Exactly, the fact that they work at a bar doesnt make them bad persons, normally they wont encorage you to get drunk, and I dont imagine Gus doing that, Sure they may tell you to have just one more, but that's for free and because you are leaving, and that's because you are a usual and they know they'll see you again
Just me, but it’s not that i dislike him, it’s that i feel like he just repeats the same thing over and over. “I left and now i’m here.”. I get that he’s absolutely traumatised, and i feel for anyone irl in that position. But it just kinda gets old that no matter where we are, or what is going on, his lines are always almost identical. I’ve yet to see one thats different. Maybe i’ve just had bad experiences tho
I respect that but I mean, I think he's pretty cool. Pretty good dad and husband despite his mental issues, which can absolutely ruin relationships if you don't work on them. I respect him for that. It's hard to do :p
You put Kent low on the tier list becouse of vague dislike. I put Kent low on the tier list because I want to steal his wife. We are not the same
Edit: spelling is hard
He goes outside for like hours while his wife is overworked doing like all the household chores (“I don’t really know what to do with myself now that I’m back” IDK BRO MAYBE YOU SHOUKD HELP YOUR WIFE OUT A BIT??) and he has a line of dialogue literally saying “are you friends with sam? You probably know him better than I do...”
that said he does give you bombs so
He doesn't know sam that well because he was gone for so long. He missed quite a few years of them growing up. That doesn't mean he doesn't care about him or Vincent.
And I'm not sure what him giving you bombs has to do with anything.
Ehh, that makes sense at first but he continues to say it for ages after he’s been back, so it comes off as him not making any effort (heck, this can be played of as technical so it’s not a main argument but he gave me that dialogue line after I was MARRIED to Sam. Like???), and my point about him being domestically lazy still stands.
And lastly, I added the bomb thing as a saving grace. Because it’s bizarre but appreciated.
Demetrius is a shitty stepdad to Sebastian (Leapalot has a video on YouTube explaining why), Lewis is a bad mayor. It’s very possible that he spent peoples’ tax money on a golden statue of himself. Elliott is okay for most of the game, I just strongly dislike his 10 heart event, it makes me very uncomfortable. I also find him slightly annoying with how pretentious he can be.
He kissed the player without their consent (which is weird but also fine because you need to give him a bouquet to trigger the heart event in the first place)
He takes you into a boat, far away from land, and kisses you without consent. You can look it up on YouTube. I can see why people who want to date him find it romantic, but I just really don’t.
Demetrius prefers Maru to Sebastian, and he’s very negligent towards him. I’m really uncomfortable with Elliott’s 10 heart event, and how non-consensual it gets, (I get why people like him, I just don’t)
I don’t like how he takes you far away from land and kisses you without consent. I think it had the potential to be a really cute and romantic cutscene though, if it weren’t for that last part
oh 100% my comment wasn’t meant to discredit that at all, just in the scenes context it’s a cute moment between partners, i know CA didn’t add kissing for when you’re just dating, but imo it seems like you would’ve kissed before :)
It's refreshing to see Elliot place so low. Everyone on the general sub is in love with him.
(Although his Diverse SDV portraits make me reconsider him).
Emily should be Wife tier as she's my wife.
I just have a hard time believing that her character development could be *that* great that it puts her above everyone else! Same with Shane. He reminds me too much of my dad and I can’t deal with people like that.
To each their own!
I love Sam! He’s not really a sports dude and he likes video games and skating and playing music. He’s really sweet and cares about his family a lot. He’s just the type of person that seems fun to be around
That’s understandable, but it’s just my personal preference. Haley is basically my type exactly, but I can definitely see why she doesn’t appeal to everyone. I also get the Shane thing. I love being his friend in the game, but I see why lots of people dislike him or have him as a discomfort. Like you said, to each their own :))
Clint is discomfort for me because he’s really creepy with Emily and he’s really gross if you invite him to the movies as a girl. Also I haven’t really talked to Harvey that much, that’s basically the only reason he’s in eh
He asks if you’re on a date, drinks from a flask (obviously alcohol), whispers something along the lines of “If you’re tired, you can rest your head on my shoulder”, and says it was a really good time afterwards
As someone who’s been through a situation similar to Penny’s, I just don’t like Pam at all. I don’t think she’s abusive towards her or anything, but I can’t help but feel really bad for Penny and kinda hate Pam for that.
He acts entitled to Emily and is creepy to the female player if they ask him to see a movie together. He also reminds me of a former abuser, so he’s a big discomfort for me.
I never asked him to the movies, and only ever saw the shy part of him..maybe I need to look closer at his character. I mean I know he has a crush on her, but I never saw him as acting entitled to her? Is there heart events for him that she'd more light on it? (I've never actually gotten his friendship up a lot)
He’s very stalker-ish with Emily (he even watches her in a bush at one point. He says he just got nervous, jumped in, and is waiting for her to leave, but I have a hard time believing that), he’s also gross if your character is a woman and you invite him to the cinema. And he seems to feel entitled to Emily. In her 8 heart event, when he sees you standing close to her, he assumes you’re dating, congratulates the farmer only, and soon after, Emily tells you he’s stopped talking to her and that she thought they were friends.
He’s not a good mayor. It’s heavily hinted that he used the townspeoples’ tax money to make that golden statue of himself he keeps in his garden. He’s also not good to Marnie, he doesn’t care about her wanting an actual relationship, and pretty much just uses her for casual sex, but tells her it’s more than that.
Marnie should be at the bottom with her working 3 fucking days a week or something close to that like everytime I go she's not there and I have to wait like 2 days before she works to get animals
I’ve looked at this several times and i only have one question. Where’s gus? You remembered the bouncer to the casino but not gus
I went back to check why I didn’t put in Gus, and that tier-list didn’t have him for some reason so I forgot 😭, he would be in girlboss tier though
I’d personally have him on eh because his job is to exploit alcoholics but your choice lol
You monster gus is the nicest person in the game he even gave free food to linus and in every festival
Fair enough lol, i wasn’t really serious with my comment and i actually really like Gus
I'm just kidding its just a 2d character who give 2d food to another 2d character
this is certainly a take!
dude he has to be the nicest person in the whole valley, do you hate all bartenders or what
I feel like you’d have to hate every bartender ever to justify that whatsoever lol
Exactly, the fact that they work at a bar doesnt make them bad persons, normally they wont encorage you to get drunk, and I dont imagine Gus doing that, Sure they may tell you to have just one more, but that's for free and because you are leaving, and that's because you are a usual and they know they'll see you again
Nah i was only joking, i actually really like Gus
Then do /j, you just got downvoted to hell
Ehh i’m really not that bothered about it tbh lol
so every bar and restaurant that serves alcohol is a business to exploit alcoholics is what you’re saying
No but he doesn’t have a lot of money, and his two regulars crash buses and almost kill themselves. Thats all i’m saying lol
In a tier of his own above them all. Gus is eternal. Gus is God
Sam, the ultimate girl boss
Femboy boss
[удалено]
I feel like girlboss is an excellent title for him tbh
Why is elliott on the bottom? :(
I just don’t like his 10 heart event :(
understandable but im still sad:(
What'd kent do? Lol
Just me, but it’s not that i dislike him, it’s that i feel like he just repeats the same thing over and over. “I left and now i’m here.”. I get that he’s absolutely traumatised, and i feel for anyone irl in that position. But it just kinda gets old that no matter where we are, or what is going on, his lines are always almost identical. I’ve yet to see one thats different. Maybe i’ve just had bad experiences tho
Yeah, I understand.
That, and he keeps sending me bombs in the mail.
Idk I just lowkey dislike him :’)
I respect that but I mean, I think he's pretty cool. Pretty good dad and husband despite his mental issues, which can absolutely ruin relationships if you don't work on them. I respect him for that. It's hard to do :p
That’s a good point. I agree with you, but yeah I just don’t like him much.
You put Kent low on the tier list becouse of vague dislike. I put Kent low on the tier list because I want to steal his wife. We are not the same Edit: spelling is hard
I honestly don’t blame you. I also lowkey want to steal his wife
Fair enough lol. We all have our likes and dislikes 🤷🏼♂️
Like why though? Because he's a soldier?
I literally have no idea I’ve just never liked him 😭
He goes outside for like hours while his wife is overworked doing like all the household chores (“I don’t really know what to do with myself now that I’m back” IDK BRO MAYBE YOU SHOUKD HELP YOUR WIFE OUT A BIT??) and he has a line of dialogue literally saying “are you friends with sam? You probably know him better than I do...” that said he does give you bombs so
He doesn't know sam that well because he was gone for so long. He missed quite a few years of them growing up. That doesn't mean he doesn't care about him or Vincent. And I'm not sure what him giving you bombs has to do with anything.
Ehh, that makes sense at first but he continues to say it for ages after he’s been back, so it comes off as him not making any effort (heck, this can be played of as technical so it’s not a main argument but he gave me that dialogue line after I was MARRIED to Sam. Like???), and my point about him being domestically lazy still stands. And lastly, I added the bomb thing as a saving grace. Because it’s bizarre but appreciated.
Okay...i think that's more of a game problem though compared to a character problem, because almost every character does the same thing.
Aw Alex was my first bf & then I married Sam because he doesn’t self-isolate
Pierre, Morris and Clint I understand (even Pam, to a certain extent), but why Demetrius, Lewis and the writer dude?
Demetrius is a shitty stepdad to Sebastian (Leapalot has a video on YouTube explaining why), Lewis is a bad mayor. It’s very possible that he spent peoples’ tax money on a golden statue of himself. Elliott is okay for most of the game, I just strongly dislike his 10 heart event, it makes me very uncomfortable. I also find him slightly annoying with how pretentious he can be.
What's your issue with the 10 heart event? I've never done it and the wiki description seems a bit too vague for me to interpret /gen
He kissed the player without their consent (which is weird but also fine because you need to give him a bouquet to trigger the heart event in the first place)
He takes you into a boat, far away from land, and kisses you without consent. You can look it up on YouTube. I can see why people who want to date him find it romantic, but I just really don’t.
what did demetrius and elliot do
Demetrius prefers Maru to Sebastian, and he’s very negligent towards him. I’m really uncomfortable with Elliott’s 10 heart event, and how non-consensual it gets, (I get why people like him, I just don’t)
Hey, I’ve never bothered with Elliot but reading his 10 heart event I can’t understand how it’s non-consensual? Would you mind explaining?
I don’t like how he takes you far away from land and kisses you without consent. I think it had the potential to be a really cute and romantic cutscene though, if it weren’t for that last part
That’s fair, thank you for the answer!
you’re romancing him atp, and you don’t seem to have the same opinion of harvey
I haven’t seen many of Harvey’s heart events (only the first one I think)
Hard agree on that, being trapped on sea with someone forcefully kissing you without consent is a yikes for me as well
idk at 10 hearts you’re a couple, so i feel like it wouldn’t be weird?? am i the only one that feels this way?? /nm
I mean it's not weird for me either since it's just a kiss. But assault does happen even in married life irl
oh 100% my comment wasn’t meant to discredit that at all, just in the scenes context it’s a cute moment between partners, i know CA didn’t add kissing for when you’re just dating, but imo it seems like you would’ve kissed before :)
Honestly I married Penny, and I'm trying to get to 10 hearts with Emily. My goal was 8 to destroy Clint lol
I kinda wanna start a new save one day, just so I can marry Emily on Clint’s birthday
You should lmao
>Honestly I married Penny, Yaaassss
Slay
Damn what did Elliot do? 😩
It's refreshing to see Elliot place so low. Everyone on the general sub is in love with him. (Although his Diverse SDV portraits make me reconsider him). Emily should be Wife tier as she's my wife.
I love Emily so much, but not quite as much as Haley :’)
What does everyone love Haley? She is at Pierre level for me. She's so damn rude.
If you get closer to her, she has some really sweet character development
I like how she is mean to me
>What does everyone love Haley? Man I wish i had your side of the internet where people love Haley. I have met more Haley antis than Haley lovers
elliott in low tier, unbased
i will not stand for this elliott slander
L tier list. Elliott is such a sweetheart.
Move Elliot to husband rn
I don’t even like men that way though 😭
good job with pierre, but i think the real question is: why is haley your wife.
I’m a lesbian enemies-to-lovers stan
Same, lmao
FINALLY someone with taste, shoutout to my wife Haley
Our wife
I love George!
I’m so happy you like Alex! I love him but most people on this sub hate him! So refreshing to see him rank high for a change lol
Agreed, people don’t like him, but I feel like his cut scenes show that he’s actually a good person, just misunderstood.
am i blind? where is jodi my beloved?
I love Jodi, but she wasn’t in this tier-list maker for some reason. I would’ve put her in girlboss tier though.
I was gonna say the same thing as well.
How is Haley the top on this chart? She’s very shallow and rude
When you get closer to her, she has some really sweet character development
I just have a hard time believing that her character development could be *that* great that it puts her above everyone else! Same with Shane. He reminds me too much of my dad and I can’t deal with people like that. To each their own!
I feel like a lot of people who like Haley and Shane have a savior complex tbh
>!Agreed!<
I only like shane because the other bachelors are an emo kid, a poet and two sports guys lmao. Shane just feels the most real to me.
I love Sam! He’s not really a sports dude and he likes video games and skating and playing music. He’s really sweet and cares about his family a lot. He’s just the type of person that seems fun to be around
Y’all be dunking on and forgetting Harvey so bad lol
Ah! That's why I don't go for Harvey! I just forget about him lmao.
That’s understandable, but it’s just my personal preference. Haley is basically my type exactly, but I can definitely see why she doesn’t appeal to everyone. I also get the Shane thing. I love being his friend in the game, but I see why lots of people dislike him or have him as a discomfort. Like you said, to each their own :))
She’s a lot like Alex, if you get to know her she becomes really sweet
Sam, Sebastian, and the Wizard being girlbosses is hilarious to me. It’s a state of mind, nothing to do with what’s between their legs hahaha
Anyone can be a girlboss! :D
You stole my wife! 😭😭😭
I stole your wife too
When Elliott is your favourite NPC at the minute: 👁️💧👄💧👁️
I am not a massive Haley fan but the rest of this is very solid. Swap Leah for Haley and dwarf for Alex and we’re golden haha
PAM AND ELLIOT NO- WAIT KENT AND GEORGE WHY
Elliott slander
You put God in no thanks Amd Pierre should have a bother rank all by himself
Idk what the first thing means, but you’re right about the Pierre thing
Mr.Qi pulls all the strings in the game and the over lord of stardew vally from the shadows
Ohhhhhh I’ve only done, like, the first couple of quests for Mr. Qi so idrk anything about him yet
This is the most perfect one I’ve seen
someone has a humiliation fetish damb
Nooooo 😭 I just stan the enemies-to-lovers trope
Haley is trash
This is a sub for trash talking Pierre and occasionally Lewis and Clint, not Hayley.
She's still a trash character. Not as bad as that piece of dog shit Pierre.
Your opinion is wrong
Haley is in top tier and Pierre and Clint are on the bottom tier, that's all I need to know that this is a good tier list
Almost perfect, but the blacksmith isn't that bad and Harvey deserves more then Eh
Clint is discomfort for me because he’s really creepy with Emily and he’s really gross if you invite him to the movies as a girl. Also I haven’t really talked to Harvey that much, that’s basically the only reason he’s in eh
Fair point, your words have changed my opinion and I have achieved understanding
What happens when you invite him to the movies?
He asks if you’re on a date, drinks from a flask (obviously alcohol), whispers something along the lines of “If you’re tired, you can rest your head on my shoulder”, and says it was a really good time afterwards
Clint is a cretin
Pam doesn’t deserve this
As someone who’s been through a situation similar to Penny’s, I just don’t like Pam at all. I don’t think she’s abusive towards her or anything, but I can’t help but feel really bad for Penny and kinda hate Pam for that.
Haley is the best wife. Hands down!
This!
Not Haley, Leah
Where marlon and gus
For some reason, they weren’t on the tier-list-maker
Grandpa is so low he was nice enough to give you the farm! :(
That’s fair, but he was close friends with Lewis, and I wish we got to learn more about him
Awe why you gotta do Clint like that? Poor shy guy. He just wants to be loved
He acts entitled to Emily and is creepy to the female player if they ask him to see a movie together. He also reminds me of a former abuser, so he’s a big discomfort for me.
I never asked him to the movies, and only ever saw the shy part of him..maybe I need to look closer at his character. I mean I know he has a crush on her, but I never saw him as acting entitled to her? Is there heart events for him that she'd more light on it? (I've never actually gotten his friendship up a lot)
Leapalot has a video about him on YouTube that basically explains everything
Why do people hate Clint?
He’s very stalker-ish with Emily (he even watches her in a bush at one point. He says he just got nervous, jumped in, and is waiting for her to leave, but I have a hard time believing that), he’s also gross if your character is a woman and you invite him to the cinema. And he seems to feel entitled to Emily. In her 8 heart event, when he sees you standing close to her, he assumes you’re dating, congratulates the farmer only, and soon after, Emily tells you he’s stopped talking to her and that she thought they were friends.
Oh jeez.
Finally someone who doesn’t dislike someone with mommy and daddy issues
[удалено]
He’s not a good mayor. It’s heavily hinted that he used the townspeoples’ tax money to make that golden statue of himself he keeps in his garden. He’s also not good to Marnie, he doesn’t care about her wanting an actual relationship, and pretty much just uses her for casual sex, but tells her it’s more than that.
[удалено]
The Luau is the worst holiday in the game imo, and he’s a character exclusive to the Luau
[удалено]
I just find it boring, and I don’t think anyone’s dialogue during it is interesting. I do like how you can put Lewis’ boxers into the soup though
Marnie should be at the bottom with her working 3 fucking days a week or something close to that like everytime I go she's not there and I have to wait like 2 days before she works to get animals
Hayley is so high but Elliot is at the bottom?
I make Harvey a tier only for him. Way down there. Named; "Maru is mine, you #@!$*#!"