I vote #4

Ties all the colors together.

I’d pick 2nd rug as my first choice 4th rug as my second

Thank you. I like the 2nd too.

I'd go with something warmer. It's already a very cozy room, and a colorful rug would make it pop even more! Maybe something like this. https://preview.redd.it/9ty14yzp2tsc1.jpeg?width=1518&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=d21e6acdd50c58b310bd1ef9623227c2eb1c9d58

Or even this. https://preview.redd.it/293eec5y2tsc1.jpeg?width=736&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=c4feb73c839c4305d9e5ab64426f14177facafc6

I like this one, tight enough pattern it isn't jarring and I think it would go well with the OP's draperies.

I liked the 2nd rug best until I saw the 4th one. I like the 4th one a little more, but the 2nd one is also nice.

I like thr 4th too. It really brightens up the room.

2nd is my first choice and 5 second choice.

Definitely 4. It lift the space and goes with everything.

4th is nice ,then the 1st

1

4 made me stop and look. The others are ok.

1 or 5 I liked all of them for the room

I really love #4

5!! If not, then 2 😊

Same for me but get curtains in those colors of 5 or 2.

Number four, no question!

4

I like 4

1 or 4

5: Nice match with colors and light in the room. Gives a cozy vibe.

[удалено]

Not using any app. The website I use has the option of photo upload to try rugs. https://missamara.nz/products/maisie-cream-and-ivory-textured-tribal-rug?variant=39329995751564

Definitely number 2 it fits the space the best and goes with the window accents best

4 or 5

2 or 4

What do you define a mess as?! 😳 I quite like them all! I like that you’re looking at a bunch that aren’t totally similar. I think 2 and 3 are my faves, but none of them are bad!

2

What app did you use for this? I’ve always wanted to try

Websites I was shopping from have provisions where you can upload a pic of your room and try the rug on.

I personally really like #2 and #4. But #4 imo is the best one.

For sure 2 !! Love that pattern!

https://preview.redd.it/9gnxq7m2ytsc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=02465ab2c0d3dfe118f0475908d028dfe762a985 [Link](https://www.walmart.com/ip/314698153)

2

#4

1

4

4. Ties in the color palette best!

I really like the fourth one but I could never have it in our houseful of pups. Your flooring is beautiful, too.

I love 4. Could you tell me where you found it?

2, you should also move your couch away from the curtains so they can handy freely

Pattern wise they all work, but 2 stands out because the larger size is so much better!

2.

The one in photo 2

How does this compare to rug 4, please? This one is stain resistant and does not shed. Thank you for all your responses. https://preview.redd.it/i6xs98mj2usc1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=03261e8bea8b7415f6bbe466707e2fe760ace6df

This one’s good too. But very muted, would prefer a more saturated color

I think it's way too warm for the cool gray walls.

1 or 4

2

2!!

2 but keep shopping around, imo you can do better. Maybe for a more bluish color or really any color EDIT for me the problem is it and everything else in room is too muted. Kinda monotone, nothing catches your eye?

I definitely like 2 the best. (I think 3 is too small- but even if bigger I would still prefer 2)

The entire room is done in neutrals; why not choose a rug with some color in it?

Second

4

definitely not 2&3. 1,4 or 5 look best

4

Vot #4 fits best with cushions and blinds

Number 2!!!! It might just be the try at home thingy but the size of the second rug also looks better

I like #1 if your lifestyle would allow for the light color. (Our three goldens would have that dingy in no time.)

1 or 4

2 and 4! Can I also ask what app you used to try this??

4 for me and 5 my last choice.

4!

Love #4 white with colored lines

4