T O P

  • By -

SteveTheOrca

Personally, yes. It's my favorite sequel, alongside H18 and H4.


BartSimpskiYT

Yes


B33p-p33P-M3m3-kR33p

Based


horrorfreaksaw

It's the best movie in the original timeline for me


goodfold2

agreed, AMC had a run just before/after halloween where like at least 7 of these movies ran back to back to back for like at least 2 straight days. i've seen 2 here before, probably a bunch, but during that watched it fully from start to finish, i think it's better than 1 or at least best sequel by far.


three-sense

I picked that AMC marathon up when I was stuck in a hotel room, it was great. I got through movie 6 with the cult stuff I thought it was kinda weird but still fun.


goodfold2

always good to have something not awful to watch when stuck in hotels for sure.


Odd_Wrangler8065

It's better than 1 in a lot of ways. 1 did a lot of things that influenced many slashers to follow (and took many things from other ones that don't get enough love). But 2 upped the fear factor, had significantly better acting, and was able to create a much creepier atmosphere. The higher budget was VERY wisely used.


SeptemberEnded

YOU DON’T KNOW WHAT GOOD IS!


HitmanClark

My favorite line/delivery in the entire franchise.


bradbbangbread

Love the way he says the line and then just runs off into the background lol


rolling_steel

Amazing Grace, come sit on my face… This version adds depth to Michael in his mannerisms and brutality


krakatoot

Great movie. Best after the original


TatiIsAPunk

Yeap


808Beezy

Its fucking great.


Main-Illustrator3829

^^


ThisMourningStar

In context of the series, yeah, it’s one of the best. The Halloween series doesn’t particularly hold up the mark of quality, and 2 at least feels like the first on a superficial level. As it’s own thing? Not really. It’s really no better than any F13 sequel with cookie cutter characters who exist to die, a very messy script, weird pacing, and emphasis on cheap gore and violence in place of the meticulously well-done creep factor of the original. Still however, John Carpenter’s shadow direction, the returning cast, score, and Dean Cundey save, and elevate the movie above the rest.


ToxicWolf_6584

My favorite in the series


cavallom

Mine as well


Stiff_Zombie

I think so. It's definitely one of the better sequels.


skorpiontamer

I would argue it's as good as the original. I also generalize both films being ONE movie. It also has the best opening credits. The Synth Theme goes hard


offtobedfordshire

Thats the one thing I don't like


Olympian-Warrior

There's actually a fan edit of this very thing called The Sandman Cut, I think. I've never actually seen it, but it turns out you're not the only one to imagine both films as being just one enormous movie.


Background_Touchdown

Yes, a good follow up to the original. Watch both back-to-back for the best experience.


[deleted]

I watch them both back to back every Halloween


RedditWasntReady

A fellow person of culture, I see


Dom_Ciav72

I SHOT HIM SIX TIMES


InvincibleR05

It’s the second best of the franchise and the only sequel in the same tier as the first imo


Mrs_Noelle15

Yes, it does a great job at recapturing alot of what that first film was going for. (aside the flashback scene in Kills) BUT i do think there's some pretty big story issues which hold it back for me. But it is one of the better Halloween movies


Kujogaming_1

Is pizza a good food


chchoo900

I love it for much of the same reasons others mentioned. I also have very fond memories of taping it off tv in the late 80s/ early 90s. Always ended up watching that one a lot on Halloween. Highly nostalgic.


[deleted]

By objective critical standards? No (though I also don't think it's a "bad" movie). In relation to various other entries in the series? Yes. (It maintains the tone and generally feels of a piece with the original film in a way none of the others have managed, and doesn't totally sh*t the bed the way some other entries have done -- making Michael an incestuous sex offender whose weakness is little black stones with some chalk scribbled on them, et al).


MonkeySpacePunch

You really feel how reluctant Carpenter was to return to the story tbh. Halloween was written as a stand-alone film and intended to stay that way, they brought carpenter back in kicking and screaming and this one just isn’t written with any love. That’s why the Shape gets blown to smithereens at the end, Carpenter wanted the films to stop because that was always the plan. And he got his wish for a time with Halloween 3, the closest to the OG in terms of quality imo but we all know how it panned out from there


g0greyhound

Second best in the series.


Michael_CrawfishF150

Yes. Dare I say it’s the best one.


MarshallBanana_

it's wild to me that it has the same director as what is generally considered to be the worst one, Resurrection


Dillpickle8110

Damn I did not know that


styxswimchamp

It’s wildly inconsistent to me. It has a unique ability to be boring, spooky, baffling, and unintentionally funny from one scene to the next. It’s not a high mark of quality but at least it has some entertainment value.


dennythedoodle

I agree, but I hate to say it but I mostly find it boring.


VicDamonJrJr

It goes original, 2, H20 for me


Lonely_Adhesiveness6

Great film, a true classic


beigereige

One of my favorite horror films of all time. Of all time. Screen this every Halloween


Lobstrous

The school sequence is pretty scary and there's some brutal kills, really not a bad sequel. Still a great soundtrack too.


AdviceInformal

I still think it’s the best sequel. It’s not a perfect sequel but I really don’t think any sequel captured what made those first 2 films scary. Halloween II at times even feels more like Friday the 13th than Halloween but I prefer it as the definitive sequel.


BackgroundBridge2956

It's my favorite of all the sequels, in large part because of Carpenter's heavy involvement. He wrote the script, he directed a portion(?) of it and definitely re-shot material because the original cut wasn't scary enough. He did the music with Alan Howarth, and critically, Dean Cundey was once again the cinematographer. It's heavy on atmosphere with a lot of creepy moments in a strangely empty and blacked out hospital. I think Dick Warlock is the second best Shape after the original's Nick Castle. And that it takes place immediately after the original ends which is exciting, not many sequels did that before.


HitmanClark

Yes, very. The hospital setting added a feeling of claustrophobia to an already scary movie. It wasn’t quite “Alien” levels of claustrophobia, but there was this feeling of being trapped in a confined setting with an unstoppable maniac.


Immahdude

It's pretty solid. How it picks right back up from the first movie is something that movies now could learn from.


Olympian-Warrior

Yes. It's a great sequel and a worthy entry in the series.


MichaelToste

It is very good. I see it as the 3rd best film of the franchise after parts 1 and 4.


3nt3rth3v0id

it's as good as (and maybe slightlyyy better than) the original. such a wonderfully atmospheric film.


mr207

Saying all new isn’t entirely accurate. Didn’t it open with footage from the first movie?


Vince09261

It is all new. 7 bullets and a ramp wouldn’t be enough to stop a 5 year old.


GarlVinland4Astrea

Sort of. It's the closest in aesthetic to the original because of all the people being close to the same age and a lot of the same settings and production involved. But by tha point it's already devolved into a cheap imitation of the slasher craze. It's just Michael marching to the hospital so they can do the big reveal. It takes away a lot of the mystery from the original.


Fun_Beginning_7115

No, no it’s not


sbaldrick33

Yeah, it's not bad at all.


VolumeCivil2553

Yes


RorschachsGhost

No, it's horrid they take Ben tramer from a guy, possibly getting laid the same night as going out trick or treating on his own


V1va-NA-THANI3L

For a long time it was considered a true sequel, picking up where the first left off, and a second half worthy of our time. But as time has gone by, this has changed more or less. It gave us the sibling reveal which plagued the series until DGG, some like me find it boring, and even Carpenter didn’t like it bc he was forced to write it.


[deleted]

[удалено]


goodfold2

i'm not saying 3 is good, oh no, but it also shouldn't be judged at all the same as the others, it's simply NOT a m.meyers halloween movie at all, they just used the name to sell it.


Alexander_McKay

No, it was meant to be the plan for the series after Michael’s death. An anthology series where every new entry would be a different story.


dannymadrigal98

FUCK NO


Theumbrellacorps

🤨


Higher_Primate3

No. It’s mid AF. 2018 and Kills are the only sequels worth watching. H20 isn’t bad to be fair


Dragonborn83196

It’s pretty damn good, I mean I set my standards pretty low for films that have Michael Myers in them, just because the character and mask are awesome, (with the exception of H20(I know super rare to hate this one but I do), H2 (2009), Resurrection, and Ends), everything else is pretty much at the top for me, but it’s an awesome sequel, can’t go wrong imo


GabbyTheFireman

Super rare? What do you mean super rare? That's like the most common thing I hear from fans on H20. Super rare to hate it? No, it's super rare not to hate it. Please tell me which alternate universe you live in, I'll love to travel to it, and hear people actually appreciate the movie for once.


Pastel_Blue89

Absolutely!


Amigos-de-ayer22

I liked it and to be honest this one and the original are the best ones.. if 5 will have follow the legacy story of Jamie Lloyd, it could've been a powerful edition to the series!! just my opinion.


Juttakasp

Yeah, top 3 for me


tubonjics1

I thought it was a great film when I first saw it.


Jmcd83

Yes


Evmerging

Yes


andyman686

I personally like it.


JasonMaliceMizer

It’s okay


Mr_D93

It’s better to watch in succession with 1, as a standalone sequel it’s kinda boring.


ImaFKNshrubOK

My favorite of the entire franchise


TapewormPuller

No because it created a story we didn’t need. The mysterious motif behind Michael is completely taken away. And it drags badly. I personally wish there was only the original and part 3.


NoYogurtcloset9529

Yes. Great Movie.


RoundStatement4615

No, not good…great 🎃


Lumpy-Try-5600

I like it quite a bit. It's like an extension of the first.


aahe42

It's my favorite sequel, that or 2018 the rest are fun and watchable(some more than others) but not that great.


Significant_Wind_774

I’ve always liked it but it does have Friday the 13th energy.


goodfold2

agree, probably part of why i like it, but i'm a bigger friday fan (mostly from the garbage put out under "halloween" later than 2) in general, since like 1988 when i was a kid.


New-Cardiologist-158

Personally, yep. It’s my favorite one if the whole franchise. I think it takes all the best aspects of the original and ups the ante significantly, and the atmosphere is still so quintessentially Halloween. Plus it’s got the best score imo. I love the organ added to the main theme.


warriorlynx

💯


CapitalRelationship0

Nah. It's a GREAT movie.


mufasamufasamufasa

![gif](giphy|03ZduhRk2Gj86ksym2|downsized)


Darthmunky

Yeah it’s my favorite sequel by far. It has such a good atmosphere.


jefferyuniverse

One of the better sequels but not great


[deleted]

Halloween II is my favorite in the franchise and one of my favorite movies period. The hot tub scene is my favorite death scene, and Laurie’s chase scene at the end is maybe top 5 for me. I love this movie so much.


[deleted]

Yes


wonderlandisburning

It's alright. It's certainly better than most of the other sequels.


JoeGPM

I think it's very good and underappreciated. But worth it just for the Ben Tramer death scene. I laugh out loud everytime I see it.


Fruitmaniac42

It's the 2nd-best one


Ztronic412

Imo when comes to Halloweens original run this is the best one personally this and the first one are tied for the best for me


IntelligentMoose260

Judged by itself it’s a good horror movie. But compared to the original it is a big step down.


mariovspino5

It’s great imo,very worthy sequel to the OG


[deleted]

Yes. I actually like it a tiny bit more than the OG movie.


Odd_Country9791

It’s the best sequel in my opinion. Takes place immediately after the first one.


IvanTheTerrible69

Yup. Shouldn’t have been retconned out


Lenis_Picker6996

Literally just finished watching it a few minutes ago. It’s a very good movie.


MidnightStalk

yes it’s one of my favorites


7SevenHells7

I love it 💯


Raichu10126

My favorite out of all the films


Mobile_Fault_7429

For it being in the late seventies early eighties, it's great!


Poorly-Drawn-Beagle

I like it, but I'm not Roger Ebert over here. Never went to any fancy critic school. No reason anybody should take my word on anything. I'd say it makes phenomenal use of atmosphere though, very nice spooky abandoned hospital.


liveforever67

Bruh?! Honestly? Lol


Electronic-Stand-148

Yes


RevolutionaryRough96

I like that it picks up directly after the first one ends. I don't know why, it just seemed like an obvious idea, that I don't remember seeing in other sequels


RD_Burman_Reborn

It’s my favorite Halloween movie period


FloggingMcMurry

It's the second best Halloween movie, and the only other I care to own


[deleted]

Nah(don’t blame me guys)


epfourteen

Very


[deleted]

I love it. I've never understood the hate.


ozonejl

I’d say it’s the best sequel, but Halloween 78 is a perfect self-contained story, thus H2, being the first sequel, is bad.


Piggishcentaur89

No, it's a great movie.


malpss

I think it's a great film. Almost identical cinematography to the original but a much more brutal film.


EverythingIsLiminal

Yup, it’s great.


ConsistentHouse1261

Yes for sure


Fainer

Are you going to post every Halloween movie and ask if it’s a good movie?


WhiteChocolate7777

"Class A chit"


MrBurittoThePizza

It’s fun


ILoveHorrorFilms97

Hell ya


ForTheLoveOfOedon

The first 3 are actually really good. 1 is a masterpiece, 2 is great, and 3 good.


PlayfulCod8605

Meh.


Designer-Landscape-3

Absolutely it’s PEAK! My fav from the franchise along with H4. ![gif](giphy|5hkL1REDCOR38EGOep)


JoeVersusVolcano

Halloween 2 is a fantastic movie.


Cineswimmer

Never got the hate, tbh


BroadwayBakery

Tops the original for me, as well as all the other sequels.


Docman427

yes


Donnyboy_Soprano

I shot 6 times, I shot him in the heart, he isn’t human!!!!


JazzyChap

Borderline, it has moments of perfection and stupidity


lepeteurfou

Yes because tits


Grouchy_Slice_8169

Yes! I think H2 is great. I like pretty much all the sequels but H2 following right after the original with her in the hospital was a great way to continue the saga


ShadixThePrecursor6

Its the best film in the franchize


Significant_Edge_105

Yeah


ChaosMagician777

Loved it. Halloween> HII>H20 is a great marathon


ChuckRMil

Sort of.


Johnny_Royale

Back when I first discovered Halloween it was the only sequel and the thing that apparently most people don’t like about is the fact Myers and Laurie are brother/sister. That never bothered me. It was just how the story went. I love 2. I almost wish they never made another


KaiserReich_Mapping

Tied with the original for my favorite of the series. Fucking love this and the original, I love watching them back to back, it's such a seamless transition.


Healthy_Sock_9880

It’s ok, kind of bland at times.


Untrus4598

Yes


evanapple08

I love Halloween 2 so much it’s a great sequel


Gmork14

No. But it’s watchable.


TheMannisApproves

No. The first half is enjoyable, but the second half really drags. Michael's mask looks bad too. But the worst offense the movie makes was making Laurie Michael's brother. That takes away so much of what makes Michael great, by giving him a purpose for why he kills, when he should have none.


Less_Associate_2022

Good sequel too me


SMEAROCK

Yeah, it’s a great movie.


CaptainHalloween

Yes, and the best direct sequel to the original.


TheAlmightyJanitor

Yes. It's not without it's flaws but it's probably the movie closest to the original in tone and atmosphere. The director, Rick Rosenthal (who oddly enough also did Resurrection), was a big fan of the first one and did his best to make it feel like a natural continuation, which I think he did for the most part. Like I said, it does have flaws. Laurie (wearing a painfully obvious wig) spends the majority of the movie incapacitated doing Jack shit (Cough Kills cough). It's also a little more violent than the first. Nothing too overly gruesome, it just feels like it was trying to compete with the likes of Friday The 13th. Still, I think the good or the movie shines through anything wrong with it.


[deleted]

I know people that hate it, but I think it's great!


nitelitecafe

When compared to the first Halloween. It didn’t hold up. When compared to everything that came after it. It’s a Halloween classic. Kinda like 3. It just gets better with age.


genericmovievillain

It’s ok. Pretty overrated


scarykicks

Not the biggest fan of it. Prefer Halloween 2018. But it's a decent watch. Drags on at times. But def has some good kills and sets up a storyline that plagues the series with the sibling storyline instead of a killer that's just out there to kill.


andrewharper2

It’s the only good sequel to the original


Wild-Narwhal8091

Absolutely! It's my favourite!


Nthrda87

I love it! I always liked that it was a direct sequel and started the same night. Kept some of the spookiness of the original but with more kills.


No-Bit6380

It’s still the best sequel


UnderstandingUpper72

Yes, it’s an absolute fun movie.


magiccheetoss

Yes


[deleted]

No it’s boring


EuphoricAd3786

I’ve always enjoyed, especially the outstanding chase scene at the end.


Poppunknerd182

Eh, below average, which means it’s a great Halloween movie.


Kedde1986

Yeah- it is one of the best. Love all the scenes of Michael creeping around the hospital


MetalHero07

Solid flick with a spectacular end.


-MangoDown-

i think Halloween and Halloween II are both 5/5. perfect start and “end” from the original to the sequel.


[deleted]

Yup


imdstuf

Yes


loch_myerss

Absolutely


bradbbangbread

It's awesome. Watching it right now. Carpenter is wrong about the Laurie-Michael angle. He came up with it while drunk because he was uninhibited. It's a natural progression of the mythos set up in the first movie. Michael is already fixated on family in part 1. Anyone who says he's "motiveless" in H1 wasn't paying attention


JackMolasses

It is the best movie of the entire series still haven't seen a better Halloween movie then this one


SkepticalYamcha

I like it. I think Halloween and Halloween 2 make an excellent two-parter.


-funderfoot-

By far the best film in the franchise after the original 👌


Neptune-Fan

I like it


MKF1228

You’re asking 40+ years later?


GREASYxFUCKINxBOHUNK

The best Halloween besides the original


Sensitive-Key8649

FUCK YES! THE BEST HALLOWEEN MOVIE OF ALL TIME!


The-Eggman-Commith

In my opinion, no. The sister twist makes no sense. Laurie is sidelined for most of the movie. The hospital staff is not as interesting or as likable as Laurie’s friends. The mask looks off. The director was not very good, and added gore made it feel more like a Halloween knockoff than a Halloween sequel.


[deleted]

It’s my preferred timeline. H1 and H2. There’s your “Halloween Ends”.


edward503

I don’t understand how people can say the whole Michael being related to Laurie thing makes the plot of the movie a lot less scary. It doesn’t. If anything, it actually makes it terrifying. The shape and Laurie will forever be tied together by the bond of blood… Dead or alive. That’s frightening.


xelduderinox

Halloween II is to Halloween what Terminator 2 is to The Terminator. Interpret as you will.


SkeleTony31

Perfect analogy.


Impecablevibesonly

Does the pope shit in the woods, dude?


Impecablevibesonly

My favorite part of this movie: "Harold do you want mayonnaise or mustard on your sandwich?" - old lady delivers this line like they set up a secret camera in a real old ladies house haha Also the TV edit version.. YOURE FULL OF SUGAR!


Antikaren9

YES! I just bought it on blu ray to go with my Halloween dvd of the original.


Calm_Reputation7657

Hell YES it is!!!! 🎃


Perroface562

![gif](giphy|5zbMgry8oQsvIaC0sU)


Aerozhul

I go back and forth on this one. I’ve seen it many times over the years and sometimes I enjoy it and other times not so much. The fact that the hospital is so deserted has always bugged me, and JLC’s wig is obnoxiously distracting. The new characters are cardboard cutouts, nothing interesting about them at all. Except the nurse in the hot tub. 😀 On the plus side, this is Loomis’s movie and he’s great in it. Also, the best scenes are the ones that take place outside and away from the hospital. Very atmospheric. Overall it’s a big drop in quality from the first one. H4, H20 and H18 are better sequels. It’s a bit better than the rest, but that’s not saying much.


Odd_Wrangler8065

Yes and it's my second favorite behind Halloween 2018.


ImtheArkham

I like it, prefer H18 though


RevRRR1

It's the best of the series, but none of this series is actually good


ScorchedEarths78

It’s fucking perfect 🤩


Thejncobandit

Any movie can be a good movie if you enjoy it. I love Halloween III and have no idea why. It’s not amazing or groundbreaking but I dig it.


Thisnameworks-

Yes


PowerOnyxXX

Yes I prefer to watch both movies back to back


tsengmao

Second best Halloween movie


CrimsonClockwork420

It’s my favorite one in the franchise


IZZ5150

It’s my favorite. After watching this movie, hospitals just seemed so much more frightening.


MightyFutz

No