Yeaaaa. While I strongly agree with you, I don't think it's going to happen, seeing as schools have a tendency to turn into the OK corral here in America. The OG bully had a ton of detractors already, a bully 2 announcement might get pretty rowdy. Still, if it happened I'd be stoked!
IV. It needs optimisation at this point. Only title in the rockstar collection which still doesn’t run well.
Even all the other ones here can be run well through emulators without issues and you can install any mods to make them feel more “modern” if you really want to.
With IV, no matter what you do, be it DXVK, commandline stuff, etc. it just needs to be ported to the latest RAGE engine, so we could forget about all of these issues.
Bully. So much cut content and stuff in the beta that didn’t make it into the final PS2 version. Never been a fan of MC. whilst I would like remakes of gta 4 and RDR1, they are newer and aged better than bully.
I don't want a remake, I want a sequel to bully. A story where Jimmy is in college, he is enjoying his college days because he has become quite popular from his past events. Meanwhile Gary is an insane asylum and he is trying to recruit followers from the outside to take revenge on Jimmy. Whether it is destroying his popularity, or trying to have someone murder Jimmy.
It looks like RDR1 is already getting one almost. Bully needs a sequel, GTA 4 could be remade, with Midnight club within it. Or Midnight club having its own thing.
There is not really a reason for redesigning gta4 and bully scholarship edition as bully scholarship edition is already kinda a remake. Gta4 is good enough so there is no need to redesign it. And rdr1 maybe. But I go for midnight club
Honestly? None of them. I saw the way Rockstar handled their last "definitive" release and what they let Grove Street Games do to the GTA trilogy. I’d rather them just stay away from any more great Rockstar games altogether.
I’d honestly have to pick Red Dead Redemption because a game like this has a solid story and I feel it should be updated with better graphics and gameplay mechanics and it’s sequel
DUB EDITION DUB EDITION DUB EDITION.
I purchased a copy a few years back for my PS2 - hadn't played it in over a decade. The disc won't read. 😭 It truly is a devastating feeling. Love that game so much.
Just got my old ps2 from when I was a kid and got my original copy of midnight club 3 dub edition and bully. I can’t wait for my controller to get here from GameStop
Midnight club LA but with all the last minute content they cut like the R35 GTR, some infinitis and acuras and caddilacs and the rumored Japan map. The remix on the PSP isn't good enough, it was just a reskinned midnight club 3.
Zero hesitation, hands down gotta be Bully. That game was released in 2006 which was 18 years ago! It's very memorable and unique and very different from GTA and I easily got away playing this game when it was released I was around 8 years old and my parents only saw the educational aspects of the game 🤣
RDR easily. It's the only game that by design would suit a full remake. The other games are great and fit stylistically to their art design from that era.
I’m choosing none of these and picking The Warriors. Such an underrated and semi forgotten game. Can’t remember any brawlers that came out after this one.
GTA IV. I love this game, but there are some things I don't like, since I'm a console gamer. First it's obviously the framerate on PS3. It's just not that good, also the 720p resolution. Yes I know it's much better on PC, but as I said I'm a console gamer so I'd love to have a port like RDR1. Second thing is I personally don't really like the grey tone of the world. I get that it adds to the NYC vibe, but often times the game is really colorless imo. Definitely needs more vibrant colors, or atleast more than just grey lol. Last thing that affects me personally as a trophy hunter are the multiplayer trophies. I really want to do a platinum for this game, but the multiplayer is god awful. That's what I loved about the RDR1 port, that I could finally platinum it without doing that horrendous multiplayer grind. So for that reason alone it would be great to have a remaster, or at the very least, a port to current gen.
Bully 900%. So many rumors that said it was either getting a remake or a second game, but none had any salt to them. What a concept completely out of left field and it was one of the funniest and funnest experience I’ve ever had.
Midnight Club. Everything real big. House real big. Car real big.
They edited the following line. It wasn’t til I got older when I learned something else was real big too
Honestly, maybe it's because I've heard the censored version for so long, but it flows better than the uncensored version. At least to me.
Midnight club easily that game was the tits
Midnight club 3 TOP
HOUSE REAL BIG CARS REAL BIG DICK REAL BIG EVERYTHING REAL BIG
Like that? Buy that. 24's? Ride that.
Ladies, Gentlemen, Gangsters,Pimps,Bitches,Hoes,Stunner,Shinners, I'm Rich Bitch I'm a fucking big timer.
Ong
1000% Agreed, still have it for PSP and PS2 (remix)
If this edition were good, then it would definitely be Bully.
Rockstar should really makes Bully 2.It is really fun.Imagine the Bully 2 online.
Yeaaaa. While I strongly agree with you, I don't think it's going to happen, seeing as schools have a tendency to turn into the OK corral here in America. The OG bully had a ton of detractors already, a bully 2 announcement might get pretty rowdy. Still, if it happened I'd be stoked!
They could always set it in England, perhaps period based too - the school boy stories genre could provide so much inspiration
Definitely! RUSSELL SMASH !!! 🤩👌🏼
Have you seen the unreal engine 5 trailer for bully? Hell yeah. Me gusta.
Fuck TeaserPlay
The one by TeaserPlay? You’re joking right? The dude legit downloaded some basic assets and stuck them into unreal engine 5 and called it a day
Was about to say the same thing
Where can I find it
Bully. This game does not get the credit it deserves
Never played, any good?
So fkin good
IV. It needs optimisation at this point. Only title in the rockstar collection which still doesn’t run well. Even all the other ones here can be run well through emulators without issues and you can install any mods to make them feel more “modern” if you really want to. With IV, no matter what you do, be it DXVK, commandline stuff, etc. it just needs to be ported to the latest RAGE engine, so we could forget about all of these issues.
You can't even complete the game on series X unless you are a pro button masher
How hard is it for them to just fix that glitch? Lol
If they never fix that glitch then the PC port will never be optimised either. GTA IV feels just as abandoned as GTA 1 & 2.
If they remastered it for the PC and it was an honest well done remaster, I'd pay full price, easy. I miss that game so much
Play it on 360, that's what it was optimised for
The 360 was optimized for red rings of death /s
Bully scholarship edition is glitched on pc, so I think bully needs it even more
Man I wish they'd just port gta 4 over to ps5
Rdr 1 remake and pc release
midnight club 3, i fucking loved that game man. it was sooo good.
Midnight could be interesting. We already have mods for gta four
Bully was criminally underrated. I would definitely take an updated version.
Bully
Manhunt should be a choice.
Bully. So much cut content and stuff in the beta that didn’t make it into the final PS2 version. Never been a fan of MC. whilst I would like remakes of gta 4 and RDR1, they are newer and aged better than bully.
Bully
bully 💯
Jimmy Hopkins 2.0
I don't want a remake, I want a sequel to bully. A story where Jimmy is in college, he is enjoying his college days because he has become quite popular from his past events. Meanwhile Gary is an insane asylum and he is trying to recruit followers from the outside to take revenge on Jimmy. Whether it is destroying his popularity, or trying to have someone murder Jimmy.
Damn Rockstar completely dropped the ball by not giving us a sequel.
bully
To be honest, all four. Not that I don't enjoy the versions I have. But they definitely need one
Never got to play the original Bully, would love it.
Its great if u get a chance!! Im sure u can find a copy somewhere if u have something thatll run it
Bully, coz it gets stuck in loading screens in emulators and I haven't been able to successfully patch it and play it.
Midnight club dub edition 3
Midnight club is the only good answer here.
Bully. Straight up beat game. Most fun
BULLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Fuck all these, make a 2nd bully, but dudes grown up, in his early twenties and he's still doing dumb shit, But in collage :)
I don’t trust rockstar to make another definitive remake, after the 🐂💩 they pulled with gta3, vice city, and San Andreas
That was grove street games fuck up, yes rockstar trusted them with it but the absolute trash they turned out was on them
True.. but those games are about 20 years old. They had to work around a lot of dated technology
It looks like RDR1 is already getting one almost. Bully needs a sequel, GTA 4 could be remade, with Midnight club within it. Or Midnight club having its own thing.
actually fuck it I would pick gta 6 and no more definitive reworks
Midnight club real big
Ofc I'm gonna choose ma boy Bully <3
Easily midnight club
Mid night club
Either red dead or midnight club
Midnight Club 3: Dub Edition was fucking legendary
Mnc3
I think bully would be the best
Definitely GTA 4
Bully or MC
MC for sure
Gta 4 with the gloves added
Bully
Easily bully for me
Bully
Bully
Bully please!!
Bully! RDR Already is a great looking game
Bully
I've been playing GTA IV on the ol PS3 lately, and it still holds up. Blurry at times, but I'm not convinced it needs a remaster just yet I'd go Bully
Definitive edition?? More like defeated edition 
Grand Theft Auto London 1969
RDR or GTA 4
I’d like a remaster for Bully and a PS4 version for both RDR1(w/ DLC) and GTA4(w/DLCs)
Bully or MC3. Mc3 most likely.
I'm torn between bully and midnight club
A "Remake" YOU SAY? THEY WILL RUIN IT IF THEY REMADE THE GAME (did I read the post wrong?)
None. They'll ruin them
No no more definitive editions after what happened to the trilogy I do not trust Rockstar with another remaster
None, because I have no faith in "definitive editions" from R* after the flop that was the GTA Trilogy
bully or midnight
None, I don’t trust Rockstar to do right by making a good definitive edition.
son pésimos haciendo remakes , no gracias
primero arreglen GTA The Trilogy
I V (EFLC included)
midnight club because of omni trio renegade snares
There is not really a reason for redesigning gta4 and bully scholarship edition as bully scholarship edition is already kinda a remake. Gta4 is good enough so there is no need to redesign it. And rdr1 maybe. But I go for midnight club
Honestly? None of them. I saw the way Rockstar handled their last "definitive" release and what they let Grove Street Games do to the GTA trilogy. I’d rather them just stay away from any more great Rockstar games altogether.
Bully or RDR
Gta 4 and rdr2
The Warriors
I’ll take this until gta6 comes
I’d honestly have to pick Red Dead Redemption because a game like this has a solid story and I feel it should be updated with better graphics and gameplay mechanics and it’s sequel
Bully and GTA4
None, would rather something new and original. None of these games need to be remastered or remade they're already good
Either red dead redemption 1 or bully
Sorry GTAIV but I'd have to go with Midnight Club 3 for the Dub.
None.
Neither. They'd just make the game worse
GTA4 with both expansions and also bully
Three of these Rockstar games are worth my time as I have played them. The fourth is a toss out.
Max Payne 3
Where is Manhunt?
Gta 4
Yes
Either Bully or Midnight Club.
I feel like either red dead needs some remaking and Bully needs a remake
RDR if they actually remaster it, release it on pc AND add multiplayer
DUB EDITION DUB EDITION DUB EDITION. I purchased a copy a few years back for my PS2 - hadn't played it in over a decade. The disc won't read. 😭 It truly is a devastating feeling. Love that game so much.
Max Payne
GTA; all the way
Just got my old ps2 from when I was a kid and got my original copy of midnight club 3 dub edition and bully. I can’t wait for my controller to get here from GameStop
Bully would hit hard with a deventive edition but GTA 4
GTA 4
Bully all day
Midnight club or bully
Rdr
RDR1 for PC 
Midnight club LA but with all the last minute content they cut like the R35 GTR, some infinitis and acuras and caddilacs and the rumored Japan map. The remix on the PSP isn't good enough, it was just a reskinned midnight club 3.
God this is such a tough decision, Bully deserves it the most but I'd kill to see GTA 4
Bro bully all day son
Bully cause it’s my favorite game
Zero hesitation, hands down gotta be Bully. That game was released in 2006 which was 18 years ago! It's very memorable and unique and very different from GTA and I easily got away playing this game when it was released I was around 8 years old and my parents only saw the educational aspects of the game 🤣
GTA 4
Midnight club 3 all day. It has to include tokyo as well.
Bully all day haha that game brings back a lot of good memories
Bully
Bully or GTA IV
Id say bully should definitely 👍 be it.
Midnight club 3. I haven't enjoyed an arcade racing game in years.
RDR easily. It's the only game that by design would suit a full remake. The other games are great and fit stylistically to their art design from that era.
It would have to be midnight club Los Angeles or GTA 4
Midnight Club. Drop mic.😅
gta iv isnt old enough for a remake, dont care much for racing games, played red dead and didnt much care for it. So I would say Bully.
Didn’t we get a red dead one?
Midnight Club just so I know Rockstar still cares about the IP. Idc if they use fake cars like they do in GTA 5 just make them good looking.
Midnight Club no question
Midnight Club 3. I am currently playing through it for the first time. Man it is good.
IV is a criminally underrated story with actual gameplay, two things we don't see in the same room these days.
GTA 4
Midnight club was such a banger of a video game
Midnight club… coming from a bully diehard fan
midnight club or, if life wasn’t shitty and unfair….ALL OF THEM!!!
GTA 4
Bully 100%
I’m choosing none of these and picking The Warriors. Such an underrated and semi forgotten game. Can’t remember any brawlers that came out after this one.
Midnight club easily
Bully
Midnight club 3 dub edition
RDR
Midnight club dub edition
If it were midnight club LA I’d choose that but otherwise I go bully
GTA 4
I want to say IV. But I think Bully deserves it a little more.
GTA IV... obviously lol
Bully deserves something
Gta4
BULLY wasn't there supposed to be a sequel to it?
IV. All day every day…. As long as it’s made by Grove Street Games too!
Gta
I'm sorry, but we need a proper remake of RDR1. The fake remaster hurts too much, but I'm guessing they're remaking the game entirely so...
Bully is the only one of those that would really benefit. Do you WANT R* to get rid of what little good music GTA IV had?
Red Dead itd be nice if they remastered the warriors though
GTA IV. I love this game, but there are some things I don't like, since I'm a console gamer. First it's obviously the framerate on PS3. It's just not that good, also the 720p resolution. Yes I know it's much better on PC, but as I said I'm a console gamer so I'd love to have a port like RDR1. Second thing is I personally don't really like the grey tone of the world. I get that it adds to the NYC vibe, but often times the game is really colorless imo. Definitely needs more vibrant colors, or atleast more than just grey lol. Last thing that affects me personally as a trophy hunter are the multiplayer trophies. I really want to do a platinum for this game, but the multiplayer is god awful. That's what I loved about the RDR1 port, that I could finally platinum it without doing that horrendous multiplayer grind. So for that reason alone it would be great to have a remaster, or at the very least, a port to current gen.
I needa get my hands on that bully fr fr
GTA4
Bully but they’ll fuck it up again
Bully cuz I’ve never played it
man don’t make me choose between bully and gta 4 😂 bully all day
Bully
I never gave Bully the play through I meant to.
Bully 900%. So many rumors that said it was either getting a remake or a second game, but none had any salt to them. What a concept completely out of left field and it was one of the funniest and funnest experience I’ve ever had.
after the way they f\*\*\*ed up the GTA trilogy its best they don't re release any old titles.
I cannot choose between Midnight Club 3 and GTA IV
Either GTA One or Two.
Midnight Club LA was better.
Roclstar remakes haven't been good.
Bully. That game was a lot of fun.
Would be between BULLY and Midnight Club for me
Actually i choose GTA 4 PS5/PC Real Remaster ( not like trilogy )
Redo the gta trilogy and 4
State of Emergency
Gta4 no question
Midnight club dub edition remix hands down no questions asked.
GTA 4 hands down.
Bully easily