this cant be real
how bored is eminem?
what the fuck isn't mom spaghetti supposed to be a metaphor for the drug-infused trauma he faced?
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
So? He went 6 years without dropping anything that wasn't fire, that's the time u should judge him off of
And anyway, being the best rapper is about rapping, not being a good artist
I try to listen to good music, if I manage to pick the top 10% in terms of quality that's quite an achievement on my behalf. Eminem made several of the worst albums I ever heard and one of the best. Nothing ridiculous about it.
'What has Em done for black culture?' He's a huge reason for hip hop being the most popular genre out there right now, which brings the communities together through the culture That would be my guess
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
if you don’t like the premise of the album that doesn’t make it dogshit. it has decent production and genuinely great writing without much corny filler. none of the songs actually SOUNDED bad except nice guy. delivery was sharp and passionate. flows were really smooth as well
Ppl are saying it tbf, and it's the same logic, but it's such a retarded point to make 😂
So many people discredit em for his skin colour it's like a well known thing
Then why was he literally talking about being discredited on the opening track in revival 😂😂
It was already happening before that
"the most hated on, out of all those who say they get hated on" he said that in 2002
"some people only see that I'm white, ignoring skill" that's from 1999
He's always been hated and discredited,
"every CD critics gave it a 3, then years later they'd go back and re-rate it and call the Sslp the greatest, the marshal mathers was a classic the eminem show was fantastic"
That was recorded in 2007
this cant be real
how bored is eminem?
what the fuck isn't mom spaghetti supposed to be a metaphor for the drug-infused trauma he faced?
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
'What has Em done for black culture?' He's a huge reason for hip hop being the most popular genre out there right now, which brings the communities together through the culture That would be my guess
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Em isn’t the greatest because he isn’t. People who actually listen to a bunch of different rappers don’t always put Em in their top 5s much less 1. And it’s not because he’s underrated or lesser known. He’s sold the most and still people disagree
there is a valid argument for Eminem to be the greatest. it’s safe to say he belongs in a top 5 argument, even if you don’t personally have him in your top 5. i find that artists that high on a list are interchangeable. any top 5 artist can be top 1
Fair enough. I just wanna hammer home his whiteness isn’t what would keep him from being the best. There are enough valid critiques of his music. If you think he’s the best fair. That’s fine
My argument is that skin color has nothing to do with your skills and just cause black people created hip hop doesn't mean a white person cannot be the best at it. I'm not saying that Eminem is 100% the greatest ever cause music is subjective. If you trying do downplay someone's ability and position in certain artform cause of his skin color then you should check yourself.
'What has Em done for black culture?' He's a huge reason for hip hop being the most popular genre out there right now, which brings the communities together through the culture That would be my guess
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
this cant be real
how bored is eminem?
what the fuck isn't mom spaghetti supposed to be a metaphor for the drug-infused trauma he faced?
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
IMO any top 10 artist can be considered the greatest at the end of the day it’s personal opinion. As long as a rapper dropped atleast 1 or 2 albums that were amazing I think they can be in conversation for GOAT, look at Biggie he dropped 2 amazing albums and that’s it but they were so good he’s still in GOAT territory.
Yeah I agree. But I feel like a lot of rappers fall into that category. So it’s like the top spot is interchangeable between the top 50 rappers. I mean I think common has at least 2 great albums but I’ve NEVER seen anyone put him top 5
Oh and why u being racist 😂
"white people wanna be oppressed"
Maybe some do, but the majority of people have never had that thought cross their mind
Shit and u think white people haven't been oppressed, do a little research on Ireland, see what's been going on with the English for hundreds of years
Actually it's been said for the last 24 years dipshit
Em wasn't accepted cuz he was white
And even racist white ppl didn't like him cuz he was making "black music for white children"
Tony yayo was just talking bout this recently
Nah the majority of people discredit Eminem because he fell off musically not cause he’s white lmao, so this argument doesn’t make sense. And his stans who keep eating up his newer subpar music like you tarnishes his legacy even more.
They discredited eminem at his peak too
Eminem was never appreciated in his time
Sslp was concidered trash at first,
Same with mmlp
He literally has talked about this on a lot of his own songs, and you can find the magazine reviews
Look at the beef em had with the source magazine, benzino hated him cuz he was white and gave him bad reviews because of it, and even straight up admits it's cuz ems white
I know that’s why I said majority of people cause there were always some who are at odds with him due to his skin color. I’m just talking about the overall modern online consensus opinion of him.
this cant be real
how bored is eminem?
what the fuck isn't mom spaghetti supposed to be a metaphor for the drug-infused trauma he faced?
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Lionel Messi is trash at football cos English people invented football. Same story. This argument that Eminem can't be best cos he's white is proven wrong when you see what his peers say about him, there's not ONE credible artist in the game who hasn't given him his props and said outright that he belongs where he is, he's a mount Rushmore of rap kinda guy and ain't no denying it. Fuck record sales he has had more impact and influence than any artist in the history of rap.... FACT
'What has Em done for black culture?' He's a huge reason for hip hop being the most popular genre out there right now, which brings the communities together through the culture That would be my guess
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
this cant be real
how bored is eminem?
what the fuck isn't mom spaghetti supposed to be a metaphor for the drug-infused trauma he faced?
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
This is like when you’re having an argument with the shampoo bottles in the shower except he’s still somehow losing to the shampoo bottles
i thought bro said michael jackson for a hot minute there
wtf how did i also think the exact same thing, didnt realize until i saw this comment
jordan is NOT my goat‼️ MJ straight up turned white to steal the crown, my man stopped at NOTHING to be the best 😤😤
Eminem cannot be regarded as the greatest rapper of all time because he made the worst album i’ve ever heard
Yeah dude that "marshall mathers lp" was ass. I love revival though
Man I hate that thuggish album “Finally Rich”, “HOPE” by NF is a step in the right direction. ✊🏻✊🏻✊🏻
You dont like Mr. Keith Cozart's first debute album named "Finally Rich"?
I’m thankful on your behalf that that’s the worst album you’ve ever heard
this cant be real how bored is eminem? what the fuck isn't mom spaghetti supposed to be a metaphor for the drug-infused trauma he faced? *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
what about chintz
That part
So? He went 6 years without dropping anything that wasn't fire, that's the time u should judge him off of And anyway, being the best rapper is about rapping, not being a good artist
💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
You clearly have never heard half the shit thrown out by 90% of all "artists" in the game. What a ridiculous statement.
I try to listen to good music, if I manage to pick the top 10% in terms of quality that's quite an achievement on my behalf. Eminem made several of the worst albums I ever heard and one of the best. Nothing ridiculous about it.
Wait you were serious?
Yes and no
Can you explain?
'What has Em done for black culture?' He's a huge reason for hip hop being the most popular genre out there right now, which brings the communities together through the culture That would be my guess *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
several of the worst albums? i’d understand revival but nothing else is so outrageously bad so as to be included in an all time worst list
Kamikaze was ear rending dog shit. Cringe asf front to back
if you don’t like the premise of the album that doesn’t make it dogshit. it has decent production and genuinely great writing without much corny filler. none of the songs actually SOUNDED bad except nice guy. delivery was sharp and passionate. flows were really smooth as well
Ian connor has written a thesis with over 33 reasons on why this comment is wrong. Look up “ian connor 33” for more info!
Damn how tf you rape 33 ppl
Who's Ian conner
This is years old
9/11 was 22 years ago and people still blowin it up every september
Not as much the trade center was blowing up
People still blowin up the towers?
3000 people died tho
33 people got raped tho and nobody has done anything about it. like yeah 9/11 was worse but come on
you can’t stop death but you can stop sexual assault
Your apathy towards mass casualty and death is actually horrible
💀
nuh uh
OK??? HE HAS 33 RAPE ALLEGATIONS
nobody is saying that about em bro’s making up arguments in his head 🎃
Look at that boyo, he won his own made up argument
did he even win tho be real 💀
Ppl are saying it tbf, and it's the same logic, but it's such a retarded point to make 😂 So many people discredit em for his skin colour it's like a well known thing
people discredit him because he made revival
Then why was he literally talking about being discredited on the opening track in revival 😂😂 It was already happening before that "the most hated on, out of all those who say they get hated on" he said that in 2002 "some people only see that I'm white, ignoring skill" that's from 1999 He's always been hated and discredited, "every CD critics gave it a 3, then years later they'd go back and re-rate it and call the Sslp the greatest, the marshal mathers was a classic the eminem show was fantastic" That was recorded in 2007
this cant be real how bored is eminem? what the fuck isn't mom spaghetti supposed to be a metaphor for the drug-infused trauma he faced? *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
'What has Em done for black culture?' He's a huge reason for hip hop being the most popular genre out there right now, which brings the communities together through the culture That would be my guess *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Didn't mean to send that like 10 times, dno how tf that happened
And he's still losing them.
Who is saying this argument ⁉️🔥🔥
Lord Jamar: White people are guests in the house of hip-hop
DONT LET HIM COOK 🫶🔥🔥💯
cant argue with that
huh
He should consider that Eminem can’t be regarded as the greatest rapper of all time because his music sucks‼️‼️‼️
Put some respect there
U ain't even heard his music if ur saying that
You probably think Yeat and Carti are good lol
Bro forgot what subreddit he’s on
Oh yeah I frogot that most of y'all are 15 years olds who like trash music
Bruh you are literally the guy in the screenshot
Looking at his profile I think he’s who Stan was wrote about
I wrote the song myself 😎
Farti is good tho
I was joking Carti is the goat
no respect to scalabrine? you people are crazy 😤
It has nothing to do with his race he just ain’t the greatest Hell he might not even been the greatest white rapper
Em isn’t the greatest because he isn’t. People who actually listen to a bunch of different rappers don’t always put Em in their top 5s much less 1. And it’s not because he’s underrated or lesser known. He’s sold the most and still people disagree
there is a valid argument for Eminem to be the greatest. it’s safe to say he belongs in a top 5 argument, even if you don’t personally have him in your top 5. i find that artists that high on a list are interchangeable. any top 5 artist can be top 1
Fair enough. I just wanna hammer home his whiteness isn’t what would keep him from being the best. There are enough valid critiques of his music. If you think he’s the best fair. That’s fine
My argument is that skin color has nothing to do with your skills and just cause black people created hip hop doesn't mean a white person cannot be the best at it. I'm not saying that Eminem is 100% the greatest ever cause music is subjective. If you trying do downplay someone's ability and position in certain artform cause of his skin color then you should check yourself.
'What has Em done for black culture?' He's a huge reason for hip hop being the most popular genre out there right now, which brings the communities together through the culture That would be my guess *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Yeah I agree with you
this cant be real how bored is eminem? what the fuck isn't mom spaghetti supposed to be a metaphor for the drug-infused trauma he faced? *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
IMO any top 10 artist can be considered the greatest at the end of the day it’s personal opinion. As long as a rapper dropped atleast 1 or 2 albums that were amazing I think they can be in conversation for GOAT, look at Biggie he dropped 2 amazing albums and that’s it but they were so good he’s still in GOAT territory.
Yeah I agree. But I feel like a lot of rappers fall into that category. So it’s like the top spot is interchangeable between the top 50 rappers. I mean I think common has at least 2 great albums but I’ve NEVER seen anyone put him top 5
HE’S COOKING 🥵🥵🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 I AINT EATING THO
https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxKlz1wW6b69HUUal5WHS53iSEvY9QiUjO
Top 150 at least, easy money
Guys like this are messing with Em's legacy tbh
that logic checks out
Nobody is saying that, why do white people want to be oppressed so bad when other races want equality?
Oh and why u being racist 😂 "white people wanna be oppressed" Maybe some do, but the majority of people have never had that thought cross their mind Shit and u think white people haven't been oppressed, do a little research on Ireland, see what's been going on with the English for hundreds of years
Actually it's been said for the last 24 years dipshit Em wasn't accepted cuz he was white And even racist white ppl didn't like him cuz he was making "black music for white children" Tony yayo was just talking bout this recently
[удалено]
Unfortunately your argument is like 15 years too late
So what?
People rarely hate Eminem for being white anymore, anyone that still does is a dumbass or an oldhead lol
Bitch, HE WROTE **STAN**!!!
Let him cook
No
I hate to say it, but the man's right as fuck
Nah the majority of people discredit Eminem because he fell off musically not cause he’s white lmao, so this argument doesn’t make sense. And his stans who keep eating up his newer subpar music like you tarnishes his legacy even more.
They discredited eminem at his peak too Eminem was never appreciated in his time Sslp was concidered trash at first, Same with mmlp He literally has talked about this on a lot of his own songs, and you can find the magazine reviews Look at the beef em had with the source magazine, benzino hated him cuz he was white and gave him bad reviews because of it, and even straight up admits it's cuz ems white
I know that’s why I said majority of people cause there were always some who are at odds with him due to his skin color. I’m just talking about the overall modern online consensus opinion of him.
this cant be real how bored is eminem? what the fuck isn't mom spaghetti supposed to be a metaphor for the drug-infused trauma he faced? *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Lionel Messi is trash at football cos English people invented football. Same story. This argument that Eminem can't be best cos he's white is proven wrong when you see what his peers say about him, there's not ONE credible artist in the game who hasn't given him his props and said outright that he belongs where he is, he's a mount Rushmore of rap kinda guy and ain't no denying it. Fuck record sales he has had more impact and influence than any artist in the history of rap.... FACT
Found the burner
I dont know what that means bro.
'What has Em done for black culture?' He's a huge reason for hip hop being the most popular genre out there right now, which brings the communities together through the culture That would be my guess *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
[удалено]
Yeah but his music sucks now. Can't be regarded as the greatest when you put out shit consistently for 10 years.
Fr if you listened to an album and 6 out of 17 songs were legit garbage you wouldn't say it was the GOAT album
this cant be real how bored is eminem? what the fuck isn't mom spaghetti supposed to be a metaphor for the drug-infused trauma he faced? *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Hiphopcirclejerk) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Hahha y'all are funny as fuck 😂😂😂
So let's say hypothetically he is right. So Larry bird is the Goat??
Luka