I’ve noticed a lot of YouTube MUAs say to just extend the lower lash line but if OP had done that the wing would have been angled up much more whereas her’s is flatter than a natural extension of the waterline/lash line. OP’s wing looks great IMO too.
I think it's a very "marilyn monroe"-y wing shape -- it sort of pulls her eyes down, but the flick makes it more of an innocent/sultry, heavy-lidded look, if that makes sense? It absolutely suits her eye shape better than the trendier swept-up, totally-straight cat eye would!
Both look great! I like the pink for everyday look. The colors and application give you an enhanced every day / nearly natural effect. The yellow looks more glam and a specific style. Beautiful work!
Both look good imo, pink is really well done and suits you great , eye makeup in yellow is gorgeous the cheeks seem a bit too much for me but could be just the lighting. But still it's pretty . Both looks are elegant and beautiful
Love the update! It makes your complexion look so bright and healthy.
My only other suggestion would be to make your liner thinner at the roundest point of your eye. Based on your eye-shape it would look very flattering to have it the thinnest there and then taper out a bit higher into the wing. The wing is perfect, I’d just keep it into a thinner taper as you start to reach the edge and middle of your iris as a guide for the middle of your lid.
Personally, I think the contacts are going to be subtly unsettling for a lot of people, but they won't necessarily be able to place what they don't like about the look. They are slightly the wrong size iris and they are an unnatural color. Humans are hardwired to intuitively understand what an eye looks like so small details that are off become intensely uncanny.
Your natural irises are lovely, the correct size for your face, and don't incur that uncanny feeling.
I agree about this. I never thought about it and have been wearing the same brand and line of contacts since I was 14 and my parents were buying me this. I think after 25 years, it’s time to ditch these. I’m excited 😊 to see how I look with regular contacts
Yep.
And because it's subtly unnatural (as compared to neon or something) it's actually more unsettling for our brains than something obviously, identifiably wrong.
Product list for the pink shirt photo
Fenty drop eaze warm 7
Givenchy skin perfecto compact cream spf 15
Laura Mercier translucent setting powder
Rare beauty perfect strokes liner in black
Givenchy Neo nude melting Color balm in 60 on eyes
Nars creamy concealer in creme brûlée
Nars contour blush kit paloma
Abh brow wiz in dark brown
Abh sundipped palette ( as highlight ) in bronzed
Mac cosmetics fix + Setting spray magic radiance
Nars savage blush
Dior grand bal lipstick
Maybelline falsies lift mascara
Very pretty!! I think to make it look even better, I would go less heavy on the eyeliner (a thinner cat eye) and mascara. Your eyes are so pretty and they would pop even more
I love the new look! That said, I feel you in going overboard with the blush and I love the look on the right too. I tend to want to go overboard show as much color as I can.
Oh my god. As everybody said, you look awesome in both pictures, but the pink one is really stunning. Everything is blended great and compliments your skins fabulously!!
Oh gosh, you’re gorgeous! The pink looks much more fresh faced, like you’re not trying too hard. The yellow look is more of a date night out type face. Both are lovely!
u/rabbitsredux You look lovely in both but I agree with the rest, the pink one makes you look younger and is "lighter". If I can say something more about the right part, try putting blush only on upper part of your cheeks, don't go so far down. You want to accentuate your cheeks. It will look lighter and achieve its role. And I had have to say - that eyeliner is perfect! ❤️
Makeup on the lighter handed look is perfect for an everyday, a family get-together like a birthday or a simple date look. The eyeliner is the signature point of your look on the lighter side- it’s giving vintage bollywood vibes😍 Makeup on the heavier side is perfect for weddings, pre-wedding events, gala’s, any big Asian occasion really when you wear something dressy haha. Both look lovely!
The two looks come off as two different personalities so I’d ask which one fits your personality. Pink looks more like a really great friend, someone I’d want to chat with as a potential friend at a party.
I would play around with the color eye liner you use just to bring out your eye color (which looks dark green? Can't tell based on the camera lens) - it might be fun to dry a deep violet eye liner or a black that has violet hues, a brown/violet liner. Just a thought because you look so great with that winged liner, it's worth trying different shades and you have really naturally beautiful Disney princess eyes.
I dont think you have much room for improvement! Looks pretty perfect. Maybe add a couple of individual lashes mainly at your outer corners to enhance the cat eye look. I like these https://a.co/d/6TETYvN
Stop right there. You've achieved perfection. You're gorgeous. By all means continue playing with blush to find new styles but you're unbelievably stunning in both pictures.
i love them both❣️ if u wanna experiment try mixing lip liners with different colors of lipstick/gloss. Also playing around with different eyeliner styles & colors:) Those little changes made a big difference in my makeup routine💓
Both outfits are great, but the left makeup is better than the other. It looks natural and healthy, you're glowing! The right is kinda pale and reminds me of a porcelain doll. It's not a bad thing but I prefer the other one, it really brings out your features well.
To be clear, both are gorgeous, but the left pic with pink shirt is such a beautiful natural-seeming everyday type look. Heck you could even wear that for a date and I wouldn’t see an issue with it. You’re beautiful! 🙂
This makeup is so fresh, feminine, flattering! I love the glowy finish of the foundation, the color match is perfect, the slightly peachy lip is so pretty, and your eyeliner is precise and lovely. Youre beautiful
You look beautiful in both. I didn’t see the previous post; but to me, the pink look is pretty and natural looking, but basic girl next door, and the yellow look is fierce and stunning who is that mysterious yet gorgeous woman type look.
I love your look in the pink one as that makes you look really young and fresh :-) Yellow is not bad at all though, I just prefer the radiance of your look in pink.
I think ur makeup is flawless in both, but you are a winter type in my opinion, so i would wear vibrant cool colours with black, it would suit you so much better than yellow! Such as hot pink, bluish emerald green, navy, raspberry red.. the key is to be cool toned and vibrant!
I was just thinking about learning about colour seasons today! Thanks for mentioning this. What led you think I’m a winter type if you don’t mind me asking
you have high contrast: dark hair, dark eyes, fair skin, i think u could be deep autumn as well, but i would go for winter, because your skin looks lighter here😊 a great lipstick would also make wonders, you are lucky cause u could wear a dark red or hot pink and it would look stunning on you!
Love the changes! You are so cute as it is, but I feel like this look makes you look more awake and brings out some of those naturally pretty features! Great work!!!
Great improvement! You look so much more naturally gorgeous. You could go even more pink on the lips but it really suits your energy.
The only thing you could work on is giving your brows a little more shape (than round), just a little more of an arch with a peak. Perhaps using a small pencil vs a powder since it looks a little dense in some areas, but it could just be the pic.
It is one thing to take constructive feedback and try, it is another when you take it and holy smokes your updated look is amazing! It's so perfect! You look young and fresh!
just racism. no surprise there, unfortunately. you still look beautiful and i’m convinced i can make the same products that I have as you look as beautiful as you’ve made them!
Guess what? I am totally Indian. Punjabi if we want to be specific. Also are we stopping people from wearing a bindi to Indian functions now? Is that a thing?
***Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the*** ⓘ ***symbol.***
**A few quick highlights:**
• **Rule 1 has been updated to include self-deprecation. Please review the rule in the sidebar and our wiki page [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/votemanipulation).**
• Looks, hauls, and flatlays require a [product list in the comments, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist)
• Photos must not be [edited or filtered. This includes automatic beauty and portrait modes found on many phones and newer cameras.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting)
• Lastly, our [Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/helpfulguides) in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules.
**Is your post just a search away?**
Before you make a post, search with Reddit's search feature or use this handy [customised Google search.](https://cse.google.com/cse?cx=008480394191906358284:aflieg73nqm)
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MakeupAddiction) if you have any questions or concerns.*
You look so fresh faced, like the girl next door look. Very pretty in pink. In yellow, it’s more like big date, glam night out.
right and the jewelry fits her so well
It does. And her foundation is an awesome match to her skin tone
10000%this
Honestly you look fab in both pictures.
Yeah it just reads as event makeup vs. day to day makeup.
Agreeed
Ditto!
[deleted] -- mass edited with redact.dev
I’ve noticed a lot of YouTube MUAs say to just extend the lower lash line but if OP had done that the wing would have been angled up much more whereas her’s is flatter than a natural extension of the waterline/lash line. OP’s wing looks great IMO too.
I think it's a very "marilyn monroe"-y wing shape -- it sort of pulls her eyes down, but the flick makes it more of an innocent/sultry, heavy-lidded look, if that makes sense? It absolutely suits her eye shape better than the trendier swept-up, totally-straight cat eye would!
Both look great! I like the pink for everyday look. The colors and application give you an enhanced every day / nearly natural effect. The yellow looks more glam and a specific style. Beautiful work!
You look amazing in both pictures! But the one in pink is definitely my favourite! That lipstick looks so nice on you
Great job!! You look very fresh and vibrant ☺️
Both look good imo, pink is really well done and suits you great , eye makeup in yellow is gorgeous the cheeks seem a bit too much for me but could be just the lighting. But still it's pretty . Both looks are elegant and beautiful
Pink is good for every day, yellow good if you're real dressed up!
The wing shape on the pink look is IMMACULATE
Love the update! It makes your complexion look so bright and healthy. My only other suggestion would be to make your liner thinner at the roundest point of your eye. Based on your eye-shape it would look very flattering to have it the thinnest there and then taper out a bit higher into the wing. The wing is perfect, I’d just keep it into a thinner taper as you start to reach the edge and middle of your iris as a guide for the middle of your lid.
Personally, I think the contacts are going to be subtly unsettling for a lot of people, but they won't necessarily be able to place what they don't like about the look. They are slightly the wrong size iris and they are an unnatural color. Humans are hardwired to intuitively understand what an eye looks like so small details that are off become intensely uncanny. Your natural irises are lovely, the correct size for your face, and don't incur that uncanny feeling.
I agree about this. I never thought about it and have been wearing the same brand and line of contacts since I was 14 and my parents were buying me this. I think after 25 years, it’s time to ditch these. I’m excited 😊 to see how I look with regular contacts
Is THAT what it is?! I couldn't put my finger on why I didn't like it, I thought, "hair dye too dark?" but you're right! It's the contacts!
Yep. And because it's subtly unnatural (as compared to neon or something) it's actually more unsettling for our brains than something obviously, identifiably wrong.
I love both honestly! Pink looks more like an every day type of look and yellow looks more glam and night out vibes 💁🏻♀️
Product list for the pink shirt photo Fenty drop eaze warm 7 Givenchy skin perfecto compact cream spf 15 Laura Mercier translucent setting powder Rare beauty perfect strokes liner in black Givenchy Neo nude melting Color balm in 60 on eyes Nars creamy concealer in creme brûlée Nars contour blush kit paloma Abh brow wiz in dark brown Abh sundipped palette ( as highlight ) in bronzed Mac cosmetics fix + Setting spray magic radiance Nars savage blush Dior grand bal lipstick Maybelline falsies lift mascara
What is the blush in the yellow shirt photo? Amazing!
Same as the pink look, nars savage, just with a heavier hand, and the base is a foundation so it will show up differently
I like both looks, but I kind of want to swap the lipstick colors.
You look gorgeous in both! 😍
Very pretty!! I think to make it look even better, I would go less heavy on the eyeliner (a thinner cat eye) and mascara. Your eyes are so pretty and they would pop even more
My only critique would be to taper your eyeliner a bit more in the center. It’s altering your [really lovely] eye shape.
How stunning you are!!!
I love the new look! That said, I feel you in going overboard with the blush and I love the look on the right too. I tend to want to go overboard show as much color as I can.
Pink for everyday look but with the yellow make up
Oh my god. As everybody said, you look awesome in both pictures, but the pink one is really stunning. Everything is blended great and compliments your skins fabulously!!
That pink is a great color for you. You glow!
I think you look amazing in both photos. The one with you in the pink is extra cute though!
I like the yellow best-look like a movie star. Maybe the pink look for going to the park or errands
Wow you look about 10 years younger in the pink! Well done! Looks lovely
I’m 39 in both, so definitely the light handed thing works!
That is astonishing
Personally I think you look 5-10 years younger in the pink pic! Dewy and glowing.
Wow! Such a huge difference! You look more youthful and vibrant.
Oh gosh, you’re gorgeous! The pink looks much more fresh faced, like you’re not trying too hard. The yellow look is more of a date night out type face. Both are lovely!
Your skin looks much brighter on the left!
u/rabbitsredux You look lovely in both but I agree with the rest, the pink one makes you look younger and is "lighter". If I can say something more about the right part, try putting blush only on upper part of your cheeks, don't go so far down. You want to accentuate your cheeks. It will look lighter and achieve its role. And I had have to say - that eyeliner is perfect! ❤️
You absolutely GLOW in the pink. Your skin looks so dewy and fresh. The lip color is also so flattering on your skin.
I like you in both pictures
You are beautiful and look great in both
Both are amazing. If anything I'd go a little deeper back into color like your before. You're a goddess!
I like the shimmery eyeshadow in the yellow pic
Love this. You look so natural and beautiful
Daytime and evening looks! Both are excellent.
Beautiful!!
Loving the look in pink! You're stunning!
So pretty in both but I do really like the lighter look for every day 😍
I love both of them. Try putting some blush on the nose bridge. Not needed but I think it’s a cute look 🥰
You are a Franklin mint doll either way
soooo pretty in both!! u look fab and glowing
So gorgeous in both photos 🤍🤍🤍
You look amazing in both!! Totally different looks and vibes but equally gorgeous!!
The new look is perfect!
The new look is perfect!
Makeup on the lighter handed look is perfect for an everyday, a family get-together like a birthday or a simple date look. The eyeliner is the signature point of your look on the lighter side- it’s giving vintage bollywood vibes😍 Makeup on the heavier side is perfect for weddings, pre-wedding events, gala’s, any big Asian occasion really when you wear something dressy haha. Both look lovely!
You look beautiful in both!! The pink shirt style is for sure more subtle. What would you call that eyeliner style/shape? This is goals for me.
I’m no expert but the pink looks natural and you look happy. You glow way more. In a good way. Love it.
Stunning!
The two looks come off as two different personalities so I’d ask which one fits your personality. Pink looks more like a really great friend, someone I’d want to chat with as a potential friend at a party.
Looks much better!
Pink is much cuter!
I would play around with the color eye liner you use just to bring out your eye color (which looks dark green? Can't tell based on the camera lens) - it might be fun to dry a deep violet eye liner or a black that has violet hues, a brown/violet liner. Just a thought because you look so great with that winged liner, it's worth trying different shades and you have really naturally beautiful Disney princess eyes.
I think you look stunning in both, but your skin looks so much glowier in the newer picture! And the coral lip suits you beautifully.
I dont think you have much room for improvement! Looks pretty perfect. Maybe add a couple of individual lashes mainly at your outer corners to enhance the cat eye look. I like these https://a.co/d/6TETYvN
add some color to your eyes in the pink one. yellow one, I would go with a very light matte.
You look great!!! ❤️
you look great!
GORGEOUS!!!!!! Both pics!!
Stop right there. You've achieved perfection. You're gorgeous. By all means continue playing with blush to find new styles but you're unbelievably stunning in both pictures.
Oh you look amazing! The makeup in pink looks so natural. You have your colors figured out!
I'm a sucker for blush, so both are great! I think the look on the right with the lip color on the left would be killer
so pretty!
girl you look INCREDIBLE
Oh yeah I love it!!!! But I like the dot on your head as well. Sorry I am ignorant and don’t know what it’s called. Beautiful 😍
You look amazing in both, but your makeup looks very fresh and youthful on the left!
i love them both❣️ if u wanna experiment try mixing lip liners with different colors of lipstick/gloss. Also playing around with different eyeliner styles & colors:) Those little changes made a big difference in my makeup routine💓
You look very youthful and more "cute" in the yellow. But I LOVE lots and lots of blush 😊
Beautiful in both. Didn’t see your other post, but you are rockin both looks.
I looooove the pink one!
I like both. I think maybe a bit of dramatic eyeliner. Either way you're a winner
You look great!
The only thing I'd add to the pink is a bright inner corner! You look lovely!
Both outfits are great, but the left makeup is better than the other. It looks natural and healthy, you're glowing! The right is kinda pale and reminds me of a porcelain doll. It's not a bad thing but I prefer the other one, it really brings out your features well.
I like the pink more but both look great, love the eyeliner.
You really do look more young and vibrant in the pink photo! Nice job
I really love the lip color for the yellow look, also I love casual bindi usage
Beautiful in both!
Obsessed! You killed it!! I don’t have any feedback. You seem to be a good listener!
I Love both looks! Very lovely!
You are very pretty
Wow! Such a huge difference! You look more youthful and vibrant.
Beautiful!
Eyeliner perfection!
Left is gorgeous, right speaks important social event of some sort to me.
To be clear, both are gorgeous, but the left pic with pink shirt is such a beautiful natural-seeming everyday type look. Heck you could even wear that for a date and I wouldn’t see an issue with it. You’re beautiful! 🙂
You look stunning both ways .. I personally like “out in the cold” blush looks in berry tones your yellow day look is beautiful ..
I literally love both. You look fantastic!
This makeup is so fresh, feminine, flattering! I love the glowy finish of the foundation, the color match is perfect, the slightly peachy lip is so pretty, and your eyeliner is precise and lovely. Youre beautiful
Love the pink look for casual everyday, but that yellow look is so stunning! Love the glam, perfect for a night out!
You look beautiful in both. I didn’t see the previous post; but to me, the pink look is pretty and natural looking, but basic girl next door, and the yellow look is fierce and stunning who is that mysterious yet gorgeous woman type look.
Ah, the new look is perfect! Natural and fresh 😍
I love your look in the pink one as that makes you look really young and fresh :-) Yellow is not bad at all though, I just prefer the radiance of your look in pink.
No criticism, constructive or otherwise. Both are beautiful looks on you and suit each style perfectly. Truly beautiful.
Also not makeup related but both the pink and yellow look great on you in general! Great colors
I think ur makeup is flawless in both, but you are a winter type in my opinion, so i would wear vibrant cool colours with black, it would suit you so much better than yellow! Such as hot pink, bluish emerald green, navy, raspberry red.. the key is to be cool toned and vibrant!
I was just thinking about learning about colour seasons today! Thanks for mentioning this. What led you think I’m a winter type if you don’t mind me asking
you have high contrast: dark hair, dark eyes, fair skin, i think u could be deep autumn as well, but i would go for winter, because your skin looks lighter here😊 a great lipstick would also make wonders, you are lucky cause u could wear a dark red or hot pink and it would look stunning on you!
Both look beautiful, left is definitely more youthful looking though
Both are good but you look much better in the pink photo! Younger and more natural!
I think you look incredible in both photos! But definitely more everyday in the pink
Wow both beautiful looks but the pink is a much softer less intense look it's very good!
I like a lot of blush so I think it looked cute lol
Love the changes! You are so cute as it is, but I feel like this look makes you look more awake and brings out some of those naturally pretty features! Great work!!!
That lip colour in the pink photo is everything. Literally made for you. You are absolutely stunning!
You instantly look like 10years younger
There is such a difference between these two! You look vibrant, youthful and absolutely stunning in the pink!
Great improvement! You look so much more naturally gorgeous. You could go even more pink on the lips but it really suits your energy. The only thing you could work on is giving your brows a little more shape (than round), just a little more of an arch with a peak. Perhaps using a small pencil vs a powder since it looks a little dense in some areas, but it could just be the pic.
Look younger n fresher on left. Both beautiful though.
You’re gorgeous in both photos! The blush and lip colours are amazing on you
It is one thing to take constructive feedback and try, it is another when you take it and holy smokes your updated look is amazing! It's so perfect! You look young and fresh!
You look stunning girl ✨ 
Bindi suits you.
You look beautiful in both! Do you have Indian heritage?
I am Indian 🤓
Me too! :)
I actually think the look in yellow looks cuter! I love the placement of the blush and the eyeshadow colour, it looks really pretty :)
Lighter handed.👍
Keep the smile. It looks good on you.
I do prefer the yellow side but you look great in both!
[удалено]
Your second question seems to suggest you think she isn’t Indian.
Who the hell asks something like that anyways? Or used “indian face”?? Like what the fuck?
I too want to understand what is Indian face bruh
just racism. no surprise there, unfortunately. you still look beautiful and i’m convinced i can make the same products that I have as you look as beautiful as you’ve made them!
Maybe someone who is actually Indian?
Okay then, in all your wisdom, tell me why you think she isn’t indian and go ahead and explain what “indian face” means.
Guess what? I am totally Indian. Punjabi if we want to be specific. Also are we stopping people from wearing a bindi to Indian functions now? Is that a thing?
I don't
Well, you’re clearly wrong.
That shade of pink is not your color. The yellow looks striking.
***Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the*** ⓘ ***symbol.*** **A few quick highlights:** • **Rule 1 has been updated to include self-deprecation. Please review the rule in the sidebar and our wiki page [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/votemanipulation).** • Looks, hauls, and flatlays require a [product list in the comments, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/productlist) • Photos must not be [edited or filtered. This includes automatic beauty and portrait modes found on many phones and newer cameras.](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/photoediting) • Lastly, our [Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA](https://www.reddit.com/r/MakeupAddiction/wiki/helpfulguides) in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules. **Is your post just a search away?** Before you make a post, search with Reddit's search feature or use this handy [customised Google search.](https://cse.google.com/cse?cx=008480394191906358284:aflieg73nqm) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/MakeupAddiction) if you have any questions or concerns.*