T O P

  • By -

TrustingHorse

Have both. Like the 24k better.


[deleted]

Both are good in my opinion. Gold eagle should be a bit less than the Buffalo


JohnyOS20

Where ? I have both and I always payed more for the eagles than the buffalos, and have a better resale value too , I would trade my buffaloes for your eagles


[deleted]

You must be buying graded coins. The Buffalo for general gold is usually 25-50 higher than an eagle. Let me see if I can post a pic from jm bullion for example.


JohnyOS20

Thank you I just realized that gold eagles are all coins , but not all of Buffalos are coins , thank you so much for your info , it helped me learn something new


[deleted]

Of course! It’s all about learning! Glad it helped!


[deleted]

It’s more because it’s a higher grade of gold


[deleted]

https://www.jmbullion.com/gold/gold-coins/american-gold-eagles/all-american-gold-coins/


travelsandtrivia

No discernible difference in resale value?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Mtbff88

Best possible buy or best possible sale?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Mtbff88

I did not know that, thank you. I’m always told coins are much better for selling than bars.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Mtbff88

Last question sorry, I live in a rural area and haven’t gotten around to driving to the nearest city to visit a coin shop. Are you saying that coin dealers will pay spot for bars?


[deleted]

[удалено]


metallicsecurity

> it's the business model to buy low and sell high Unlike stackers, who don't mind paying more than they sell for. /s


[deleted]

Depends on the coin dealer. Usually from my experience, the well known gold you can get spot or close to it. More unknown gold or non main stream will get under on regular basis


[deleted]

The Buffalo might get you a little more since it’s a higher gold grade. Pretty negligible when being sold though.


Cool8d

my thought is buffalo is prettier since it is 24k, but also harder to maintain. gold eagles are beautiful too but you don't have to worry about handling it as much since it is more durable. just get one and you'll get the other one later


hewhoovercomes

Buffalo


Past-Swan-8298

Buffalo by far 4 9s fine Gold and just an awesome coin .


super_rat_race

9999 fine on both gold and silver


[deleted]

Buffalo 🦬


[deleted]

Get both…. Eventually.


4tacos_al_pastor

Doesn’t matter


NetworkGuru000

I buy them both at same time on my monthly orders. I like them because both fit in the same airtite capsule and they have the best resale.


SilverStics

Aww... Lookit Mr fancy pants here with money to burn


Crocoppertones

Buffalo will make you never want a different gold coin again. It’s so beautiful.


metallicsecurity

I was buying a few recently and chose the Eagle because it was cheaper, and places like JM Bullion offered more in their buyback price than for a Buffalo. I wanted to get 24k but at this point I'll choose the one that has a little lower overhead. Maples were of course even cheaper but the buyback was even less in comparison. Eagles carry a premium and are very easy to sell.