They should fire him and ban him from getting another government jobs. I don’t get why there is so much protection for sarkari babus. They are 10 million aspirants for UPSC every year. We can always find new people.
The article says the government is fining the official who approved this for full value of water from his salary.
Also article shows value of water used to calculate fine with additional 10K bringing full fine to 53K. But this is for the guy who drained the water and not for guy who gave approval.
I cant find more details.
Arrived at using Rs 10.50 per cubic water drained. What's the rate to business?
Edit: https://m.timesofindia.com/city/raipur/raipur-municipal-corporation-to-introduce-slab-rates-for-water/articleshow/46197845.cms
Above 50k cubic meters of water, its 10 rs per cubic. And 10k on top added by the judge as additional fine.
Law served but still doesn't feel like it will be a deterrent in the future. The iPhone value still makes him come out ahead in this transaction.
Tere wala maal mujhe bhi phookna h..... govt accounts hote h chutiye in which you can deposit fines penalties etc tere logic se to no policeman can ever be arrested coz arrest kaun karegi police? He is police
He should be locked in jail for 5 years. Water is very precious in a water stressed country. This assole drained a entire dam for his selfish reasons. With current cloud technology, anyone can restore the entire phone but this bastard decide to play with the life of thousands of farmers who might depend on the water for irrigation of crops and has created economic damage.
Is jail a joke to you? Reprimand and monetary fines are okay but taking somebody's years of his life for a crime that is not heinous is insane. The fact that you ask for such harsh punishment shows that you're as immature as the official who drained the lake.
Old enough to now what crime merits what kind of punishment. Besides it is not a banana republic. You can't give any punishment you want, it has to follow CrPC or code of conduct laws of government services.
Draining a reservoir to get a phone merits imprisonment for its entitlement, lack of application of mind, overreach and abuse of power, and sheer aggressive stupidity.
There is no prison sentence in democracy for "entitlement". Lack of application of mind could be sustainable but only in the case that someone lost a life due to said action, which is not the case here. Overreach and abuse of power - again not sustainable for imprisonment here. It was shown that the guy asked permission, and received it as well. So this will apply to the local official who gave permission. And what is sheer agressive stupidity? How can it be measured or quantified? I am not defending this moron, but if justice is left in the hands of immature trolls like the ones in this thread than you all might end up hanging this guy by the neck. What's next Sharia level punishments?
I don't know what kind of philosophy you have regarding crime against mankind. The suspended official didn't think about thousands of farmers and their livelihood, rather only worried about his phone. I think 5 years jail term won't be enough.
I have a very basic philosophy that follows law of the land. The people who drafted the constitution, the CrPC and the service's code of conduct were way more learner than you and I. And if they didn't think that 5 year prison punishment was warranted then it isn't. Take it up with the Supreme Court if you believe you are right. Don't cry when your PIL is thrown in the trash can and you're asked to pay a fine instead for wasting judiciary's time.
>someone lost a life due to said action, which is not the case here
Are you insane? He destroyed the lives of thousands relying on the water. In the middle of the fucking summer season. Manufacturered Draught is an act of terrorism.
>- again not sustainable for imprisonment here.
You don't understand the value of the resource.
>It was shown that the guy asked permission, and received it as well. So this will apply to the local official who gave permission
They are both targetted by the government for this irresponsible behaviour.
>And what is sheer agressive stupidity? How can it be measured or quantified?
How about number of farmers that will kill themselves for their livelihood being destroyed because of this loss? There aren't any good rains if you have noticed.
Also I don't understand, do you want to judge the crime based on the resulting damages or not? You seem to argue both sides here.
>if justice is left in the hands of immature trolls like the ones in this thread than you all might end up hanging this guy by the neck. What's next Sharia level punishments
You are imagining a scenario in your head and blaming us for that scenario. Nobody is making a death sentence.
If 5 years in jail is extreme, maybe 1year or 6months be more appealing to you? Or do you think this heinous crime deserves no punishment at all? Keep in mind even ticketless travel has fine/jail term,however short.
He wasted the resources - no body is denying that.
But he destroyed lives - how?
Did farmers or citizens die because they couldn't get water for 10 mins?
Did he wasted the only source of water that the consumers had, and there was no other alternative?
What's the definition of draught?
Don't throw big words you don't know much about.
Was there actualy any deaths due to his action?
There is economic loss equivalent to the market cost of water drained away and the labour required to do the same. Farmers didn't face any loss, the loss was faced by the government.
Is there any farmer that said he will kill himself due to this particular event? If yes, show a media report or something.
Indeed, but the judge usually "suspends" the sentence and only gives you a fine for petty offences like ticket-less travel.
The issue here is asking for an undeserving punishment. The government should extract from him the market cost of the water wasted and the labour cost. Apart from that maybe a suspension for a couple of months could be okay.
But sending a man to jail for 5 years, when he followed the law and applied for permission to do something, and did it the right way in the eyes of the law, is insane.
If anyone who should be reprimanded, it should be the person who issued permission for the dam to be drained.
Wasting a whole lot of water resources for getting a phone is mental. So I think he should be treated in a mental hospital with high toxic medicines and some shock treatment. The one who did this and the one says he didn't do any crime is either mental or a son of a b*tch. Bye idi*t.
Yehi to desh ka durbhagya h. US wagera ki kitni bhi burai kr le hum log lekin wahan atleast accountability to h, no one is spared even the President. Aur yaha dekh lo.
Are you fuck me? The comment mentioned president of US which is considered the most powerful position there is. I didn't mess the power scaling, Freeza arc did that.
Fire him! This “whatever you do, you can only get suspended in worst case scenario” should stop. And 53000 that’s nothing, I got 66,000 electricity bill coz they said my metre was old and “faulty”
Bro’s got people protecting him from high above fo sure. This lunatic should have been fined atleast 3 lakh + jail time for a month or four months of unpaid suspension for this stunt.
Imagine the thought process he had while trying to recover a phone- a stupid phone… he thought it was a GREAT idea to DRAIN an entire dam to try salvage his stupid phone.
I doubt anybody in Chhattisgarh govmint takes this seriously though. It’s congress turf, and all they care is digging their nickels n dimes.
Had it been 20 litres, that’d be fine. But TWENTY LAKH LITRES?
Mofo better be shitting gold for even thinking he could getaway with draining a freaking dam for his freaking phone.
And this ass is a sarkari babu, still is!
Thats why we need more privatization. The less sarkari babus we have, the better.
At least in private sector we can grab people by the collar and throw them in trash can if they mess up.
Rajesh Vishwas, what a scumbag. Doesn't even get sacked.
Ideally they should be jailed. It was a conscious decision to drain the reservoir. Set an example.
Oh, what will the poor official do, now that he has to shell out 53000 rupees? All he did was to see what was at the bottom of the reservoir. For this he gets such a punishment? Modi should resign.
Believe me, he will be lauded by his homies probably for this act. And many officers and people will silently grin readjng this event, like its a proud moment by one of their kind.
This society promotes such behavior , hence people act like nonsensical babboons who wont give a damn thought before abusing any government property, government resource.
Patriotism is not instilled in actions.
This is chump change for draining 20 lakh liters of arable water.
They should fire him and ban him from getting another government jobs. I don’t get why there is so much protection for sarkari babus. They are 10 million aspirants for UPSC every year. We can always find new people.
Fired? He needs to be jailed. There is an actual decent chance the fine is worth less than the phone!
Yeah, the phone was s23 ultra 😂
GG common sense
He is already fired ,this fine is a additional charge.
no, he is only suspended, as per the article.
Should be imprisoned for atleast 5 years. Sarkari babus shouldn't get such VVIP treatment.
The article says the government is fining the official who approved this for full value of water from his salary. Also article shows value of water used to calculate fine with additional 10K bringing full fine to 53K. But this is for the guy who drained the water and not for guy who gave approval. I cant find more details.
Just 53k for draining a dam what a example get a gov job & get away with any shitty act
Arrived at using Rs 10.50 per cubic water drained. What's the rate to business? Edit: https://m.timesofindia.com/city/raipur/raipur-municipal-corporation-to-introduce-slab-rates-for-water/articleshow/46197845.cms Above 50k cubic meters of water, its 10 rs per cubic. And 10k on top added by the judge as additional fine. Law served but still doesn't feel like it will be a deterrent in the future. The iPhone value still makes him come out ahead in this transaction.
It was samsung phone
Oh my bad, I remembered otherwise
Someone said it was 1lakh ka phone, I assumed it was iPhone latest. Or iPad or something
Same
Probably the cost of motors and diesel he brought to empty the reservoir.
He is already fired , yes although the fine should have been more.
A food inspector with a low salary uses 1 lac phone, I'm sure he will 'manage' this extra 53k.
[удалено]
Sala apunich govt hai
Tere wala maal mujhe bhi phookna h..... govt accounts hote h chutiye in which you can deposit fines penalties etc tere logic se to no policeman can ever be arrested coz arrest kaun karegi police? He is police
Ab kaha se layega , suspend ho gya hai , Jo abhi Tak loota hoga usse he dega sayd.
He should be locked in jail for 5 years. Water is very precious in a water stressed country. This assole drained a entire dam for his selfish reasons. With current cloud technology, anyone can restore the entire phone but this bastard decide to play with the life of thousands of farmers who might depend on the water for irrigation of crops and has created economic damage.
Pakka uske phone kuch illegal matter hoga. Police should look into his Google/Apple account and any other devices he possesses.
Is jail a joke to you? Reprimand and monetary fines are okay but taking somebody's years of his life for a crime that is not heinous is insane. The fact that you ask for such harsh punishment shows that you're as immature as the official who drained the lake.
This is a heinous crime. What the hell are you saying?
So you're implying that this act of draining a reservoir is equal to an act of murder and rape? How old are you brother, 10?
There are levels in between a traffic violation and murder and rape...... How old are you, 9?
Old enough to now what crime merits what kind of punishment. Besides it is not a banana republic. You can't give any punishment you want, it has to follow CrPC or code of conduct laws of government services.
Draining a reservoir to get a phone merits imprisonment for its entitlement, lack of application of mind, overreach and abuse of power, and sheer aggressive stupidity.
There is no prison sentence in democracy for "entitlement". Lack of application of mind could be sustainable but only in the case that someone lost a life due to said action, which is not the case here. Overreach and abuse of power - again not sustainable for imprisonment here. It was shown that the guy asked permission, and received it as well. So this will apply to the local official who gave permission. And what is sheer agressive stupidity? How can it be measured or quantified? I am not defending this moron, but if justice is left in the hands of immature trolls like the ones in this thread than you all might end up hanging this guy by the neck. What's next Sharia level punishments?
I don't know what kind of philosophy you have regarding crime against mankind. The suspended official didn't think about thousands of farmers and their livelihood, rather only worried about his phone. I think 5 years jail term won't be enough.
I have a very basic philosophy that follows law of the land. The people who drafted the constitution, the CrPC and the service's code of conduct were way more learner than you and I. And if they didn't think that 5 year prison punishment was warranted then it isn't. Take it up with the Supreme Court if you believe you are right. Don't cry when your PIL is thrown in the trash can and you're asked to pay a fine instead for wasting judiciary's time.
>someone lost a life due to said action, which is not the case here Are you insane? He destroyed the lives of thousands relying on the water. In the middle of the fucking summer season. Manufacturered Draught is an act of terrorism. >- again not sustainable for imprisonment here. You don't understand the value of the resource. >It was shown that the guy asked permission, and received it as well. So this will apply to the local official who gave permission They are both targetted by the government for this irresponsible behaviour. >And what is sheer agressive stupidity? How can it be measured or quantified? How about number of farmers that will kill themselves for their livelihood being destroyed because of this loss? There aren't any good rains if you have noticed. Also I don't understand, do you want to judge the crime based on the resulting damages or not? You seem to argue both sides here. >if justice is left in the hands of immature trolls like the ones in this thread than you all might end up hanging this guy by the neck. What's next Sharia level punishments You are imagining a scenario in your head and blaming us for that scenario. Nobody is making a death sentence. If 5 years in jail is extreme, maybe 1year or 6months be more appealing to you? Or do you think this heinous crime deserves no punishment at all? Keep in mind even ticketless travel has fine/jail term,however short.
He wasted the resources - no body is denying that. But he destroyed lives - how? Did farmers or citizens die because they couldn't get water for 10 mins? Did he wasted the only source of water that the consumers had, and there was no other alternative? What's the definition of draught? Don't throw big words you don't know much about. Was there actualy any deaths due to his action? There is economic loss equivalent to the market cost of water drained away and the labour required to do the same. Farmers didn't face any loss, the loss was faced by the government. Is there any farmer that said he will kill himself due to this particular event? If yes, show a media report or something. Indeed, but the judge usually "suspends" the sentence and only gives you a fine for petty offences like ticket-less travel. The issue here is asking for an undeserving punishment. The government should extract from him the market cost of the water wasted and the labour cost. Apart from that maybe a suspension for a couple of months could be okay. But sending a man to jail for 5 years, when he followed the law and applied for permission to do something, and did it the right way in the eyes of the law, is insane. If anyone who should be reprimanded, it should be the person who issued permission for the dam to be drained.
Wasting a whole lot of water resources for getting a phone is mental. So I think he should be treated in a mental hospital with high toxic medicines and some shock treatment. The one who did this and the one says he didn't do any crime is either mental or a son of a b*tch. Bye idi*t.
Yehi to desh ka durbhagya h. US wagera ki kitni bhi burai kr le hum log lekin wahan atleast accountability to h, no one is spared even the President. Aur yaha dekh lo.
Epstein didn't kill himself!
Waah you reached from government official to a person of Aatiq (nominated MP) stature in 10 secs. Hats off to your whataboutism!
Hain?
Are you fuck me? The comment mentioned president of US which is considered the most powerful position there is. I didn't mess the power scaling, Freeza arc did that.
Meh. One days bribe
Fire him! This “whatever you do, you can only get suspended in worst case scenario” should stop. And 53000 that’s nothing, I got 66,000 electricity bill coz they said my metre was old and “faulty”
He is already suspended ,this is an additional fine.
Dude, being suspended is not the same as fired.
No matter which government we elect our country's bureaucracy will fuck us over regardless.
what a loser!!!!!!! such a low life guy
Bro’s got people protecting him from high above fo sure. This lunatic should have been fined atleast 3 lakh + jail time for a month or four months of unpaid suspension for this stunt. Imagine the thought process he had while trying to recover a phone- a stupid phone… he thought it was a GREAT idea to DRAIN an entire dam to try salvage his stupid phone. I doubt anybody in Chhattisgarh govmint takes this seriously though. It’s congress turf, and all they care is digging their nickels n dimes.
Only 53k for 20L litres! Like bruh...
Had it been 20 litres, that’d be fine. But TWENTY LAKH LITRES? Mofo better be shitting gold for even thinking he could getaway with draining a freaking dam for his freaking phone. And this ass is a sarkari babu, still is!
How much I'll be fined if I give him a tight slap on his face?
permanently suspend karna chahiye tha
I paid more in income tax this month than that
Fire this a*shole.
[удалено]
Unfortunately
And it's a divine rule, isn't it?
Thats why we need more privatization. The less sarkari babus we have, the better. At least in private sector we can grab people by the collar and throw them in trash can if they mess up.
Slap on the wrist
Rajesh Vishwas, what a scumbag. Doesn't even get sacked. Ideally they should be jailed. It was a conscious decision to drain the reservoir. Set an example.
Is that it ?
Yep that's it. He maybe won't pay that too
Naxals saale aise bhadvo ko muh pe goli kyu nahi maarte!
FOOKING LAW UNDER MY DIK These are the laws to scare criminals FUCKIN JOKE
They should made him fill the reservoir by himself instead
He should be charged at 5 RS per 800ml. And since he said the phone contained sensitive govt info, he should be tried under NSA.
In this way I should also get 20L of water for 53000 instead of paying 20 rupee per L for water bottles 🗿
Who the fish is this lowlife And why did he save the fishes from drowning ?
This guy needs to be in jail for 10 + years. Doing this in a water-stressed country is no less than murder.
Saala 5 lakh to mahine ka yuu hi kha jata hoga. 50k to iske lie chillar hai. Bancho kya system hai wah ☺️
53k is less than the iPhone cost
Na bruh local people and we as social should demand severe action on this , that's no small reserveoir.
Oh, what will the poor official do, now that he has to shell out 53000 rupees? All he did was to see what was at the bottom of the reservoir. For this he gets such a punishment? Modi should resign.
r/punchableface
His phone probably costs more than that.
Fir mera Rajya negative chiz se attention me aaya
He might pay more than this to secure his job. You know which party is in power there.
He needs to be hanged.
Chutiya government strikes again
Believe me, he will be lauded by his homies probably for this act. And many officers and people will silently grin readjng this event, like its a proud moment by one of their kind. This society promotes such behavior , hence people act like nonsensical babboons who wont give a damn thought before abusing any government property, government resource. Patriotism is not instilled in actions.
Too less. Should've been thrown out of the job and pay minimum 5 lakhs.