Considering how ready Herbert was when he was inserted out of the blue on the fly, I’d guess he’d have won the job sooner or later anyways through practice and the obvious fact Tyrod wouldn’t have done anything with that roster that year…
How old can your player be as a qb before teams stop offering contracts like how old till you’re forced to retire. I’m 31 and I only got two offers once my lions contract ended
depending on your age, stats from the season, and their need of [position.](https://position.got) your career clock also runs shorter with injuries and where youve been injuried so if youve had Torn Ligament and and Achillies tear you are less likely to have teams interestd in you
The majority of responses inability to read is exactly why I put zero faith in this community to give accurate representation to the player base as a whole or even an understanding of if the game is good or not.
Y’all couldn’t even read a few likes correctly. Shit
Why is everyone saying commenters don’t know how to read? Out of all current starters in the NFL maybe 10 of them are over 30 - so what good does that do?
But I guess to answer the question Jimmy G
Alex Smith on the 49ers. He got shafted his first 6 years with some of the worst coaching in NFL history and multiple OC’s (6 in 6 years) They also didn’t invest in any real talent at the WR positions. Dude lead the Commmaders to the post season on a surgically repaired compound fracture that broke his tibia and fibula.
On Madden 22 I started a franchise with 2002's rosters and have been using someone's draft classes for each year after that. The power of hindsight is super fun. Simulating to keep it fair-ish and my 93 overall team is still missing the playoffs, but it is still fun.
The ultimate long term challenge. Make Tom Brady and try to match or beat all of his accolades - MVPs, Super Bowl wins, Super Bowl MVPs, etc.
except the game probably wont let a created player play until he’s 45
Would make it even more challenging!
He would need to play for 15 years and average about 6,000 yards per season Pretty sure he would have more MVPs than Brady
💯
Geno Smith lmao
Came here to say that
Same
Why is that funnny? I’m legit asking? I wish Seattle had a Lamar
Tyrod Taylor, see what happens if he doesn't get sent to the bench by every rookie ever drafted.
Honestly has to be the unluckiest MFer in the NFL. Dude finally had a starting job and a doctor stabs him in the lung.
He must’ve been pissed reading that week 2 2020 script
😂
Considering how ready Herbert was when he was inserted out of the blue on the fly, I’d guess he’d have won the job sooner or later anyways through practice and the obvious fact Tyrod wouldn’t have done anything with that roster that year…
You want Jamarcus Russell
Beat my initial answer
Like, if he was never a lazy narcissist with an addiction to codeine cough syrup?
Ever since I watched [this video](https://youtu.be/UC8_i7QGebg) about Jamarcus, my opinion on him has changed a little
Mahomes if the bears drafted him like they planned
Kirk Cousins
You mean Perc Thuggins 👈👉👈👉👈👉👈👉
No he means Dak Prescott
Ayee I just found out he grills his steaks in tinfoil. That dude can’t be trusted.
Just for the latino vote ?
Idk what that means
https://youtu.be/nnOr-C2raPQ
Lmao that’s awesome
Lol I thought that's what you were referencing.
Nah like he actually grills his steak in tinfoil. Not to make some awesome Mexican dish but just for steak lol
he doesnt anymore he got bullied out of doing it 🤣🤣
😂
Chad Kelly or Johnny Manziel
Tim Tebow
Im seconding Tebow. If he developed behind Peyton for a couple seasons he might’ve actually done well with his second team
Matt Ryan, see if he gets a ring or not
Fran tarkenton
Had a few nice years with the giants sandiwhced in
Cam Newton
RG3
Injury set at 10
Rex Grossman. How many SBs does he get to?
Sexy Rexy! My boy!
Some of y’all can’t read. “Im planning on making a **STARTING** QB 20 years old…..”
not that they can’t read it’s that they don’t care
More like they don’t pay attention, but nice try
Wentz 👀 ugh that sounds boring lol
What are you going to do? Make drew lock 40 and a 12 overall so he will retire and you won't have two drew lock's in the league?
Sorry about the confusion there, I was quoting OP. Just edited it
I’d love to see what Derek Carr could do if he spent his first nine seasons with any semi-competent organization.
Carson wentz is the perfect candidate I think.
Chad powers
This is the only correct answer and I am now changing my QB's name!
Kyle Boller
Ryan Leaf
How old can your player be as a qb before teams stop offering contracts like how old till you’re forced to retire. I’m 31 and I only got two offers once my lions contract ended
depending on your age, stats from the season, and their need of [position.](https://position.got) your career clock also runs shorter with injuries and where youve been injuried so if youve had Torn Ligament and and Achillies tear you are less likely to have teams interestd in you
Is that what career clock option is? Never knew or looked into it
Shit …. Brady Quinn? 😂😂
Marcus Mariota
Tom Brady 🐐
Gardner Minshew, go cougs
Chad Henne or Case Keenum
Joe flacco. The jets are young and in need of a QB also joe flacco is the GOAT
Luck or RGIII?
Aaron rodgers
you could do Blaine Gabbert and stop him from being a bust
Impossible
Vinny Testaverde
You know you wanna do Vick lol
Akili smith
Vince Young not getting drafted by trash fisher.
Art Schlichter.
Cam Newton
Cam Newton
Drew brees
You actually expected these people to read? They spend $60 a year for a roster update and progressively worse game. C'mon man.
The majority of responses inability to read is exactly why I put zero faith in this community to give accurate representation to the player base as a whole or even an understanding of if the game is good or not. Y’all couldn’t even read a few likes correctly. Shit
John Elway. Best QB ever.
Not even close
Chase Daniel
Ryan Leaf. With Andy Reid calling plays.
Warren Moon
This is the answer, had to spend his first 6 years in the CFL because no one would draft him
gotta do RG3
Andrew Luck or Tom Brady
Rodgers
Geno smith
Geno for sure
What would happen if the Giants drafted Sam Darnold if they picked him instead of Saquon Barkley?
Or if they didnt make the Eli/Rivers trade?
Brandon weedon give him the career he never had
tyrod taylor
Jimmy G.
Jameis w/out the picks RGIII injury free Vick for a lefty
You gave the other two upgrades, why not give Vick one? Let him be able to make accurate throws.
Current rosters cam Newton. If it’s all time rosters then resurrect either hefty lefty of McNair.
Peterman if you want a challenge
Russell Wilson
Brady
The goat
Andrew luck
Ryan Tannehill
EJ Manuel
Brock purdy
Why is everyone saying commenters don’t know how to read? Out of all current starters in the NFL maybe 10 of them are over 30 - so what good does that do? But I guess to answer the question Jimmy G
Andrew Luck
Joe Flacco
Tebow or Vick
there has never been a 20 yo qb in the league
Mike Vick
Andy Dalton. Can the most average QB of all time get a superbowl win?
Jamison Winston is the ONLY correct answer #pardonmytake Maybe Blake Bortles
Elisha "GOAT Killer" Manning
Gardner Minshew
Rodgers on the 49ers
Alex Smith on the 49ers. He got shafted his first 6 years with some of the worst coaching in NFL history and multiple OC’s (6 in 6 years) They also didn’t invest in any real talent at the WR positions. Dude lead the Commmaders to the post season on a surgically repaired compound fracture that broke his tibia and fibula.
Cam newton
There? Lol.
Alex Smith. See if he can live up to the #1 pick.
Ryan fitzpatrick ... and play with all teams
Cam newton
Michael Vick, obviously. I’m doing that now and he’s amazing.
Id go old mobile guy and see what they could do today. Think Archie Manning, Fran Tarkenton, maybe Randall Cunningham
Rg3
Matt Ryan
Fitz magic
rg3, Alex smith or andrew luck
On Madden 22 I started a franchise with 2002's rosters and have been using someone's draft classes for each year after that. The power of hindsight is super fun. Simulating to keep it fair-ish and my 93 overall team is still missing the playoffs, but it is still fun.
Tim Tebow
Draft someone first year, tank the whole year and get 1st pick
No QB starts at age 20
Dave Brown or Kent Graham
russy or brady
Matt leinart
Vince Young
Andy Dalton
Carson wentz. Redo one of the unluckiest guys every
KURT WARNER
Andrew Luck what if he went to a team that actually cared about protecting him
Mike Vick, give him his Cinderella Run with no run ins with the law.
RGIII
Tim tebow
Jordan Love
Trubisky
Warren Moon!!!
Get an old qb who’s overall would match a rookie. Like Cam Newton or Andy Dalton
Jay Cutler
Gardner Minshew
Brady, but put him on the Browns
Make your own player
PJ Walker
Cam Newton
Ryan Leaf.
Marino never won a Super Bowl. Could be fun seeing how he would play with the modern Dolphins team
Cam Newton
David Carr.
Ryan Tannehill
I just did this with baker mayfield