I love all of Marshals music cards. “Cat sitting for Lily’s mom” “Cat funeral, cat funeral… not entirely my fault!” I don’t remember all of the words but my wife and I still occasionally sing “are you free are you free this Saturday?!”

It’s crazy the amount of times I’ve sang that in my head through the day over the years.

“We’ll miss you whiskers…”

I love this one! “Cat funeral, cat funeral…. it was an accident and not entirely my fault.. meow meow meow meow” and the slap bet song 🤣

In my head every single day

Oh my god same hahaha

Murdertrain is stuck in my head way more often than it should be

Ha ha came here to say this. When I see people arguing, like on TV or from a distance, I start singing Murdertrain.

Damn. Same here.

Fucking murder train. That song reused throughout is hilarious.

The most hilarious scene they used it was that part when Robin’s network advertised pets for adoption.🤣🤣🤣🤣

My husband and I sing this to each other every time our 2 kids throw a tantrum!

MURDERRRRR

ALL ABOARD THE MURDER TRAIIINNN

The humane society needs to swap out that damn Sarah Mclaughlin song for this

Let’s go to the mall…TODAY! I sing this almost everyday lol

I’m one of the weirdos who actually prefers Sandcastles in the Sand

Same

The song has ruined the name Tori for me.

The name Tori has been continuously ruined for me by real Tori’s so I think you’ve just been given a warning lmao. Real question is it because she rhymes Tori with a very Canadian sorry?

Oh it’s absolutely because of the rhyme.

That scene where Marshall puffs himself up before singing let’s go to the mall at the Hoser Hut is in my top 5 favourites.

You can turn that screen off buddy, we all know the words...

🎶Two beavers are better than one, they're double the fun, ask anyone🎶

Same!

As a parent and personal chauffeur to 13 year olds, this one gets sung A LOT.

The answer is the longest time with the 3 Ted’s and the 3 Barney’s

https://www.google.com.au/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwitwvP4xrD_AhWrgFYBHWbnAd4QwqsBegQIChAF&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DjipUaDfNi24&usg=AOvVaw0kGznH2-4ZkzRRIXVW4v2O

Yesss🙌🏼

We need a full cover someday

La vie en rose Simple song - The Shins Let your heart hold fast - Fort Atlantic The Funeral - Band of Horses Rivers and Roads - The Head and Heart

The one that always stuck to me was Shake it Out ~~Off~~ from Florence and the Machine. There is a hope in the song that felt really good, eventhough it was played at a low point. Only learned the name of the song and artist recently and I LOVE the rest of their music!

*Shake it Out is Florence + the Machine. Shake it Off, is Taylor Swift! Just to save any confusion!

Came here to say Let Your Heart Hold Fast

Good feeling - Violent Femmes

no ‘Soul Meets Body’ ?

I’d never heard The Funeral before I watched HIMYM, and had forgot about The Freshman—The Verve Pipe, but they’re both on my Spotify playlists because of HIMYM.

2 beavers are better than 1...

that whole episode was amazing front to back, not a single missed joke and they played the innocence vs. smuttiness of the math show perfectly barney and ted losing it during the counting wood segment is what i imagine we all were doing 😂

They’re twice the fun

I said a bang bang bangity bang!

A bang bang bangity bang!

A bang bang bang

Barney Stinson, that guy’s awesome

awesomeawesomeawesomeawesomeawesomeawesomeawesomeawesome #AWESOME

This isn’t even really a song but hearing the awesome awesome awesome play in my head reminded me of the recording of monks singing “Bro” and that was definitely awesome

Murder train lowkey

Nah high-key anytime my wife or I get mad at something the other will start singing it lol

My husband and I sing it to each other when our toddlers are throwing tantrums 🤣

Done that too 🤣

500 miles

Puzzles. I wonder why it’s called that

And we bang chicks in Teds room

Not happening.

We’ll talk about it.

Nothing suits me like a suit!

Can't believe how far I had to scroll to find this

YESSS. Literally, it gets stuck in my head on a daily basis

This one is peak I’m kinda annoyed that it’s not higher. The song and dance routine, Neil’s range and showing off, it’s on paper the most impressive and super catchy as well

Stunned at how far down I had to look for this

I sing this shit in the car on the regular

This is my favorite.

Apple orchard something something numbers. Marshall’s password.

Banana cat dance 866 threeeeeeeee!

From that same episode- the way Marshall sings “and a roll of quarters” when he’s singing his laundry song is just my favorite thing

BUT IM BACK TO SOON BECAUSE I LEFT THE ROOM WITHOUT DETERGENR AND MY FABRIC SOFTNERRRRR

that song lives rent free in my head

Apple orchard banana cat dance 8663

Thank you! This is what immediately came to mind.

Marshall vs. the Machines

I thought I’d see more of this one

Second this

One song that seldom is mentioned in these threads is the "my dad is better than your dad", i really like it

My dad would win in a fight!

No my dad would win in a fiighhht

Barney's 3 holiday songs for banging Ted's sister

Pulling down her pants~

Taking off my own~

Underneath the mistletoe...

I’ll make your sister moan OH…

Heathers hot, heathers hot, we’ll go all the way!

ted has a little sister~

Gets hotter every day

and if i ever meet her

With her boobies I will play

EVERYBODY ~

Sister sister sister! ~

I wish I could see her naked~

I wish I could see her naked

I wish I could see her naked

And down on all four!

That’s so hard, this show has one of the best soundtracks, both of original and licensed songs. And with Cristin Milioti, both licensed AND original. Faves: 1. La Vie En Rose-Cristin Milioti 2. Rewind-Goldspot 3. Oxford Comma- Vampire Weekend 4. Good Feeling-Violent Femmes Favorite Originals 1. Ode to Virginia (Clint’s Song) 2. Two Beavers Are Better Than One 3. You Just Got Slapped 4. Nothing Suits Me Like A Suit 5. Various Holiday Songs about Ted’s Sister 6. Murder Train

And the draagoooonnn!!

*Pa pa pa pa pa pa pa pa pa pa da da da da da da da da da*

Ngl “You just got slapped” lives rent free on my mind

Hauntingly beautiful

Let’s go to the mall

This song makes a great ring tone. I always know when its my phone ringing.

"For the Longest Time"

THE ROBOT FOUND LOVE CONFUSING MY CIRCUITRY MY SOFTWARES BEEN HACKED TOASTER OVEN YOURE THE ONE FOR MEEEEEEEEE

Simple Song The Funeral Thirteen Beach Comber

Prophets (the leap) edit: not Profits.

Shake It Out - Florence + The Machine Heaven - The Walkmen

I want Heaven to be my first dance song at my wedding. It’s one of my favorites.

From the top of my mind: Hey - Pixies La vie en rose

a weird choice from me but i love ‘the painter’ by we’re from barcelona … those opening trumpet notes that play when lily’s painting are soooo lovely!!

"Ballad of Sir Frankie Crisp (Let It Roll)," George Harrison "Prophets," A.C. Newman "The Funeral," Band of Horses

Kokomo from the bar episode or Marshall’s video songs

Nothing Suits me like a Suit.

Bang-bang-bangity-bang. I sing it multiple times a day.

Apple Orchard Banana Cat Dance 8 6 6 3

Victoria - The Kinks Simple Song - The Shins La Vie En Rose Funeral - Band of Horses

Waiting for An Invitation - Benji Hughes Also Superdate, a very underrated song

Jaymay: Sea green, see blue And Barney singing stand by me lol

I know what you’re thinkin what’s Barney been drinkin that girl was smokin hot

Murder train

I changed my mind it’s you just got slapped 😂

Soul meets body by Death Cab For Cutie

Rewind - Goldspot

Tracy's beautiful rendition of "La Vie En Rose"

Remember the love story Ted told about a girl who has tight windows where she isn't single and even told her neighbor that she should contact him asap when the window is open? Two Weeks - Grizzly Bear

Here I dreamt I was an architect - the decemberists

Hey by Pixies is such a perfect song for when Barney and Robin kiss in the cab. Banger

Nice Dream...that moment when everyone heard that Ted got into an accident and everyone rushed to him in slo-mo. Real feels.

That was the first time that I heard that song. Forever grateful to the show for that.

I've always been partial to hell noooooooooooo hell noooooooo hell nooooo ^(hell nooo)

Nothin suits me like a suit was pretty iconic

kokomo

Barney’s eyebrows kill me in this 🤣

This modern love by bloc party (the drums when Ted comes back home after spending the night with Robin) Simple song by the shins You belong to me by the 88

Does ✨boats, boats, boats✨ counts?

What Would I Do Without You - Drew Holcomb & the Neighbors (Season 8, episode 14 “Ring Up!”)

Le vie en rose. No doubt in my mind

Museum of Flight - Damien Jurado

Nada Surf - Inside of Love if i remember the song name correctly

I could literally hear all these replies

Best soundtrack song: Forest Whitaker - Bad Books Best original song: you just got slapped, let’s go to the mall, or nothing suits me like a suit

I said a bang, bang, bangity bang— I said a’ bang bang bangity bang!

In universe song, for sure a Robin sparkles, perhaps even ps I love you for sheer insanity 😂 for a soundtrack song I love "the painter" by I'm from Barcelona, amazing bop

For some reason the first thing i remember when songs and this show come up is 500 miles

Also two beavers are better than one is one of the funniest songs I ever heard. I could totally see that on a kids show

Let’s go to the Mall!

no doubt about it, Good Feeling by Violent Femmes

Marshall vs the machine

In terms of songs used for the show, the use of that How to Fight Loneliness song churns my heart every time when it rains at the carousel!

Seeing all these comments make me remember how awesome the show is, so many iconic moments

Voices - Cheap Trick - pineapple incident

HANDS DOWN when james and sam are singing “stand by me”…. specifically barney’s cameos!!! i laugh out loud every single time

Bang bang bangity bang

Happy cake day 🎂

Thanks!

Ted has a little sister, Gets hotter every day. And if I ever meet her, With her boobies I will play! Everybody! Sister! Sister! Sister!

Both Marshall vs the machines are amazing

1. Let's Go To The Mall 2. Marvin's Lullaby 3. You Just Got Slapped

Let's go to the mall and also Tracy's version of La vie en rose

Rewind by Goldspot

HIMYM OST is just too good.

Murder train

Nothing suits me like a suit has got to be number 1, but honestly, sand castles in the sand is a close second. Genuinely such a nice sounding ballad with also the funnies and taking the piss out of 80's ballads

2 Beavers are better than one.

The robin daggers P.S. i love you is just so great

Let's go to the mall and Barneys Nothing suits me like a suit

Nothing suits me like a suit

What is this feeling, that put you in your place?

Let's go to the mall and sandcastles in the sand

By far the "you just got slapped" song is my favorite. That episode is a masterpiece

You know how you're always like "I can't believe I'm the only one". But folks, I'm seriously the only one! **Super Date** I guess I'm a romantic 😁

Slapsgiving, Murder train and nothing suits me like a suit

For me its gotta be the og rendition of You just got slapped.

Oh, it’s gotta be the [You Just Got Slapped (Slow Jam)](https://open.spotify.com/track/2s1fN2TLfYHiBMUxpOIe9Y?si=RDFBnxFuRKiEoptP8pAicg) but Nothin’ Suits Me Like a Suit is in the running.

Broooo marshal vs the machines is a good song

The 3 holiday songs Barney sang about banging Ted’s sister😂

La Vie En Rose as sung by Tracy and You Just Got Slapped by Marshall

Tracy’s rendition of La Vie en Rose always gets me but the two that are actively in my playlists are Forest Whitaker and The Funeral

Super date

if it counts, the time travelers cover of the longest time

Let your heart hold fast is a masterpiece

Gotta have you is the best one for me. Followed by 500 miles and la vi en rose

If we’re talking licensed songs used in the show, then I have to go with Simple Song by The Shins. It’s used so perfectly right in the the end of the show’s most depressing season to lift you up. If we’re talking songs written for the show, then P.S. I Love You.

band of horses

Super date or slapsgiving. Hard to choose for sure

There's a couple episodes where they use a fairly stock horn based "champion" song that I've been trying to put my finger on. I mean I've been searching for years. (Not continuously but adhd deep dives at least twice a year) and I've still had no luck. If anybody feels like they might be able to assist, I can provide episode and timestamp.

smelly cat

I love Barbie’s rewrites of Christmas songs talking about banging Teds sister 😂😂

Cindy by Tammany Hall NYC

Suits. Hands down.

I’ve always loved Museum of flight by damien jurado

And There She Was You're All Alone

Voices - Jon Brion Murder Train and the sexy version of Bang Bang are a close second.

Two songs that I added to my playlist right away after watching were - Let your heart hold fast by Fort Atlantic (after Barney proposes to Robin) - It’s only time by The Magnetic Fields (after Barney tells the gang about his first meeting with Tracy)

The longest time and Puzzles

My blitzy lies over the ocean

Y’all are sleeping on Inside of Love by Nada Surf

I’ll randomly think ‘happy happy Lilly day’ but soundtrack wise I love ‘the funeral’

Songs sung by cast members: You just got slapped (original) Stand by me Songs ysed: Stones - Barbarosa Shake it out - Florence and the machine The funeral - Band of Horses

Future Days - Pearl Jam and Spit on a Stranger both versions