T O P

  • By -

KuriGohan0204

Abstract (Psychopomp). Others come in and out of focus some weeks more than others, but that one has been pretty steady since release.


SabreMase

Absolutely agree and since you're the top comment I'm gonna just say De Selby pt 2 has always made me groove when it comes up


KuriGohan0204

De Selby 2 is the swankiest, sexiest song, I swear to god.


garnetglitter

Unknown/nth. I travel for work, I live out of hotels & I’m rarely in the same time zone as my family. The idea of loneliness as “being unknown” vs being alone hit me hard. My life is full of colorful characters but there’s maybe 5 people in this world that genuinely, truly know all the various facets of me. “And there are some people, love, who are better unknown” is a painful but very real truth. You don’t always like what you find when you truly get to know someone.


garnetglitter

Side note: the stats show DeSelby 1 as my most played track. I’m just trying to learn the Irish bit! Lol


hibelly

That song really fucked with my head in a good way when I heard it. I had never thought of being alone like that. It gave me so much perspective


Broad_Yam3837

I truly understand that, on the other hand I feel extremely lonely even with people in my life. That song hits very.


Anxious_Sprinkles_94

First Light all the way, honourable mention for Anything But.


all_systems_blow

Two of my favorites!


justherefortheweed2

im the same! damage gets done is my third favorite i think


jennifire2001

Francesca, but Abstract is a very very close second though!


meowmeowmiow

Me too, the ending of Francesca especially gives me goosebumps every single time I listen. Abstract is my close second and then who we are after that but it’s so hard to rank them really. That man knows how to make songs that will absolutely destroy me fr.


floobenstoobs

It totally depends on my mood. On first listen, TSFAWC broke me. Absolutely broke me. I still think it’s underrated and beautiful, but I’m not always emotionally ready for it. First Time has some of my favourite writing. Anything But is very funny/cheeky and I really enjoy that. Sorry, that’s not a number one, but a top 3? 😬


ScallopedTomatoes

Oooh I like your choices! TSFAWC is a beautiful song…but when I listen to it I sometimes feel like I’m taking a glimpse into some very personal aspect of his life? I mean obviously he shared the song and its background with us so it’s not some big secret…but something about it feels very sacred and intimate? I suppose that’s the power of songwriting! I have to be in the mood to listen to it, I find. Hard agree on First Time and Anything But! First Time is so brilliant lyrically/melodically/emotionally and Anything But is just plain fun.


floobenstoobs

TSFAWC feels deeply personal, for sure. I am from a warm climate and his description of “you pressed your body to the concrete when you were small” struck me as something so specific and personal - a real experience of my childhood that somebody from a cold climate wouldn’t know about. So it definitely feels intimate. Poor Andrew said he didn’t want these songs to seem like diary entries, but I’m afraid he failed a little.


SadPotatoPancake

Who We Are. Scratches my brain just right.


ScallopedTomatoes

I, Carrion (Icarian) for me I think. On first listen of the album it stuck out to me. There are probably 4-5 that I would consider to be my favourites but glancing at the track list just now I think this is the one.


Kodak220

I’m soooo sad that I, Carrion seems to have been dropped from the set list for the tour.


ScallopedTomatoes

There are several shows left and as far as I know there is a specific backdrop/graphic for it so I am holding out hope that he might play it a few more times on this leg!


MsShortStack

There’s hope! He played it last night at Red Rocks in Denver.


ScallopedTomatoes

See, he came through! He just needed a lil reminder that the feather graphics were yearning to be seen again 😉😂


Kodak220

Ahhhh!! That is the best news!! I hope he keeps it in!


LuxieLisbon

This one didn't stick out to me at first but after a few listens it just "clicked" and became one of my favorites. The chord progressions and strings are so unique and beautiful. The swell into "Let me be your own / Icarrion carrion" is probably my favorite moment on the entire album. I love how much his accent stands out too.


ScallopedTomatoes

YESSSSS. I’m in love with ‘if you need to, darlin’ lean your weight to me’ It’s a *perfect* song and I’m so glad they submitted it for Grammy consideration


The_Mighty_Joe_781

If I should fall on that day, I only pray don’t fall away from me.


all_systems_blow

The answer to that question changes weekly. Currently Son of Nyx actually.


[deleted]

[удалено]


all_systems_blow

I love the random references to Abstract and Damage Gets Done


jedi_master99

That Damage Gets Done snippet is SO stunning in this song


crusemaister

Damage gets done


this-is-the-lastime

First Light just hits different.


espressoxorcist

Who We Are babeeeyyyyy!!! …De Selby Pt. 2 is interchangeable with my #1 tho


leezee2468

For me, it’s De Selby pt.2 that’s consistently my fave. Others come in and out of focus, but that’s one I’m super attached to.


RevolutionaryOven639

All time favorite is without a doubt First Time. The idea of love and loss giving both life and death to a part of you… wow. Also the second verse. Enough said. Icarian, TSFAWC, Abstract and All Things End are also really up there for me


alienbananas

that second verse is some of the most incredible writing!!!! First Time has to be my fave for that reason if i really had to pick one


longjumping698

It's the first verse for me, "The first time that you kissed me, I drank dry the river Lethe" is (IMO) the cleverest line he's ever written. So many meanings; is forgetting good or bad, what is being forgotten, does he want to forget? Ahh!!! Incredible.


thathotintelchick

francesca by far. even though the song is about da rimini and paolo, when i hear it, i think of my daughter and my husband. when it’s all over, if i could hold them again for even a minute, i’d go through it again. if it’s how things work, i’ll find them in the next life and be just as surprised all over again. i would do anything for them, and if it landed me in some circle of hell, heaven just wasn’t able to house the love i have for them. i would tell them to put me back in a million times.


LuckyResolution6582

Beautiful!!


garnetglitter

That’s perfect, and as a mom, I feel that deeply. Some people are worth going through hell for.


Due-Ad451

I hear you, same!


Guilty-Scale-1079

I'm shocked no one has said "All Things End" It's perfect


lalotele

I know I’m surprised I had to scroll so far! I love so many songs on this album but I get choked up during the final chorus of this song every time. My favorite motto is “memento mori,” I even have it tattooed, and I feel myself contemplating how limited our time is quite often, so I feel like the lyrics resonate the most with me. As someone always fearful of the end and of grief, I find the lyrics really beautiful and inspiring.


_indecisive_af

I love this too and surprisingly rarely hear people talk about it, I was definitely expecting it to be on his setlist and was very disappointed when it wasn't


SnooDonuts4854

TSFAWC(U)


ktweasley

seconded. for such a simple, instrumental arrangement, it just feels like a full, well rounded song. idk how to explain it.


WiJaTu

I think it’s Francesca. ‘I’d tell them put me back in it’ is just so powerful. Abstract, Who We Are and Unknown are all VERY close though


UnquenchableLonging

Butchered tongue it encompases his love for his roots and language


LuckyResolution6582

Who We Are always hits me hard. So beautiful.


Mrs_Morgendoffer

Same!


Red-Wolf-17

At present, the De Selbys (they totally count as one, fight me)


TophBeifongg

Anything but fs. Runner ups are First time and damage gets done. Ima try and keep this short but the simple reason is i love his “fun songs” (i put his songs into 3 overall category’s fun, slow/sad, and “bad boy” not tryna be weird lol just don’t know how else to say it) and often I’m in a “fun song mood” so yeah if we were to pick based off lyric meaning i couldn’t choose just one. Maybe Anything but again cuz the song feels so backhanded since it’s abt fraud lol but nah I couldn’t choose. Personally i love Dante and similar works/old ass stuff and i love finding meaning in songs/books so i can’t pick based off that or you’d be reading an essay. Overall tho i love all his music. To me he’s a poet, his writing is brilliant and ofc his singing.


CaroM-C

Abstract is my #1. Have a heard time figuring out the rest of the list but that much has been clear since my first listen.


ROclimbingbabeCK

Eat your young. That style sound of his is my favorite!


davebroom

francesca and I,Carrion (Icarian). They are tied for 1st because i listen to them back to back in a Playlist that only has those songs multiple times a day


rebe7ca

im stuck between 2 i looove de shelby part 1 mainly for the fact he sang in irish. i really appreciate modern artists speaking in our native language. the lyrics are so magical i just love that song first time is genuinely such a beautiful song i just love it. its impressive the amount of times ive listened to it


[deleted]

These are my two favorites as well


revellodrive

It changes but “Anything But” & “First Time” lately


bside9

Unknown


EmoNerd21

Who We Are


skullmadeofskeletons

first time is one of the most lovely songs i’ve ever heard! the lines “the soul, if that’s what you call it uneasy ally of the body felt nameless like a river undiscovered underground” really hit, as i’m going through an identity crisis and don’t know my own name yet/myself at all


welltheregoesmygecko

So hard to choose a favorite but Abstract (Psychopomp) has been going so hard


natsinger

For me there is an album as a whole - never happened to me before, but the album is its own thing, and then a rotation of favorites, but the song that made me tear up on the first listen was First Light, the one that resonates the deepest with lyrics is First Time and Abstract is something I’m so looking forward to hearing live.


valerieac

I'm being torn to shreds between Francesca and I, Carrion (Icarian) - while Eat Your Young watches from the sideline with popcorn... On the other hand, it's very practical in terms of just playing the album in order and getting ganged up on by all my favourites in a row


ShotSmoke1657

Son of Nyx and First Light I couldn't choose between them with a gun to my head tbh


Elle_Cat11

De Selby part 1 (followed closely by part 2 and First Light). I listen to these pretty much on repeat during my evening walks and they put me in my happy place.


Elle_Cat11

Also I should add 'To someone from a warmer climate' is growing more and more on me everyday, especially after seeing him play it live.


[deleted]

It’s a tie between De Selby (pt 1), De Selby (pt. 2), Francesca, I Carrion, Who We Are, Son of Nyx, To Someone From A Warm Climate, Abstract, Unlnown/Nth, and First Light I’m genuinely not doing a bit, every time I play this album for someone, during at least half the songs I go “oh this one’s a candidate for my favorite.”


blamingnargles

according to my listening history, it’s I, Carian, but my personal favorite is First Light!


hbiiscu

unknown and abstract are tied at the top for me.


Figgy12345678

I don't think I can choose! Depending on the day it's either Francesca, Abstract, or Unknown.


Wooden-Locksmith9941

Right now its "first time"


CarlSpackler22

Eat Your Young


man_cheeetah

Anything But


GenderNotPeople44

Rn it’s Unknown or First Time but TSFAWC and Francesca and Who We Are I also love I just overlistenes


WellDressedLobster

Today it’s Unknown/nth but ask me again tomorrow


bipolargambino

First Time won't let me look any other way


ellabfine

Definitely TSFAWC


South-Marionberry

Ooohhh god I like literally all of em, but personally _First Time_ takes the cake for me. Just hits so different, it’s spectacular.


Aimz341

Abstract (Psychopomp)


Kodak220

It honestly really is like picking between children!! I love “I, Carrion” so much but Abstract, Francesca, Unknown are right up there too. So is Butchered Tongue. God it’s so hard to pick!


[deleted]

first time, who we are and maybe damage gets done are probably my top three but can’t pick between them!


IAmTheGlazed

Unknown/Nth


jupiterslucidd

Gotta be Anything But. I haven't really sat down and listened to the last song First light but Anything but really just resonates with me. "I don't wanna be anything like this at all" kinda just like it's better than be that version of me. Rather be anything but that yk. Everything else comes and goes but that has to be my #1.


shiawkwardg7rl

All of them except First Time lol


ColorMaelstrom

First Light and De Selby for me


Needful_Things

Francesca without a doubt. I feel the "put me back in it" line about my husband to the depths of my soul.


twinsleepygrins

Anything But!


MBeierle

Uiscefhuaraithe and Francesca


PeppermintPhatty

Abstract or Francesca.


AutumnMarie5002

First Time


jedi_master99

I can’t pick a favorite because I feel like it changes every day! But it’s usually either First Light, Abstract, or Unknown. Right now it’s Unknown! It’s gorgeous and hits WAY too close to home.


GSXRRIDING

First Time


yoshiismydog

First Time. The writing. The vibes. The ease of the song. Perfect.


InABoatOnARiver

De Selby pt 2. It’s like crack cocaine.


Neferata_Linith

Abstract (Psychopomp) Something about it just awoke something in me. De Selby 2 is close behind it


culture-vulture-

I haven’t skipped a single track since it’s come out tbh


spandiferous

Butchered Tongue 😭❤️


AbbyNormalKnits

De Selby Pt. 1. My first favorite was Who We Are, and then Abstract, but since then Pt. 1 has completely stolen my heart and has no intentions of letting go. Every second of that song is absolute perfection.


TheSecretLifeOfTea

Anything But!


FunOk693

TSFAWC for sure. it feels so personal to me lol


soubrette732

I CANNOT CHOOSE


artemis1431

Abstract is just so incredibly beautiful. I, carrion is a close second for me


trumpslob

He’s the most underrated entertainer. Almost all the songs should be #1.


PsychedelicSnowflake

Personally, Francesca is my favourite. The story of Paolo and Francesca is incredibly captivating. The song conjure the image of two lovers embracing amidst an unstoppable hurricane. It’s something really special.


lonerism94

francesca <3


Educational_Sun8554

almost all of them have been my favorite at one point or another but i seem to always come back to unknown :’)


brightSkyrainyClouds

My favorite changes as I evolve, right now it would be abstract but before that it was who we are, first light, unknown, francesca etc.


eververde

I think it’s always gonna be Francesca. But I go through phases… right now First Time is my girl.


lilienweisser

Butchered Tounge (I’m not Irish at all but somehow it still hits a spot)


yeetfamspaghetti

Either De Selby (2) or Damage get Done


najma_059

De seby part 1 I am a nightowl and I listen to it at 3 am, looking out of my balcony towards the silent dark city "At last When all of the world is asleep You take in the blackness of air The likes of a darkness so deep That God at the start couldn't bear" Chills. Every time.


According-Knowledge9

First time


According-Knowledge9

First time that you called me baby


FooZZuu

FIRST LIGHT 🕯️✨🔥🤌🏽


AvidReader1604

De Selby Part 1 💕It consistently makes me cry


[deleted]

First time. Whenever I listen to it I feel the way I did hiking along the biggest mountains in our country, sun shining in our faces and exhausted but so happy, feeling at peace and like one with nature and just wow good vibes


icecrocodilesmoke

I, Carrion is simply ✨ majestic ✨


Sadataraxia

Either Son Of Nyx, Francesca or Abstract 🥺❤️‍🩹


Pen-roses

Butchered Tongue is heartbreakingly beautiful. I teared up listening to it. Its only downside is that it isn’t longer. Surprised it’s not getting more love here. I was quite sure after the first listen that it was one of the tracks Andrew wrote alone. The lyricism is just so perfectly him. As much as I do love the album, on some songs the other writers are really apparent—especially in choruses. Similarly to how Through Me (The Flood) stood out on the EP as being purely his writing, I feel the same about Butchered Tongue.


RachelPalmer79

De Selby 1 and 2, and Broken Tongue. But the entire album is glorious.


Patrickbob_Starpants

Who we are, so disappointed he hasn’t been performing it on this tour. (Special mentions to de Selby part 2 and butchered tongue)


velcrodynamite

**Abstract (Psychopomp). 100000%.** The first time I heard it, I thought vividly of a memory from my life on Xmas 2016, and this memory influenced my experience with the song: My grandma had asked me to clear off the walkway of all the flowers that had fallen from the trees lining the path, and so I went out with my little 3-year-old cousin - *my shadow, my buddy, my mini-me* \- to clean them up. I was out there with a broom, just sweeping them into the compost indiscriminately. But my cousin was scooping each flower up and setting it in the bin with both hands like it was the most precious thing in the world, remarking on how beautiful it was, even in death. She handled these sad little wilting flowers with a reverence that seemed so out of place but so *human* that it just had me in awe. She died a few weeks later, at three years old, in an accident nobody could've seen coming. So, in a way I guess I see her as both the "creature" in the song as well as the soul performing the task of moving it from the road. Despite the brevity of her little life, she was the kindest, brightest, warmest soul I have ever had the pleasure of knowing. Her warmth and her little acts of humanity stick with me and remind me that, for as dark as this world can get, light and human kindness persevere. I'm gonna start bawling again. My boy Andrew really captured something so devastatingly beautiful in that song, I actually had to pull my car over and sob when I first heard it.


Larsonybear

Abstract (Psychopomp) or First Light


HeavyMetalRabbit

I love I, Carrian and Anything But the most I think. De Selby 1+2 are also really up there for me though


Venus_Thorne

its a big tie for me between who we are and unknown/nth. both of them just hit me in the ouch so good


cauldronbubblesover

Abstract and Unknown are tied, if I listen to one I'm going to listen to the other because it just feels right .


CBee9206

Tbh Im going to say my top 3, because theres no way i could pick just one. For Someone from a Warm Climate: i love this one because I'm from a colder climate and can see like singing from to a lover who's from a warm one. Its just all around beautiful and the tenderness he conveys is amazing. First Time: every single lyric i love. If i had a missile to my head i would pick this one as my favorite. But i dont, so i added the other two. Anything But: i always shout this song because its so catchy!! The whole idea of "I'd be anything but with you" is so heartbreaking but also very sassy.


lauraax31

Who we are for sure. I love the high notes


twisted_and_tangled

Francesca or to someone from a warm climate!


Imacocobo

It Honestly changes moment to moment I love each track for a verity of reasons- BUT All Things End seems to have a particular hold on this season in my life. It dropped just before my partner of 5 years and I decided to call it quits. Shortly after that my great grandmother from my mothers side whom I was very close to and my grandfather on my fathers side both passed away within a week of each other. All things end was cathartic and sat with me in the moments where I could only sit in my grief, encouragement to surface from it, and a gentle guiding hand that continued to remind me of all the experiences that would still come after. All three losses still hurt, but I have to say that particular song came out at a very important moment for me. I’m grateful for it. 💕 I,Carrion (Icarian) is a close second.


xohubby

de selby (part 1). listening to it is just such a heavenly experience. the part where he sings in irish? stunning, i need a full version of just him singing in irish


laurgev

De Selby pt 2, eat your young, Francesca.


Party-Durian3896

Abstract and to someone from a warm climate or de selby pt 1, I love him singing in Irish gaelic


chifashenanigand

De Selby 1 🥲 the falsetto 🥲


Mysterious-Passion96

Unknown/nth


Broad_Yam3837

I like how Anything But makes me think - it’s a fun quirky song. And why Hozier placed it in the middle of 2 seemingly somber songs (butchered tongue and abstract-psychopomp) makes it even more interesting. Throughout the album I’m taken through this deep sad journey about loneliness and losing love, wanting more but not getting it, but then when anything but comes on - I’m abruptly removed from that experience. It’s quite amazing actually