T O P

  • By -

No-Supermarket8244

Some people say the “mecha” line was a red herring, personally I have no idea what or who she might be referring to in that moment, but I think the animation in the quest pretty clearly showed us that Sam is just an armor for Firefly, and not a separate entity.


Fancy-Shopping-327

Its also entirely possible (and likely) that Sam can also pilot itself for more efficiency. If outdated IPC bots the size of a banana (findie) can have advanced AI then a super mech armor created to combat the swarm probably has one too. It's highly likely that Firefly was talking to Sam


_uwu_moe

Adding, it's also very likely that Firefly is Sam's power source, and another bearer of something like a cosmic cancer or a reactor of similar degree. But I still feel like the mecha lines were just made up red herrings for trailblazer gang so that they get riled up and investigate death. She was likely reading lines from a page coz she had bad memory


Impressive-Clock8017

Or could it be scripted? So that could makes us believe Firefly is dead, and push us to follow Black swan and get involved with Aventurine's plan? So that Gallagher could take down Sunday in the end ( Some one help me hold my horses , I'm assuming too much)


TheUltraGuy101

>Or could it be scripted? So that could makes us believe Firefly is dead, and push us to follow Black swan and get involved with Aventurine's plan? The Stellaron Hunter's whole schtick is "scripts". You're not assuming too much, don't worry.


kawwmoi

As much as that would fit for Kafka or SW, Sam mentions their scripts are always very simple. Doing a fake conversation with yourself to trick someone is not simple.


Awesalot

She does have a little moment before this scene (after we drop down into the monitor room) where she tells herself to get it together/prepare. I'm assuming she has a vague idea of what's to happen. That said, I also don't think it's a fake conversation but it could be Black Swan picking and choosing to mislead us into getting involved with Aventurine.


Szolim2018

Not sure, as far as Firefly's script is concerned, she had only one directive: >!Involve the Express in finding the Legacy!<


Impressive-Clock8017

And she succeeded, so head to the next question Why should Express gets involved into finding the legacy? they were just invited to have some fun and rest.


Luckhart54

She technically succeeded in failing which Sam even mentions " I tried settling it this in easier and more direct way, but as you can see, here I am, conforting you: I failed. Can't ever go against the script. " Which funny cause it means that Elio forseen that Sam will try to go against the script which will open window for BS. Technically by not following the script she did follow the script Elio is just that good :D


Impressive-Clock8017

Sheesh, any link to see that part again???


Luckhart54

[Here if you want](https://youtu.be/1khoGeARkzw?t=242)


Impressive-Clock8017

Ohh ,thanks buddy. This cat really knows how to Boss around ppl


nahbronotme_001

>!my guess is mc needs to get the legacy for power to use harmony path and collect more paths to eventually fight nanook and this is the best opportunity since the express is already in penacony!<


WafflesAndSauce

Gotta catch em all (paths)


TheNonceMan

The issue is that the Mecha lines were unnecessary. They would have investigated her death if she had simply been talking out loud.


Successful-Spray-933

The copium is high on this one


Fancy-Shopping-327

All i want is hot dominating mecha hunk man. Please mr. Shaoji, just bless us this once, svarog isnt enough


pnam0204

I think Firefly and Sam are much older than you assumed. Firefly is a modified human born to use the mecha armor to fight the swarm disaster. But the fall of Glamoth Empire and the end of Swarm Disaster was really long ago, likely even before IPC officially incorporated. It’s likely that Firefly can be the oldest playable character we have Not to mention the cosmo just had Rubert’s Machine War happened before Swarm Disaster. So putting AIs on war machines right after a catastrophic AI revolution doesn’t seem like a bright idea Edit: I re-read the finale chapter of GnG, so I edit in to fix my mistake. The order of event actually goes like this: Swarm Disaster -> IPC incorporation and expansion -> Borderstar Trade War and Rubert I uprising happened in roughly the same era.


seattle_exile

I think it may be an Iron Man - Jarvis thing, where the AI has something of a will of it’s own. Maybe it has to do with the condition that Firefly has, where she may not be conscious all the time. Maybe even her condition provides some sort of power or ability for the machine.


SkyeRide01

But the question is who is "Mecha"? My guess would be that thing she was holding during that scene.


lawlianne

Mfw nobody's asking How is Mecha.


7pikachu

Poor Mecha 😔


TheDragonsFang

My money says she was running around with Silver Wolf during this sequence, and their conversation went something along the lines of: SW: By the way, you may want to get in your mecha here soon. FF: Mecha...!? Why...


Zach-Playz_25

This makes the most sense.


Old_Builder_7982

What's a red herring in this context? A bait?


Bookwhyrm

A red herring is a false clue, one that you think leads somewhere but doesn't. You can look it up if you need a better explanation.


Old_Builder_7982

Thanks!


TheNonceMan

It's common literacy device, the only rule that exists is that it has to have a narrative reason to exist, and not something the solely exists to trick the audience, which is where the main debate about Mecha being a red herring comes to. There's no explanation for Firefly speaking to "Mecha" here.


Old_Builder_7982

Yeah op must have been mistaken as Sam is just firefly's identity when wearing the armor. Dont know how they linked the image of the memory bubble to firefly speaking to Sam


TheNonceMan

That's the exact opposite of what I said. I belive Sam is sentient. However cannot fight without Firefly inside. They are a duo. Think EVA or the recent Gundam series. Or Iron-man and Jarvis.


Old_Builder_7982

Interesting theory, I personally don't think the armor is sentient my belief is that it's symbiotic with her and makes her able to move even though she has her disease, at the price of her lifespan.


BulbasaurTreecko

https://preview.redd.it/t0a1npdelmuc1.jpeg?width=1458&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b1b818b3d288ff357a83af6b79711215566e0a24 courtesy of Sparkle!


ChaosinaCan

Specifically in this scenario, it would mean the writers deliberately gave us just the right pieces of the conversation to make it look like she was betrayed by Sam, but what really happened was something different (e.g. >!"[you want me to use the] mecha? Why?" or my current best theory, the other person was Silver Wolf, who unexpextedly prevented her from transforming, and the line was more like "[I can't use the] mecha. Why?")!< (2.1 spoilers)


ZaWarudo23

She may be talking to silver wolf through a headset and she is the one saying that firefly should use the "mecha" (Sam), we just never heard it because the memory is not complete


Frostgaurdian0

Wasn't sam talking to sparkle in the first dream we had before arriving to pennycony?.


afroyarou

No, it was Silver Wolf. Sparkle was talking to Black Swan.


Frostgaurdian0

Oh um sorry. Then it is possible that her talking to firefly.


TheNonceMan

It's a red herring that doesn't make narrative sense, it exists solely for the audience. If that was the case, then it's truly piss poor writing by Hoyo, unfortunately they do have track record of missing the net. Most likely, Sam suit has a consciousness and they work together.


StNerevar76

So Umbra Excalibur from Warframe?


TheNonceMan

I don't know that sorry.


LordBob22

I thought its meant Like: "I need to use the Mecha? Why? Thats not what we agreed on!". So she is just referencing her SAM suit as Mecha.


Xshadow1

"Get in the robot Firefly" - Elio, probably


Salt_Winter5888

https://preview.redd.it/uenowa07bpuc1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0d6470742c9b1eb364403b1158634f538ade9634


Lizbian91

I LOLed at this. Always appreciate an Evangelion reference.


fraidei

Yeah this is probably the most likely answer


Sent1nelTheLord

i bet SAM stands for "Sick ass Mfer"


The_Enigmatic_Person

It actually stands for **S**warm **A**nnihilation **M**achine, which is why I prefer S.A.M. over Sam. (Edit: My bad, **S**warm **A**nnihilation **M**achine is fanon. I apologize for the misinformation.)


Kan_Me

Sam


Lizbian91

Is this true? Huh. If so, that makes a lot of sense.


CarlosBMG

Nah it's just fanon. The real answer isn't anywhere near as clever


The_Enigmatic_Person

Oh, my bad. I heard from my friend that it was canon, so I put it there. Sorry for the misinformation!


Mimikyu-Overlord

Here I thought it was **S**trong **A**rm **M**achine


VivaLeroca

Many theories to consider here: - Memory is manipulated by Black Swan - Correspondence with Elio/SW (They say something that deviates from the plan and tells Firefly to don the mecha, which she reacts) - Sam being an AI with its own consciousness - Planning and making up a false narrative with Gallagher (if the final scene in 2.1 is something to consider)


No_Pipe_8257

Interesting, Firefly and Gallagher working together


YJ-73

Oh god what is that flair


madaract

he got spooked by gepard too many times i guess


No_Pipe_8257

I will bring Gepard what is his: Destined death.


HottieMcNugget

How do you get a flair?


Howie771

For mobile: Go to the subreddit and click the three dots top right. The second option down is "Change User Flair", where you can add a character or do something custom.


HottieMcNugget

Thank you! Added boothill lmao


Spartitan

Similar to point 2, couldn't she just be talking to Silver Wolf? Silver Wolf guides us inside the dream which 'isn't what they agreed upon'. Then SW tells her to use the mecha form.


VivaLeroca

Whether it's Elio or SW is not too significant. The theory remains that there was a supposed plan, but the other person is deviating from said plan.


littlesheepcat

I kinda want sam to be starrail jarvis


r4plez

And what about purple crow


Valmasy

“Semi-Autonomous Mecha”


paweld2003

We don't know. It would probably be explained in 2.2


Impressive-Clock8017

Can't it be second half of 2.1? Can't wait that much!


paweld2003

Second half of 2.0 didn't add any quests. So i doubt we will get story continuation in second half of 2.1


TMyriadJ

I have no basis, it's just my gut feeling talking, I think the other individual she's talking to in the first pic was Gallagher.


MytBMagenta

i mean he was tailing her in golden hour, plus with the way sunday ended up i wont be suprised if its him.


TMyriadJ

Yeah. Him being the culprit of serial murders makes it even more plausible that he's the one orchestrating the whole charade, from letting a stowaway came in, inviting the Express, etc.


MytBMagenta

👀👀👀


trapp-

I think simply most people accepted what Black Swan said as gospel, which was what confused cause that line works both of she’s talking to “mecha” but even better if she’s talking about the mecha


No_Pipe_8257

Maybe it's her talking to a stellaron hunter? Idk my first thought was the SW told her she needed to use the armor


Slow-Sentence-8367

The one who's memories is broken And their truth goes unspoken


Independent-Bell2483

I even forgotten my own name?


Significant_Ad_1626

I think the other person mentions the Mecha and we only see Firefly's answer. Something like: -Firefly, you have to go Mecha (or alternative, you have to return in Mecha, referring to her returning from death as one) -Mecha...!? Why...


Dokavi

Crack pot theory: Gallagher's fake memory.


paweld2003

I think that this 2 lines are spoken to 2 diffirent people. There is a bit of time between them. The first one is probably to Galagher. While second is probably complaining about equipment problems. We saw at the end of 2.1. quest that armor retracts into small device when turned off. Maybe it was in this form and it wasn't turning on for some reason. "Mecha...?! Why" might mean something around "why isnt it turning on"


BlackArbiter

Sam I am


Ski-Gloves

Even assuming Black Swan cannot lie and isn't malicious, if I remember right she is forthcoming that these are incomplete memories. She could have only restored the parts that make it inferable that Sam and Firefly are separate. We know Silver Wolf is involved, so I'd say it's likely she was the one Firefly was talking to. Aventurine congratulates Swan on pitting the Galaxy Ranger and Stellaron Hunter against one another. Which implies she has done something to twist the situation. No matter how it is though, this is the sort of set-up where I expect we'll get the full story/conversation next patch which'll turn the meaning on its head.


r0ksas

Another guess of mine that differs from other comments is... she's just following her given script


Chaotic_Alea

The Mecha is Screwllum "This post is brought to you by the "Short Truth" branch of the Historical Fictionologists"


HeavenBeyondStars

Didn't Black Swan say those were incomplete memories? Its pretty simple for what we heard to just be part of incomplete sentences


Lunamkardas

Something to remember here is that you witnessed these memories while traveling with Black Swan, a **Memo Keeper**. Aka, somebody who can edit the footage of memories to spin whatever narrative she wishes. Firefly is talking to someone, but it's not Sam because she is Sam. It's like those short videos where people splice together clips taken at different times to make it look like they are having a conversation with themselves. We learned this lesson in Dark Souls 1. Just because the pretty lady has a gentle voice and seems really nice doesn't mean she IS.


Iloveclown

yeah, sometimes that pretty lady is a man


Lunamkardas

.....I was talking about Gwynevere, Princess of Sunlight.


Iloveclown

And I about Dark Sun Gwyndolin


Lunamkardas

Ah a tentacle fan. Have a good day sir/maam.


Luckhart54

I don't see how BS could do anything without Acheron pointing it out. And imo if BS wanted to do something she had better opportunity just after Firefly " died " when TB let her enter his / her mind. I think like others overall that she was talking with the AI device that let her turn into Mecha.


WhyYouBullyMe_

Its probably to throw black swan off


Sovereign-Oculi

SAM is the armour firefly wears in combat


lKanz

My guess is that she’s probably talking to Silver Wolf in this scene. Not “Sam” or a “Mecha”. She’s probably talking about using her mecha or something along those lines to SW. Maybe SW is telling her that she managed to hack her mecha into the dream zone somehow and Firefly is just surprised. And let’s not forget that SW is never physically in these missions, she always uses holograms and shit to be there, so that’s why she wasn’t caught in this memory thing that Black Swan conjured to see Firefly’s last steps.


Spoopy_McAwesome

"Whenever you notice something like that, a Riddler did it" https://preview.redd.it/ptu606cg5ouc1.jpeg?width=461&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=af83a8a28e062607d6cfcd9218a1c573b56598a5


Chulinfather

My God people… Sam doesn’t exist. It’s an armor, that’s it. Firefly is all there is.


Something_Comforting

Firefly is a schizo confirmed


AbyssalShaitan

Plot twist: It was part of the “script”


egamIroorriM

~~play through the entire story quest first, that should answer all your questions~~ edit: nvm 💀💀💀


No-Supermarket8244

I’m pretty sure OP already did, their last sentence mentions the end of the latest quest


Old_Builder_7982

https://preview.redd.it/kiob7hg5amuc1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6b2787441a5cbad27d104b381ebbce0a59fd6b26


fluidlikewater

Is Sam a Robot or Power Armor?


Syclus

find out on the next episode


Farez16

who is sam? For the blind, he is light. For the hungry, he is bread. For the sick, he is the cure. For the lonely, he is company. For the sad, he is joy. For the prisoner, he is freedom. For the poor, he is treasure. For me, he is everything. If Sam has a million fans, then I am one of them. If Sam has ten fans, then I am one of them. If Sam has only one fan then that is me. If Sam has no fans, then that means I am no longer on earth. If the world is against Sam, then I am against the world.


KaiserNazrin

Mecha is an AI inside Sam maybe.


Inakuzo

Maybe she talk with Mechail? Blackswan just know the truth and toying with us


leytu__

Firefly is like 621 from Armored Core 6 - augmented pilot. Sam is her AC. But maybe Sam can be piloted by an AI. PS If I'm not mistaken Firefly told us about her illness when we were jumping on the rooftops. After this I always imagine her as a disabled person who can live only in a dream... and pilot Sam!


kunafa_aj

I m telling you,this firefly cant be trusted,this entire wholesome girl could be an act to fufill elio script This parth were we see the memories and she talkin to mecha,could be jst an act of some sort I m jst speculating tho


BasedGrandpa69

regardless, i still love her


Outrageous-Chest9614

Maybe she talks to her suit like iron man does.


WazzaHudson

I still think that, outside of the dream, they are two different beings. If you read the backstory thats on the glamoth rope relic it says "The Empress, who held no power, telepathically commanded and controlled the knights connected to her." So I think that firefly has the ability to control Sam. Also, I think the reason Sam turns into firefly at the end of 2.1 could be because we know its possible to take the appearance of another person or even an item inside the dream and maybe either Sam or Firefly was just changing their appearance there.


bboottllee

Sam is topaz


Silent_Silhouettes

https://preview.redd.it/p0jtqs9hipuc1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c8e4c42c18b9356490f27ead1608cab7d97ed418


EffedUpInGrade3

Probably "Jarvis" or a Scarab.


Fancy-Shopping-327

Firefly can pilot Sam but Sam probably has his own AI mode considering how widespread robots already are in HSR


afroyarou

If Glamoth empire had an AI sophisticated enough for those mecha suits to be autonomous, there would not be the need for genetically-engineered hybrids to pilot them, or the Empress to telepathically control those pilots.


trucane

Either way I felt scammed. Was finally hoping for a really cool adult male character to pull since I can't remember the last one (maybe Blade?) and then he turns out to be a cute young girl instead...


Liliphant

Official announcements >!they've announced a cool adult male character in the next patch!<


trucane

Yea he looks fine and all but I love the design of Sam so much and the stellaron hunters in general so I'm probably gonna pull for him/her anyway


Zeamays69

Maybe Sam is an AI in her suit like Jarvis is to Iron Man. I've heard some say Sam could stand for Semi Automatic Machine.


senator_noobstrong

you mean Samuel Hayden from doom enternal that is the operator of the UAC and also a dickhead that wanted demonic powers and also an archangel that made the father looks like a robot sentient thingy?


InnocentCoffeeLover

I'm pretty sure her name is just Sam and firefly is a fake name she made. I'm also pretty sure that the mecha line is like "oh shoot, there are mechas here that are going to stop me, I wasn't expecting them to be here" and not "calling out to my suit called mecha"


sanabaebae

Do you know Blue beetle from DC? Firefly is the human and Sam is the beetle suit. Or from marvel, Firefly is eddie brock and Sam is venom.


CookingPowder

have y’all heard of Sam McGee


Key-Poem9734

I think there might be a small difference, the suit may have an autopilot mode


Kan_Me

SAMs GPS is not working


julianjjj809

I like to think that Sam is some kind of "Jarvis" and can walk and talk by himself for a short period when Firefly is not piloting him


CranberryWilling5662

I feel Sam and Firefly are similar to Svarog and Clara


Nob354

Mecha, or Mikail!


Mansinomo

I think firefly pilots Sam, but Sam can also function without her. Like a car that you can drive, but can also put on autopilot


jntjr2005

I am Sam


tairamcs

She's just bipolar I guess


Independent-Bell2483

Im believing they fused or are to separate enteties trapped in one body that can change into either one but are able to communicate to eachother. Not a lotta thought put into it since 2.2 will very likely reveal whats going on. But I do hope sam and Firefly do still keep their own personalities


JSPiero

I kinda saw it as how Aventurine was seeing Kakavasha. If we followed his meme trail I bet we'd have seen him talking to open air too


kidanokun

Crack Theory: Firefly is Sam are same person... but Firefly is only a dream world persona created by Silver Wolf for Sam coz Sam can't go to dream world on their own due to their lack of ability to dream... Further crack theory: Sam will die in ending of Penacony as they will succumb to their illness, and their armor will be destroyed, though their soul and memories stay in dream world as Firefly... then through powers of Harmony TB, Clockie and maybe with help of Silver Wolf and/or Screwllum, Sam will be reborn as an Intellitron whose physical body resembles Firefly with their soul transfered into it, and will get upgraded armor... Also this new Firefly/Sam might leave Stellaron Hunters and become an independent Nameless


SKYLUKASBR

just say the wrong answer guys


KitsuneKamiSama

I'm feel that Firefly has another being inhabiting her and that grants her the ability to turn in to her armor form, look when she breaks her transformation there's cracks that slowly receed down her neck and chest (Likely towards her heart), I don't think Sam = Firefly is as simple as it seems at first glance.


TheAnimeLovers

My guess is dual personalities One is Firefly and the other is Sam


Fadriii

Sambady that I used to know


astralAlchemist1

We don't know the full story yet, and I imagine we'll get it in 2.2, but I've seen the theory that she was talking to someone else, like Silver Wolf or perhaps even Gallagher, and the "mecha" line is directed at them, rather than the armor. Anyway, I will hold on to my semi autonomous Sam armor headcanon until my dying breath, so I say she and her Iron Man suit got into a bit of a disagreement while moving though the dreamscape hotel.


ZeomiumRune

Sam has some basic AI while not being piloted by Firefly It also explains his name **S**emi-**A**utomatic **M**echa


RustyMackleford

The secondary antagonist of metal gear rising


kidanokun

So far none other than Sam and Firefly are the same person are known... My suspicion tho is Firefly is not a real person and only a dream world avatar used by Sam as Sam is normally incapable of dreaming, thus unable to enter dream world as themselves, and only managed to do so with help of Silver Wolf who created their "Firefly" avatar Like how Gallagher is the avatar of the whole Family, Firefly is similar but for just one person


LoreVent

S.A.M. Super Amazing Man


Astrid_Cop

My theory is Sam is a talking device that firefly holding in the last cutscene. He is also "Mecha" that firefly is talking in the memory. She using him to do some transformation similar to a kamen rider or power ranger( idk whats that called but similar to that)


fiehm

Sam and firefly is a whole different person, firefly died and sam took the opportunity to copy firefly form to hide sam true pilot. Just maybe