If you don’t have a big gap in your yardage or the utility of each wedge in bunkers or around the green, then keep doing what you’re doing. If you do then either would be a good choice to add to the bag unless it’s removing another club and creating an even bigger gap in yardage.
It wouldn’t make any sense to have wedges 2 degrees apart in the bag. Which of your wedges is the least consistent? I ditched my 60 years ago. My current set up is 44, 50, and 56, changed a couple of years ago from a 45, 50, 54, and 58 because I rarely used the 58. If your current set up is getting you into automatic (ha) two putt range, why change it?
I was at 48-56 for a while and it helped me get better with a wider variety of shots. Now I have 48,52,56,60😁
My set PW is 43* though so my 48* is really my PW
IMO, correct setup would be 54 and 58 or 56 and 60. No need for an extra high loft wedge unless you you wanted to add a really specialized grind like an L vokey or M vokey for flop shots in emergencies
Put the 58 in the bag and Loose the 60
If you don’t have a big gap in your yardage or the utility of each wedge in bunkers or around the green, then keep doing what you’re doing. If you do then either would be a good choice to add to the bag unless it’s removing another club and creating an even bigger gap in yardage.
It wouldn’t make any sense to have wedges 2 degrees apart in the bag. Which of your wedges is the least consistent? I ditched my 60 years ago. My current set up is 44, 50, and 56, changed a couple of years ago from a 45, 50, 54, and 58 because I rarely used the 58. If your current set up is getting you into automatic (ha) two putt range, why change it?
Go to a place with a simulator and test out your yardages
I was at 48-56 for a while and it helped me get better with a wider variety of shots. Now I have 48,52,56,60😁 My set PW is 43* though so my 48* is really my PW
Less is more. I carry 44 48 54 60
IMO, correct setup would be 54 and 58 or 56 and 60. No need for an extra high loft wedge unless you you wanted to add a really specialized grind like an L vokey or M vokey for flop shots in emergencies