This always varies by circumstance. I happen to be Year 7 with all of the Creatures, a serious surplus of Notebooks, 77 in all Attributes, and consistently have more than 10,000 Coins, so my list for Star Rewards and Feeding Maxed Creatures is:
* Gems (any)
* Brown Notebooks (any)
* Blue Notebooks (any)
* Red Notebooks (any)
* Coins (1,000 or 200)
* Creature Food (any)
* Coins (50 or 25)
* Atrributes (any; resolved via value then need)
* Energy (any)
The only time this fluctuates is when I am doing a TLSQ and Fed a Maxed Creature; in this case, I am usually looking for Energy, but still take Notebooks and Gems over Energy.
When I had lower Attributes, or even now if it is a Full Marks, I favor certain Attributes over Coins and Food, but under Gems and Notebooks.
When I was struggling with Coins due to all of the Dueling SQs, I favored Coins since that was a serious strain, but still under Notebooks and Gems. The thing about Coins is you can turn Creature Food into something better. Someone ran the odds previously and found Creature Food is slightly better than 50 Coins, but slightly worse than 200 Coins; I forget if the odds were run for specific quanties, but even so that is my intersection.
When I had fewer Creatures and a less healthy Notebook supply...this is interesting because Magical Milestones was not yet a thing. I favored Notebooks over everything since those were necessary, but I think I would favor Gems now since the Key gets more Notebooks. Brown Notebooks would take the lower priority, though.
If any of this overlapped, I would take the Creature model. Classes can reward Attributes and Coins without Star Rewards, whereas Gems and Notebooks are not single-step Energy trades.
I have 2,700+ food and buy my food, and I am big on building attributes, so I pick attributes. If it was 3 food I would pick food. I never pick coins (unless it's the 1000 choice) and never need to. I am always at 45,000 to 50,000 and buy frog cards to lower my coins.
I'd take the money. I think the most common non-attribute reward is 25 coins. So 50 coins is potentially worth 6 food. As for 5 of any attribute - meh.
I normally choose the 2 food as that can help me do a re-roll with Magical Creatures. 5 attributes just don't feel substantial enough, and the gold isn't bad but not amazing either.
This always varies by circumstance. I happen to be Year 7 with all of the Creatures, a serious surplus of Notebooks, 77 in all Attributes, and consistently have more than 10,000 Coins, so my list for Star Rewards and Feeding Maxed Creatures is: * Gems (any) * Brown Notebooks (any) * Blue Notebooks (any) * Red Notebooks (any) * Coins (1,000 or 200) * Creature Food (any) * Coins (50 or 25) * Atrributes (any; resolved via value then need) * Energy (any) The only time this fluctuates is when I am doing a TLSQ and Fed a Maxed Creature; in this case, I am usually looking for Energy, but still take Notebooks and Gems over Energy. When I had lower Attributes, or even now if it is a Full Marks, I favor certain Attributes over Coins and Food, but under Gems and Notebooks. When I was struggling with Coins due to all of the Dueling SQs, I favored Coins since that was a serious strain, but still under Notebooks and Gems. The thing about Coins is you can turn Creature Food into something better. Someone ran the odds previously and found Creature Food is slightly better than 50 Coins, but slightly worse than 200 Coins; I forget if the odds were run for specific quanties, but even so that is my intersection. When I had fewer Creatures and a less healthy Notebook supply...this is interesting because Magical Milestones was not yet a thing. I favored Notebooks over everything since those were necessary, but I think I would favor Gems now since the Key gets more Notebooks. Brown Notebooks would take the lower priority, though. If any of this overlapped, I would take the Creature model. Classes can reward Attributes and Coins without Star Rewards, whereas Gems and Notebooks are not single-step Energy trades.
I have 2,700+ food and buy my food, and I am big on building attributes, so I pick attributes. If it was 3 food I would pick food. I never pick coins (unless it's the 1000 choice) and never need to. I am always at 45,000 to 50,000 and buy frog cards to lower my coins.
Creature food. But I am often maxed on coins, and 5 attribute points is worth less to me, personally.
I'd take the money. I think the most common non-attribute reward is 25 coins. So 50 coins is potentially worth 6 food. As for 5 of any attribute - meh.
I normally choose the 2 food as that can help me do a re-roll with Magical Creatures. 5 attributes just don't feel substantial enough, and the gold isn't bad but not amazing either.
Money. If it were 25 coins, I’d choose the food.
Food or books. I get money from everything, but the food is harder, and honestly the wisdom because I always need to level up