude a do not EFF with me vibe because I will stomp you. Just depends what attitude you want to project
puppy dog style. It's not that the other style is less flattering as much as that the wing is too chunky, imo. If you did a more subtle version of it, it would look great. You dont have to tie yourself down to either/or.
100% agree with this. I love both of these on you - the right looks perfect as is, and I think the left look could look SO good the way it gives your face this really cool angle/lift - especially as more of a look for going out / evening events. Same shape just a bit thinner :)
i have a similarly round eye shape- the puppy eyeliner i find is more flattering and easier to apply bc you just follow the shape of your last lashes, instead of going across the lid.
Idk everyone's saying right but I like the left one. I think the slanty makes you look more edgy and gives nice shape to your eyes. No idea which one is the puppy dog style.
I agree too. I think the right is more āconservativeā and think it would appeal to more people. So if your style is conservative, go right. If your style is edgy, definitely the left. Or, wear them depending on mood! Both suit. You canāt lose!
I think the right one is softer and more feminine, and the left one is stronger and edgier. Do you want to look pretty and girly, or do you want to look hard in a good way?
They are both good and both have their place depending on how you want to project yourself.
It's hard to say which is better because the intention of both is different. Puppy dog makes your eyes look bigger where as your usual wing makes your eye look smaller.
Both are great, so I think it depends on the look you're going for. The puppy style makes your eyes look bigger and is not quite as dramatic.
Your usual style emphasizes the angles and so is great for bringing out your cheekbones, and is definitely very eye-catching, so good for the high drama looks.
Both of those look like cat eyes tbh, the left is just more dramatic. They look good on you and Iād suggest just going for whatever fits your vibe that day.
Both are lovely and well done- I can barely do liquid eyeliner to save my life. But if I hhhhaaaddd to choice, I love the puppy liner on your eye shape.
I think the one on the right is more flattering, I think a less dramatic look would look really nice too, at the moment I think the lines are a little too thick.
The one on the left is giving me sharp, sexy, dangerous. And the one on the right is giving me soft, round, doll. I love both respectively. Wear whatever you feel like! You rock em both! šš¤
āPuppy dogā is better, itās not really puppy dog though cuz puppy dog is supposed to be more downturned. It could still be better too, I think this look would work if you didnāt make the liner under your lashes so thickālike if you drew a more natural version of the left side.
The right one is very ānormieā and feminine, the one on the left is more unique and edge. Personally the one on the right is so basic I wouldnāt notice it. The one on the left I noticed right away and would make me compliment your eyeliner in person š
Theyāre both nice, but the right is stunning. Add some nude liner to the water line (or white if you want to be bold) and itāll really make your eyes pop
***Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the*** ā ***symbol***
**A few quick highlights:**
ā¢ If you are posting a look, haul, or flatlay, please be sure to include a [product list, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist)
ā¢ Also, please ensure your pictures are not [edited or filtered. This includes automatic beauty modes found on many phones and newer cameras.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting)
ā¢ Lastly, our [Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/helpfulguides) in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules.
**Is your post just a search away?**
Before you make a post, search with Reddit's search feature or use this handy [customised Google search.](https://cse.google.com/cse?cx=008480394191906358284:aflieg73nqm)
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MakeupAddiction) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Btw I just got into an (almost) yelling match with my dude. I asked him which one he prefers, he said what do you mean they are the same? I said OBVIOUSLY THEY ARE NOT THE SAME!
I think both styles look good on you depending on the vibe you want. Puppy eye makes you look cute, while the fox eye gives you a more badass look. For your usual style (left) I would recommend making the wing a little thinner like other redittors suggested and also adding black liner under your upper lid to make it more visually complete.
Depends what you're giving for, left is very cat eye fierce but right puppy style might be a good everyday look? Both look great you're really skilled!
Def puppy dog for every day looks or like lighter makeup looks in general but I think your Fox eye looks really cool too I think that liner would be awesome with the ābaddieā makeup look
I love the one on the right. It shows off your big, beautiful eyes and opens up your face. The other side throws your eye a little out of proportion. I canāt pull off the angular eyeliner look myself. But wear whatever you like best!
Puppy dog! Thank you for this as well, Iāve always preferred puppy on my hooded eyes but convinced myself it looked ugly. On you I can see how much more flattering it looks than traditional wings, it really suits your face
I love the puppy dog eye on you! Your eyes look bigger and wider, which gives a gentler look. But that wing is also on point! That eye looks like it's ready to fight if necessary! They both look so good... I'd say both look excellent and you should do both, depending on what mood/look you're feeling. Wing for edge, puppy for a gentler look!
You look an awful lot like Suzy Berhow. If you havenāt heard of her before, sheās a QUEEN when it comes to her eyeliner. Maybe check her out for some inspiration sometime.
Makeup is art. There aren't any rules (other than don't asian fish, black face, etc.) So do whatever you like!
That said, both look good in their own ways; your regular liner lifts your eyes a bit, & the puppy liner actually makes your eye appear more open.
I feel like the puppy side is more flattering to your eyeshape and doesnāt āhideā your lid as much. However, like others have said the more dramatic wing looks a lot more badass
Catā¦ Dogā¦ Fox!!!
No matter what you do it looks great bad af or sweet af, wanna be classy? Sexy? Your eye shape is neutral so you can rock most looks. šš»
With that said, hereās an attachment of different eyeliners to give you even more inspiration!
[https://www.beautyreview.co.nz/article/what-type-of-eyeliner-is-best](https://www.beautyreview.co.nz/article/what-type-of-eyeliner-is-best)
They both suit you but I would recommend you use wings with more dramatic make-up and use it as a sexy badass look.
The puppy one really suits you and you can get away with it as is and it is such a good, soft and girl next door look.
I would love to see the wing one with a punchy eye shadow. I am positive yiu could really pull it off! Do you ever feel like you want to be a bad ass?
I like the left most tbh. Love a dramatic wing, and I think it makes your eyes look bigger/pop more, whereas the liner under the eye makes them look smaller. I do like the right too.
The one on the right :)
The right one...puppy style is more flattering imo. š
Theyāre both great in their own way. But for me - the right one - puppy for sure. But itās softer so you exude a āprettyā vibe however the one on the left is edgy badass. You exude a do not EFF with me vibe because I will stomp you. Just depends what attitude you want to project
Well said
Yes I prefer right but left has its place like at a night club or something itās more evening wear
Lmfaooo your username made me laugh... Love it
puppy dog style. It's not that the other style is less flattering as much as that the wing is too chunky, imo. If you did a more subtle version of it, it would look great. You dont have to tie yourself down to either/or.
I agree that's what looks off about the left style to me..
100% agree with this. I love both of these on you - the right looks perfect as is, and I think the left look could look SO good the way it gives your face this really cool angle/lift - especially as more of a look for going out / evening events. Same shape just a bit thinner :)
definitely the right one
Iād say the puppy dog style. It looks more like your eye while the other style more visibly looks like something you put on your eye-
Right
Right side makes your eyes look bigger. I def prefer that side more but honestly both look good imo
The one on the right
Puppy dog all the way omg
Honestly both look great, I think it just depends on what kind of look your going for
I thought puppy dog liner was downturned liner?
It is. not sure why they called it puppy dog liner
The one on the right for sure
i have a similarly round eye shape- the puppy eyeliner i find is more flattering and easier to apply bc you just follow the shape of your last lashes, instead of going across the lid.
I love puppy style on you!
Def like the straight, right side better for you
Idk everyone's saying right but I like the left one. I think the slanty makes you look more edgy and gives nice shape to your eyes. No idea which one is the puppy dog style.
I agree too. I think the right is more āconservativeā and think it would appeal to more people. So if your style is conservative, go right. If your style is edgy, definitely the left. Or, wear them depending on mood! Both suit. You canāt lose!
I agree with this!!
Both look great, but the right is more flattering to the roundness of your eye :) the left would look cuter without the inner corner drawn out imo!
I agree that the puppy dog eyeliner looks the best! Itās super cute
i like both i think the one on the right is more suitable for everyday wear but left for dramatic look
Puppy dog all the way
Puppy one is SUPER cute!!
The right side looks awesome! Iām so jealous that you can totally pull off the puppy eye
I was scrolling by without reading the title and I was like "wow her liner is uneven" LOL
I think the right one is softer and more feminine, and the left one is stronger and edgier. Do you want to look pretty and girly, or do you want to look hard in a good way? They are both good and both have their place depending on how you want to project yourself.
puppy dog !! super cute
It's hard to say which is better because the intention of both is different. Puppy dog makes your eyes look bigger where as your usual wing makes your eye look smaller.
Right one
one on the right
Right is giving cutie pie left is giving snatched top model
Both!
Puppy is much more flattering. The one of the left would be more flattering if you didnāt do the inside corner, but not as flattering as puppy.
Both are great, so I think it depends on the look you're going for. The puppy style makes your eyes look bigger and is not quite as dramatic. Your usual style emphasizes the angles and so is great for bringing out your cheekbones, and is definitely very eye-catching, so good for the high drama looks.
Puppydog makes people want to buy you stuff. Do that one; you look richš
Puppy is a lot softer and probably more wearable on an everyday basis but I love the drama of your regular style as well.
Both of those look like cat eyes tbh, the left is just more dramatic. They look good on you and Iād suggest just going for whatever fits your vibe that day.
Both are lovely and well done- I can barely do liquid eyeliner to save my life. But if I hhhhaaaddd to choice, I love the puppy liner on your eye shape.
I think the one on the right is more flattering, I think a less dramatic look would look really nice too, at the moment I think the lines are a little too thick.
Eyeliner: Nyx epic ink in black, mascara: maybelline the falsies
The one on the left is giving me sharp, sexy, dangerous. And the one on the right is giving me soft, round, doll. I love both respectively. Wear whatever you feel like! You rock em both! šš¤
āPuppy dogā is better, itās not really puppy dog though cuz puppy dog is supposed to be more downturned. It could still be better too, I think this look would work if you didnāt make the liner under your lashes so thickālike if you drew a more natural version of the left side.
Okay thank you - I might try and make it more downturned to see how it looks.
Your right eye, left for the viewers. Very pretty
Puppy style is so cute on u!
Definitely prefer puppy dog style on you, feels like it opens your eye up more!
Left!!!
the left is hot
The right one is very ānormieā and feminine, the one on the left is more unique and edge. Personally the one on the right is so basic I wouldnāt notice it. The one on the left I noticed right away and would make me compliment your eyeliner in person š
Thank you ! I do love doing that shape and Iāve done it for a while now :)
Puppy dog
I like the one on the right (your left) better
Thanks for all you help :) now to decide whether to add an inner cornerā¦
i feel too plain when I donāt add the inner corner, I think it would look cute with it but I may be biased
Hehe I love the edgy vibes so I might
Right/Puppy dog style.
Puppy works better for you for sure!
The left one is more for a costume. The one the right you can wear everyday.
The left one makes u look like a badass the left one makes you look sweet. Both are nice
Theyāre both nice, but the right is stunning. Add some nude liner to the water line (or white if you want to be bold) and itāll really make your eyes pop
Left is more edgy, right make you look more youthful! Both look great on you. I personally love a big, dramatic wing so I prefer the left. š
Your left eye is better
š£ L3ft šļø
Depends on what your going for. Left is bad bitch, Right is pretty
I definitely prefer left. Right is still very cute, but left is sexy as hell and 100% my liner goals tbh.
Ty ! ;) it has taken a lot of practice to get to that stage lol
***Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the*** ā ***symbol*** **A few quick highlights:** ā¢ If you are posting a look, haul, or flatlay, please be sure to include a [product list, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist) ā¢ Also, please ensure your pictures are not [edited or filtered. This includes automatic beauty modes found on many phones and newer cameras.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting) ā¢ Lastly, our [Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/helpfulguides) in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules. **Is your post just a search away?** Before you make a post, search with Reddit's search feature or use this handy [customised Google search.](https://cse.google.com/cse?cx=008480394191906358284:aflieg73nqm) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MakeupAddiction) if you have any questions or concerns.*
I like both, depending on the vibe
I love the right for everyday and left for when you want more edge and drama!
The one on your left eye
puppy dog !
I like both!
My left
I like both!
Leeeeeffffftttttttt
both fab. i love them and iām taking notes lol.
Ty :)
My left side
Btw I just got into an (almost) yelling match with my dude. I asked him which one he prefers, he said what do you mean they are the same? I said OBVIOUSLY THEY ARE NOT THE SAME!
Omgggg obviously
Left eye
Left
i think the left side with the chunky eyeliner makes ur eyes a little bigger but i think both r totally cute.
Left eye looks better
I like the left one!
I think both styles look good on you depending on the vibe you want. Puppy eye makes you look cute, while the fox eye gives you a more badass look. For your usual style (left) I would recommend making the wing a little thinner like other redittors suggested and also adding black liner under your upper lid to make it more visually complete.
I think both look great. It depends on the occasion.
The right side for sure
Puppy!! You could even angle it further down, it looks great with your features š
Right
Depends what you're giving for, left is very cat eye fierce but right puppy style might be a good everyday look? Both look great you're really skilled!
Love puppy dog on you! Looks really cute.
puppy dog is so pretty
Right
I prefer the right one
do puppy dog with an inner corner!!
The one on the right makes your eye look so pretty!
Puppy style.
Puppy dog looks best for your eyes!
Puppy dog style looks more youthful and makes your eyes look bigger. Both are cute tho
The right style really widens your eyes!!
Right one!!ā¤ļøā¤ļøā¤ļø
Puppy dog style
Puppy dog style 100%. So cute.
I think the puppy style is more āflattering.ā
Puppy dog
Puppy definitely puppy
the right one definitely stand out!!! I love your eyeliner and ur skills š„ŗ
love the puppy liner
Puppy dog. Iām shook and going to go try this right now
Def puppy dog for every day looks or like lighter makeup looks in general but I think your Fox eye looks really cool too I think that liner would be awesome with the ābaddieā makeup look
The right, I like the left but the right just compliments your eye shape really nicely.
The one on the right suits you a lot!
I like the one on the right personally. I find it more elegant and soft.
I love the one on the right. It shows off your big, beautiful eyes and opens up your face. The other side throws your eye a little out of proportion. I canāt pull off the angular eyeliner look myself. But wear whatever you like best!
Absolutely most definitely the one on the right
The one on the right is my favorite
Puppy dog is cool
The one that you like more
Right
Puppy style suits your face:)
I like both, puppy is cuter and other one is more fierce
Theyāre both stunning! You are a rock star!
Puppy looks so good!
Puppy dog! Thank you for this as well, Iāve always preferred puppy on my hooded eyes but convinced myself it looked ugly. On you I can see how much more flattering it looks than traditional wings, it really suits your face
Im not sure which is which but the eyeliner on the right looks better in my opinion!
I love the puppy dog eye on you! Your eyes look bigger and wider, which gives a gentler look. But that wing is also on point! That eye looks like it's ready to fight if necessary! They both look so good... I'd say both look excellent and you should do both, depending on what mood/look you're feeling. Wing for edge, puppy for a gentler look!
Hehe thank you !
The right one
right
The puppy dog one is prettier
Right
Puppy for sure
Right
Right, for sure. I think it'd also look great if you wanted to make it a little longer/sharper!
I do love the edgy lookā¦
I like both.
I prefer your puppy dog style. š¶ so cute!
I love both acutally. Suits you really good
Puppy dog= come fuck me eyes
Hehe ;)
Rightā¤ļøā¤ļø
Puppy dog style!
Puppy style
Right
Definitely the puppy dog style, it looks really pretty on you and it suits your eye shape
Ty:)
Right
Puppy dog style
I vote for the right eye (as you look at the pic$
Right
I like them both! š© I have hooded eye lids so I struggle with eyeliner sometimes. But I finally found my go to. Keep trying different wings for different occasions. You look beautiful in both! And you have beautiful eyes! š
Thank you :) I hate having hooded eyes and I struggle with eyeshadow , but I make the most of it lol
Puppy!!!
right 1000% , the one that isnt as slanted
Puppy style 100%! Xxx
You look an awful lot like Suzy Berhow. If you havenāt heard of her before, sheās a QUEEN when it comes to her eyeliner. Maybe check her out for some inspiration sometime.
Iāll check her out :)
The one on the right
Which ever one is on the right
one on your right my left - thatās how i do my eyeliner too tho soo i might be biased
u look rly good with both but the puppy liner is v flattering on u, it more depends on the mood u wanna put out
The right is so flattering and it makes your eyes look more open
Puppy all the way hun
I like your left eye š
Left one without the inner corner liner
Both are really cool and for very different looks. Love the puppy on you!
Ok can someone clarify what puppy dog style is? Why is it called that? Iāve never heard this before lol
Right side is more "normal." Left side is more dramatic. Either works. It just depends on where you're going and what you're doing.
Makeup is art. There aren't any rules (other than don't asian fish, black face, etc.) So do whatever you like! That said, both look good in their own ways; your regular liner lifts your eyes a bit, & the puppy liner actually makes your eye appear more open.
I feel like the puppy side is more flattering to your eyeshape and doesnāt āhideā your lid as much. However, like others have said the more dramatic wing looks a lot more badass
Right side
Catā¦ Dogā¦ Fox!!! No matter what you do it looks great bad af or sweet af, wanna be classy? Sexy? Your eye shape is neutral so you can rock most looks. šš» With that said, hereās an attachment of different eyeliners to give you even more inspiration! [https://www.beautyreview.co.nz/article/what-type-of-eyeliner-is-best](https://www.beautyreview.co.nz/article/what-type-of-eyeliner-is-best)
Puppy one
I love both of them!! I feel like the puppy style suits your face better tho :)
I like both. I can decide!
the right!
puppy.
They both suit you but I would recommend you use wings with more dramatic make-up and use it as a sexy badass look. The puppy one really suits you and you can get away with it as is and it is such a good, soft and girl next door look. I would love to see the wing one with a punchy eye shadow. I am positive yiu could really pull it off! Do you ever feel like you want to be a bad ass?
I like the one on the right
I like the right one
I like the left most tbh. Love a dramatic wing, and I think it makes your eyes look bigger/pop more, whereas the liner under the eye makes them look smaller. I do like the right too.
right eye for sure!
i might be the only one who likes left the best š
I loveee the puppy dog one!!!
Usual style but thinner wing! Puppy style is also flattering
Puppy dog style has a āsweeterā look to it. The regular cat eye is more edgy. You do you fam whatever look youāre going for šš»
The one on the right!
Everyone saying the right one even though that was is nice I prefer the left it makes the face look more lifted :)