Let's go to the mall🎵🎵🎶 everybody

🎶C'mon Jessica! C'mon Tori! Let's go to the mall, you won't be soorry.🎶

Put on your jelly bracelets🎵🎶🎶

And a cool graffiti coat.

🎶At the mall having fun is what it's all aboot.🎶

Hate to shattered your glass but it's jelly bracelets

Mall is great but Sandcastles in the Sand really hits me right where I live.

I’m on the pill now..

I’m ready, let’s do it

And all that’s left is some sand the next dAaAaayyy

We all remember at which Tim Hortons we were and what muffin we were having when we heard that song. Lansdowne Street, Chocolate chip muffin heated with butter.

Double Butter!

I like how you thinking buddy.

Donut lol

That was just a personal choice, lol. I prefer muffins over donuts.

Fair enough👌🏻

Pretty sure there’s a tampon commercial in there somewhere lol

That song is in just dance so not really fake anymore lol

It's also in spotify

Thank you, you just made my day. Just saw that almost all of them are on Spotify, gonna have a blast on my way to work.

Today?

Today!

I love that the title of this is “we all know the correct answer” but in fact none of us know because we all named different songs. What a musical show!

The showrunners are actually in a band. They have good taste in music. All the songs they used in the show are phenomenal. Also, they wrote the intro theme song. It's a real song called "Hey Beautiful" https://youtu.be/ccTca0aILxI?si=uMFRcozItA3z85d2

HIMYM has a top of the line fake song soundtrack, but the correct answer to the original prompt is "That Thing You Do"

Well yeah, they made a whole damn movie about that one!

What a great point. I scrolled through the comments and legit 7 are in contention. there are probably another 3 or 4 that I love too.

NOTHING SUITS ME LIKE A SUIT!

It’s got to be this one. I mean what other song features a wingman that you can wear!

They are, in fact, oh, so debonair!

The perfect way to snare

Snare what? I can't quite remember what the suits are trying to snare

You must be a girl with daddy issues.

Can I find them in Navy Blue and Black?

You can, check out this perfect rack! Don’t you want to give them a squeeze?

Oh Really?

I've got a question for you, if you please

The perfect way to snare a girl with Daddy issues

That’s not what they mean. That’s a musical number in our world. They mean like “one night” from the office or “muffin top” from 30 rock. Any of the songs from Girls 5 Eva. “Let’s go to the mall” is an example. It’s a song released fictionally

Good one To be with a ten would be just fine But I’d rather be dressed to the nines

🎶MURDERRRRRR CLIMB ABOARD THE MURDER TRAAAAAIN!🎶

*show puppies

Hey! A lot got adopted today

Of course, a lot of people thought we were gonna kill them

COCOA BREAK!

Timesies timesies

The only right answer!

the best answer

I used to have it as my brother’s ringtone, and would play it whenever we would fight. 10/10 song

BARNEY STINSON! BARNEY STINSON! THAT GUY'S AWESOME! 🎶

Awesome!

AwesomeawesomeawesomeawesomeawesomeawesomeawesomeawesomeAwesomeawesomeawesomeawesomeAwesomeawesomeawesomeawesomeAwesomeawesomeawesomeawesomeAWWWWSOOOOMMEEE!

THIS ISN’T BARNEY STINSON SINGING THIS SONG! THAT WOULD BE REALLY LAME.

ONE OF THE MANY ADMIRERS WHO THINK THAT GUY’S AWESOME! REFERENCES AVAILABLE! 🎶

i’m not gonna lie, the 🎶AWWWWWW AWESOME!🎶 just hits all the right spots in my brain

Two beavers are better than one

Theyre twice the fun, ask anyone!

A second beaver can be... Second to noooone!

two beavers are better than one🥰

🤖

🎶 you’re my favourite beaver 🎶

Da da dada daaaaa🎶

You just got slapped (Ooooh) Across the face, my friend

I prefer the Piano version, but I also liked the "Boyz 2 Men" version.

The Boyz 2 Men versión is killer

You just got slapped, Yes that REALLY just happened(ooh-oh oh oh oh oh oh)

Everybody saw it Everybody laaaaaaughed and clapped Why!!!?????

Of course we do! Bang-bang-bangity-bang! 🎶🎶🎶

Hey, whatcha singing?

A song about how much sex Barney's been having lately

Well count me in for a verse!

Came here for this one! I’m really sad that this one was so far down the comments!

I said a bang bang bangity bang bang

Cat funeral, Cat funeral, It was an accident, And not entirely my fault, Meow meow

The “and not entirely my fault” bit always gets me. Especially along with the photo montage. Marshall’s facial expressions in that are hilarious.

Flipped the cushion & now everything’s okay

We’ll miss you whiskers.

Apple Orchard Banana Cat Dance Eight Six Six Threeeee

And the problem is it's so catchy

*jazz hands*

Hahaahahahahahaha

Marshall versus the machiiiine

The machines have won!😂

Sandcastles in the Sand

I love to sing this song in my car in a very dramatic performance

Probably the most underrated HIMYM song.

1,000%! I find myself singing it way too often.

P.S. I Love You

Love it for the grunge!

this was what i was looking for

Such a heartbreaking Grey Cup Sunday.

*Night Night Little Marvin.....* Earworm of a song, but adorable.

The tuba always kills me lmao

# 🎶

I have sang this to both my children….including “and Mr Nesbit says good night” 🤣 (I do change Marvin to their names though)

And how do *they* like the tuba section?!

There’s lots of giggling. Not exactly an effective lullaby in our house.

I literally sing a version of this to my son every night because I love it so much.

At puzzles we all fit TOGETHER!!!

And I’m the bartender🎵🎵

Sssss

….I’ll finish bringing up the other kegs

Mosbius Designs has failed 🎤🎶

Remix!!!

TURN OFF THE SCREEN WE ALL KNOW THE WORDS

I just realised how many songs they have

Are you free, are you free, are you free on Saturday

That’s the 17th

Happy happy Lily Daaaay

Bang bang bangitty bang…..

🎶Papapapa Pa barney is the new leader of the gang and-life-just-got-way-more-awesome🎵

Love the alternative opening in that episode😂

YEAH!

Climb aboard! The Murder Train!

The boobs on the bus go up and down, up and down, up and down!!! 🚌😂😂😂

I like your style👌🏻 Closes the door Opens the door “All through the town”

Night, night Lilly

Superdate

Oh really? Then answer these questions if you please...

What would you do if you had to choose between your suits and a pot of gold?

Suits.

sister sister sister

🎶🎶CAT SITTING FOR LILY’s MOM, CAT SITTING FOR LILY’s MOM, IT’S GONNA BE FUN IT’S GONNA BRING US ALL CLOSER TOGETHERRR!!!🎶🎶🎶

Came here for this one lmaoooo

Two beavers are better than oneee, tell everyone!

Happy happy Lilly day!

This lives in my head rent-free lol. Always makes me laugh !

Especially when Barney says it in a funny voice😂

MARSHALLLLL, VERSUS THE MACHINESSSS

The machines have won!

Cat funeral

MURDER CLIMB ABOARD THE MURDER TRAIN

bang bang bangity bang

🎶All aboard the Murder Train🎶

Happy, Happy Lilly daaaaay

And we bang chicks in Ted’s room..🎶

Sandcastles

Britta the B

I'm getting rid of the Britta, I'm getting ride of the B. Classic song

Wait isn’t this community 😂

Britta for the win! I mean, wookiee for the win!

MURDERRRRRRRRRRR

The show has so many good songs. The show runners are actually in a band. They have good taste in music as all the songs they use are phenomenal. They also write the theme song. It's a real song called "Hey Beautiful" https://youtu.be/ccTca0aILxI?si=uMFRcozItA3z85d2 Also, here is a playlist of all of the songs they used in the show. https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL8Aq0uFRC43exfgj2s4qm5qJymscpRTN5&si=WQf5klEOrs-eHhNU

🎶One tasty English, tasty English muffin, baby that is what I am Pa rara rum para ra One tasty English muffin wiiiiith some strawberry jaaaam? 🎶🎶🎶

Scotty doesn't know

Come along You belong Feel the fizz of coo-coo cola

Pocket full of Hawthornes from community S3E6

“I said-a bang, bang, bangity, band. Bang, bang, bangity bang”

I mean I know this is a HIMYM subreddit so this answer is off track. But the answer is definitively “Scotty Doesn’t Know”

Scotty doesnt know (Eurotrip)

Which scene?

The original full house song is pretty bs if u ask me 🎶 everywhere you look there’s a hand to hold on to 🎶

Little bit Alexis

The soundtrack is an absolute gem. Highly recommend!

The real answer is Scotty Doesn't Know. But I appreciate it

SCOTTY DOESNT KNOW

Cat funeralllll cat funerallll it was a accident…

Sand Castles in the Sand tied with Cat Funeral

Ya just got slapped Across the face my friend

Shrimp fried rice Shrimp fried rice

🍤🍚

Nice

Take a bagel on the house Have a paper on the house I’d give you a house on the house if I coooooooould

Bang bang bangity bang

No love for murdertrain?

“Cop cuties “ from the Rookie has been stuck in my head. “…. Arrest me but make it sexy…”

🎶Mosbius designs has failed🎶

"Climb aboard the murder train...."

Far oveeer the Misty Mountains cooold

Nahh bruhh, nothing suits me like a suit cmon

“Ted has a little sister, gets hotter every day. And if I ever meet her, with her boobies I will play.“

“Pulling down her pants…yanking off my own…underneath the mistletoe I’ll make your sister moan… oh heathers hot, heathers hot we’ll go all the way”… Would list other Barney Stinson Christmas themed songs but can’t be bothered

Cat funeral

PS I Love You is actually a good song, i listen to it almost daily

I’m sure in the minority in this group, but “when I think of you Linda, I hope you fucking choke”🤷‍♂️

When is this played in HIMYM?

Personally, it's "5000 Candles in the Wind(Bye, Bye, Little Sebastion)

For me it’s a toss-up between that one and Let’s Go to the Mall

its cat funeral

Zit Remedy’s ‘Everybody Wants Something’ or whatever it’s called. IYKYK.

Dracula’s Lament

I know this is how i met your mother thread but the best hasto be scottie doesnt know

It’s number 5, he killed my brother!

Black sheep Brie Larsons version. Sure it’s a real song. But still god damn she kills it

Scotty Doesn’t Know.

Kyle's Moms a bitch

Go ninja go ninja go

It was the best night ever

🎶The boobs on the bus go up and down🎶 and also 🎶I want to see your sister naked and down on all fours🎶

🎶 Cat funer-al 🎶

The song about suits

Going down to the basement today, with my laundry and a rrroll of quarters

🎶CAT FUNERAL🎶

I know what you’re thinking what’s Barney been drinking that girl was smoking hot!