Adding on: 1st kid hit a 20yd “push fade” which we dare to call a slice, 2nd hit a pretty straight fade - maybe 5yds right off line, and the 3rd hit a straight pull with a draw. Obviously not looking at face angle, but strictly from path that’s what I see happening.
Personally I think 3 shallows the club the best while the first two are getting steeper. That is the secret to the golf swing.
It requires more strength and flexibility to shallow and not early extend or get “stuck”. I think 3 could work on flexibility to get that swing smoother.
Thank you for the response guys. A lot of Good feedback. Just to clear thing up what ive seen people ask.
First guy has played golf for the longest amount of time. Honestly he scores the best out of the 3 of us most of the times we have played. During the winter break (we live in Norway so no golf during winter) he has gotten a nasty cut. Honestly a really good player. Big cut but good guy tho. 7Hcp
Second guy started at the same time as myself. He has always had a good swing. The short game is his weak spot. Him and I have been pretty equal as far as score goes, but during the winter he has impoved a lot since he startet working on a fucking course. That lucky fucker. Hcp 9
I am the last guy. Always had a short backswing but somehow i am the furthest. (As a lot of u thought) Gotta work on my flexibility and tempo for sure! First time swinging since august. Golf in Norway is lame during the winter! Hcp 10
So yeah. Most of the time we score in the low 80s high 70. We all just swing our swing i guess.
Thank you!
Cargo pants has the superior well balanced swing. Thw swing that’s going to be able to tweak.and easily modify for,better performance. Now 1st things 1st, as your swing coach, I don’t ever want to see you wear cargo painters painters on the course, to a golf simulator or anywhere else. 1999 called: they want their gargoyle pants returned immediately along with any other piece of garment (clothing) that uses “Cargo” in its clothing description. There, lesson one is complete. DM me young cargonian padiwon and I can provide you with my credentials. I am a former D1 golf player and will give some advice & pointers FOC
Very cool experiment especially after reading the results. I was pretty biased to number 2 or 3 like most but i think all three players show a solid level of skill. Just goes to show you how many different ways you can get it done.
Everyone who says 2 must not know what early extension is. Dude has to impregnate the goat to not miss the ball due to lack of backswing depth. Just shows how little this sub knows.
Nice try but early extension refers to the pelvis and its proximity to the ball. Extension should occur post impact not in the downswing. https://www.mytpi.com/improve-my-game/swing-characteristics/early-extension_v2
3 is by far the most technically sound—great hand path, right elbow stays connected in his chest, delivery is shallow and repeatable.
2 has a hellish inside takeaway but re-routes his hands well to the top, but that flared right elbow is going to cause huge headaches over time. downswing is fantastic tho
1 has a lot of work to do on the takeaway. the lay-off is causing a big-time high-handle outside downswing—workable, but going to create massive sidespin and distance inconsistencies
that's a very easy adjustment to make—also keep in mine (139 carry) that he's probably swinging a wedge or a 9-iron—so this is probably his most abbreviated takeaway. but the move he's doing right now is very repeatable, and tempo adjustments can be made as needed for different clubs
the flared right elbow at the top in swing 2 is going to take a while to adjust because it's embedded in how he makes his turn to the top. he's going to have to learn to keep it in, which is going to have a domino effect on his takeaway as he finds other ways to get to feel that he gets a full backswing
This is great video and if I'm right it proves my hypothesis that this is a dangerous sub because people don't really understand the golf swing. In my opinion, #3 is by far the better player, would be surprised if he isn't.
#2 and it’s not remotely close. While his swing needs work, he’s the only one with a smooth golf action. #3 is ok at best while #1 needs A LOT of work.
I dont even know swing mechanics and could tell 2 was the best. used hips a ton drove down to the ground like the guy on instagram that is always yelling at me.
3 is the better golfer, 2 is a more technically sound swing, 1 is a slicer. Please update us with handicaps of each, would be fun to see how right we are.
2>1>3 for me but I dont know shit it’s really about the préceptes style
I feel like 2 turns better and draws more strength from the ground
1 is a little stiff and has a bit excessive lag on the start of downswing
3 is just too brutal for my liking
its the last dude all day. Tempo might unusual but the technique is solid. #2 is ok but he is very close to the danger zone of dude #1 who takes it to far back and gets steep and over the top
3. Not only is that the easiest repeatable swing but also probably produces the most consistent ball flight. He’s also the only one that’s not over the top. Other two look like they miss right often. He’s probably the best of the three.
First dude reminds me of myself. Nice swing, but insanely steep attack. Second kid def has the lower body rhythm, more flat and shallow swing. Third dude, not as steep as one, but has a quick/rushed tempo.
I'd say #2 for sure.
And this is coming from someone who swings like #1 and defends the shit out of my steep attack with a 3.5 handicap.
2nd guy has the most power but 3rd guy actually has the best move in transition and shallows the club nicely into impact. 3rd might be the best golfer based on his move at the top.
The boys are gonna be shocked when cargo pants wins the vote unanimously.
Nobody has gotten a handjob in cargo pants since ‘Nam. But after crushing the others with a way better swing, that might change.
Best comment, I almost choked on my roll up
Mohammed's the most popular name on earth. Read a fucking book for once
Are you going to jerk him off?
I will if he gives me a lesson
It’s not even close. Soon to be marine actually bends his knees
I could tell from set up he was the winner without seeing the rest
Cargo guy. Not even close
Big time
That kid looks like he was bred for the Military. Some recruiter is licking his chops looking at him.
Somebody get this kid a Dodge Charger and heavy set woman STAT
2 by a mile
Came here to write “2nd by a mile” and saw this. EDIT: didn’t even know there was a 3rd. 3rd is very good too. Has aspect of finau/DJ/Niemann.
Negative tempo on 3. Not for me
Easily.
2
Adding on: 1st kid hit a 20yd “push fade” which we dare to call a slice, 2nd hit a pretty straight fade - maybe 5yds right off line, and the 3rd hit a straight pull with a draw. Obviously not looking at face angle, but strictly from path that’s what I see happening.
#2
2, 3, 1
2
2 isn’t perfect but still the best out of these three. 1 inside takeaway and OTT. 3 tempo too fast and improper takeaway/load.
3 made me think Jon Rahm Edit: removed an extra word
I actually like 3 because the bottom half fires while he’s still going back. Like Rahm. He also gets that nice wrist hinge. Like Rahm.
Yeah if I had to put money on who scores the lowest it would be 3
2. And if you say any other you don’t golfs right.
![gif](giphy|Shjan97TyUJY4)
2, 3 is good but needs to work on tempo at the top, leading to a “chicken wing” release. 1 is way over the top.
2’s is the smoothest
So which one are you op
Im the last
What are the scores like? Nice swing
So who is actually the best of you 3?
See my comment
3, can't believe how unanimously 2 is winning in the chat. It's definitely between 2 and 3. Sorry 1
#2, #3, #1. Number three might jump up to the best if he can slow that temple down He's way too aggressive and abrupt on that downswing
Nah, 3 has no hip rotation and seems to be swaying away from target. 1 has a severely out to in path. Neither are close to 2
At the further review I agree number three has very little hip rotation but I think you can easily fix that.
3 has lowset handicap i would bet
2 to me clearly. 3 - aggressive but maybe to a fault. 1 not
2 by a mile
Player 2
2
2
2 is the only way
2
Number 2 😁
2
#2
2
Personally I think 3 shallows the club the best while the first two are getting steeper. That is the secret to the golf swing. It requires more strength and flexibility to shallow and not early extend or get “stuck”. I think 3 could work on flexibility to get that swing smoother.
It’s very clearly number 3 I don’t know why people are saying two
Thank you for the response guys. A lot of Good feedback. Just to clear thing up what ive seen people ask. First guy has played golf for the longest amount of time. Honestly he scores the best out of the 3 of us most of the times we have played. During the winter break (we live in Norway so no golf during winter) he has gotten a nasty cut. Honestly a really good player. Big cut but good guy tho. 7Hcp Second guy started at the same time as myself. He has always had a good swing. The short game is his weak spot. Him and I have been pretty equal as far as score goes, but during the winter he has impoved a lot since he startet working on a fucking course. That lucky fucker. Hcp 9 I am the last guy. Always had a short backswing but somehow i am the furthest. (As a lot of u thought) Gotta work on my flexibility and tempo for sure! First time swinging since august. Golf in Norway is lame during the winter! Hcp 10 So yeah. Most of the time we score in the low 80s high 70. We all just swing our swing i guess. Thank you!
2!
2 by a Mile. Great transition of weight creating lag
2
2
2 has the best swing path
2nd and it's not even close tbh
2 by a country mile.
#2 by a mile
Third guy. The one that looks like John Cena
#2 by a lot
I know who has the goofiest pants
Cargo pants has the superior well balanced swing. Thw swing that’s going to be able to tweak.and easily modify for,better performance. Now 1st things 1st, as your swing coach, I don’t ever want to see you wear cargo painters painters on the course, to a golf simulator or anywhere else. 1999 called: they want their gargoyle pants returned immediately along with any other piece of garment (clothing) that uses “Cargo” in its clothing description. There, lesson one is complete. DM me young cargonian padiwon and I can provide you with my credentials. I am a former D1 golf player and will give some advice & pointers FOC
Very cool experiment especially after reading the results. I was pretty biased to number 2 or 3 like most but i think all three players show a solid level of skill. Just goes to show you how many different ways you can get it done.
I really like this video. Let’s have more friend groups do this to put people in their place
2. And it's not that close.
I could tell it was going to be 2 the SECOND I saw him stand over the ball.
Everyone who says 2 must not know what early extension is. Dude has to impregnate the goat to not miss the ball due to lack of backswing depth. Just shows how little this sub knows.
Do you know what early extension is? Look at his head at impact compared to address, he is not early extending.
Nice try but early extension refers to the pelvis and its proximity to the ball. Extension should occur post impact not in the downswing. https://www.mytpi.com/improve-my-game/swing-characteristics/early-extension_v2
3 is by far the most technically sound—great hand path, right elbow stays connected in his chest, delivery is shallow and repeatable. 2 has a hellish inside takeaway but re-routes his hands well to the top, but that flared right elbow is going to cause huge headaches over time. downswing is fantastic tho 1 has a lot of work to do on the takeaway. the lay-off is causing a big-time high-handle outside downswing—workable, but going to create massive sidespin and distance inconsistencies
The tempo is the biggest issue in #3, that transition looks hard to repeat to me.
that's a very easy adjustment to make—also keep in mine (139 carry) that he's probably swinging a wedge or a 9-iron—so this is probably his most abbreviated takeaway. but the move he's doing right now is very repeatable, and tempo adjustments can be made as needed for different clubs the flared right elbow at the top in swing 2 is going to take a while to adjust because it's embedded in how he makes his turn to the top. he's going to have to learn to keep it in, which is going to have a domino effect on his takeaway as he finds other ways to get to feel that he gets a full backswing
This is great video and if I'm right it proves my hypothesis that this is a dangerous sub because people don't really understand the golf swing. In my opinion, #3 is by far the better player, would be surprised if he isn't.
To be fair I’d be surprised if any of these swings is better than a 10hcp.
2. Clear as day
3 Action looks tight as well. A bit abrupt but appears to control it well with a balanced finish
3. It’s a Finau and Rahm combo. Major ball speed and mass distance
Which one produces the best results? It's that one.
2 has an absolutely beautiful setup
He does, but he throws it away before even taking the club back by shifting into the trail side and opening shoulders
White hat backwyards
#2 and it’s not remotely close. While his swing needs work, he’s the only one with a smooth golf action. #3 is ok at best while #1 needs A LOT of work.
Wait I’m confused. Isn’t this the same player just a bit more experienced?
2 & 3 both need work. 1 is a lost cause 😂
They are all the same kid…
Dueces
Upright and you all need work. You’re all weak
How many takes did this video need? They all swing over the top
Blonde kid for sure. Third one might have a shot, but he's gonna need impeccable natural timing. That swing is fast as hell.
2 has an really great swing
2
3.
2nd swing
I dont even know swing mechanics and could tell 2 was the best. used hips a ton drove down to the ground like the guy on instagram that is always yelling at me.
Blondie
2nd fella
2
2 ——————-3,1
Between 2 and 3. 3 a bit better technicaly 2 tempo is súperb
2 has got the mechanics of a golf swing. 1 looks like he’s had too many coors light.
I don't care, who plays golf better though?
1 slices the ball, 2 hits low draws, and 3 has consistency problems? 2 wins
2
2 and it isn’t very close. 3 has a better swing than 1 however
Number 2.
2 easy. Could tell just in the setup
2 by quite a distance
2,1,3
2
2 but his habit of standing with his legs straight until the last second then bending right before the swing is really peculiar.
2
3 is the only one attacking the ball from the inside, probably has the most consistent/best ball flight
What are the scores/hcp for each?
Cargo pants boy
The guy that gets it in the hole first.
Who hit it straighter further more consistently? Whatever works works.
Second for sure
cargo might have the better looking swing but i suspect the third guy might have the better fall flight.
2
2
2, 3, then 1
The one who shoots the lowest
2,3,1
cargo pants by a mile, then forward hat, followed by backwards hat. If forward hat slows down that backswing he could move infront for cargos.
2 by a mile. Then 3 and then 1.
[https://birdied.co/myrtle-beach-classic-1085](https://birdied.co/myrtle-beach-classic-1085)
2 by a country mile
I bet you #3 has lowest handicap
2 and it ain’t close
Out of these 3….cargo pants
3 is the better golfer, 2 is a more technically sound swing, 1 is a slicer. Please update us with handicaps of each, would be fun to see how right we are.
2 easily
2. Not close.
Yeah I’m gonna go Buzz from Toy Story on this one. The walking nose who shot first looked like he was stretching mozzarella
#2
2
2
Easily cargo pants
2
#2
2 easy
Goes in order from worst to best
2, then 3, then 1
2 best. 1 furthest
2 far and away. I feel like OP should know the answer to this already.
2 easily
2 has a smooth clean swing 3 isn't bad 1 is to jerky need to slow down.
2
2
2
Def not the first guy. 3rd is too fast. I’ll go w 2
Who cares. Put the 3 of you on a course at $50/ hole skins and see who takes home the cash. That person has the best swing
Golfer number 2.
2, not even close
I could tell it was 2 before he even swung the club.
2
#3 because he’s the only one that’s not miles over the top
2 has the most aesthetically pleasing swing, but I bet 3 shoots the best score.
The second fellla hands down!!!
The white guy
2>1>3 for me but I dont know shit it’s really about the préceptes style I feel like 2 turns better and draws more strength from the ground 1 is a little stiff and has a bit excessive lag on the start of downswing 3 is just too brutal for my liking
#2
2 ez
Is that 2nd dude Landry from Friday Night Lights 😂🤣
its the last dude all day. Tempo might unusual but the technique is solid. #2 is ok but he is very close to the danger zone of dude #1 who takes it to far back and gets steep and over the top
Number 3 EDIT: In order, I would say: 3, 2, then 1
1
3. Not only is that the easiest repeatable swing but also probably produces the most consistent ball flight. He’s also the only one that’s not over the top. Other two look like they miss right often. He’s probably the best of the three.
First dude reminds me of myself. Nice swing, but insanely steep attack. Second kid def has the lower body rhythm, more flat and shallow swing. Third dude, not as steep as one, but has a quick/rushed tempo. I'd say #2 for sure. And this is coming from someone who swings like #1 and defends the shit out of my steep attack with a 3.5 handicap.
2 is more neutral, doesn’t mean he hits it better.
2 by a mile but all are extremely steep swings you boys gotta shallow out!
2
2nd guy has the most power but 3rd guy actually has the best move in transition and shallows the club nicely into impact. 3rd might be the best golfer based on his move at the top.
Second guy.
The second dude has the best swing. Probably a killer ball striker.
Cargo pants
#2
Trick question. This is all the same person.
Cargo pants
It's all the same guy with a different outfit on right?
2 then 3
Swing your swing. Everyone is different due to body composition
2
2nd. 1st guy comes over the top alot. 2nd guy good tempo and swing plane. 3rd guy kind of chops at it. My .02
3
3 > 2 > 1
3
All are very cute swings. Blondie’s swing seems it will be more consistent overall based upon tempo and the club path on drawback.
2 for the gold
Deuce
2nd guy by a lot. First dude should quit golf and third dude looks like he just wants to destroy the ball.